Full text
Protestant or evangelical · About 8 min ·  · History between us

Isn't Catholicism paganism mixed in after Constantine?

The short answer

No. Sunday worship, baptism, bishops, the Eucharist (the bread and wine of Communion) as Christ's body, and prayers for the dead are all on record before Constantine, the first Christian emperor. Christians did borrow dates, buildings and customs from the cultures around them. But what they filled them with came from Jesus.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · Two versions of the question

There are two versions of this question. The careful one says the first Christians were simple.

Later centuries, it says, piled on rituals and ranks that you don't see in the .

Many thoughtful Protestants ask that, and it deserves a straight answer.

The popular version goes much further. It says Catholic worship is the pagan religion of ancient Babylon, in disguise.

Pagan religions are the old faiths with many gods. Babylon was a great city of the ancient world, in what is now Iraq.

A lot of it comes from one book from the 1850s, The Two Babylons, by a Scottish minister called Alexander Hislop.

He traced Christmas, Easter and much more back to Nimrod, a king in Genesis.

He also brought in a legendary queen called Semiramis, who he said was Nimrod's wife.

Experts on the ancient world say he got Babylonian religion wrong.

But his ideas still go round in some evangelical churches.

Part 2 · Worship before Constantine

was the Roman emperor who became a Christian in the early 300s. So the fairest test is simple.

Look at how Christians worshipped before him, when being a Christian could get you killed.

A handbook for churches called the Didache was written in the first or second century. It tells Christians to meet every Lord's day, meaning Sunday.

There they're to break bread together, the meal Christians call .

They're also to choose and : a group of local overseers and their helpers.

Around AD 155, a Christian teacher called wrote to the Roman emperor, to explain what Christians actually did on Sundays.

He wrote that the bread and wine, once blessed with thanks, are Jesus's own body and blood. In his words, they are:

the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh
Justin Martyr, First Apology, 66 (around AD 155)

In the early 200s, Tertullian, a Christian writer in North Africa, describes how Christians were .

He also mentions them tracing the sign of the cross on their foreheads.

And every year, he says, Christians made offerings for the dead. It was a way of praying for those who had died.

All of this was in place a century before any emperor became a Christian.

Constantine didn't invent Catholic worship. He met it.

So the first Christians weren't as simple as the careful version says.

Whether each practice is also in the Bible is a fair question too. Other answers on this site take those one at a time.

Part 3 · And Easter?

One claim you may have heard is that Easter is named after Ishtar, a Babylonian goddess.

The two words do sound a little alike in English.

But Christians were keeping the feast of Jesus's death and rising long before Constantine.

Around AD 150, , a bishop from what is now Turkey, travelled to Rome to talk about which day to keep it on.

The churches of his region kept it by the Jewish calendar, on the day the lamb was sacrificed.

For those churches, Jesus was the true Passover lamb.

That's why, in many languages, the feast isn't called Easter at all.

Its name comes from Pascha, which grew out of the Hebrew word for Passover: Pasqua in Italian, Pascua in Spanish, Pâques in French.

So where does the English word come from? The oldest answer comes from Bede, an English writer of the 700s.

He says the English month around April was named after Eostre, a goddess the English had once held feasts for.

When they became Christians, the old name stayed with the new feast. Bede wrote that they were:

calling the joys of the new rite by the time-honoured name of the old observance
Bede, The Reckoning of Time, 15 (AD 725)

For a long time scholars argued over whether Bede made her up.

Then in 1958, inscriptions to goddesses with a similar name turned up in Germany. Many scholars now think she was real.

Either way, it's a story about an English month, and Ishtar doesn't come into it. The Ishtar link goes back to Hislop's book.

Language experts reject it, because there's nothing behind it but a similar sound.

So the English name may well come from an old English goddess, and most of the world never used it.

The feast itself grew out of Passover, not Babylon. It celebrates Jesus rising from the dead.

Part 4 · The man who pulled his own book

Some of the sharpest criticism of Hislop came from a Protestant, not a Catholic.

In 1966 an American preacher, Ralph Woodrow, wrote a simpler version of Hislop's ideas. It sold well, and was translated into many languages.

Then Woodrow checked Hislop's sources for himself. Hislop said Nimrod and Semiramis were married, but no encyclopedia Woodrow read said so.

They didn't even live in the same century.

Again and again, Hislop's footnotes didn't say what he claimed. So Woodrow did something rare: he pulled his own popular book out of print.

He stayed a Protestant who disagreed with Catholic teaching. His point was about how you test a claim:

citing a similarity does not provide proof
Ralph Woodrow, Christian Research Journal (2000)

Part 5 · What Christians really did borrow

To be fair, the critics have a point here. Christians did reuse dates, buildings and customs from the world around them.

Old customs can carry old meanings, so each one deserves a look.

Christmas is the best-known case. The first record of 25 December as Jesus's birthday is a Roman calendar from 354.

The same day was also a feast of the sun god.

An old Catholic reference book admits the sun feast is a strong explanation. Others think Christians worked out the date another way.

So it's still open. Either way, the date was borrowed, or at least shared. What it celebrates, the birth of Jesus, wasn't borrowed at all.

Part 6 · Old shapes, new meaning

The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says the Church takes good things from human cultures and gives them new meaning.

Water, bread, oil and light become signs of grace, of the new creation in Jesus Christ.

The Bible does the same. Other peoples had sacrifices and feasts that followed the seasons too.

In ancient Israel, the Catechism says, rites like these became signs of the covenant, the bond God made with his people.

did it too. In Athens he found an altar marked To an Unknown God.

He began a sermon from it, and said: What therefore you unknowingly worship, I proclaim to you.

Popes did this early. In AD 601, wrote to missionaries in England:

Don't tear down the pagan temples. Destroy the idols, bless the buildings with holy water, and set up altars.

The locals used to sacrifice cattle to their gods. Instead, he said, let them feast on saints' days and thank God for their food.

Notice what was borrowed: a building and a party. The God being worshipped didn't change.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a church that meets on Sunday mornings in a cinema.

Plenty of churches around the world do this, in cinemas, school halls and hotel ballrooms.

On Saturday night, that big screen was showing an action film. The seats still smell a bit of popcorn.

The sound system was built for car chases and explosions, not hymns.

Then on Sunday morning the same room fills up. The same screen shows the words of the songs. The same speakers carry the sermon.

People pray, read the Bible and share bread. Not a single person there thinks they're worshipping the movies.

What matters is what's said and done in the room, not what the room was built for.

That's how the Catholic Church sees a borrowed date or custom. The shape came from somewhere else. What fills it comes from .

But there's a limit. The Catechism says fitting the faith into a culture can mean a breaking with ancestral customs incompatible with the Catholic faith.

In plain words, some things can be taken in, and others have to go.

Part 7 · What about customs at home?

And in many families, the limit is a real question: which customs at home can a Christian keep?

In 1995, after a meeting of Africa's Catholic bishops, wrote to the Church in Africa about exactly this.

He said God had been getting people ready for the long before it reached them.

Those values include honouring ancestors. The bishops wrote that Africans believe intuitively that the dead continue to live and remain in communion with them.

But every custom has to pass two tests: compatibility with the Christian message and communion with the universal Church.

So it has to fit what Christians believe, and keep you one with the whole Church.

The Catechism rejects conjuring up the dead, magic and wearing charms. Even for healing, it says, traditional cures can't justify calling on evil powers.

There's no single worldwide list of which customs pass. The bishops asked for the hardest questions to be studied in depth, country by country.

So for a custom like a bride price, ask what the Catholic bishops in your own country have said. The answer on ancestors goes further.

As for the charge of paganism: plenty was borrowed, and most Christians who keep Christmas share in the borrowing.

The test of a practice isn't where its shape came from. It's whether what it says about Jesus is true.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 15
  1. Wikipedia, “The Two Babylons” · Hislop's pamphlet (1853) and book (1858), its claims, and how scholars judge them.
  2. Ralph Woodrow, “The Two Babylons: A Case Study in Poor Methodology”, Christian Research Journal 22:2 (2000) · The author of Babylon Mystery Religion explains why he withdrew it.
  3. The Didache, 14–15 · Gathering on the Lord's day to break bread; appointing bishops and deacons.
  4. Catholic Encyclopedia, “The Didache” (1908) · Proposed dates range from before AD 70 to Harnack's 131–160.
  5. Justin Martyr, First Apology, 65–67 (c. AD 155) · The earliest full description of Sunday worship and the Eucharist.
  6. Tertullian, The Chaplet (De Corona), 3 (early 200s) · Baptism, offerings for the dead, Easter to Pentecost, and the sign of the cross.
  7. Bede, Ecclesiastical History of the English People, I.30: Gregory the Great to Mellitus (AD 601) · Keep the temples, destroy the idols, turn the old sacrificial feasts into feasts on saints' days.
  8. Catholic Encyclopedia, “Christmas” (1908) · The calendar of 354, the solar feast's “strong claim” on the date, and the 25 March theory.
  9. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1149–1150 · The liturgy takes up elements of human culture as signs of grace.
  10. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1204–1206 · Cultures redeemed, not abolished, and customs incompatible with the faith left behind.
  11. Catholic Encyclopedia, “Easter Controversy” (1909) · Polycarp came to Rome about the date of Easter around 150; the churches of Asia kept it on the day of the Passover lamb, Christ being its fulfilment.
  12. Catholic Encyclopedia, “Easter” (1909) · Bede on the English name; Pascha from the Hebrew pesach, and Pasqua, Pascua, Pâques in other languages.
  13. Wikipedia, “Ēostre” · Bede's account in The Reckoning of Time 15 (Faith Wallis's translation), the scholarly debate, and why the Ishtar link is rejected.
  14. John Paul II, Ecclesia in Africa (14 September 1995), 42–43, 62, 64 · African values as a preparation for the Gospel; ancestors and the communion of saints; the two tests for inculturation; study of marriage, ancestors and the spirit world.
  15. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2116–2117 · Divination, conjuring up the dead, magic, charms and the invocation of evil powers rejected.