From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/children-communion-order
← OrthodoxWhy do Catholic children wait for Communion and confirmation?
Read it as an illustrated story · 6 minBecause Western, or Latin, Catholics give first once a child can begin to reason, at about seven, and usually keep confirmation for the , who can't be at every . The Catholic Church calls the Eastern way, all three at once for babies, ancient and rightful.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 1233, 12441290–12921306–1308
- Code of Canon Law
- canons 891, 913–914
- Vatican II
- Orientalium Ecclesiarum, 12–14
Go to an baptism and you'll see something beautiful. The baby is baptised, anointed with holy oil and given Communion, all in one go.1 That anointing, chrismation, is the same Catholics call confirmation.1
Now picture the Catholic cousin: baptised as a baby, but waiting until about seven for Communion, and longer still for confirmation. To an Orthodox family it can look like the West broke baptism into pieces.1
So is the Catholic child missing out?
One welcome in three parts
The Catholic Church teaches that baptism, confirmation and Communion belong together. They're three parts of one welcome into the Christian life.
Without the other two, baptism is certainly valid and efficacious, real and working, but the welcome remains incomplete.2
But no Catholic child is left outside while waiting. The says the of baptism doesn't need anything added later to be real.2
And here's what surprises people: the Catholic Church agrees with more of the Orthodox view than you'd expect. Its Catechism says that early on, confirmation and baptism were usually one single celebration.3
Babies once received Communion in the West too. In Rome it was still the normal practice until the 1100s, a drop from the cup. Then it slowly died out as lay people stopped receiving from the cup, though some places kept it until the 1500s. No banned it.4
Why the West split them
The reason was practical before it was theological.
Babies were baptised all year round, and a bishop couldn't be at every baptism.3
The East let the parish priest do the anointing, using oil a bishop had blessed. The West kept the anointing for the bishop himself, so it came later, whenever he visited.3
Think of it like this
Think of a wedding. Some couples do it all in one day: the ceremony in the morning, a big dinner at night, everyone they love in one room.
Other couples marry quietly first, then hold the big celebration months later. Maybe the grandparents live overseas and need time to fly in. The couple wants them there, so they wait.
Are the second couple any less married in the months between? Of course not. They were married the day of the ceremony. The party just comes when the whole family can gather around the same table.
Same marriage, different timing. The East does it all on one day. The Latin Church waits, the way a couple waits for the grandparents, so the bishop can be there.
The Catechism says each way protects something real. The East shows more clearly that the three belong together as one. The West shows more clearly each new Christian's bond with the bishop.3
Catholics and the Orthodox both see each bishop as a successor of the , so that bond links the child back to the very first Christians.3
Why seven for Communion?
The wait for Communion has a different reason from the bishop's visit. The Latin Church wants a child to know who they're receiving.6
Over the centuries, local customs pushed first Communion later and later: ten, twelve, even fourteen.5
In 1910 Rome set it at the age of discretion, which it defined as the time a child begins to reason, about seven.5 It blamed the delays on a strict movement that treated Communion as a reward rather than a remedy.5 In other words, Communion is medicine, not a prize for being good.
Church law today calls that same point the use of reason. Children who reach it are prepared, make their first confession, then receive Communion as soon as possible.6
They need to understand who is according to their capacity, meaning as well as a child can, and receive him with faith and devotion.6 A child in danger of death can receive sooner, if they can tell Christ's body from ordinary food and receive it reverently.6
Confirmation, the law says, also comes at about the age of discretion. But a country's bishops may set another age. It can also come sooner in danger of death, or when the minister judges a serious reason calls for a different time.6 That's why it varies so much from place to place.
The Eastern way isn't second best
The Catechism says the Eastern Churches give Communion to all the newly baptized and confirmed, even little children. They're remembering Jesus's words: Let the children come to me.7
The praised the ancient discipline of the sacraments in the .8
It even asked that the old Eastern way of confirming be fully restored: their priests confirm, with holy oil blessed by a patriarch or bishop.8
So is the Catholic child missing out? No. The child is already fully God's. The Latin Church spreads the welcome over a few years. The East gives it all at once.
Sources8
- 1Orthodox Church in America, ChrismationChrismation is always given with baptism, and Communion follows at once, for infants as for adults; Western churches often separate them.
- 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1306–1308Baptism, confirmation and Eucharist form a unity; baptismal grace is complete in itself.
- 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1290–1292Why East and West differ on confirmation, and what each practice expresses.
- 4Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), Communion of ChildrenInfant Communion in the early Church; Tours (813); the years of discretion after Lateran IV.
- 5Sacred Congregation of the Discipline of the Sacraments, Quam Singulari (1910), under Pius XFirst Communion at about seven; delays of ten to fourteen years corrected.
- 6Code of Canon Law, canons 891, 913–914Age for confirmation; preparation of children for first Communion.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1233, 1244Eastern rites give all three sacraments to infants; the Latin Church waits for the age of reason.
- 8Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (21 November 1964), 12–14The ancient Eastern discipline of the sacraments confirmed; priests confirm with chrism.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.