Part IV · Chapter 13
Rome vs the Christians

How dangerous was it, actually, to be a Christian?

6 scenes · about 16 min read

The short answer

It depended on where you lived and who your neighbours were. For most of three centuries, being a Christian was illegal, but Christians weren't hunted.

Around AD 112 Emperor Trajan set the rule. Officials weren't to go looking for Christians, or act on unsigned accusations. But anyone reported who wouldn't give up the faith was punished.

So a Christian could live quietly for decades, then be dead within days because a neighbour reported them.

Two persecutions across the whole empire changed the scale: under Emperor Decius in 250, and under Diocletian from 303. Some historians think far fewer people were killed than later stories of the claimed.

What's clear is that becoming a Christian bought you no money, no status and no safety. Whatever explains why the movement grew, it wasn't that joining paid off.

Follow the trail

Six documents: three by Romans, including the persecutors themselves, and three by the Christians they persecuted.

AD 64Historical2 min read

Nero blames Christians for the fire of Rome

Tacitus, a Roman historian

In July 64 a great fire destroyed much of Rome, and rumour said Emperor Nero was behind it. Nero blamed the Christians and had many put to death as public shows. , a Roman historian, recorded it about fifty years later.

IWhat was going on

In July 64 a fire burned for days and destroyed much of Rome. Rumour said Emperor Nero had wanted it, to clear space for his building plans, and the rumour wouldn't die.

Christians were a small, new group in the city. Romans had begun to see them as separate from the Jews.

IIWhat was at stake

Romans thought the gods kept the city safe, as long as everyone honoured them. People who refused the gods looked like a danger to everyone.

Christians met privately and wouldn't join public worship. They were rumoured to do shameful things at their meals. They were easy to blame and hard to defend.

IIIWhat happened

Nero accused the Christians. Tacitus says those who admitted being Christians were arrested first. On their information a large number were convicted, less for the fire than for hatred of mankind.

Nero turned their deaths into a show in his own gardens. Some were sewn into animal skins and torn apart by dogs. Some were . Some were set alight to light up the night.

IVWhat came of it

Even Romans who despised Christians began to pity them. Tacitus says it looked like one man's cruelty, not justice.

Around AD 96 , a leader of the church in Rome, wrote a letter. Christian tradition, starting from it, places the deaths of the and in Rome in these same years. The Roman church kept their graves.

As far as the sources show, this persecution was limited to the city of Rome.

VRead the source
Nero fastened the guilt and inflicted the most exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abominations, called Christians by the populace.
Annals, book 15, chapter 44 · Annals 15.44

Why it matters

From then on, being a Christian could be treated as a crime in itself.

Tacitus disliked the Christians, and still recorded what was done to them. He's a hostile witness, so his account can't be put down to Christian storytelling.

The first violence by the Roman state against Christians came from a ruler looking for someone to blame.

c. AD 112Historical2 min read

The emperor sets the rules

Emperor Trajan, writing to Pliny

Around AD 112 Pliny, a Roman governor in today's Turkey, asked Emperor Trajan how to treat Christians. Trajan replied: don't hunt them, ignore unsigned accusations, but punish those reported who won't give up the faith. That rule held for over a century.

IWhat was going on

Around AD 111 Pliny the Younger governed Bithynia and Pontus, on the Black Sea coast of today's Turkey. Someone had put out an unsigned list of people said to be Christians.

Pliny had executed those who kept admitting it. Then he wrote to Emperor Trajan to ask whether he had done right. Romans prided themselves on law, and he wanted rules, not guesswork.

IIWhat was at stake

No law spelled out what the crime was. Pliny asked: is the name Christian itself the crime, or only crimes that go with it? Does age matter? Can someone who gives it up be pardoned?

He had found no robbery and no plot. He found only people who met before dawn to sing to Christ, and promised not to steal or cheat.

The real problem was that they refused to worship the gods and the emperor's image.

IIIWhat happened

Trajan answered briefly. Don't go looking for Christians. Don't accept unsigned accusations. He called them a bad precedent, out of keeping with the times.

But if someone is reported and proven to be a Christian, punish them. If they deny it and prove it by worshipping the gods, pardon them, whatever their past.

IVWhat came of it

Trajan's answer became the pattern for about a hundred and forty years. Being a Christian was a crime, but the state didn't go looking for them.

So the danger depended on neighbours. A Christian could live quietly for decades. Then a rival, a debtor or an angry crowd could report them, and they could be dead within days.

VRead the source
They are not to be sought out; if they are denounced and proved guilty, they are to be punished, with this reservation, that whoever denies that he is a Christian and really proves it—that is, by worshiping our gods—even though he was under suspicion in the past, shall obtain pardon through repentance. But anonymously posted accusations ought to have no place in any prosecution.
Letters 10.96 (to the Emperor Trajan) · Letters 10.97

Why it matters

The test was never what you believed in private. It was one public act: a pinch of incense, a prayer to the gods, a curse on Christ.

For Christians that act meant denying Christ. So what looked like an easy way out would have cost them what they cared about most. They were refusing a small thing that meant everything to them.

c. AD 155Historical2 min read

An old bishop refuses to curse Christ

The church of Smyrna, writing about its bishop

Around AD 155 in Smyrna, in today's Turkey, a Roman governor put the old Polycarp on trial. Again and again he offered to set him free if he would curse . Polycarp refused, and was put to death.

IWhat was going on

Polycarp was bishop of Smyrna, today's İzmir on the Turkish coast. A bishop was the leader of a city's Christians.

, a later bishop who had known him when Irenaeus himself was a boy, says Polycarp had been taught by John, one of Jesus's apostles.

The church of Smyrna wrote the account as a letter to other churches, soon after his death. It's the oldest surviving account of a martyr's death outside the New Testament. A martyr is someone killed for their faith.

IIWhat was at stake

During games in the city, a crowd watched some Christians die and began shouting: Away with the atheists; find Polycarp! Christians were called atheists because they refused the gods.

Polycarp's friends talked him into hiding at a farm. He was betrayed by a young man of his own household, under torture. Armed men came for him in the evening.

He was very old. Everyone, even his captors, would have been glad to see him give in.

IIIWhat happened

He fed the men who came to arrest him and asked for time to pray. On the way into the city, officials begged him. What harm is it to say Lord Caesar, calling the emperor lord, and offer the sacrifice?

In the stadium the governor tried again. Respect your age, swear by Caesar's fortune, curse Christ, and go free.

Polycarp said he had served Christ eighty-six years. How could he curse his King and Saviour?

The governor threatened beasts, then fire. Polycarp was tied to a stake and the fire was lit. The account says the flames didn't consume him, so an executioner stabbed him.

IVWhat came of it

The church of Smyrna gathered his bones, counting them more precious than jewels. They planned to meet at his grave each year on the day he died.

The letter is careful to say Christians worship Christ alone, and love the martyrs as his . It's one of the earliest signs of keeping saints' days.

It also criticises a man named Quintus, who handed himself in and then gave way. The , it says, doesn't teach people to go looking for death.

VRead the source
Then, the proconsul urging him, and saying, Swear, and I will set you at liberty, reproach Christ; Polycarp declared, Eighty and six years have I served Him, and He never did me any injury: how then can I blaspheme my King and my Saviour?
The Martyrdom of Polycarp (Letter of the Church of Smyrna) · Martyrdom of Polycarp 9

Why it matters

The governor wasn't a monster. He kept offering a way out, and that shows what was really being asked.

What Rome asked for was small: a few words, a pinch of incense. Polycarp refused because those words meant denying Christ, not because he was against Rome. He told the governor that Christians honour rulers.

The account shows martyrdom as the Church wanted it understood. Not seeking death, not hating enemies, but not lying about Christ.

AD 203Historical2 min read

A young mother writes from prison

Perpetua, at Carthage

In AD 203 in Carthage, North Africa, a young mother named Perpetua was arrested with others preparing for . In prison she kept a diary, one of the earliest surviving texts by a Christian woman. It records the day she was sentenced.

IWhat was going on

Carthage, in today's Tunisia, was one of the great cities of Roman Africa. In 203 a group of catechumens, people preparing for baptism, were arrested there.

Among them was Vivia Perpetua, about twenty-two, well born and educated. She had a baby she was still nursing.

With her was Felicity, a slave who was eight months pregnant. Perpetua kept a diary in prison, and an editor finished the story after her death.

IIWhat was at stake

Perpetua's father was a pagan. He loved her and begged her to save herself: think of my grey hair, think of your mother, think of your son, who won't live without you.

She loved him too, and grieved that he alone in the family wouldn't be glad for her. All she had to do was offer a sacrifice for the emperors' welfare.

IIIWhat happened

She and the others were baptised while under arrest. At the hearing, her father appeared holding her baby and pulled her off the step.

The judge was Hilarianus, standing in for the governor, who had died. He pleaded too: spare your father, spare your child, sacrifice. She answered: I will not. He asked if she was a Christian. She said: I am a Christian.

All were sentenced to the wild beasts. Her father was beaten with rods in front of her, for interfering.

Felicity was afraid she would be left behind. She gave birth in prison to a baby girl a few days before the games. A Christian woman raised the child.

IVWhat came of it

In the arena the women were mauled by a cow and then killed by the sword. Perpetua helped Felicity to her feet.

Before the end the martyrs gave each other the kiss of peace, the greeting Christians still share at .

Her last recorded words were to fellow Christians at the gate: stand fast in the faith, love one another, and don't be upset by what I suffer.

VRead the source
Hilarianus said, ‘Are you a Christian?’ And I replied, ‘I am a Christian.’ … The procurator then delivers judgment on all of us, and condemns us to the wild beasts, and we went down cheerfully to the dungeon.
The Passion of the Holy Martyrs Perpetua and Felicity · The Passion of Perpetua and Felicity 6

Why it matters

Her diary is rare: a young woman in the 200s telling her own story, in her own words.

It shows what the choice cost. Refusing meant breaking a loving father's heart and leaving a baby behind.

Perpetua and Felicity are still named at Mass, the Catholic Sunday service. Their names are in the Roman Canon, the oldest form of its central prayer.

AD 250Historical2 min read

Everyone must sacrifice to the gods

Emperor Decius

In 250 Emperor Decius ordered everyone in the empire to sacrifice to the gods and get a certificate to prove it. Many Christians died rather than obey. Many others gave in, and the Church had to decide whether they could come back.

IWhat was going on

By 249 the empire was in deep trouble. Emperors came and went in quick , and armies fought each other. The Goths, a people from beyond the border, raided across the Danube.

Decius, a general, took power in 249. To win back the gods' favour, he ordered every person in the empire to sacrifice. Each had to get a signed certificate from local officials saying they had done it.

IIWhat was at stake

The order may not have been aimed at Christians at all. It asked for everyone's loyalty. But Christians were the people who couldn't give it without denying Christ.

And for the first time the rule was everywhere at once, enforced with paperwork. There was nowhere to hide and a deadline to meet.

IIIWhat happened

Fabian, the bishop of Rome, was killed early in 250. Many Christians held firm and were imprisoned, tortured or killed.

Many others gave in. , bishop of Carthage, had gone into hiding. He wrote that some ran to the market-place to sacrifice before anyone asked. Others bribed officials for a certificate without sacrificing.

Several dozen of these certificates survive on papyrus from Egypt.

IVWhat came of it

Decius was killed in battle against the Goths in 251, and the order lapsed. Then came the hard question: could the ones who gave in come back?

Councils, meetings of bishops, at Carthage and Rome said yes. First came a time of penance, showing they were sorry, judged by the bishop.

A Roman priest named Novatian said never, and set himself up as a rival bishop. The Church sided with mercy.

VRead the source
They ran to the market-place of their own accord; freely they hastened to death, as if they had formerly wished it.
On the Lapsed (De Lapsis) · On the Lapsed 8

Why it matters

The Church decided that grave after baptism can be forgiven, through the Church, after real repentance.

That decision is one root of confession today, where Catholics tell their sins to a priest and are forgiven. The form changed a lot: penance then was public and often long, and private confession spread centuries later.

The Catholic Church teaches that no sin is too serious to be forgiven ( 982).

That teaching came out of a crisis of people who were frightened and failed.

AD 311Historical2 min read

The persecutor admits he failed

Emperor Galerius

In AD 311, after the harshest persecution yet, the dying Emperor Galerius issued an official order. In it he admitted the persecution had failed, and let people be Christians again.

IWhat was going on

From 293 the empire was run by four emperors at once, under Diocletian. In February 303 they began the Great Persecution, the last and harshest.

Churches were pulled down and Scriptures burned. Christians lost their rank and legal rights. Clergy were jailed, and then everyone was ordered to sacrifice.

Lactantius was a Christian who taught Latin in Nicomedia, Diocletian's capital. He says Galerius, Diocletian's junior colleague, pushed hardest for it.

IIWhat was at stake

In the West it was over within about three years. In the East it went on for eight.

The point of it was to bring Christians back to the gods of Rome. It didn't work: churches kept meeting, and many Christians chose prison or death over sacrifice.

By 311 Galerius, now senior emperor, was dying of a painful illness.

IIIWhat happened

On 30 April 311, at Nicomedia, Galerius issued an edict, an official order. It admits the persecution had failed. Many Christians held to their faith, and now honoured neither the gods nor their own God.

So, he says, he grants them pardon. They may be Christians again and rebuild their meeting places, as long as they keep order. They should pray to their God for the emperor and the state.

Lactantius says Galerius died a few days later.

IVWhat came of it

Prisoners were freed. In the East, the emperor Maximin Daia soon started the persecution again, until his defeat in 313.

That same year and Licinius, ruling West and East, agreed at Milan on two things. Christians and everyone else could worship freely, and seized church property was to be given back.

VRead the source
because great numbers still persist in their opinions, and because we have perceived that at present they neither pay reverence and due adoration to the gods, nor yet worship their own God, therefore we, from our wonted clemency in bestowing pardon on all, have judged it fit to extend our indulgence to those men, and to permit them again to be Christians.
On the Deaths of the Persecutors, chapter 48 (the letter of Constantine and Licinius, 313) · On the Deaths of the Persecutors 34

Why it matters

The empire's strongest effort to end Christianity had failed, and the man most behind it said so in writing.

Then the story turned. Within the century Christian emperors were banning pagan sacrifice, and Christians learned to use the state's power against others.

The Catholic Church now teaches that no one may be forced in religion, because of the dignity of every person. It says so in Dignitatis Humanae, the 's teaching on religious freedom (section 2).

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church's use of these sources is narrow, and should stay narrow. Persecution doesn't prove a religion true. Plenty of people have died bravely for things that were false.

What it does show is motive.

For three centuries there was no money, rank or political power to be had from being a Christian. There were frequent, specific losses.

Whatever the first Christians were doing, they weren't doing it to get ahead.

These centuries also shaped the Church for good. Honouring the martyrs, the calendar of feast days, care for the graves of the dead, and the practice of penance all come out of this time.

The next chapter follows them.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Revisionist historians

Some historians argue the number of martyrs was far smaller than later tradition claimed. They say the persecutions came and went and were mostly local, and that the stories of the martyrs were shaped by later needs.

The sharpest form of this is Candida Moss's, a scholar, in The Myth of Persecution (2013). She argues that most martyr stories were written or heavily reworked long after the events.

The account of , usually dated soon after his death around 155, may in her view come from the next century.

Perpetua's text raises a similar question. The usual view is that the prison diary at its centre is her own, framed by an editor's opening and ending. Some think the editor shaped more than that.

The documents above agree that persecution came and went. But the ones that carry the argument here were written by the persecutors themselves: Pliny's letter, Trajan's reply, the certificates of 250 and Galerius's edict. None of them depends on how the martyr stories were edited.

Roman perspective

From the state's side, Christians refused the ordinary public duty that held the empire together.

They were also widely suspected of incest and cannibalism, because of rumours about their shared meal and the . , a Christian teacher in Rome, wrote his Apology to answer those charges. An apology here means a reasoned defence.

Protestant readers

Protestants share the same sources and honour the same martyrs as examples of faithfulness. Where many part ways is what came later: asking the martyrs to pray for us, and venerating their , the bones and belongings of saints. They hold that it draws attention away from Christ.

The next chapter takes that up directly.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself6
What the state actually required5 steps

Rome almost never asked Christians to stop believing. It asked them to do one public act: offer a sacrifice, swear by the emperor, curse Christ.

That's why their refusals tell us so much.

  1. Sacrifice, and you go free

    The same offer comes up again and again in the trial records: do this, and go free.

    “Swear by the fortune of Cæsar; repent, and say, Away with the Atheists.”
  2. A certificate would do

    Under Emperor Decius, a certificate saying you had sacrificed was enough. That's why some Christians bribed officials for one without sacrificing.

    “although they have not polluted their hands with abominable sacrifices, yet have defiled their conscience with certificates.”
    HistoricalOn the Lapsed (De Lapsis)On the Lapsed 27
  3. The charge was social, not doctrinal

    Tacitus, the Roman historian, names the charge as hatred of the human race.

    The real objection was that Christians stayed out of the public worship of the gods.

    “an immense multitude was convicted, not so much of the crime of firing the city, as of hatred against mankind.”
    HistoricalAnnals, book 15, chapter 44Annals 15.44
  4. Torture was used to check the story

    To check what Christians told him, Pliny, the Roman governor, tortured two slave women who held office in their church.

    “But I discovered nothing else but depraved, excessive superstition.”
  5. And the state could not make it stop

    The clearest proof is the edict, the official order, that Emperor Galerius issued in 311. In it, he admits the persecution had failed.

    “because great numbers still persist in their opinions … we, from our wonted clemency in bestowing pardon on all, have judged it fit to extend our indulgence to those men, and to permit them again to be Christians.”
Every claim this chapter leans on3 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Tacitus, writing about AD 116, records that Nero blamed the Christians for the fire of 64, that their name came from 'Christus' who was executed under Pontius Pilate in Tiberius's reign, and that they were killed with spectacular cruelty.

Rests on
  • Annals 15.44
    “Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus, and a most mischievous superstition, thus checked for the moment, again broke out not …”
    Read the full passage
    “Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus, and a most mischievous superstition, thus checked for the moment, again broke out not only in Judæa, the first source of the evil, but even in Rome … Covered with the skins of beasts, they were torn by dogs and perished, or were nailed to crosses, or were doomed to the flames and burnt, to serve as a nightly illumination.”
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Cyprian of Carthage records that during the Decian persecution many Christians ran to sacrifice of their own accord, and treats those who obtained certificates without sacrificing as also guilty.

Rests on
  • On the Lapsed 8
    “They ran to the market-place of their own accord; freely they hastened to death, as if they had formerly wished it.”
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-22).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Around AD 112 the Roman governor Pliny reported to the Emperor Trajan that Christians in Bithynia met on a fixed day before dawn, sang a hymn to Christ "as to a god", bound themselves by oath to avoid wrongdoing, and later reassembled to share food.

Rests on
  • “they were accustomed to meet on a fixed day before dawn and sing responsively a hymn to Christ as to a god, and to bind themselves by oath, not to some crime, but not to commit fraud, theft, or adultery ... When this was over, it was their custom to depart and to assemble again to partake of food, but ordinary and innocent food.”
Limits
  • Pliny is reporting what accused Christians told him under interrogation. He does not describe the Eucharist itself; the "food" may be the agape meal or the Eucharist.
  • The web translation is unattributed.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-21).

Questions people ask next