From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/gospels-reliable
← No religion, or not sureWeren't the Gospels written decades later, and aren't they full of contradictions?
Read it as an illustrated story · 8 minACG works this question through in his own story. Read that part of his story: What kind of book it is · 7 min
They were written decades later, most likely between about AD 65 and 100, and they do differ in details. But the earliest came while people who had known Jesus could still be alive, and they differ the way honest retellings do, not like a story agreed in advance.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 126
- Vatican II
- Dei Verbum, 11, 12 and 19
The are the four books in the that tell the story of Jesus's life: Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. Jesus died around AD 30.
If the first Gospel came around AD 70, that's forty years of stories passed on by word of mouth. Skeptics compare it to the party game where a whispered sentence goes down a line until it comes out as something else.
So can you trust what they say about him? It's a fair worry.
The dates, honestly
Catholics don't hide the gap. The notes in the English Bible on the Vatican's own website say Mark was written shortly before or shortly after AD 70.3 Many scholars, they say, put Luke around AD 80 to 90, and John's final form around AD 90 to 100.4,5
None of the four actually names its writer. The names come from early Christian writers. The same notes even say modern research often points to an unknown Greek-speaking Jewish Christian as Mark's author.3
Forty years sounds like a long time. But it means Mark was written while people who had known Jesus could still be alive.
Even John, the last of the four, was finished within the lifetimes of people who had known Jesus's first followers.
The differences, honestly
And yes, the stories differ. At the empty tomb, Mark has one young man in white. Luke has two men in dazzling clothes. Matthew has an angel.6,7,8
In Mark, Jesus's last meal with his friends is the meal, the Jewish feast remembering the escape from slavery in Egypt.11 In John, Jesus is sentenced the day before Passover, and the hours don't match Mark's either.12
Mark's own writing seems to stop with the women running away afraid. The Catholic Bible's notes say the longer ending was written by someone else, though it's still counted as Scripture.6
None of this is hidden. It's printed in the footnotes.
Think of it like this
Picture four old friends at dinner, thirty years after a road trip they took together. Someone brings up the night the car broke down, and they all start telling it at once.
One swears it was pouring with rain. Another says it was just drizzle. One says a farmer towed them, another is sure it was two farmers. One remembers they slept in the car. Another has completely forgotten that part, and argues about it.
Nobody at the table decides the trip never happened. In fact, if all four told it word for word the same, you'd get suspicious. You'd think they'd practised it together.
Small differences are what honest memories look like. And notice what nobody argues about: the car broke down, they were stuck, someone helped. That's how historians read the Gospels. They expect the details to differ, and they look hard at where everyone agrees.
Memory worked differently then
Most people in Jesus's world couldn't read. Teaching was learned by heart and passed on by mouth.
In the early 100s, a called Papias collected what he could from people who had known Jesus's first followers.10
One of them told him that Mark had been 's interpreter, and wrote down what he remembered of what Jesus said and did, as Peter had taught it: accurately, but not in order.10
That's a chain: Peter, then Mark, then an older church leader, then Papias. And Papias's own books are lost. We only have these lines because a later historian quoted them.10 So the link to Peter is an early report, not a proof.
The strongest objection
The sharpest case on the other side comes from Bart Ehrman. He grew up an evangelical Christian and is now an agnostic.14 He's a Bible scholar and a bestselling critic of how far the Gospels can be trusted.13
In Jesus Before the Gospels he gathers research on memory. Anthropologists who studied oral traditions in Yugoslavia, Rwanda and Ghana found that stories always change as they are passed along.13
Psychologists have shown how easily people form false memories, and legal research shows how often eyewitnesses get things wrong.13
So, Ehrman argues, the Gospels can't simply be trusted as eyewitness reports. Some of what they say may be memories that shifted on the way.13
He has a point: the Gospels aren't word-for-word records. The real question is whether the heart of the story survived.
Here's the direct reply. Memory research is mostly about details drifting: who stood where, and what words were said.
The Gospels' biggest claims don't rest on one person's memory of a detail. Jesus was , and his followers said they'd seen him alive.
Within about 25 years was passing those on as a fixed summary, naming people who were still alive to be asked.16
Not every scholar agrees with him about memory. Richard Bauckham, a British Bible scholar, argues the opposite in Jesus and the Eyewitnesses (2006). The first three Gospels, he says, rest quite closely on what eyewitnesses told, and John's was written by one.15
One of his clues is names. How often each name turns up in the Gospels matches how common it was among Jews of that time, which he takes as a sign that most of the people in them were real.15
The book won prizes, and one judge said it put something of a bomb under a lot of Bible scholarship. Ehrman isn't convinced, and others have challenged the names argument.15 The memory question is still open, with serious scholars on both sides.
Luke at least tells you how he worked. He says others had written accounts based on eyewitnesses, so he looked into everything carefully and wrote it down in order.9 That doesn't prove he got everything right. But it shows he was trying to report, not invent.
Luke's preface also shows where the dinner-table picture has a limit. The Gospel writers weren't four old friends at one table, and not all of them saw it themselves. The Catholic Bible's own notes say one of Luke's sources was Mark's Gospel.4 So where Luke and Mark agree, it isn't always two separate memories.
What they all agree on
Now line the four up and see what they share. Jesus was crucified, executed on a Roman cross, and buried. All four say women found the tomb empty early on Sunday morning. Three tell of his followers seeing him alive again.6,7,8
Mark's Gospel ends sooner. But even there, the young man at the tomb tells the women: He has been raised. And he promises: there you will see him, as he told you.6
The details wobble, but the spine of the story doesn't.
History, told by believers
The Catholic Church holds that the Gospels are real history, written by believers who chose how to tell it. In 1965 the said they faithfully hand on what Jesus , while living among men, really did and taught.1
The adds that the writers selected certain of the many elements which had been handed on, and explained some of them for the churches they wrote for.2 So Catholics expect the four to differ.
Then how can the Bible be without error, with one angel at the tomb in one Gospel and two men in another?
Here's the Catholic answer in plain words. Whatever the writers really meant to teach, God stands behind it. So the first job is to work out what each one meant.
In the Council's own words: everything asserted by the inspired authors or sacred writers must be held to be asserted by the .1
The Holy Spirit here means God himself, at work in the writers. So what they assert, God asserts. And so, the Council says, Scripture teaches without error that truth which God wanted put into sacred writings, for the sake of .1
In other words, the question is what each writer was really asserting, and why: to teach about God, and how to reach life with him. The Council also told readers to notice what kind of writing each book is, and the customs of its time.1
To be fair, many Christians, evangelical Protestants among them, hold the Bible's accuracy more strictly, down to every detail. Catholics believe it's without error too, but they don't read the four tomb accounts like police statements that must give the same headcount. They read it this way because they believe that's how the texts themselves were written.
So a Catholic can admit the details differ without the heart of the story falling. They're the kind of differences honest retellings leave behind. In the Council's words, the writers told us the honest truth about Jesus.1
Sources16
- 1Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum (18 November 1965), 11, 12 and 19The Gospels' historical character, literary forms, and truth "for the sake of salvation".
- 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 126The three stages in the formation of the Gospels.
- 3New American Bible, Introduction to Mark (on vatican.va)Mark dated shortly before or shortly after AD 70.
- 4New American Bible, Introduction to Luke (on vatican.va)Luke dated by most scholars after AD 70, many proposing AD 80-90.
- 5New American Bible, Introduction to John (on vatican.va)John's final form probably AD 90-100.
- 6Mark 16, with notes (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The young man at the tomb; the notes on the Longer Ending.
- 7Luke 24 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Two men in dazzling garments at the tomb.
- 8Matthew 28 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)An angel rolls back the stone.
- 9Luke 1:1-4 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Luke's preface on eyewitnesses and careful investigation.
- 10Eusebius, Church History, book 3, chapter 39 (NPNF, New Advent)Papias on the living voice and on Mark as Peter's interpreter.
- 11Mark 14 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The Last Supper prepared as the Passover meal.
- 12John 19, with notes (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Jesus sentenced on preparation day; the note compares Mark's "third hour" with John's noon.
- 13Bart D. Ehrman, Jesus Before the Gospels (HarperOne, 2016), book page on bartdehrman.comAn agnostic scholar's case, from anthropology, psychology and legal research on memory, that oral stories change as they are passed on.
- 14NPR, Fresh Air: Bart Ehrman on How Jesus Became God (7 April 2014)Ehrman's background: a young evangelical Christian, now an agnostic historian of early Christianity.
- 15Wikipedia, Jesus and the Eyewitnesses (Richard Bauckham, 2006; 2nd ed. 2017)Bauckham's case that the Gospels rest closely on eyewitness testimony, the names argument, its awards and its critics, including Ehrman.
- 161 Corinthians 15:3-8 (New American Bible, Revised Edition, USCCB)Paul hands on the fixed summary (died, buried, raised, appeared), naming witnesses, most still living.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.