From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/statues
← Protestant or evangelicalWhy the statues and images? Is that not idolatry?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minNo. Catholics don't worship statues or think a statue is God. Images remind them of Jesus, Mary and the saints, and any honour shown goes to the person pictured. God himself ordered carved figures for his holy place. And a meeting of settled the question in 787.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
The worry comes straight from the Ten Commandments. God told Israel not to carve images and bow down to them.
So when Catholics kneel near statues and light candles in front of them, it's fair to ask: isn't that exactly what God forbade?
Presbyterians and the wider family they belong to, the Reformed churches, push this further. The Heidelberg , one of their main teaching books, from 1563, says God can't be pictured in any way. People and things may be pictured, it says, but not to worship them or to serve God through them.9
And it doesn't want pictures in church at all: God's people should be taught by preaching his Word.9
God ordered images himself
But the same God who banned idols told to put two gold angel figures on the ark, the gold chest that was Israel's holiest object.1
Later, when the people were dying from snake bites in the desert, God told Moses to make a bronze snake and put it on a pole. Whoever looked at it lived.2 Jesus even compared his own death on the cross to it (John 3:14).
So the commandment can't mean never make any image, and the Reformed agree. It means don't make an image and treat it as a god.
The problem was never the carving.
It was worship going to the wrong place.
Images can go wrong
To be honest, that same bronze snake later became an idol. Much later, King Hezekiah smashed it, because people had started burning incense to it as a god.3
God can command an image, and people can turn a good image into an idol.
The reformers had a point here. A statue or a medal treated like a lucky charm is a problem. The Catechism calls that superstition, and it says wearing charms is also reprehensible.4
The honour goes to the person
In the 700s, a movement in the East tried to destroy every holy image. In 787 a of bishops at Nicaea, in what is now Turkey, said no.5
It was led by the patriarch of Constantinople, the East's leading bishop, with the 's envoys there too. Catholics and the both count it among the great councils of the early Church.5,6
The Orthodox Church still holds to its answer today, and so does the Catholic Church. The council said:
For the honour which is paid to the image passes on to that which the image represents, and he who reveres the image reveres in it the subject represented.
The Catechism calls this respectful , which means deep respect. It's not the worship that belongs to God alone.6 Even that respect, it says, is not directed to images in themselves, considered as mere things. It goes to them as images leading us on to God incarnate: to God made human, in Jesus.6
A statue doesn't hear prayers, doesn't work by itself and never deserves worship. Its whole job is to point past itself.
Think of it like this
Think of your country's flag at a big football match. The flag goes up. Thousands of people stand. Some put a hand on their heart, and some have tears in their eyes as they sing the anthem. If someone ran onto the pitch and set that flag on fire, the whole stadium would be furious.
But nobody in that stadium thinks they're worshipping a piece of cloth. Nobody thinks the flag can hear them, or that the fabric itself is holy. Their respect goes through the flag to the country it stands for, and to the people who lived and died for it.
A statue of Mary works the same way for Catholics. The respect goes through the plaster to the person, and the worship goes to God alone.
So why kneel and light candles?
Then why do Catholics kneel, light candles or even kiss a statue? The Vatican's guide to popular devotion lists habits like these: kissing or touching images, kneeling, wearing medals.10 It calls them simple ways of giving external expression to the heart.10
And it gives the warning too. Without the heart behind them, these gestures can turn into empty customs or mere superstitions.10 An image is honoured for the person it shows, never because some power is thought to live in it.10
So what separates a kissed statue from Hezekiah's bronze snake? Not the kiss. It's who the gesture is for.
People in Hezekiah's day burned incense to the snake as a god.3 A Catholic kissing a statue of Mary is greeting Mary herself.
If someone starts treating the statue itself as having power, it becomes what Hezekiah smashed, and the Church says so.4,10
Why a picture of Jesus is allowed
Catholics agree with the Reformed churches on the first step. God as he is can't be pictured. A holy image cannot represent the invisible and incomprehensible God, the Catechism says.8
That's why the banned images of God. Israel never saw his form.6 A monk who defended icons in the 700s, John of Damascus, said that before Jesus, God absolutely could not be represented by an image.8
But then something changed everything. Catholics believe that in Jesus, God took a human face. People saw him, touched him and ate with him.
If God made himself visible, a picture of Jesus tells the truth about him.
By becoming human, the Catechism says, the opened up a new way for God to be shown.6 So the fight in the 700s was really a fight about Jesus. If he couldn't be pictured, was he really human?
What about the Heidelberg Catechism's point, that God wants his people instructed by the living preaching of his Word?11 Catholics agree the Word comes first.
Every , the Catholic Sunday service, has readings and a sermon. But the Catechism says image and word illuminate each other.8
Where's the rule on images?
Catholic lists of the Ten Commandments have no separate one about images, but nothing was deleted. Catholics, like Lutherans, count them the way did in the 400s, and read the words about images as part of the first commandment.7
So a Catholic kneeling near a statue of Mary isn't praying to plaster. The statue is a reminder. The honour goes to Mary, and the worship goes to God alone.
Sources11
- 1Exodus 25:17-22 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)God orders two gold cherubim for the ark.
- 2Numbers 21:4-9 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The bronze serpent; the note links it to John 3:14.
- 32 Kings 18:4 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Hezekiah smashes the bronze serpent because people burned incense to it.
- 4Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2110-2117Superstition, charms, divination and idolatry condemned.
- 5Second Council of Nicaea (787), DefinitionReverence for images, never the worship due to God; honour passes to the person shown.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2129-2132Images in the Old Testament, Nicaea II, and veneration versus adoration.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2066How the Commandments are numbered in different churches.
- 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1159-1162The Incarnation and the new "economy" of images.
- 9Heidelberg Catechism (1563), Questions 97-98 (Schaff, Creeds of Christendom III)The Reformed view: God may not be imaged; no pictures in churches as books for the laity.
- 10Congregation for Divine Worship, Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy (2001), 15 and 241
- 11Heidelberg Catechism (1563), Q&A 98 (Christian Reformed Church translation)God wants the Christian community instructed by the living preaching of his Word, not by images.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.