The Orthodox allow a second marriage. Why does Rome only give annulments?
Because the Catholic Church reads Jesus's words as ruling out a new marriage while the first husband or wife is alive. An annulment isn't a divorce: it finds that a true marriage never began. The Orthodox, out of mercy, allow a second marriage with repentance.
Part 1 · Why it sounds strange
Picture a couple married twenty years, with kids, now going their separate ways.
Then a Catholic church court, set up to look into marriages, tells them their marriage never existed.
The are one of the three main branches of Christianity, with Catholics and Protestants.
To many Orthodox, that sounds strange, even a bit dishonest. It can sound like Catholic divorce with paperwork.
Their own practice is different, and it isn't careless. For the Orthodox Church, only a first marriage carries the full meaning.
But sometimes a marriage truly breaks. Then, after repentance and confession of , the Orthodox Church allows a second marriage, with its own service.
The Orthodox call this oikonomia, a Greek word for running a household.
It means keeping the strict rule, but applying it with mercy for the person in front of you.
In 2013 Francis, the head of the Catholic Church, was talking to reporters on his flight home from Brazil.
He said of the Orthodox: they give a second chance, they allow it.
And Catholics haven't always been fair about this. An old Catholic encyclopedia called the Eastern way more and more lax.
But the Orthodox see a broken marriage as falling short of what Jesus asks.
*The second wedding comes through penance, not as a party.* Penance means sorrow for what went wrong, and turning back to God.
Part 2 · How the Orthodox do it
There's a step before that second wedding that many people don't know about. The Orthodox Church grants its own church divorce first.
A divorce from the state's courts isn't enough on its own.
In the Greek Orthodox Church in Australia, for example, the priest must first exert every effort to reconcile the couple.
The Russian Orthodox Church calls divorce a sin that brings great suffering, above all to children.
Jesus named only one reason, adultery, meaning being unfaithful. But the Russian Church accepts a few others where the marriage is already destroyed.
Among them are abandonment, a threat to the other's life, and addiction to drink or drugs.
Even then, it isn't automatic. A church divorce cannot be given to satisfy a whim.
The marriage must already be past saving.
And the second marriage isn't the same for everyone. The one who wasn't at fault may marry again.
The one at fault may remarry only after repentance and a penance. A third marriage is allowed only in exceptional cases, with a longer penance.
So the Orthodox Church, through its own courts, accepts that a marriage has died, and allows a new one, out of mercy.
That's the one step the Catholic Church believes no church may take.
Part 3 · Why Catholics only give annulments
Why won't the Catholic Church do the same? It goes back to Jesus himself. He said:
Whoever divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery against her.
So the Catholic Church holds that a true marriage between two Christians can't be ended by any human power.
Once they've come together as husband and wife, only death ends it.
To be fair, Rome does dissolve a few marriages: if the couple never slept together after the wedding, or if they weren't both baptised.
The Church sees those as rare cases of a bond that wasn't yet complete. A completed one, it holds, only death can end.
And Rome, meaning the pope and the Catholic Church, has long been careful with the Orthodox over this.
In 1563 the , a meeting of Catholic , ruled that adultery doesn't end a marriage.
But it worded the ruling so it didn't condemn the Eastern practice directly.
Envoys from Venice, which then ruled Greek islands such as Crete, said that was out of regard for the Greeks, the Orthodox Christians living there.
Why so firm? Because Catholics believe a marriage isn't only a promise two people make. God himself seals it.
The , the Catholic Church's official summary of its beliefs, says that bond can never be undone.
It says the Church does not have the power to go against it. So *Catholics don't refuse oikonomia* out of hardness.**
They believe the bond belongs to God, so no church can set it aside, even out of mercy.
So what can the Catholic Church do? It can ask whether a true bond ever formed.
For an annulment, a church court looks back at the wedding day itself.
Maybe one of them couldn't truly consent, freely and knowingly, or was tricked about something serious.
It doesn't say the love was fake. It says the bond never formed. If the court finds that, both are free to marry.
And what happens to the children?
In church law they stay legitimate, as long as at least one of the two married in good faith, honestly believing the marriage was real.
Here's an analogy that might help, and it starts with something both Churches agree on.
When a husband dies, his widow is free to marry again. Nobody says her first marriage wasn't real.
It's still part of her story, and she still grieves it. But death ended it, and both Churches say she may start again.
The Orthodox say a marriage can also die while both are alive: when the love, the trust and the life together are gone for good.
Then the Orthodox Church doesn't end the marriage.
It recognises a death that has already happened, grieves it, and out of mercy allows a new start.
An annulment is a different finding. It doesn't say a marriage died.
It says a true bond never formed on the wedding day, though the love may have been real.
Catholics believe only death ends a true marriage: a bond God has made can't be broken by any human power, not even the Church's.
So for Catholics a broken marriage is a deep wound, not a death.
A church court can only look back at the wedding day, and ask whether the bond was ever there.
Part 4 · Where that leaves people
To be honest, the system has had real problems. The courts were slow and costly, and some worried annulments came too easily.
In 2015 Pope Francis made annulments simpler and faster, and asked that it be free of charge where possible.
What about Catholics who remarry without an annulment? The Catechism says the new union cannot be recognized as valid if the first marriage was.
As a rule, they don't receive , the holy bread and wine at , while that situation lasts.
In 2016 Pope Francis opened a careful path, for some cases, after guidance from a priest. It's never automatic.
But the Church insists they aren't cut off.
asked pastors to tell apart someone unjustly abandoned from someone who wrecked their own marriage.
And John Paul II asked pastors to help divorced people know they can and must share in her life, the life of the Church.
This matters when families mix. Say an Orthodox Christian with a church divorce wants to marry a Catholic.
The Catholic Church still sees that first marriage as real, so a Catholic church court would first look at it, before any new wedding.
So Catholics and Orthodox agree that marriage is for life, and that a broken marriage is a wound.
Where they differ is what the Church may do afterwards.
For Catholics, mercy can examine a marriage, heal the people in it and welcome them.
But it can't undo a bond God made.
Think back to the widow. What do Catholics and Orthodox actually disagree on?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 13
- Orthodox Church in America, Marriage · One marriage as the ideal; a penitential service of second marriage; mixed marriages.
- Pope Francis, press conference on the flight from Rio de Janeiro (28 July 2013) · The Orthodox follow oikonomia and give a second chance.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), Divorce · Trent's definition and its milder wording out of regard for the Greeks; an older Catholic view of Eastern practice.
- Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia, Divorce · The priest must try to reconcile the couple; the Spiritual Court grants an ecclesiastical divorce, needed before a second or third marriage.
- Russian Orthodox Church, The Basis of the Social Concept (2000), X.3 · Divorce as sin; the 1918 grounds and later additions; church divorce and the conditions for a second or third marriage.
- Code of Canon Law, canons 1061, 1095–1098, 1137, 1141 · Grounds that prevent consent; a consummated sacramental marriage ends only by death; children of a marriage entered in good faith are legitimate.
- Mark 10:11–12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus on divorce and remarriage.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1640 · The bond is established by God; the Church has no power to dissolve it.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1629 · A church tribunal can declare that a marriage never existed.
- Pope Francis, Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus (15 August 2015) · The reform of nullity cases: a briefer process before the bishop, free of charge where possible.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1650–1651 · The divorced and civilly remarried, and the care owed to them.
- John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio (22 November 1981), 84 · Discernment between situations; the divorced remain part of the Church's life.
- Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia (19 March 2016), 305 and note 351 · Discernment for the divorced and civilly remarried: 'in certain cases, this can include the help of the sacraments'.