From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/tongues-healing
← Protestant or evangelicalDo Catholics believe in speaking in tongues and healing?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minYes. The Catholic Church teaches that the still gives gifts like tongues, prophecy and healing, and millions of Catholics pray this way. It also teaches that every gift must be tested, used in love, and never chased for show.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Vatican II
- Lumen Gentium, 12
- Vatican doctrine office
- Instruction on Prayers for Healing
If you come from a Pentecostal church, Catholic worship can look very still. Set prayers, kneeling, long silences. No one shouting hallelujah from the back.
So it's fair to wonder: does the Catholic Church even believe the Spirit still moves the way he did in the ?
Yes, the gifts are real
It does. lists gifts of healing and varieties of tongues among the gifts the Holy Spirit gives.3
The says these gifts can be extraordinary or simple and humble.1 They're given to build up the Church, to do good, and to meet the world's needs.1
It calls them a wonderfully rich for the whole Church, as long as they're real gifts of the Spirit and used with love.1
Some churches believe the most striking gifts, like tongues, don't work today the way they did in the Bible. That view is called cessationism, because it holds that those gifts have ceased, or stopped.8
Their best argument: the miracles were signs that confirmed the ' message. Once the apostles were gone and their message was written down in the Bible, the signs had done their job.14
Baptists are split on it, at least in the US. In a 2007 survey of Southern Baptist pastors there, half said the Holy Spirit gives some people a special language to pray to God privately. 43% said no.12
The researcher who ran the survey described a substantially cessationist portion of the denomination, beside a large group open to the gift.12 And from 2005 to 2015, the Southern Baptists' international mission board banned its missionaries from using a private prayer language.13
The Catholic Church doesn't hold the cessationist view. Tongues will cease, Paul says, but when the perfect comes, and we see face to face.15
Catholics take that as seeing God at the end, not the day the Bible was finished.
And the gifts didn't stop with the apostles. Around AD 180, , a in Gaul, today's France, wrote of Christians in the Church who speak all kinds of languages.16
Millions of Catholics pray this way
And it isn't only on paper. In 1967, at a weekend retreat for students from a Catholic university in Pittsburgh, in the US, something started.
Some of the leaders had first prayed with Protestants who already prayed this way.8
Soon Catholics were praying with praise, tongues and prayer for healing. It became a movement called the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, and by one 2013 estimate it had over 160 million people.8
Francis said it was born ecumenical: born across church lines.6
Walk into a Catholic charismatic prayer meeting today and the songs, the raised hands and the praying over people may feel very familiar.
The Spirit didn't wait for the churches to agree.
These meetings usually happen outside , not during it. And not every Catholic likes them: some say they make worship feel more Pentecostal than Catholic.8
Every gift gets tested
Paul wrote do not forbid speaking in tongues. In the same breath he added, everything must be done properly and in order.4
And love is the test. His famous chapter on love, the one read at so many weddings, sits right between his two chapters on the gifts.
In the 1960s the said the same. Extraordinary gifts are not to be sought after, it warned.2 Church leaders must test them, not indeed to extinguish the Spirit, but to test all things and hold fast to that which is good.2 That's Paul's own advice, almost word for word.
Think of it like this
Think of the worship band at church on a Sunday. Keyboard, bass, drums, two guitars, three singers. Every one of them has a different part to play.
But imagine the keyboard player decides his part is the best one, and plays it as loud as he can, all the way through every song. However gifted he is, nobody can follow the tune any more. The singing falls apart.
That's why there's a worship leader, keeping everyone on the same song, at the same pace, so the whole church can join in.
That's how Catholics see the Spirit's gifts. The gifts are the instruments, love is the song, and testing them is the worship leader's job. A gift that drowns everyone else out has missed the point of the gift.
Where Pentecostals see it differently
Many Pentecostal churches, like the Assemblies of God, teach that speaking in tongues is the first sign that you've been in the Holy Spirit.10
So what about Paul's question, Do all speak in tongues? They read it as being about the gift of tongues that Paul lists among the Spirit's gifts. The tongues that come with Spirit baptism, they say, are the same in essence as that gift, but different in purpose and use.10
Catholics read Paul's question as expecting the answer no.3 For them, tongues is one gift among many, which the Spirit hands out as he wishes.3
Many Catholics in the Renewal speak of being baptised in the Holy Spirit too. What they mean by it, and how it fits with baptism and Confirmation, is in the answer on baptising babies.
And healing?
Catholics pray for healing all the time. There's even a for it, the Anointing of the Sick, where a priest prays over a sick person and anoints them with oil.5
In 2000 the Vatican's teaching office said any Catholic may pray to God for healing.7
No one owns the gift, either. The same document says healing isn't kept for one special group of believers: the Spirit chooses whom he works through.7 It also asked Catholics who lead healing services to keep them prayerful and calm, so they never become a show.7
Casting out evil spirits, called exorcism, is a different question, and the answer on the devil covers it.
One thing belongs here, though. The Catechism says mental illness is a very different matter, for doctors to treat.11
Claimed healings get checked hard. At Lourdes, a shrine in France where sick people have gone to pray for healing, doctors have checked reported cures since 1883.
More than 7,000 cures have been reported there. About 70 have been officially recognised as miracles.9
That doesn't mean the others were fake. A cure is declared a miracle only after checks that can take years, when doctors agree it is unexplained in the present state of our knowledge.9 It's a very high bar, set on purpose.
To be honest, there's a hard part too. Many people who pray for healing aren't healed the way they hoped. The Catechism says it straight: even the most intense prayers do not always obtain the healing of all illnesses.5 Even the sacrament asks for the body to be healed only if that's good for the person's .5
Yes to the gifts, and yes to testing them. Pentecostals and Catholics may pray in different styles, but they're asking the same Spirit for the same thing.
Sources16
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 799–801Charisms, extraordinary or simple; welcomed with gratitude; always tested by charity.
- 2Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964), 12Charisms received with thanks; extraordinary gifts not to be sought; leaders test them.
- 31 Corinthians 12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Gifts of healing and tongues; "Do all speak in tongues?"
- 41 Corinthians 14 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Do not forbid tongues; everything properly and in order; five words with the mind.
- 5Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1505–1513The charism of healing; prayers not always answered with healing; the Anointing of the Sick and James 5.
- 6Pope Francis, Pentecost Vigil address, Circus Maximus (3 June 2017)Fifty years of the Renewal: "It was born ecumenical!"
- 7Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Instruction on Prayers for Healing (14 September 2000)Any Catholic may pray for healing; no group of believers owns the charism; healing services kept prayerful and orderly.
- 8Wikipedia, "Catholic Charismatic Renewal"The 1967 Duquesne retreat, the 2013 membership estimate, and CHARIS (2019).
- 9Sanctuary of Our Lady of Lourdes, "The miracles of Lourdes"The medical bureau founded in 1883; over 7,000 cures reported, 70 recognised as miracles.
- 10Assemblies of God (USA), Statement of Fundamental Truths, 8 (archived 2019)Tongues as the initial physical evidence of baptism in the Holy Spirit, different in purpose from the gift of tongues.
- 11Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1673Exorcism: the Church's authority from Jesus; a major exorcism only by a priest with the bishop's permission; psychological illness is a matter for medicine.
- 12Baptist News Global (Associated Baptist Press), "Half of SBC pastors believe in ‘prayer languages,’ study reveals" (13 June 2007)LifeWay survey of 405 Southern Baptist senior pastors: 50% yes, 43% no, 7% unsure on a private prayer language; "a substantially cessationist portion".
- 13Baptist Standard, "IMB streamlines missionary appointment, drops ban on ‘private prayer language’" (15 May 2015)The Southern Baptist International Mission Board's 2005 ban on missionaries using a private prayer language, dropped in May 2015.
- 14Wikipedia, "Open Brethren" (on cessationism)Cessationism holds that the sign gifts were given to the early Church only, to authenticate the apostles, and ceased with the last apostle.
- 151 Corinthians 13 (New American Bible, USCCB)Tongues will cease; when the perfect comes, the partial passes away; then we shall see face to face (13:8-12).
- 16Irenaeus of Lyons, Against Heresies V.6 (c. AD 180)Many brethren in the Church have prophetic gifts and through the Spirit speak all kinds of languages.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.