Part V · Chapter 15
Scripture before there was a bound Bible

Who decided which books are in the Bible, and how?

6 scenes · about 16 min read

The short answer

No one person, and not all at once. Churches settled it over about three centuries, mostly by reading the same books in worship. Bishops and councils later wrote the list down.

Jesus didn't hand the a . For about twenty years there was no Christian writing that has survived, only preaching. Then came letters, then the , the accounts of Jesus's life.

Most books were read everywhere early on. A handful were argued over.

The first surviving list of exactly our 27 New Testament books is a 's Easter letter from AD 367. Councils in North Africa confirmed it at the end of that century.

All Christians share those 27. The differs: Catholic Bibles have 73 books in all, most Bibles 66, and Bibles a few more than Catholic ones.

The gap is mainly seven books found in the Greek Old Testament the early Church used, but not in the Hebrew list the rabbis kept.

The Catholic Church doesn't claim to be above the . Its point is about order: the community that wrote, kept and recognised these books is older than the collection. Protestants answer that the books carry authority in themselves, and the churches only recognised it.

Follow the trail

Six stages, from preaching with nothing written down to a fixed list of books.

c. AD 30–50Historical2 min read

Twenty years of preaching, nothing written

The apostles and the first Christians

For about twenty years after Jesus, roughly AD 30 to 50, his followers had no New Testament. The apostles taught by word of mouth. Christians , met for the Lord's Supper, and passed on what the witnesses had seen.

IWhat was going on

Jesus wrote no book. He taught by speaking. He chose twelve apostles, close followers sent out to pass on what they had seen and heard.

The first Christians were Jews. Their Bible was the Jewish Scriptures, what Christians now call the Old Testament, often read in a Greek translation.

Many people who had known Jesus were still alive. If you wanted to know what he said, you could ask one of them.

IIWhat was at stake

How do you keep a message accurate when nothing is written down?

The ancient world trusted memory more than we do. Teachers had their students learn words by heart and repeat them. The question was who could be trusted to hand the message on.

IIIWhat happened

Around AD 50 , an apostle who travelled founding churches, began writing letters to them. The earliest Christian writings we have are these letters, not the Gospels.

When Paul writes to Corinth around AD 54, he uses the words of a teacher passing on a lesson. He hands on what he himself received.

It's the account of the Last Supper, Jesus's last meal with his friends, and a list of people who saw Jesus risen.

IVWhat came of it

His letters answer questions from churches that already existed. They already met on Sundays and already shared the Lord's Supper, the meal of bread and wine Jesus asked them to repeat.

So the Church wasn't built from the New Testament. The New Testament was written from inside a Church already living the faith.

VRead the source
For I received from the Lord what I also handed on to you, that the Lord Jesus, on the night he was handed over, took bread
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · 1 Corinthians 11:23 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Catholics see here the root of Tradition: the living handing-on of the faith, with Scripture written down from within it.

Protestants agree the apostles first taught out loud. They hold that what the apostles taught was then written down in Scripture. Both sides start from the same fact: preaching came first.

c. AD 50–100Historical2 min read

Paul's letters, then the Gospels

Paul, and the Gospel writers

From about AD 50 Paul wrote letters to the churches. Between about AD 65 and 100 the four Gospels, the accounts of Jesus's life, were written. Churches copied these writings by hand and passed them from one to another.

IWhat was going on

Paul's letters date from about AD 50 to the early 60s. Most scholars date the four Gospels to between AD 65 and 100. Mark is usually counted first, and John last.

There was no printing. Every copy was written out by hand. Churches lent letters to each other. Paul tells the church at Colossae to swap letters with the church in nearby Laodicea.

IIWhat was at stake

As the eyewitnesses grew old and died, their words had to be kept somehow.

At the same time other writings were appearing, some claiming an apostle's name. How could a church tell which writings carried the apostles' teaching?

IIIWhat happened

The Second Letter of , one of the New Testament's letters, speaks of all Paul's letters. It admits some things in them are hard to understand, and sets them alongside the other scriptures.

That letter is one of the latest in the New Testament, and many scholars think a follower of Peter wrote it. Either way, it shows Paul's letters being collected and treated as Scripture very early.

IVWhat came of it

By the middle of the 100s, Christians at Sunday worship read from what , a Christian teacher in Rome, called the memoirs of the apostles. They read the prophets too.

The Gospels and Paul's letters were becoming, in practice, a second set of Scriptures beside the Jewish ones.

VRead the source
as our beloved brother Paul, according to the wisdom given to him, also wrote to you, speaking of these things as he does in all his letters. In them there are some things hard to understand that the ignorant and unstable distort to their own destruction, just as they do the other scriptures.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · 2 Peter 3:15–16 (NABRE)

Why it matters

No council handed down these books. They earned their place by being read in church, week after week, from the beginning.

That's why the later lists mostly confirm what churches were already doing. The argument is about the books at the edges.

c. AD 180–300Historical2 min read

Most books agreed, a few argued over

The churches

By the late 100s the four Gospels, Acts and Paul's letters were read in churches almost everywhere. A few other books were accepted in some regions and doubted in others. Meanwhile, some teachers offered gospels of their own.

IWhat was going on

In the 140s a wealthy shipowner named Marcion taught that the God of the Old Testament wasn't the Father of Jesus. He threw out the whole Old Testament. He kept only an edited Luke and ten of Paul's letters.

Other groups, often called Gnostics, from the Greek for knowledge, offered secret gospels of their own. The churches had to say which books were theirs.

The best known today is the Gospel of Thomas: 114 sayings of Jesus, with no story of his life, death or rising. A full copy in Coptic, a language of Egypt, was dug up near Nag Hammadi in Egypt in 1945.

Scholars date its writing anywhere from about AD 60 to 250, most of them to the 100s. Almost two-thirds of its sayings resemble ones in the four Gospels; others read like Gnostic teaching.

IIWhat was at stake

Which writings truly come from the apostles and teach their faith? And who decides?

Churches judged by a few questions. Did the book come from an apostle or his circle? Was it read widely in the churches? Did it match the faith they had always been taught?

IIIWhat happened

Around 180 Irenaeus, bishop of Lyon in Gaul, today's France, argued there are exactly four Gospels, no more and no fewer.

A list now called the Muratorian fragment names most of our New Testament. It's usually dated to about 170, though some scholars date it later.

It says the Shepherd of Hermas, an early Christian book, may be read, but not in public worship, because it was written recently.

IVWhat came of it

Around 325 the church historian Eusebius sorted the books into three groups: acknowledged, disputed and rejected.

Paul's fourteen letters, he said, were undisputed, though some in Rome doubted Paul wrote Hebrews.

James, 2 Peter, 2 and 3 John, Jude and Revelation were still doubted in some places. The Shepherd was dropped from the lists.

Eusebius set the Gospels of Thomas, Peter and Matthias below even the rejected books, and gave his reasons.

No church writer in the long line of teachers had thought them 'worthy of mention'. Their style was 'at variance with apostolic usage', and their teaching out of step with the faith the churches had received.

VRead the source
All scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for refutation, for correction, and for training in righteousness
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · 2 Timothy 3:16 (NABRE)

Why it matters

The canon, the official list of books, wasn't decided overnight, and the record is honest about that. The core was settled early; the edges took time.

Catholics see the whole Church working it out together, guided by the . Protestants see the churches recognising books that already had authority in themselves.

AD 367Historical2 min read

The first list that matches ours

Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria

In AD 367 , bishop of Alexandria in Egypt, sent his yearly Easter letter to the churches. In it he listed the books of the Bible. It's the first surviving list of exactly our 27 New Testament books.

IWhat was going on

Athanasius was bishop of Alexandria, one of the great churches of the East. He was sent into exile five times for defending the Council of Nicaea's teaching that Jesus is fully God. That was a great meeting of bishops in 325.

Each year the bishop of Alexandria wrote a Festal Letter, a feast-day letter announcing the date of Easter to the churches of Egypt. It often carried teaching too.

IIWhat was at stake

Writings falsely using old names were going round among Egyptian Christians. Some simple believers were being led astray.

Athanasius feared they would mix such books in with the inspired Scripture. He decided to set out the list plainly.

IIIWhat happened

In his letter of 367 he listed the Old Testament books, with Baruch counted alongside . Then he listed the 27 books of the New Testament.

Other books, he added, such as Wisdom, Sirach, Esther, Judith and Tobit, weren't in the canon. But they were appointed by the Fathers to be read by new believers. The Fathers are the great teachers of the early Church.

The books invented by heretics, people teaching against the faith, should not be read at all, he said.

IVWhat came of it

His New Testament list matched the one the churches eventually agreed on everywhere.

His Old Testament list was shorter than the one the Latin Church, the Western church, later confirmed. The edges of the Old Testament stayed less settled than the New.

VRead the source
These are, the four Gospels, according to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Afterwards, the Acts of the Apostles and Epistles (called Catholic), seven … In addition, there are fourteen Epistles of Paul … And besides, the Revelation of John.
Festal Letter 39 (the list of the canonical books) · Festal Letter 39.5

Why it matters

Here is the New Testament as all Christians have it today: Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant alike.

It came to us from a bishop teaching his churches, three centuries after Jesus. No Christian today reads a New Testament the Church didn't first hand on.

AD 382–419Revealed2 min read

Councils in Africa confirm the list

Bishops in North Africa and Rome

Between 393 and 419, councils of bishops in North Africa listed the books of the Bible. Their New Testament had the same 27 books. Their Old Testament included Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach and Maccabees. They asked the bishop of Rome to confirm it.

IWhat was going on

A list linked to a synod, a church meeting, in Rome under Damasus in 382 names the books too. Scholars debate whether that list really dates from then.

Damasus also asked the scholar Jerome to revise the Latin Bible. Jerome's translation, later called the Vulgate, the common version, became the Bible of the Latin West for a thousand years.

IIWhat was at stake

The early Christians used a Greek Old Testament. It contained books that weren't in the Hebrew Bible of the Jews: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, 1 and 2 Maccabees, and parts of Esther and Daniel.

Jerome preferred the Hebrew list. Should these extra books count as Scripture?

IIIWhat happened

Councils at Hippo in 393, and at Carthage in 397 and 419, listed the books of the Bible. Their lists included those extra Old Testament books.

The council of 419 asked Boniface, bishop of Rome, to confirm the list. These were the books received from the fathers to be read in church, it said.

IVWhat came of it

The Latin Church read these books as Scripture from then on. The Council of Florence repeated the full list in 1442.

The Greek churches read them too. The Orthodox today include them in their Old Testament, though with less agreement on exactly how much authority they carry.

VRead the source
It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be included in the list of the sacred books.
Catechism of the Catholic Church (English, 2nd edition) · CCC 120

Why it matters

Catholics now call these books deuterocanonical, 'of the second canon': accepted later, but fully Scripture.

The , the official summary of Catholic teaching, says it was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings belong in the Bible.

That's the Catholic claim in one line. The Church didn't make the books holy; it recognised them.

AD 1546Revealed2 min read

Trent names every book

The Council of Trent

In 1546 the , a meeting of Catholic bishops, named every book of the Bible. The Protestant Reformers had set seven Old Testament books apart. Trent defined the full list the Western Church had used since the councils of the 390s.

IWhat was going on

The Reformers wanted every teaching tested by . So which books counted as Scripture mattered more than ever.

, who began the Reformation, followed the Hebrew Bible for the Old Testament. In his German Bible he set the extra books apart as useful reading, not equal to Scripture.

He also doubted James, which he called an epistle of straw, along with Hebrews, Jude and Revelation.

IIWhat was at stake

Some of these disputed books supported Catholic teaching. Second Maccabees, for example, describes prayer for the dead. Catholics connect that to , a final cleansing after death.

If the edges of the canon were open, so was the argument.

IIIWhat happened

On 8 April 1546, at its fourth session, the Council of Trent listed every book of the Old and New Testaments by name. The list included the deuterocanonical books, the seven disputed Old Testament books.

It declared them sacred and canonical, and condemned anyone who knowingly rejected them. It also named the Latin Vulgate as the authoritative text for the Church's teaching.

IVWhat came of it

Lutherans kept the traditional books for popular use. Later Protestant Bibles mostly dropped them, or printed them in a separate section as the Apocrypha.

The Church of England's statement of belief, the Thirty-Nine Articles, said they are read for example of life, but not to establish .

So today Catholic Bibles have 73 books and most Protestant Bibles 66. The Orthodox have a few more than Catholics.

VRead the source
And it has thought it meet that a list of the sacred books be inserted in this decree, lest a doubt may arise in any one's mind, which are the books that are received by this Synod.
Council of Trent, Session IV: Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures · Session IV, Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures

Why it matters

The Protestant historian Philip Schaff complained that Trent settled the list without critical inquiry, simply confirming traditional use. Catholics answer that confirming traditional use was exactly the point.

Whatever their Old Testament, all Christians read the same 27 books of the New, handed on by the same early Church.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church doesn't claim to be above Scripture. Dei Verbum, the 's teaching on revelation, says the opposite: the Church's teaching office serves the word of God.

The claim is this. The apostles' , the faith they handed on in words and practice, produced and kept these writings. That same Tradition is what let the Church recognise which ones came from the apostles.

Seven Old Testament books are the hard case. Protestants call them the Apocrypha, and Catholics call them . The honest history is complicated in both directions.

They're in the Septuagint, the Greek Old Testament the early Church used, and the Fathers, its great early teachers, quoted them.

The New Testament seems to echo them too. Hebrews 11 praises those who were tortured and refused release to rise to a better life, which recalls the mother and her seven sons in 2 Maccabees 7.

They weren't in the Hebrew list the rabbis settled later. Jerome doubted them, and translated them anyway.

So the easy stories on both sides are wrong. Catholics didn't add books at Trent, and Protestants didn't simply delete books in the 1500s.

Both were choosing between traditions that had lived side by side for centuries, and each chose a different one.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Protestant readers

Most hold that the books belong in the because God inspired them, not because the Church declared it. In their view, the Church discovered the list; it didn't give the books their authority.

Many follow Jerome and the Hebrew list for the Old Testament. That's why Protestant Bibles have 39 Old Testament books, not 46.

Eastern Orthodox readers

The Orthodox generally use a wider Old Testament than Catholics. It includes books such as 3 Maccabees and 151.

They have never defined the list as precisely as Trent did.

Critical scholars

Historians describe the canon, the list of books, as forming through use, not by decree. The lists record what had already become standard.

Most accept that the process was largely complete in the 300s, and that the disputes at the edges were real.

Bart Ehrman, an agnostic scholar at the University of North Carolina, goes further. In Lost Christianities he argues that early Christianity was very diverse, and that one party, which he calls the 'proto-orthodox', won out, and handed down the four Gospels as Scripture.

Catholics reply that winning is not the same as choosing. By 's day the four Gospels were already read in churches almost everywhere, while, by Eusebius's account, no teacher in the churches' own line had thought books like Thomas worth citing.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself8
Church first, then canon5 steps

This isn't a claim about who has authority. It's a claim about what came first.

You can see it in the documents themselves.

  1. The message was handed on before it was written

    Paul uses the words teachers used for passing on a tradition: he received it, and he handed it on.

    “For I received from the Lord what I also handed on to you.”
    HistoricalSacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition)1 Corinthians 11:23 (NABRE)
  2. Letters were already being collected and misread

    The Second Letter of Peter treats Paul's letters as a known collection, and as Scripture.

    “speaking of these things as he does in all his letters … just as they do the other scriptures.”
  3. A settled list appears only in 367

    It appears in a bishop's letter to his churches about the date of Easter. It isn't a formal ruling on doctrine.

    “These are fountains of salvation, that they who thirst may be satisfied with the living words they contain … Let no man add to these, neither let him take ought from these.”
  4. The Catholic explanation of how

    The Catechism describes Tradition as the way the books were recognised. It isn't a rival source beside Scripture.

    “It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be included in the list of the sacred books.”
  5. And a defined list in 1546

    Trent made its list because the question had been reopened, not because it had never been settled.

    “a list of the sacred books be inserted in this decree, lest a doubt may arise in any one's mind.”
Questions people ask next