Why do Catholics keep the bones of dead people under their altars?
5 scenes · about 14 min read
Because the first Christians did. They kept the bones of their , people killed for their faith, and met at their graves. Later, churches set their altars over those graves.
The earliest record is usually dated to about AD 155, though the scholar Candida Moss puts it around 200 or later. The church of Smyrna, in today's Turkey, wrote about the death of its . They collected his bones, called them more precious than jewels, and planned to keep the day each year.
The same letter answers an objection some Protestants would raise fourteen centuries later. The pagan authorities worried the Christians would start worshipping Polycarp. The Christians replied that they adore and love the martyrs as his .
So the line Catholics draw between worship and honour isn't a later excuse. It's in the earliest account of a martyr's death we have. Popular devotion has sometimes blurred that line, and fake were a real scandal.
Four scenes of Christians dying for their faith, and one of the practice that grew around them.
The first Christian killed for his faith
Stephen, in Jerusalem
A few years after Jesus's death, Stephen, one of his early followers in Jerusalem, was stoned for what he preached. The book of Acts says he died praying for his killers, as Jesus had. A young man named Saul minded the killers' coats.
IWhat was going on
A few years after Jesus's death, his followers in Jerusalem were still Jews. They prayed at the Temple, the centre of Jewish worship, and met in homes.
Some spoke Aramaic, the local language. Others were Greek-speaking Jews who had come from abroad.
The Greek speakers complained that their widows were being missed in the daily share of food. So the chose seven men to run it. Stephen was one of the seven.
The story is told in the Acts of the Apostles, Luke's history of the first Christians. Stephen also preached, and argued with members of the Greek-speaking synagogues, Jewish meeting houses, in the city.
IIWhat was at stake
His opponents brought him before the Sanhedrin, the Jewish high in Jerusalem. Witnesses claimed he had said Jesus would destroy the Temple and change the customs gave.
For his hearers the Temple was where God lived among his people. Talk of changing it struck at the heart of their faith.
This was an argument among Jews about a Jewish , the rescuer God had promised.
IIIWhat happened
Stephen answered with a long speech retelling Israel's history. He ended by charging his hearers with resisting God, as their ancestors had resisted the prophets.
Then he said he saw Jesus standing at God's right hand.
They threw him out of the city and stoned him. He died praying for the people killing him, as Jesus had on the cross. The witnesses left their cloaks at the feet of a young man named Saul.
IVWhat came of it
Acts says a harsh persecution of the Jerusalem church began that day. Believers scattered through Judea and Samaria, the lands around Jerusalem, and took the message with them.
Saul joined in the persecution. A few years later he became a follower of Jesus himself: the apostle .
VRead the source
As they were stoning Stephen, he called out, “Lord Jesus, receive my spirit.” Then he fell to his knees and cried out in a loud voice, “Lord, do not hold this sin against them”; and when he said this, he fell asleep.
Why it matters
Stephen is remembered as the first Christian martyr, from the Greek word for a witness. A martyr is someone whose death testifies to what they believe. Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants all honour him as the first.
Luke tells it so that Stephen's death mirrors Jesus's. From the start, Christians saw martyrdom not as heroics but as following Christ all the way, forgiveness included.
A bishop who asked not to be rescued
Ignatius, on the road to Rome
Around AD 107 , bishop of Antioch in Syria, was taken under guard to Rome to die in the arena. On the way he wrote to the Christians of Rome, who might have saved him, and begged them not to try.
IWhat was going on
Ignatius was bishop, the leading pastor, of Antioch in Syria. It was the city where Jesus's followers were first called Christians.
Under the emperor Trajan he was arrested and sent to Rome to die in the arena. Ten soldiers guarded him on the long road west. He called them leopards.
Churches along the way came out to meet him. At Smyrna he stayed with its bishop, Polycarp. He wrote seven letters on the journey: six to churches and one to Polycarp.
IIWhat was at stake
Rome didn't hunt Christians as a policy. Around 112 Trajan told a governor not to search them out, and to ignore accusations that came without a name.
But a Christian who was accused and refused to honour the gods and the emperor's image could be executed. To Romans the gods kept the empire safe. Refusing them looked like disloyalty and stubbornness, a danger to everyone.
Ignatius knew the church at Rome might use its influence to save him. He feared it would.
IIIWhat happened
His Letter to the Romans asks them to do nothing. He wanted his death to be his last witness to Christ, not something to escape by pulling strings.
He pictures himself as wheat ground by the beasts' teeth into pure bread for Christ. The picture comes from the , the bread of the Lord's Supper.
IVWhat came of it
Early writers say he died in Rome under Trajan, around 107 to 110. His letters were collected and copied, and the church historian Eusebius had them in the 300s.
Some readers, then and now, worry that he seems to want death. But he didn't hand himself in. He was arrested, and he asked only that no one buy his way out.
VRead the source
I am the wheat of God, and let me be ground by the teeth of the wild beasts, that I may be found the pure bread of Christ.
Why it matters
His letters are among the earliest Christian writings outside the . They show churches led by a bishop, with priests and , within a lifetime of the apostles.
They also show what martyrdom meant to the first Christians: not defeat, but becoming like Christ in his death. Orthodox, Catholic and scholars still read him for both reasons.
An old bishop won't curse the Christ he served
Polycarp, in the stadium at Smyrna
Around AD 155 in Smyrna, in today's Turkey, a crowd demanded the death of Polycarp, the city's old bishop. The governor offered to free him if he cursed Christ. Polycarp said he had served Christ eighty-six years, and would not.
IWhat was going on
Polycarp was bishop of Smyrna, today İzmir in Turkey. , a later bishop who listened to him as a boy, says Polycarp had been taught by the apostles. He was a living link to the first generation.
Around 155 a wave of hostility hit Smyrna. Other Christians had already been thrown to the beasts when the crowd started shouting for Polycarp.
IIWhat was at stake
The crowd called Christians atheists, because they refused the city's gods. To them that was an insult to the powers that kept Smyrna safe.
The governor didn't want to kill an old man. He offered a way out: swear by the emperor's fortune, call the Christians atheists, and curse Christ.
IIIWhat happened
Friends had persuaded Polycarp to leave the city for a farmhouse nearby. Someone from his own household, under torture, gave away where he was. The police took him to the stadium.
He wouldn't curse Christ or swear by the emperor. The crowd demanded fire. When the flames didn't kill him, an executioner stabbed him.
The church of Smyrna wrote down what happened in a letter. It went to the church at Philomelium, a town inland, and to every church.
IVWhat came of it
The letter, the Martyrdom of Polycarp, is the oldest account of a Christian martyr outside the New Testament.
It's careful about one thing. It tells of Quintus, who pushed himself and others forward for trial. Then he lost his nerve at the sight of the beasts, and sacrificed.
The church didn't praise those who handed themselves in, because the doesn't teach it.
VRead the source
Eighty and six years have I served Him, and He never did me any injury: how then can I blaspheme my King and my Saviour?
Why it matters
Polycarp joins the apostles' generation to the later Church. He was taught by those who had known Jesus, and died for him well over a century after the cross.
His answer became the pattern for martyrs after him: loyalty to a person, not only to a cause. Christians of every tradition still tell his story.
A young mother and a slave die together
Perpetua and Felicity, at Carthage
In AD 203 in Carthage, North Africa, Perpetua, a young mother, and Felicity, a pregnant slave, were arrested for their faith. Perpetua kept a diary in prison. It tells how her father begged her to think of her baby, and how she refused.
IWhat was going on
Carthage, in today's Tunisia, was one of the great cities of Roman Africa, with a large church. In 203 the emperor was Septimius Severus. Games were planned for the birthday of his son Geta.
Vivia Perpetua was about 22, well born and educated, married, with a baby son she was still nursing. She was a catechumen, someone preparing for . Her father wasn't a Christian.
Arrested with her were Felicity, an enslaved woman eight months pregnant, and Revocatus, also a slave. Two young men were taken too. Their teacher Saturus later gave himself up to share their fate.
IIWhat was at stake
The test was simple: offer a sacrifice for the emperors' welfare. For Romans it was a gesture of loyalty, like saluting a flag. For Christians it meant giving worship to someone other than God.
Her father begged her again and again. Refusing meant leaving her son and breaking her father's heart.
IIIWhat happened
In prison Perpetua was baptised, and kept a diary of her days and her dreams.
The governor, Hilarianus, gave her a last chance in front of her father. She said she was a Christian.
All were condemned to the beasts. In prison Felicity gave birth to a girl, and a Christian woman took the baby to raise as her own.
In the arena a wild cow tossed the two women. Perpetua, wounded, guided the trembling hand of the young gladiator to her throat.
IVWhat came of it
An editor finished her diary with an account of their deaths. Christians in Africa kept reading it for centuries. of Hippo, the great North African bishop, preached on their feast day.
Perpetua and Felicity are still named in the Roman Canon. It's one of the oldest prayers of the , the Catholic Sunday service. A slave and a noblewoman are remembered side by side.
VRead the source
‘Spare the grey hairs of your father, spare the infancy of your boy, offer sacrifice for the well-being of the emperors.’ And I replied, ‘I will not do so.’ Hilarianus said, ‘Are you a Christian?’ And I replied, ‘I am a Christian.’
Why it matters
It's one of the earliest surviving writings by a Christian woman, in her own words.
It also shows the cost plainly. Martyrdom tore families apart, and the early Church didn't hide that. It kept her father's pleading in the story.
Smyrna keeps its bishop's bones
The church of Smyrna
After Polycarp's death around AD 155, the Christians of Smyrna gathered his bones and laid them in a fitting place. They planned to meet there every year on the day he died. It's the first time we can see Christians honouring a saint's remains.
IWhat was going on
After Polycarp died, the Christians of Smyrna wanted his body. Some locals urged the governor to refuse. They said the Christians might start worshipping Polycarp instead of Christ.
The soldiers burned the body. The Christians gathered what remained of his bones.
IIWhat was at stake
This raised a question Christians still argue about. Is honouring a holy person's remains, their relics, a kind of worship?
The church of Smyrna answered in the same letter. Christ they worship as the . The martyrs they love, as his disciples who loved their King.
IIIWhat happened
They took up his bones, valued them above jewels, and laid them in a fitting place.
There they planned to gather every year on the day of his death. It was to remember those who had finished the race, and to prepare those still running it.
IVWhat came of it
Other churches did the same for their own martyrs. In Rome, Christians met at martyrs' tombs in the catacombs, underground burial galleries outside the city.
When churches were built above ground, the altar was set over a martyr's grave, or relics were placed beneath it. Catholic Church law still asks that relics of martyrs or other saints be placed under a fixed altar.
Orthodox altars carry relics too. They're sewn into the cloth on which the Eucharist, the Lord's Supper, is celebrated.
The Protestant Reformers rejected the honouring of relics. In 1543 , one of their leaders, wrote a whole work against it.
VRead the source
Accordingly, we afterwards took up his bones, as being more precious than the most exquisite jewels, and more purified than gold, and deposited them in a fitting place, whither … the Lord shall grant us to celebrate the anniversary of his martyrdom.
Why it matters
Catholics and Orthodox see in Smyrna the line they still draw: worship for God alone, honour and love for the saints.
Many Protestants honour the martyrs too, without honouring their remains.
The Anabaptists, Protestants who baptise only believers and not babies, honour them in the Martyrs Mirror of 1660. It starts with the early martyrs and goes on to Anabaptists killed by Catholic and Protestant authorities alike.
Popular devotion has sometimes blurred the line, and fake relics were a real scandal. The Smyrna letter shows the line was drawn from the start.
How early that start is depends on the letter's date. Most date Polycarp's death to about 155, with 166 the main alternative. Candida Moss suggests the letter was written around 200 or later.
Its closing note, on how the letter was copied and handed down, was added later still.
Even on the latest dating, the line is in the text by the early 300s, when the historian Eusebius copied the passage word for word. And the practice doesn't rest on one letter: Christians across the empire met at their martyrs' tombs.
Why Catholics read it this way
Catholics ask the saints to pray for them the way they'd ask a friend to pray for them. They believe the dead who belong to Christ are alive, and still in touch.
The Catholic Church has never taught that saints give , God's help, on their own, apart from Christ. Its , the official summary of its teaching, is careful to say the opposite.
The bones under the altar are a physical form of the same belief, and they come from the age of persecution.
Christians met to pray at the graves of the martyrs on the days they died, in Rome in the catacombs, the underground burial places outside the city. When churches were built above ground, the relics came with them.
Catholics draw a line between two things. Adoration, or worship, belongs to God alone. Veneration, or honour, is given to the saints.
That line is old, clear and written down in the 100s. Whether every Catholic keeps to it in practice is a fair question, and a separate one.
How others read the same evidence
Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.
Reformed and Evangelical readers
Many say asking the saints to pray for us has no basis in Scripture. They worry it can hide Christ as the one mediator, the one go-between for God and people, and cite 1 Timothy 2:5.
They also point to popular practice, which has often blurred the official line.
Eastern Orthodox readers
The honour the saints and their relics as fully as Catholics do.
They draw the same line between worship and honour. It was set out at the Second Council of Nicaea, a meeting of bishops, in 787.
Historians of religion
Some see the honouring of martyrs as a Christian version of older Mediterranean customs around heroes and the honoured dead.
Catholic historians grant that Christians shared some funeral customs with their neighbours, such as meals at the grave. What was new was the reason: the martyr was honoured as a witness to Christ, waiting to rise.
Check it yourself
Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.
Read the sources yourself7
- The church at Smyrna · c. AD 155–160 · New Advent, Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1
- Perpetua, with an anonymous editor · AD 203 · New Advent, Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 3
- Ignatius of Antioch · c. AD 107–110 · New Advent, Ante-Nicene Fathers / Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers
- Holy See · 1997 · Libreria Editrice Vaticana (vatican.va IntraText)
- 2011 · United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
- Wikipedia contributors · accessed 2026-11-03 · Wikipedia
- Eusebius of Caesarea · c. 324 · New Advent, Ante-Nicene Fathers / Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers
Veneration and worship, distinguished in 1555 steps
The objection came first from pagans, people who worshipped the Roman gods. Later it came from Protestants.
The answer has been the same since the 100s.
The worry, stated by the opponents
The authorities refused to hand over the body for one reason. They expected the Christians to start worshipping Polycarp instead of Christ.
“to go and entreat the governor not to give up his body to be buried, lest, said he, forsaking Him that was crucified, they begin to worship this one.”
The answer, in the same paragraph
The answer uses two different words for two different things. Christ they adore. The martyrs they love.
“For Him indeed, as being the Son of God, we adore; but the martyrs, as disciples and followers of the Lord, we worthily love on account of their extraordinary affection towards their own King and Master.”
The practice that followed
They kept the bones, prepared a place and planned a yearly day. The saints' days in the Catholic calendar grew from customs like this one.
“we afterwards took up his bones … and deposited them in a fitting place.”
The theology stated much later
The Catechism, the official summary of Catholic teaching, says the saints intercede: they pray to God for us. It doesn't make them a separate source of grace.
“They do not cease to intercede with the Father for us, as they proffer the merits which they acquired on earth through the one mediator between God and men, Christ Jesus.”
And canonisation defined as recognition
When the Catholic Church declares someone a saint, it claims to recognise their holiness, not to create it.
“By canonizing some of the faithful, i.e., by solemnly proclaiming that they practiced heroic virtue and lived in fidelity to God's grace, the Church recognizes the power of the Spirit of holiness within her.”