Part XIII · Chapter 32
The Shroud of Turin

Is the Shroud of Turin really the cloth that wrapped Jesus's body? And if science showed it was a medieval fake, would the Catholic faith fall with it?

10 scenes · about 21 min read

The short answer

No one knows for certain. The Catholic Church has never declared it genuine, and no Catholic has to believe it is. The faith wouldn't fall either: it rests on the people who saw Jesus risen, not on a cloth.

The Shroud is a linen sheet with the faint image of a man. Its known history starts in France in the 1350s, and in 1389 the local told the it had been painted.

In 1988 three laboratories dated one corner to AD 1260–1390. That is the strongest single piece of evidence. But no one agrees how the image was made, the raw results are oddly scattered, and only one corner was tested.

On the other side, two later checks found the dated corner sound. In 2010 the Arizona laboratory found no dye or repair in its sample, and a 2026 study found leftover fragments consistent with the main cloth.

So the case for the Shroud is serious but unproven. The medieval date stands until a better test replaces it. And if the cloth were shown to be medieval, nothing in the Creed would change.

Follow the trail

Ten documents trace the Shroud's story, from a linen cloth bought for a burial to three laboratories in 1988.

c. AD 33Revealed2 min read

A linen cloth bought for a burial

Joseph of Arimathea, in the Gospel of Mark

Jesus was crucified in Jerusalem around AD 33. Joseph of Arimathea, a Jewish member, bought a linen cloth, wrapped the body and laid it in a rock tomb. The four , the accounts of his life, never mention an image on the cloths.

IWhat was going on

Jesus was crucified, the Roman death for rebels and slaves. He died in the afternoon before the Sabbath, the Jewish day of rest, which began at sunset.

Jewish law required the dead to be buried quickly, and nothing could be done once the Sabbath began. There were only a few hours.

IIWhat was at stake

The bodies of crucified men were often left unburied or thrown into common graves. Jesus's followers had scattered.

Someone respected had to ask the Roman governor, , for the body, and do it fast.

IIIWhat happened

Joseph of Arimathea, a respected member of the Jewish council, went to Pilate and asked for the body. He bought a linen cloth, took Jesus down, wrapped him and laid him in a tomb cut out of rock.

John's Gospel adds that a second man, Nicodemus, brought spices. The body was bound with burial cloths, the way Jews buried their dead.

IVWhat came of it

On Easter morning, John says, Peter, the leading apostle, and the Jesus loved found the burial cloths lying in the tomb. The cloth that had covered Jesus's head was rolled up in a separate place.

The Gospels say nothing about an image on any of them. Nothing more is recorded about the cloths.

VRead the source
Having bought a linen cloth, he took him down, wrapped him in the linen cloth and laid him in a tomb that had been hewn out of the rock.
The New American Bible (vatican.va IntraText edition; 1986 revised New Testament) · Mark 15:46 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText edition)

Why it matters

Christian faith rests on the people who saw Jesus alive after his death, not on any object. Paul, an early Christian missionary, wrote the earliest summary of the Easter news. It lists people who saw Jesus risen, not a cloth.

So whether the Shroud is genuine is a question for history and science. The faith doesn't stand or fall on the answer.

1203Historical2 min read

A crusader sees a cloth in Constantinople

Robert de Clari, a knight on the Fourth Crusade

In 1203 a French knight on the Fourth Crusade saw a cloth in Constantinople. People said it was Christ's burial sheet, and the form of his body could be seen on it. It vanished when the crusaders sacked the city in 1204.

Icon of the face of Christ, long-haired and bearded, on a gold ground with a cross in the halo.
The Image Not Made by Hands, an icon of about 1100 in the Tretyakov Gallery, Moscow. Eastern tradition remembers the cloth of Edessa as bearing Christ's face, not a full body.
IWhat was going on

The Fourth Crusade was an army of Western knights that set out to win back Jerusalem. It ended up at Constantinople instead, the capital of the Byzantine Empire, the Christian empire of the East. The crusaders got tangled in the empire's politics and debts.

Constantinople held the greatest collection of , objects linked to Christ and the saints, in the Christian world. The East also honoured an image of Christ's face on cloth, the Image of Edessa, brought to Constantinople in 944 from the city of Edessa, further east.

IIWhat was at stake

Robert de Clari was a knight from Picardy, in northern France. He later wrote down his memories of the crusade, and described the sights of the city in wonder.

Is the cloth he describes the one that later appears in France?

IIIWhat happened

He wrote that in the church of St Mary of Blachernae there was the cloth in which Our Lord had been wrapped. Every Friday it was raised upright, so that the form of our Lord could be seen on it.

In April 1204 the crusaders stormed and looted the city. No one, he wrote, Greek or French, ever knew what became of the cloth.

IVWhat came of it

The sack of Constantinople was a serious wrong. Christians looted a Christian city, and the damage to trust between East and West lasted for centuries.

In the years that followed, relics from Constantinople flooded into Western Europe.

VRead the source
And among those other there was another church [lit. another of the churches] which was called My Lady Saint Mary of Blachernae , where there was the SYDOINES in which, [lit. where] Our Lord had been wrapped, which every Friday, raised itself upright, so that one could see the form of our Lord on it [lit. there], and no one, either Greek or French, ever knew what became of this SYNDOINES when the city was taken.
Sindon in the Old French Chronicle of Robert de Clari · Robert de Clari, La Conquête de Constantinople XCII, in Peter Dembowski's literal translation

Why it matters

Defenders of the Shroud link this cloth, and the Image of Edessa, to the one that appears at Lirey, in France, 150 years later.

No document makes that link. Herbert Thurston, a Catholic priest and historian of the Jesuit order, said in 1903 that there is no positive evidence connecting them. It is a possibility, not a record.

c. 1355Historical2 min read

A knight's new church at Lirey

Geoffroi de Charny, lord of Lirey in Champagne

In the 1350s the first certain record puts the cloth in a small church at Lirey, in Champagne, north-east France. The knight Geoffroi de Charny had founded the church. He never explained how he came to own the cloth.

IWhat was going on

Geoffroi de Charny was a well-known French knight. He wrote a book on chivalry, the knight's code, and died fighting the English at Poitiers in 1356. In 1353 he founded a small church at Lirey, on his own land.

Relics, objects linked to Christ or the saints, drew pilgrims, and pilgrims brought offerings. For a small new church, a famous relic could mean survival.

IIWhat was at stake

A cloth bearing the image of Christ's whole body would be the most precious relic in the Christian world. Where had it come from?

A cloth with no history before the 1350s has a gap of more than thirteen centuries.

IIIWhat happened

Geoffroi gave the cloth to the canons, the priests serving his church, and it was put on show to pilgrims.

The Shroud's keepers today, in Turin in Italy, date the first certain evidence to the middle of the 1300s. They also urge caution about theories that science hasn't confirmed.

IVWhat came of it

The showings soon drew crowds. They also drew trouble with the bishop of Troyes. His successor later wrote that this bishop had found the man who painted it.

Herbert Thurston, a Jesuit historian, pointed out that if the cloth was genuine, Geoffroi had every reason to explain how he got it. The surviving documents show he did nothing of the sort.

VRead the source
The first certain evidences on the Shroud of Turin date back to the half of the XIV th century when the french knight Geoffroy de Charny laid the Shroud in the church he had built in 1353 in his Lirey fee in the Champagne region.
Historical Outline · Historical Outline, first paragraph

Why it matters

This silence is the gap every theory of the Shroud's origin has to cross.

Defenders suggest the family kept quiet because it had got the cloth in some improper way, perhaps when the crusaders sacked Constantinople in 1204. That is possible, but it is a guess.

1370sHistorical1 min read

A scholar outside the quarrel calls it a fraud

Nicole Oresme, theologian and later bishop of Lisieux

In the 1370s Nicole Oresme, a leading French scholar, used the Lirey cloth as his example of clergy faking wonders for money. He had no stake in the local quarrel over it.

IWhat was going on

Nicole Oresme was one of the great minds of medieval France. He was a theologian, a scholar of Christian teaching, and he wrote on money and mathematics. He advised King Charles V, and became bishop of Lisieux in Normandy in 1377.

He was known for looking for natural explanations of reported marvels, rather than accepting every story of a miracle.

IIWhat was at stake

Medieval Europe was full of claims of miracles and relics. Some were sincere. Some were frauds to draw offerings.

How should a believer tell the difference? Oresme thought many claims should not simply be believed.

IIIWhat happened

He wrote a long study, a treatise, sometime between 1355 and 1382, most likely after 1370. In it he said many clergy deceive others to get offerings for their churches.

His example: a church in Champagne where it was said they had the shroud of the Lord Jesus Christ.

IVWhat came of it

Two historians found the passage, and the historian Nicolas Sarzeaud published it in 2025.

Another historian, Andrea Nicolotti, noted that Oresme's opinion matters because he was not personally involved in the dispute.

VRead the source
I do not need to believe anyone who claims: “Someone performed such miracle for me”, because many clergy men thus deceive others, in order to elicit offerings for their churches. ... This is clearly the case for a church in Champagne, where it was said that there was the shroud of the Lord Jesus Christ, and for the almost infinite number of those who have forged such things, and others.
Was Jesus' crucified body wrapped in the Shroud of Turin? A newly discovered Medieval document is the earliest written evidence to suggest not · Press release quoting Sarzeaud's translation of Oresme's treatise

Why it matters

Until 2025 the main medieval charge of fraud came from the local bishop. Defenders of the Shroud said he was a rival with his own motives. Oresme was an outsider.

His words don't prove the cloth was painted. They show that informed people at the time doubted it.

1389Historical1 min read

A bishop tells the pope it is a painting

Pierre d'Arcis, bishop of Troyes

In 1389 the cloth went on show at Lirey again. Pierre d'Arcis, the bishop of Troyes, drafted a formal report to the pope, a memorandum. He said an earlier bishop had found the artist who painted the cloth.

IWhat was going on

By 1389 the Western Church had two rival popes, one in Rome and one at Avignon in southern France. France obeyed Clement VII at Avignon.

Geoffroi de Charny's son, also called Geoffroi, got permission to show the cloth again at Lirey. Crowds and offerings returned.

IIWhat was at stake

Lirey lay in the bishop's own diocese, the area in his care. Pierre d'Arcis believed the showings there were a fraud carried on for money, under his authority.

His opponents said he was acting out of jealousy and greed, to get the cloth for himself. He had to persuade the pope he was right.

IIIWhat happened

He drafted a memorandum to Clement VII. About thirty-four years earlier, he wrote, Henry of Poitiers, the bishop before him, had looked into the cloth.

After careful inquiry Henry found it had been cunningly painted, and the artist himself confessed that it was human work.

IVWhat came of it

The pope had already told the bishop to keep silent. went on allowing the showings, with conditions.

The memorandum survives only as undated drafts, with crossings-out and notes in the margin. Defenders of the Shroud argue it may never have been sent.

VRead the source
Eventually, after diligent inquiry and examination, he discovered the fraud and how the said cloth had been cunningly painted, the truth being attested by the artist who had painted it, to wit, that it was a work of human skill and not miraculously wrought or bestowed.
The Holy Shroud and the Verdict of History · Memorandum of Pierre d'Arcis to Clement VII, in Thurston's translation, The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 22

Why it matters

It is the only medieval document that reports an inquiry by a named bishop and a confession. But it names neither the painter nor any record of his evidence.

Critics treat it as strong evidence of forgery. Defenders treat it as one side of a local quarrel. Both have reasons.

1389–90Historical2 min read

The pope allows it to be shown, as a picture

Clement VII, pope at Avignon

In 1389–90 Pope Clement VII, at Avignon in southern France, allowed the cloth to be shown, but only as a picture. Whoever showed it had to tell the crowd out loud that it was not the real burial cloth of Christ.

IWhat was going on

Clement VII was the pope at Avignon, obeyed by France during the Western Schism, the years when two men both claimed to be pope. Rome today counts him an antipope, a false claimant.

He faced a bishop demanding a ban, and a powerful noble family wanting the showings to go on. The younger Geoffroi's own request had called the cloth a figure or representation.

IIWhat was at stake

Ban the showings, and he would offend the family. Allow them without conditions, and people would honour something that might be false.

How could he protect both the faithful and the truth?

IIIWhat happened

He allowed the showings to go on, and ordered the bishop to keep silent. But there were to be no priestly robes, no candles and no ceremony around the cloth.

Whoever showed it had to say, in a loud and intelligible voice, that it was not the real shroud of Christ, but a picture made to represent it.

IVWhat came of it

The cloth stayed at Lirey for decades more. Over the next century, under the dukes of Savoy, a noble family of the Alps, it came to be honoured as the true shroud.

In 1506 Pope Julius II approved a feast of the Holy Shroud, a yearly day of prayer in its honour. He spoke of it as the cloth in which Christ was wrapped.

VRead the source
in a loud and intelligible voice, without any trickery, that the said figure or representation is not the real shroud of our Lord Jesus Christ, but only a drawing or picture made to represent or imitate the shroud of our Lord Jesus Christ as it is alleged to have been.
The Holy Shroud and the Verdict of History · Clement VII's ruling, in Thurston's translation, The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 27 (Latin in Chevalier, Étude, Appendix G)

Why it matters

The Catholic Church's first judgement on the cloth was cautious: it may be shown, but only as an image.

Later popes spoke more warmly, but no pope has ever declared it authentic. The Church's caution is older than any laboratory.

1453–1983Historical1 min read

A fire, a move to Turin, and a will

The dukes of Savoy, and later the Holy See

In 1453 the cloth passed to the dukes of Savoy. It survived a fire in 1532 and moved to Turin, in Italy, in 1578. In 1983 it was left to the Holy See, the pope's government.

Engraving of a row of mitred bishops holding up the Shroud, which is drawn full length with its front and back figures, above a prayer, with portrait medallions in the corners.
'Il verissimo ritratto', an engraving printed in Turin in 1608. A row of bishops holds up the cloth, drawn with its double figure and the marks left by the fire of 1532 along its folds.
IWhat was going on

The Savoy family ruled lands on both sides of the Alps, in what is now France and Italy. Owning the most famous relic in Europe added to their prestige.

In 1453 Margaret de Charny, Geoffroi de Charny's granddaughter, handed the cloth over to Duke Louis of Savoy.

IIWhat was at stake

Relics were moved, put on show and fought over. Keeping a fragile linen cloth safe for centuries was not easy.

IIIWhat happened

The dukes kept it in their chapel at Chambéry, in what is now France. On 4 December 1532 fire broke out. The casket was rescued, but the folded cloth was burnt along its folds.

In the spring of 1534 Poor Clare nuns, an enclosed order of sisters, took the damaged cloth in hand. They sewed patches over the burn holes, and stitched a full-size backing cloth to the back of the Shroud, later called the Holland cloth.

In 1578 Duke Emmanuel Philibert moved it to Turin, his new capital.

IVWhat came of it

It stayed in Turin, shown to crowds on rare occasions. Umberto II of Savoy, the last king of Italy, died on 18 March 1983. His will left the cloth to the Holy See.

The archbishop of Turin now looks after it.

VRead the source
On december 4th, 1532 a fire broke out in the Sainte-Chapelle seriously damaging the Shroud later repaired by the Poor Clares in 1534 .
Historical Outline · Historical Outline, fifth paragraph

Why it matters

The fire and the patches matter for science. Any test has to allow for damage, repairs and centuries of handling.

Defenders and critics argue about exactly that when they discuss the 1988 dating.

28 May 1898Historical1 min read

A photograph shows a negative

Secondo Pia, lawyer and amateur photographer

On 28 May 1898 Secondo Pia, a lawyer and amateur photographer, took the first photograph of the Shroud, in Turin. On his negative, where light and dark come out reversed, the faint image became a clear, lifelike face.

Two views of the face on the Shroud side by side: on the left a clear, natural-looking face, on the right the faint face as it appears on the cloth.
Secondo Pia's photograph of 1898. Left, his glass negative, on which the face appears as a natural-looking positive. Right, the developed print, showing the face as it looks on the cloth.
IWhat was going on

Photography was still young, and the cloth was rarely shown. In May 1898 it was put on public display in Turin.

Secondo Pia was given permission to photograph it.

IIWhat was at stake

To the naked eye the image is faint and blurred, hard to make out close up.

What would a camera show?

IIIWhat happened

On the night of 28 May 1898 Pia took his photograph. In the darkroom, on his glass negative, the image turned into a clear, natural-looking face and body.

He reasoned that if the negative showed a normal picture, the image on the cloth itself must behave like a negative.

IVWhat came of it

The discovery caused a sensation. How could a medieval artist have painted a negative, centuries before photography?

Critics answered that an image made by pressing or rubbing cloth on a shape can also come out with light and dark reversed. The medieval quarrel became a modern scientific one.

VRead the source
If the figure that appears on the plate, that is, on the negative, is a perfect positive, it means that the imprint on the Sheet is a likewise perfect negative, similar to the photographic one, since the inversion of the light and shade occurs in an impeccable way through the action of light and chemical substances.
Remembrance of the 1898 Exhibition · Luigi Fossati, 'Remembrance of the 1898 Exhibition' (1994), quoting Secondo Pia

Why it matters

From 1898 on, the Shroud was no longer only a question for historians. Scientists began asking how the image was made.

The negative effect is real. What causes it is still argued.

October 1978Historical1 min read

Five days with the cloth

The Shroud of Turin Research Project (STURP)

In October 1978 a team of American scientists spent five days examining the Shroud in Turin. They found no paint on the image, and could not say how it was made.

IWhat was going on

In 1978 the Shroud was shown in Turin to mark 400 years since it arrived there. Afterwards scientists were allowed to examine it directly.

The Shroud of Turin Research Project, known as STURP, brought physicists, chemists and imaging experts. In October they spent 120 hours without a break examining the cloth.

IIWhat was at stake

Was the image painted? Was the blood real? Could any known method have made it?

IIIWhat happened

Their 1981 summary reported no pigments, paints, dyes or stains on the image fibres. The bloodstains contained haemoglobin, the substance in blood that carries oxygen. They also tested positive for serum albumin, a protein in blood.

They concluded the image was of a real human form. No known chemical or physical method could account for the whole image.

IVWhat came of it

Walter McCrone, an expert in examining tiny samples under the microscope, disagreed. He studied fibres lifted from the cloth on sticky tape, and found red ochre and vermilion, two red paint pigments.

He concluded it was a painting made around 1355 for a new church in need of a relic.

Later work has kept both sides busy. In 2010 a full-size replica was made that its makers say matches the original, and others replied that it doesn't.

VRead the source
However, there are no chemical or physical methods known which can account for the totality of the image, nor can any combination of physical, chemical, biological or medical circumstances explain the image adequately.
A Summary of STURP’s Conclusions · A Summary of STURP's Conclusions (October 1981), second paragraph

Why it matters

STURP's findings are the main reason many scientists still find the Shroud a puzzle.

But a puzzle is not a proof. Not knowing how something was made doesn't tell you when.

21 April 1988Historical2 min read

Three laboratories, one corner

Laboratories at Arizona, Oxford and Zurich, with the British Museum

On 21 April 1988 a strip was cut from one corner of the Shroud in Turin. Laboratories at Arizona, Oxford and Zurich dated the linen to between AD 1260 and 1390.

IWhat was going on

Radiocarbon dating measures how much of a natural form of carbon is left in something that was once alive, like the flax plant that linen is made from. It runs down at a known rate, so it works like a clock.

By the 1980s a new method needed only small samples. The archbishop of Turin, acting on the Holy See's instructions, chose three laboratories: at the University of Arizona, Oxford and Zurich. The British Museum oversaw the work.

IIWhat was at stake

If the linen was from the first century, the case for the Shroud would be strong. If it was medieval, it would match the first records at Lirey, in France.

Everyone knew the stakes.

IIIWhat happened

On 21 April 1988 a strip was cut from one corner, away from the patches and burn marks, and divided between the laboratories.

They were meant not to know which sample was the Shroud. But its unusual weave was easy to recognise, so blind testing was dropped.

In February 1989 their joint report in the science journal Nature gave AD 1260–1390. It called this conclusive evidence that the linen is medieval.

IVWhat came of it

Defenders argued the corner was repaired or contaminated. In 2005 the chemist Raymond Rogers claimed the sample area held dyed, later material. In 2010 the Arizona team examined their material and found no dye or repair.

In 2019 and 2020 statisticians used raw data released in 2017. They argued the results were not consistent across the laboratories.

A 2026 study of leftover fragments found them consistent with the main cloth.

VRead the source
The results of radiocarbon measurements at Arizona, Oxford and Zurich yield a calibrated calendar age range with at least 95% confidence for the linen of the Shroud of Turin of AD 1260 - 1390 (rounded down/up to nearest 10 yr). These results therefore provide conclusive evidence that the linen of the Shroud of Turin is mediaeval.
Radiocarbon dating of the Shroud of Turin (full text) · Damon et al., Nature 337 (1989), "Conclusions"

Why it matters

The Catholic Church has not declared the Shroud authentic. In 1998 Pope John Paul II said it is not a matter of faith, and that the Church leaves the questions to scientists.

He called it a mirror of the Gospel, an image everyone sees and no one at present can explain. Pope Benedict XVI called it an icon written in blood. An icon is a holy image that helps people pray.

Catholics may honour it, or doubt it, and remain Catholics.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church's position on the Shroud is a deliberate refusal to rule. , standing before it in 1998, said: "Since it is not a matter of faith, the Church has no specific competence to pronounce on these questions."

He handed the question to scientists. He asked them to work "without pre-established positions that take for granted results that are not such".

That rule binds both sides: the believer who assumes the cloth is genuine, and the skeptic who assumes it is not.

The refusal is not dodging the question. It follows from where Christian faith actually rests.

's first letter to the Christians of Corinth lists the people who saw Jesus risen. It names Cephas (), the Twelve, more than five hundred brothers, James and Paul himself. It names no object.

The , the Catholic Church's official summary of its teaching, calls the , as witnesses of the Risen One, "the foundation stones of his Church".

So a first-century date for the cloth would not prove that Jesus rose from the dead. A medieval date would not disprove it. At most the Shroud could show that a crucified man was once wrapped in it.

The Catholic Church has also kept a critical eye on this relic from the day it appeared. According to a later bishop of Troyes, his predecessor looked into it around 1355.

Another bishop protested in 1389, and a pope ordered that it be shown only as a picture.

In 1903 Herbert Thurston, a Jesuit priest, made the historical case against it. He built on the research of Ulysse Chevalier, a French priest and historian.

In 2013 the archbishop of Turin gave no weight to dating claims that rested on fibres of uncertain origin. Much of the documentary case against the Shroud was found and published by Catholic clergy.

That record has another side. In 1506 Pope Julius II approved a feast for the Shroud. His bull, a formal papal letter, spoke of the cloth as the very one in which Christ lay. For centuries devotion ran ahead of the evidence.

The Catechism asks pastors to "purify and correct" ordinary people's devotions where they need it, and the Shroud's history shows why. Honouring it is legitimate. Claiming a certainty the evidence does not give is not.

What the popes ask of believers is to use the Shroud as an icon, a holy image that helps people pray.

John Paul II called it "a mirror of the Gospel". Benedict XVI called it "an Icon written in blood". Francis spoke of "this icon of a man scourged and crucified".

An icon's worth does not depend on its date, so a Catholic can pray before this one whatever the laboratories decide. If a new, properly sampled test is ever allowed, a Catholic has nothing to fear from it.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

The honours a different cloth, the Image Not Made by Hands. In the account of the Orthodox Church in America, washed his face and dried it on a cloth, and his face stayed on it.

The cloth was taken to King Abgar of Edessa. The Orthodox feast on 16 August marks its move to Constantinople in 944.

The same account records two traditions about what became of it. Either crusaders stole it and it was lost at sea, or it has been at Genoa since 1362.

It is a face, made during Christ's life, and the account never says it is the burial sheet at Turin.

Reformed (John Calvin)

, a leader of the Reformation in Geneva, wrote a Treatise on Relics in 1543. In it he mocks the many churches that claimed to have Christ's shroud. Then he argues from Scripture.

The Gospels record small details of Christ's suffering and death, but never an image on the grave cloths. John describes the body wrapped in linen, with a separate cloth for the head. A single full-length sheet doesn't match that.

His verdict is blunt: "either St John is a liar, or all those who boast of possessing the holy sudary are convicted of falsehood and deceit." His wider target was the honouring of relics itself.

Skeptics (Joe Nickell, Walter McCrone)

For the skeptic the case is closed. Joe Nickell, of the skeptics' group the Center for Inquiry, points out that the cloth appeared with no history in the 1350s. A bishop reported the painter's confession.

And Walter McCrone, the microscope expert, found red ochre and vermilion paint on the image and in the bloodstains. The 1988 date then fits the documents exactly.

In Nickell's words, the date was "fully consistent with the shroud's lack of provenance (historical record) before the mid-fourteenth century." On this view, the later challenges are attempts to rescue a relic that its own century knew was painted.

Critics of the 1988 dating (Rogers, Di Lazzaro, Fanti)

Scientists who doubt the medieval date read the same evidence the other way. The chemist Raymond Rogers argued that the dated corner was chemically different from the rest of the cloth.

Paolo Di Lazzaro and colleagues say they are not arguing that the Shroud is genuine. But they find the 1988 results too uneven to be combined into one date.

Giulio Fanti points to features of the image that no copy has matched, and has argued for a date around the time of Christ.

What they share is the view that the medieval verdict is unsafe, and that the cloth should be dated again.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself6
The findings, for and against, in date order12 steps

The same ground again, with the documents on the table. Each finding has its date and its author, whichever way it points.

  1. The knight's own petition called it a copy

    1389, read in 1903

    Herbert Thurston, a Jesuit priest, studied the papal letters published by Ulysse Chevalier, a French priest and historian. Before the bishop wrote his memorandum, the pope's letter to the knight called the cloth a figure or picture ten times.

    Thurston concluded that the letter was repeating the knight's own request. He allowed one alternative: the family may have known the cloth was stolen, and preferred to call it a picture.

    “It is quite clear that Geoffrey’s petition itself described it as a figure or representation”
    HistoricalThe Holy Shroud and the Verdict of HistoryThe Month 101 (January 1903), p. 28The evidence ↓
  2. A pope approves a feast of the Holy Shroud

    1506

    At the request of the dukes of Savoy, Pope Julius II approved a Mass and an Office, the Church's set daily prayers, for a feast of the Holy Shroud.

    His bull, a formal papal letter, spoke of the cloth as the one in which Christ lay in the tomb.

    The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1912 admits that the Holy See took its authenticity for granted in acts like this. Approving a feast, though, is not a ruling of faith, and no pope has ever defined the Shroud as genuine.

    “An Office and Mass "de Sancta Sindone" was formerly approved by Julius II in the Bull "Romanus Pontifex" of 25 April, 1506, in the course of which the Pope speaks of "that most famous Shroud ( præclarissima sindone ) in which our Savior was wrapped when he lay in the tomb and which is now honorably and devoutly preserved in a silver casket."”
    HistoricalThe Holy Shroud (of Turin)Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), third paragraphThe evidence ↓
  3. A microscopist finds pigment

    1979–1990

    Walter McCrone, an expert in examining tiny samples under the microscope, studied fibres lifted on sticky tape from 32 areas of the cloth.

    He reported red ochre across the image, and vermilion in the blood areas, both held in a tempera binder, an old kind of paint base.

    His forensic tests for blood came back negative. He concluded that the cloth was painted around 1355, and he published his results in peer-reviewed journals from 1980.

    “The faint sepia image is made up of billions of submicrometer pigment particles (red ochre and vermilion) in a collagen tempera medium.”
    HistoricalShroud of Turin Research at McCroneShroud of Turin Research at McCrone, opening sectionThe evidence ↓
  4. The blood: real blood, but whose?

    After 1978

    John Heller and Alan Adler of STURP, and Pierluigi Baima Bollone in Turin, each concluded that the stains are blood. Baima Bollone went further, calling it human and typing it as AB.

    Kelly Kearse, reviewing the tests, notes a problem. The antibody in Heller and Adler's albumin test also reacted with chimpanzee and baboon blood.

    ABO typing, the usual A, B, AB and O blood-group test, cannot reliably tell human blood from other species' blood either. Adler himself would only say it was a primate's blood.

    “Typing studies involving the ABO blood group system have also been performed on Shroud bloodstains by the same investigators, concluding a blood type of AB ... ABO typing studies cannot effectively distinguish human blood from that of other species”
    HistoricalWhat type of blood is present on the Shroud of Turin? Existing Data vs. To Be DeterminedKearse, 'What type of blood is present on the Shroud of Turin?', p. 5The evidence ↓
  5. Pollen from the Holy Land, then withdrawn

    1998–2008

    In 1998 the botanist Avinoam Danin said pollen from the cloth showed it came from the Near East. He cited Uri Baruch's count of grains on Max Frei's sticky tapes, which pointed to a thorny plant, Gundelia tournefortii.

    Emanuela Marinelli, who defends Frei's work, reports what followed. Danin sent Frei's slides to the pollen specialist Thomas Litt, who ruled out Gundelia with high probability.

    In a 2008 book Danin accepted that the pollen could not show where the cloth had been.

    “I regret that, from what I have learned from our research, we cannot currently use the pollen to define any geographical indication”
    HistoricalThe question of pollen grains on the Shroud of Turin and the Sudarium of OviedoMarinelli, "The question of Gundelia tournefortii", quoting Danin and Guerra (2008), p. 54The evidence ↓
  6. Was the dated corner a repair?

    2005

    Raymond Rogers was a chemist at Los Alamos, the US national laboratory. He co-wrote the scientific summary of the 1978 examination.

    He studied threads from a sample taken beside the dated area in 1973, and others said to come from the 1988 sample. He reported a plant gum and dye on them that the rest of the cloth lacks.

    From a preliminary estimate of how fast a chemical in the flax breaks down, he also argued that the linen was much older than 1260. He concluded that the dated sample was not original cloth.

    “The radiocarbon sampling area is uniquely coated with a yellow-brown plant gum containing dye lakes. Pyrolysis-mass-spectrometry results from the sample area coupled with microscopic and microchemical observations prove that the radiocarbon sample was not part of the original cloth of the Shroud of Turin.”
    HistoricalStudies on the radiocarbon sample from the shroud of TurinRogers, Thermochimica Acta 425 (2005), abstractThe evidence ↓
  7. The Arizona piece looked at again

    2010

    Arizona kept a fragment of its 1988 sample. Rachel Freer-Waters and Timothy Jull examined it under the microscope and ultraviolet light.

    They found no coating and no dye, and nothing to suggest it came from anywhere but the main cloth. They added that Rogers's threads were less well documented.

    They also asked that any future test sample a different part of the cloth.

    “We find no evidence to support the contention that the 14C samples actually used for measurements are dyed, treated, or otherwise manipulated.”
    HistoricalInvestigating a Dated Piece of the Shroud of TurinFreer-Waters and Jull, Radiocarbon 52 (2010), p. 1526, discussionThe evidence ↓
  8. A replica, and a reply

    2010–2011

    Luigi Garlaschelli made a full-size copy of the Shroud. He used a simple technique that he argued a medieval artist could have used, and claimed it matched every listed feature of the image.

    Giulio Fanti and Thibault Heimburger replied that it did not. They wrote that its image has sharp edges, breaks into spots, and shows nothing where cloth and body would not have touched.

    “Furthermore, the authors were able to obtain a good replica of the Shroud of Turin at a 1:1 scale that possesses all the above-mentioned features and the same visual and spectroscopic properties as the original.”
    HistoricalLife-size Reproduction of the Shroud of Turin and its ImageGarlaschelli, J. Imaging Sci. Technol. 54(4) (2010), abstractThe evidence ↓
  9. The raw data released

    2017–2020

    After a legal request, the British Museum released the laboratories' raw measurements in 2017. Tristan Casabianca and colleagues found strong signs that the results do not sit together as one sample's should. The 1989 report had itself noted more scatter than expected.

    Paolo Di Lazzaro and colleagues found the ages drifting steadily along the strip. They also said the statistics do not reveal the correct age.

    “In 2017, in response to a legal request, all raw data kept by the British Museum were made accessible. A statistical analysis of the Nature article and the raw data strongly suggests that homogeneity is lacking in the data and that the procedure should be reconsidered.”
    HistoricalRadiocarbon Dating of the Turin Shroud: New Evidence from Raw DataCasabianca et al., Archaeometry 61 (2019), abstractThe evidence ↓
  10. Dating one thread by X-ray

    2022

    Liberato De Caro, Giulio Fanti and colleagues took one thread from near the 1988 area, about half a millimetre by one millimetre. They measured by X-ray how far its cellulose, the material plant fibres are made of, had broken down.

    The pattern matched linen from Masada, an ancient Jewish fortress, dated to AD 55–74. They concluded that the linen is much older than the radiocarbon date.

    But their own abstract adds a condition. A first-century date holds only if the cloth was kept within a narrow range of temperature and humidity for thirteen unknown centuries.

    “The experimental results are compatible with the hypothesis that the TS is a 2000-year-old relic, as supposed by Christian tradition, under the condition that it was kept at suitable levels of average secular temperature—20.0–22.5 °C—and correlated relative humidity—75–55%—for 13 centuries of unknown history, in addition to the seven centuries of known history in Europe.”
    HistoricalX-ray Dating of a Turin Shroud’s Linen SampleDe Caro et al., Heritage 5(2) (2022), abstractThe evidence ↓
  11. The leftover fragments

    April 2026

    Rachel Freer-Waters and Timothy Jull examined Arizona's two unused fragments from 1988. The weave, the twist of the yarn and the thread count matched the rest of the Shroud, with no sign of repair.

    They also call the cloth unusual for the date the laboratories found. And they accept that two small fragments may not speak for the whole cloth.

    “The results indicate that the analyzed fragments are consistent with the main body of the Shroud and show no evidence of contamination.”
    HistoricalAnalysis of textile fragments from the 1988 radiocarbon samples of the Turin ShroudFreer-Waters and Jull, npj Heritage Science 14 (2026), abstractThe evidence ↓
  12. Everyone's DNA

    July 2026

    Gianni Barcaccia, Alessandro Achilli and colleagues analysed material collected from the cloth in 1978. They found human DNA from several family lines, one matching the man who collected it. They also found DNA from plants, animals and red coral.

    They found no ancient proteins, only traces of skin from handling. The authors say this mixture makes it hard to single out any original DNA, and that their method cannot date the cloth either way.

    “We identified several human mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) lineages, including K1a1b1a, which matches the 1978 official collector’s mitogenome, H2a2 (i.e., the lineage of the mtDNA reference sequence rCRS), H1b, which is common in Western Eurasia, and the rare H33, which is also present in the Near East.”
    HistoricalDNA signatures preserved in the official 1978 sample collection of the Shroud of TurinBarcaccia et al., Scientific Reports 16 (2026) 21206, abstractThe evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on10 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

Christian faith in the Resurrection rests on the testimony of named witnesses, not on any object. Paul's summary in 1 Corinthians 15 lists Cephas, the Twelve, more than five hundred brothers, James and himself, and the Catechism calls the apostles, as witnesses of the Risen One, the foundation stones of the Church. The Gospels mention the linen and the burial cloths, but none of them mentions an image on them.

Rests on
  • 1 Corinthians 15:3-6 (NABRE, bible.usccb.org)
    “For I handed on to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the scriptures ... that he was buried; that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures ... that he appeared to …”
    Read the full passage
    “For I handed on to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the scriptures ... that he was buried; that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures ... that he appeared to Cephas, then to the Twelve ... After that, he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still living, though some have fallen asleep.”
  • CCC 639
    “The mystery of Christ's resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified, as the New Testament bears witness.”
  • CCC 642
    “As witnesses of the Risen One, they remain the foundation stones of his Church.”
  • Mark 15:46 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText edition)
    “Having bought a linen cloth, he took him down, wrapped him in the linen cloth and laid him in a tomb that had been hewn out of the rock.”
  • John 19:40 (NABRE, bible.usccb.org)
    “They took the body of Jesus and bound it with burial cloths along with the spices, according to the Jewish burial custom.”
  • John 20:6-7 (NABRE, bible.usccb.org)
    “and the cloth that had covered his head, not with the burial cloths but rolled up in a separate place.”
Other readings
  • Some supporters of the Shroud treat it as a physical witness to the Passion and even to the Resurrection. The Catholic Church has never adopted that view as teaching.
  • John Calvin argued that John's separate cloth for the head rules out a single full-length sheet with a body image on it.
Limits
  • The Gospels describe the burial in different words: Mark has one linen cloth, John has burial cloths, spices and a separate head cloth. Neither description settles what the Turin cloth is.
  • Scripture neither confirms nor excludes the Shroud. It is silent about any image.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

No document securely places the Turin cloth anywhere before Lirey in the 1350s. The French crusader Robert de Clari saw a cloth in Constantinople, probably in 1203, on which the form of Christ's body could be seen, and it disappeared when the city was taken in 1204. Linking that cloth, or the older Image of Edessa venerated in the East, to the Turin Shroud is a hypothesis without documentary proof.

Rests on
  • Robert de Clari, La Conquête de Constantinople XCII, in Peter Dembowski's literal translation
    “And among those other there was another church [lit. another of the churches] which was called My Lady Saint Mary of Blachernae , where there was the SYDOINES in which, [lit. where] Our Lord had been wrapped, which every Friday, raised itself …”
    Read the full passage
    “And among those other there was another church [lit. another of the churches] which was called My Lady Saint Mary of Blachernae , where there was the SYDOINES in which, [lit. where] Our Lord had been wrapped, which every Friday, raised itself upright, so that one could see the form of our Lord on it [lit. there], and no one, either Greek or French, ever knew what became of this SYNDOINES when the city was taken.”
  • Dembowski, commentary on Clari's date
    “It is highly probable that Robert saw the sindon sometime in 1203, during the reign of Alexius IV.”
  • The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 27, note 1
    “Still there is not a scrap of positive evidence to connect the relic which in 1203 is described as having disappeared from the monastery of Blachernes, near Constantinople, with that denounced in 1389 by the Bishop of Troyes.”
  • Historical Outline, second paragraph
    “But just because of this lack of certain data a lot of prudence is needed in formulating theories and easy or imaginative theories that lack scientific confirmation can not be encouraged.”
  • Life for 16 August
    “The Transfer of the Icon of our Lord Jesus Christ Not-Made-by-Hands from Edessa to Constantinople occurred in the year 944.”
Other readings
  • Supporters of authenticity read Clari's cloth, and before it the Image of Edessa, as earlier stages in the life of the same Shroud, and explain the gaps as periods when it was hidden.
  • The Orthodox Church's own account of the Image of Edessa describes a cloth bearing Christ's face, imprinted during his lifetime, not a burial sheet.
Limits
  • Clari is a single witness. His text says nobody knew what became of the cloth after the city was taken.
  • The custodian's own website says that theories about the earlier history call for 'a lot of prudence'.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Shroud's secure history begins at Lirey in Champagne in the 1350s, in a church the knight Geoffroi de Charny founded in 1353. The earliest documents that mention it are hostile. Nicole Oresme, probably after 1370, cited it as an example of clerical fraud. In 1389 Bishop Pierre d'Arcis of Troyes drafted a memorandum to Clement VII saying a painter had confessed to making it, and Clement allowed it to be shown only if the people were told it was not the real shroud but a picture made to represent it.

Rests on
  • Historical Outline, first paragraph
    “The first certain evidences on the Shroud of Turin date back to the half of the XIV th century when the french knight Geoffroy de Charny laid the Shroud in the church he had built in 1353 in his Lirey fee in the Champagne region.”
  • The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 20
    “she was the grand-daughter of Geoffrey de Charny, who, in the year 1353, had founded the collegiate church of Lirey, and had subsequently presented the shroud to the canons.”
  • Press release quoting Sarzeaud's translation of Oresme's treatise
    “I do not need to believe anyone who claims: “Someone performed such miracle for me”, because many clergy men thus deceive others, in order to elicit offerings for their churches. ... This is clearly the case for a church in Champagne, where it was …”
    Read the full passage
    “I do not need to believe anyone who claims: “Someone performed such miracle for me”, because many clergy men thus deceive others, in order to elicit offerings for their churches. ... This is clearly the case for a church in Champagne, where it was said that there was the shroud of the Lord Jesus Christ, and for the almost infinite number of those who have forged such things, and others.”
  • Press release, paragraph on dating
    “Oresme, Dr Sarzeaud explains, referenced the Shroud in a document written between 1355 and 1382, most likely after 1370.”
  • Press release, Andrea Nicolotti's comment
    “Oresme’s opinion is very important because it comes from a person who was not personally involved in the dispute”
  • Memorandum of Pierre d'Arcis, opening, in Thurston's translation, p. 21
    “Some time since in this diocese of Troyes the Dean of a certain collegiate church, to wit, that of Lirey, falsely and deceitfully, being consumed with the passion of avarice, and not from any motive of devotion but only of gain, procured for his …”
    Read the full passage
    “Some time since in this diocese of Troyes the Dean of a certain collegiate church, to wit, that of Lirey, falsely and deceitfully, being consumed with the passion of avarice, and not from any motive of devotion but only of gain, procured for his church a certain cloth cunningly painted, upon which by a clever sleight of hand was depicted the twofold image of one man, that is to say, the back and front”
  • Memorandum of Pierre d'Arcis to Clement VII, in Thurston's translation, The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 22
    “Eventually, after diligent inquiry and examination, he discovered the fraud and how the said cloth had been cunningly painted, the truth being attested by the artist who had painted it, to wit, that it was a work of human skill and not miraculously wrought or bestowed.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), "The Holy Shroud (of Turin)", fourth paragraph
    “Owing mainly to the researches of Canon Ulysse Chevalier a series of documents was discovered which clearly proved that in 1389 the Bishop of Troyes appealed to Clement VII , the Avignon Pope then recognized in France , to put a stop to the scandals connected to the Shroud preserved at Lirey.”
  • Clement VII's ruling, in Thurston's translation, The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 27 (Latin in Chevalier, Étude, Appendix G)
    “in a loud and intelligible voice, without any trickery, that the said figure or representation is not the real shroud of our Lord Jesus Christ, but only a drawing or picture made to represent or imitate the shroud of our Lord Jesus Christ as it is alleged to have been.”
  • The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 28
    “It is quite clear that Geoffrey’s petition itself described it as a figure or representation”
  • Memorandum of Pierre d'Arcis, in Thurston's translation, p. 24
    “its supporters cause it to be spread abroad among the people that I am acting through jealousy and cupidity and to obtain possession of the cloth for myself”
  • The Conspiracy against the Shroud (2001), section "The Chevalier Study"
    “the document, in the form transcribed by the Canon, contained several marked deletions and marginal notations and was clearly only a draft or so-called “pro-memoria”.”
  • The Conspiracy against the Shroud (2001), p. 4
    “The very fact that this document, presumably obtained from the archives of the Troyes diocese, was never discarded is highly evidential that d’Arcis never even sent a draft to a scrivener, let alone having submitted a finished memorandum to the Pope.”
  • The Month 101 (January 1903), p. 29, note 1
    “It is just conceivable, for instance, that the consciousness that the shroud had been stolen prevented the Charny family from giving any account of its previous history, and caused them even to acquiesce in the description of it as a mere picture or facsimile.”
Other readings
  • Jack Markwardt, writing for defenders of authenticity in 2001, argues that the d'Arcis memorandum survives only as undated drafts and may never have been sent, so its report of a confession cannot be tested.
  • Herbert Thurston, who made the case against the cloth, allowed that the Charny family might have called it a picture because they knew it had been stolen.
  • The bishop's opponents in 1389 said he acted from jealousy and a wish to own the cloth himself, as his own memorandum records.
Limits
  • The confession is reported only in the bishop's memorandum, and the painter is not named.
  • A fourteenth-century judgement that a cloth was painted is evidence of what people then found and believed. It is not a laboratory result.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

In 1453 the cloth passed from Margaret de Charny to the dukes of Savoy. In 1506 Julius II approved a liturgical feast for it. On 4 December 1532 it was damaged by fire at Chambéry, and Poor Clare nuns repaired it in 1534. In 1578 it was moved to Turin, and on the death of Umberto of Savoy on 18 March 1983 it became the property of the Holy See by his will.

Rests on
  • Historical Outline, third paragraph
    “In 1453 the Shroud became a House of Savoy property within a series of juridical acts between the duke Ludovique and Margaret .”
  • Historical Outline, fifth paragraph
    “In 1506 the Savoy asked and obtained from Pope Giulio II the acknowledgement of a liturgic celebration of their own and the date they chose was may, 4th.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), third paragraph
    “An Office and Mass "de Sancta Sindone" was formerly approved by Julius II in the Bull "Romanus Pontifex" of 25 April, 1506, in the course of which the Pope speaks of "that most famous Shroud ( præclarissima sindone ) in which our Savior was wrapped …”
    Read the full passage
    “An Office and Mass "de Sancta Sindone" was formerly approved by Julius II in the Bull "Romanus Pontifex" of 25 April, 1506, in the course of which the Pope speaks of "that most famous Shroud ( præclarissima sindone ) in which our Savior was wrapped when he lay in the tomb and which is now honorably and devoutly preserved in a silver casket."”
  • Historical Outline, fifth paragraph
    “On december 4th, 1532 a fire broke out in the Sainte-Chapelle seriously damaging the Shroud later repaired by the Poor Clares in 1534 .”
  • The Month 101 (January 1903), pp. 19-20
    “The casket was rescued from the flames— miraculously, as men were then disposed to think—but the corners of the folds were charred”
  • Historical Outline, sixth paragraph
    “In 1578 Duke Emanuel Philibert definitely transferred the Shroud in Turin in order to strengthen the project of the transfer of the capital of the Savoy states along the Po river.”
  • “With the death of Umberto di Savoia, which took place on March 18, 1983, the Shroud becomes the property of the Holy See by testamentary will.”
Other readings
  • None on these dates. Skeptics such as Joe Nickell accept the same history from Lirey onwards.
Limits
  • These dates rest on the custodian's own website and on Catholic historians writing about the Savoy documents.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

The image on the Shroud behaves like a photographic negative, as Secondo Pia's photograph of 28 May 1898 first showed. The STURP team, after 120 hours with the cloth in October 1978, found no pigment on the image fibres and no known process that accounts for the whole image. Walter McCrone concluded that it was painted with red ochre and vermilion, and Luigi Garlaschelli claimed a full replica in 2010, but both conclusions are disputed. There is no agreed explanation of how the image was made.

Rests on
  • Luigi Fossati, 'Remembrance of the 1898 Exhibition' (1994)
    “Pia was the fortunate photographer that took the first photograph of the Shroud, on May 28, 1898 night, at 21.30.”
  • Luigi Fossati, 'Remembrance of the 1898 Exhibition' (1994), quoting Secondo Pia
    “If the figure that appears on the plate, that is, on the negative, is a perfect positive, it means that the imprint on the Sheet is a likewise perfect negative, similar to the photographic one, since the inversion of the light and shade occurs in an impeccable way through the action of light and chemical substances.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), third paragraph
    “In 1898 when the Shroud was solemnly exposed, permission was given to photograph it and a sensation was caused by the discovery that the image upon the linen was apparently a negative”
  • The 1978 Scientific Examination, first paragraph
    “In October of 1978 the STURP team spent 120 continuous hours conducting their examination of the Shroud.”
  • A Summary of STURP's Conclusions (October 1981), first paragraph
    “No pigments, paints, dyes or stains have been found on the fibrils. X-ray, fluorescence and microchemistry on the fibrils preclude the possibility of paint being used as a method for creating the image.”
  • A Summary of STURP's Conclusions (October 1981), second paragraph
    “However, there are no chemical or physical methods known which can account for the totality of the image, nor can any combination of physical, chemical, biological or medical circumstances explain the image adequately.”
  • A Summary of STURP's Conclusions (October 1981), second paragraph
    “Furthermore, experiments in physics and chemistry with old linen have failed to reproduce adequately the phenomenon presented by the Shroud of Turin.”
  • Shroud of Turin Research at McCrone, opening section
    “The faint sepia image is made up of billions of submicrometer pigment particles (red ochre and vermilion) in a collagen tempera medium.”
  • Shroud of Turin Research at McCrone, "Conclusion"
    “The “Shroud” of Turin is a beautiful painting created about 1355 for a new church in need of a pilgrim-attracting relic.”
  • Garlaschelli, J. Imaging Sci. Technol. 54(4) (2010), abstract
    “Furthermore, the authors were able to obtain a good replica of the Shroud of Turin at a 1:1 scale that possesses all the above-mentioned features and the same visual and spectroscopic properties as the original.”
  • Fanti and Heimburger, letter, J. Imaging Sci. Technol. 55(2) (2011), p. 020102-2
    “the Garlaschelli image has no fuzzy borders; it is not continuous (discrete dark spots) and it has no image in noncontact areas”
  • Address of 24 May 1998, section 3
    “Therefore, it is right to foster an awareness of the precious value of this image, which everyone sees and no one at present can explain.”
Other readings
  • Walter McCrone and Joe Nickell hold that the image is a medieval painting and that the pigment evidence settles the question.
  • STURP's 1981 summary states the opposite conclusion directly: the image is that of a real human form and not the product of an artist.
Limits
  • STURP's 1981 summary is a press summary written by a participant, not a peer-reviewed paper.
  • McCrone's pigment results and STURP's no-pigment results come from fibres taken from the cloth and read by different scientists with different methods; each side has published a rebuttal of the other.
  • An image no one can yet explain is not thereby miraculous, and it is not thereby first-century.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 21 April 1988 a strip was cut from one corner of the Shroud, away from patches and scorch marks, and pieces were dated by laboratories at Arizona, Oxford and Zurich with the Holy See's authority. Their report in Nature in February 1989 gave a calendar range of AD 1260-1390 with at least 95% confidence and called this conclusive evidence that the linen is medieval. Examinations of Arizona's retained fragments published in 2010 and 2026 found no dye, coating, repair or contamination.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Critics accept that the laboratories measured correctly but argue that the corner sampled does not represent the cloth (Rogers 2005; Di Lazzaro and colleagues 2020).
Limits
  • The laboratories could recognise the Shroud sample by its weave, so the test was not blind, as the Nature report itself states.
  • Only one site on the cloth was sampled.
  • The 2026 authors acknowledge that the fragments they examined are a small subset that may differ from other parts of the cloth.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Catholic Church has never declared the Shroud authentic, and no Catholic is required to believe it is. John Paul II said in Turin in 1998 that, since it is not a matter of faith, the Church has no specific competence to pronounce, and he entrusted the question to scientists. The popes since have called it an icon of the Passion. Earlier popes did take its authenticity for granted in devotional acts, such as Julius II's approval of a feast in 1506, without ever defining it.

Rests on
  • Address in Turin cathedral, 24 May 1998, section 2
    “Since it is not a matter of faith, the Church has no specific competence to pronounce on these questions. She entrusts to scientists the task of continuing to investigate, so that satisfactory answers may be found to the questions connected with …”
    Read the full passage
    “Since it is not a matter of faith, the Church has no specific competence to pronounce on these questions. She entrusts to scientists the task of continuing to investigate, so that satisfactory answers may be found to the questions connected with this Sheet, which, according to tradition, wrapped the body of our Redeemer after he had been taken down from the cross.”
  • Address of 24 May 1998, section 2
    “The Church urges that the Shroud be studied without pre-established positions that take for granted results that are not such; she invites them to act with interior freedom and attentive respect for both scientific methodology and the sensibilities of believers.”
  • Address of 24 May 1998, section 3
    “For the believer, what counts above all is that the Shroud is a mirror of the Gospel.”
  • Meditation before the Shroud, Turin, 2 May 2010
    “The Shroud is an Icon written in blood; the blood of a man who was scourged, crowned with thorns, crucified and whose right side was pierced.”
  • Video message, Holy Saturday, 30 March 2013, second paragraph
    “How is it that the faithful, like you, pause before this icon of a man scourged and crucified? It is because the Man of the Shroud invites us to contemplate Jesus of Nazareth.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), third paragraph
    “That the authenticity of the Shroud of Turin is taken for granted, in various pronouncements of the Holy See cannot be disputed.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), third paragraph
    “An Office and Mass "de Sancta Sindone" was formerly approved by Julius II in the Bull "Romanus Pontifex" of 25 April, 1506, in the course of which the Pope speaks of "that most famous Shroud ( præclarissima sindone ) in which our Savior was wrapped …”
    Read the full passage
    “An Office and Mass "de Sancta Sindone" was formerly approved by Julius II in the Bull "Romanus Pontifex" of 25 April, 1506, in the course of which the Pope speaks of "that most famous Shroud ( præclarissima sindone ) in which our Savior was wrapped when he lay in the tomb and which is now honorably and devoutly preserved in a silver casket."”
  • NBC News, Cosmic Log, 29 March 2013
    “Because there's "no degree of security" as to the authenticity of the fiber samples, the shroud's custodians "cannot recognize any serious value to the results of these alleged experiments," Nosiglia said in a statement quoted by La Stampa's Vatican Insider .”
  • NBC News, Cosmic Log, 29 March 2013
    “The Catholic Church has taken no official stand on the authenticity of the shroud, which is kept under lock and key in Turin and is only rarely brought out for public display.”
  • CCC 1676
    “Pastoral discernment is needed to sustain and support popular piety and, if necessary, to purify and correct the religious sense which underlies these devotions so that the faithful may advance in knowledge of the mystery of Christ.”
Other readings
  • Some read the Catholic Church's public veneration of the Shroud as a quiet endorsement of its authenticity; others read the refusal to rule as quiet doubt. The texts support neither reading.
Limits
  • The Holy See owns the cloth and decides who may test it. The 1988 test remains the only radiocarbon dating of the main cloth; the Arizona laboratory (2010) and Di Lazzaro and colleagues (2020) both called for further sampling.
  • Calling the Shroud an icon is a statement about how believers may use it, not about when it was made.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

After the 1978 examination, John Heller and Alan Adler of STURP and Pierluigi Baima Bollone in Turin each concluded that the stains are blood, and Baima Bollone typed it as AB. The tests cannot settle whose blood it is: the antibody in Heller and Adler's albumin test also reacted with chimpanzee and baboon blood, ABO typing cannot reliably tell human blood from other species' blood, and Adler would say only that it was a primate's blood. In 2026 a genetic study of the 1978 samples found DNA from several people, one of them the man who collected the samples.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Supporters take the finding that the stains contain haemoglobin and serum albumin as strong evidence that a real wounded body lay in the cloth.
  • Walter McCrone reported that his forensic tests for blood were negative and that the blood areas contain vermilion.
Limits
  • Real blood, even human blood, would say nothing about whose it was or when it was shed.
  • Kelly Kearse notes that most of the immunological results were never published in a peer-reviewed journal.
  • The 2026 study found no ancient proteins in the samples it tested, only proteins left by handling.
  • The 2026 authors say the mixture of human DNA challenges the possibility of identifying any original DNA, and that their method cannot show whether the cloth is medieval or two thousand years old.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Max Frei reported Near Eastern pollen on sticky tapes he took from the Shroud in 1973 and 1978, and in 1998 the botanist Avinoam Danin argued that pollen of the thorny plant Gundelia tournefortii, counted by Uri Baruch, showed the cloth came from the Near East. The pollen specialist Thomas Litt later examined Frei's slides and excluded Gundelia with high probability. Danin then accepted, in a book of 2008 quoted by Emanuela Marinelli, that the pollen could not be used for any geographical indication.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Emanuela Marinelli, who defends Frei's work, holds that its general conclusions remain valid and hopes for further investigation of his samples.
Limits
  • Pollen on tapes lifted from a cloth shown in public for centuries can come from anywhere the cloth has been.
  • Danin went on to argue from what he saw as images of plants on the cloth, which is a separate and contested claim.
  • Litt's verdict and Danin's retraction are known through Marinelli's quotations from Danin and Guerra's 2008 book, not from the book itself.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Three lines of published work challenge the 1988 date. Raymond Rogers (2005) argued that the dated area was chemically different from the rest of the cloth. Statistical reanalyses using raw data released in 2017 (Casabianca and colleagues, 2019; Di Lazzaro and colleagues, 2020) found the results too uneven to treat as measurements of one sample. X-ray measurements on one thread (De Caro and colleagues, 2022) were compatible with an age of about two thousand years under assumed storage conditions. None of these studies produces an agreed new date.

Rests on
  • Rogers, Thermochimica Acta 425 (2005), abstract
    “The radiocarbon sampling area is uniquely coated with a yellow-brown plant gum containing dye lakes. Pyrolysis-mass-spectrometry results from the sample area coupled with microscopic and microchemical observations prove that the radiocarbon sample was not part of the original cloth of the Shroud of Turin.”
  • Rogers (2005), abstract
    “Preliminary estimates of the kinetics constants for the loss of vanillin from lignin indicate a much older age for the cloth than the radiocarbon analyses.”
  • Damon et al., Nature 337 (1989), statistical analysis
    “The spread of the measurements for sample 1 is somewhat greater than would be expected from the errors quoted.”
  • Casabianca et al., Archaeometry 61 (2019), abstract
    “In 2017, in response to a legal request, all raw data kept by the British Museum were made accessible. A statistical analysis of the Nature article and the raw data strongly suggests that homogeneity is lacking in the data and that the procedure should be reconsidered.”
  • Di Lazzaro et al., Entropy 22 (2020) 926, abstract
    “The statistical analyses highlight an inter-laboratory heterogeneity of the means and a monotone spatial variation of the ages of subsamples that suggest the presence of contaminants unevenly removed by the cleaning pretreatments.”
  • Di Lazzaro et al. (2020), section 8, Conclusions
    “Clearly, the statistical analyses do not unveil the correct age of the Shroud.”
  • De Caro et al. (2022), abstract
    “We obtained one-dimensional integrated WAXS data profiles for the TS sample, which were fully compatible with the analogous measurements obtained on a linen sample whose dating, according to historical records, is 55–74 AD, Siege of Masada (Israel).”
  • De Caro et al., Heritage 5(2) (2022), abstract
    “The experimental results are compatible with the hypothesis that the TS is a 2000-year-old relic, as supposed by Christian tradition, under the condition that it was kept at suitable levels of average secular temperature—20.0–22.5 °C—and correlated …”
    Read the full passage
    “The experimental results are compatible with the hypothesis that the TS is a 2000-year-old relic, as supposed by Christian tradition, under the condition that it was kept at suitable levels of average secular temperature—20.0–22.5 °C—and correlated relative humidity—75–55%—for 13 centuries of unknown history, in addition to the seven centuries of known history in Europe.”
Other readings
  • The Arizona laboratory replies that the threads Rogers examined were less well documented than its own sample, and that its retained fragments show no dye or coating (Freer-Waters and Jull, 2010).
  • Joe Nickell holds that the three laboratories agreed so closely that the result stands.
Limits
  • Di Lazzaro and colleagues state that the statistics do not reveal the correct age of the Shroud.
  • The X-ray result depends on assumed temperature and humidity over thirteen centuries of unknown history, and it rests on one piece of thread about half a millimetre by one millimetre.
  • Rogers's abstract names the laboratories as Arizona, Cambridge and Zurich; the Nature report shows the second was Oxford.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next