Full text
Orthodox · About 6 min ·  · Mary and the life to come

Do Catholics believe Mary died, like the Orthodox Dormition?

The short answer

Most Catholic tradition says yes, though Catholics aren't required to believe it. The 1950 definition says Mary was taken body and soul into heaven, and leaves open whether she died first. In 1997 Pope John Paul II taught that she did.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · One feast, two names

Every year on 15 August, Catholics and both keep a great feast of Mary. A feast is a holy day.

Some Orthodox Churches, like those of Russia, Serbia and Jerusalem, still use the old calendar from Roman times, the Julian calendar.

They keep the feast on their 15 August, which falls on 28 August on today's calendar.

The Orthodox call it the Dormition, which means falling asleep.

Many prepare for it with two weeks of fasting: cutting back on food, as a way of praying.

Catholics usually call it the : Mary taken up into , to be with God.

The Orthodox belief is clear. Mary truly died, like everyone does, and then her Son raised her up.

Their hymns proclaim it, and so does the Dormition icon, a painted holy image.

In that icon Mary lies on her deathbed, with the gathered round.

In the middle stands , her Son, holding her soul like a newborn wrapped in cloth.

Many people think the Catholic version says Mary never died at all. Some Catholic theologians, scholars of the faith, did teach that.

It's called the immortalist view, and before 1950 it had serious defenders.

But in 1997 , the leader of the Catholic Church, said the idea was unknown until the 17th century.

The older tradition, East and West, is that Mary died.

Part 2 · What 1950 actually said

The Catholic Church teaches that Mary was taken up, body and soul, into heaven.

Pius XII declared it on 1 November 1950 as a , a belief every Catholic must hold:

the Immaculate Mother of God, the ever Virgin Mary, having completed the course of her earthly life, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory.
Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1 November 1950), 44

Immaculate means free from from her very first moment, and ever Virgin means a virgin all her life. Both are titles Catholics give Mary.

Now look closely at the words having completed the course of her earthly life.

They don't say after she died. They don't say without dying. They were chosen with care.

John Paul II explained that Pius XII did not intend to deny the fact of her death.

Pius XII just didn't make her death a belief every Catholic must hold.

The world's , meeting at the in the 1960s, kept the same wording.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of the scoreboard at the end of a big match.

The lights go down, the crowd heads home, and the board still says 2–1. That's all it says.

It's short and a little dry, and it proves one thing: who won.

It doesn't say how the winning goal came. Was it a header, or a penalty in the last minute?

Nobody reads it and decides there was no goal. The scoreboard just wasn't built to answer that question, and it doesn't need to.

The fans still know the story.

Ask your grandfather, who was in the stadium that day, and he'll tell you every detail, whether you asked for them or not.

Pius XII's definition works the same way.

It records where Mary is now, and leaves the how to the Church's memory.

Part 3 · A pope said she died

And that memory says she died. In his 1997 talk, John Paul II said the ideas that would spare Mary a natural death seem groundless.

Then he went further: no death can ever be so fittingly described as a "dormition" as hers.

He leaned on the great teachers of the East.

One of them, St John of Damascus, asked why Mary's body should die at all. He answered:

To be clothed in immortality, it is of course necessary that the mortal part be shed, since even the master of nature did not refuse the experience of death.
St John of Damascus, quoted by John Paul II, General Audience (25 June 1997)

Immortality means a life that never ends, and the master of nature is Jesus himself.

Rome itself once called the feast the Dormition.

Pius XII's own 1950 document recalls an early pope ordering processions, prayer walks through the streets, for the Dormition of the Virgin Mary.

So the two feasts are one feast with two names.

Part 4 · Why it matters that she died

John Paul II gave the old reason: The Mother is not superior to the Son who underwent death.

To share in his rising, Mary first shared in his death.

Orthodox hymns say the same: Neither the tomb, nor death, could hold the Theotokos.

And this is the beautiful part. The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, calls the Assumption a share in her Son's rising.

It also calls it an anticipation of the resurrection of other Christians: a first look at what's coming for them too.

What happened to Mary is what Christians hope for themselves: death, then rising with Christ.

Part 5 · Do Catholics fast before it?

So do Catholics fast before it, like the Orthodox? Most don't today, but for centuries they kept 14 August as a fast day.

Since 1966 the only fast days everywhere for Western Catholics are Ash Wednesday, the start of , and Good Friday.

Each country's bishops can fill in the details, so it's worth checking your own.

Eastern Catholics, whose Churches worship the Eastern way in union with the pope, often keep the same two-week Dormition fast as the Orthodox.

Part 6 · What's still different

To be honest, one real difference is left: how a belief becomes binding, something every member must hold.

For Catholics, Pius XII's definition is a dogma. To deny it is to fall away from the Catholic faith.

The Orthodox have never turned the Dormition into a formal definition. They hold it in their worship: the hymns, the icon, the feast.

Their teachers say openly that it doesn't rest on verses or history books: there are no biblical or historical sources for this feast.

It rests on the Church's living tradition, the faith handed down, which for them carries real weight.

So the answer is yes. A Catholic can say it with the Orthodox: she fell asleep, and her Son raised her.

Catholics are free to believe it, a pope has taught it, and the 1950 words were chosen so as not to rule it out.

Quick check

Think back to the scoreboard that says 2–1. What does it tell you about how the winning goal was scored?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 10
  1. Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 2: Dormition of the Theotokos · The Orthodox belief: Mary truly died and was raised by her Son.
  2. John Paul II, General Audience, "Mary and the human drama of death" (25 June 1997) · The definition left Mary's death open; the Pope teaches that she died.
  3. Pius XII, Munificentissimus Deus (1 November 1950) · The definition, the Dormition feast in Rome, the Eastern Fathers, and its binding force.
  4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 966 · The Assumption as a share in Christ's Resurrection and a pledge of ours.
  5. OrthodoxWiki, Dormition of the Theotokos · Koimisis, falling asleep; kept on 15 August after fourteen days of fasting; no biblical or historical sources for the feast.
  6. Wikipedia, Dormition of the Mother of God · Koimesis; the two-week fast kept by Orthodox and Eastern Catholics; the icon of Christ holding Mary's soul.
  7. Russian Wikipedia, Успение Пресвятой Богородицы (Uspenie, the Dormition) · The Russian name of the feast.
  8. Frederick Holweck, "Eve of a Feast", Catholic Encyclopedia (1909) · The vigil of the Assumption; in the United States one of four vigils kept as fast days.
  9. Paul VI, Paenitemini (17 February 1966), norms II and VIII · Fast days reduced to Ash Wednesday and Good Friday; the Eastern Churches set their own fasts.
  10. Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 1250–1253 · Fasting on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday; each bishops' conference may set more.