Christians are hypocrites and judgemental. Why should I listen to them?
Often they are, and the Catholic Church admits it. Jesus's harshest words were for religious hypocrites. The Church says it's made of sinners being healed, so the real question isn't how Christians behave. It's whether what they point to is true.
Part 1 · The worry
Calling Christians hypocrites isn't a misunderstanding. Most people who say it have seen it for themselves.
They've seen the churchgoer who's cruel at home, the pastor caught in a scandal, and the Christian who looks down on everyone else.
A US research group, Barna, studied young people who weren't Christians in 2007.
87% said Christianity today is judgemental, and 85% said it's hypocritical.
The researcher expected those views to be shallow. Instead, he found they came from real stories and real run-ins with Christians.
People weren't repeating stereotypes. They'd been hurt.
And Catholics are no exception.
In 2018 an official investigation of six Catholic dioceses, or church districts, in Pennsylvania, in the US, found believable accusations against over 300 priests.
It found over 1,000 child victims who could be identified from the church's own records.
And it said church leaders had preferred to protect the abusers and their institution above all.
Part 2 · Jesus said it first
If religious hypocrisy disgusts you, you're in good company. Jesus, the Jewish teacher Christians follow, saved his angriest words for religious people.
He went after religious leaders, including some Pharisees, a group of devout Jewish teachers.
He said: they preach but they do not practice. He called them whitewashed tombs: pretty on the outside, full of bones inside.
He was a Jew speaking to fellow Jews, and his target was hypocrisy, which every religion has.
He also told a story about two men praying in the Temple, the centre of Jewish worship.
A religious man thanks God that he's not like the rest of humanity.
Further back, keeping his distance, stands a tax collector. In Jesus's day, tax collectors were Jews who collected money for the Roman occupiers.
They often took extra for themselves, so people despised them.
This one can't even look up. He just prays: O God, be merciful to me a sinner.
Jesus says it's the second man who goes home right with God, at peace with him.
The first came to show God how good he was. The second came to ask for mercy. Jesus put it like this:
everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, and the one who humbles himself will be exalted
Part 3 · The Church admits it
The Catholic Church doesn't claim its members are better than anyone else. It says every one of them is a sinner.
The , its summary of beliefs, says: All members of the Church, including her ministers, must acknowledge that they are sinners.
Its ministers are its clergy: its , priests and .
In 1964 a meeting of the world's Catholic bishops, the , described the Church like this:
the Church, embracing in its bosom sinners, at the same time holy and always in need of being purified, always follows the way of penance and renewal.
The Church is holy because of what God does in it. And it always needs cleaning up, because of what its members do.
It's a body of sinners being healed, not a club of people who've already made it.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a big city hospital.
Walk through any ward and you'll see it's full of sick people. That's the point of it.
Some patients are rude to the nurses. Some skip their medicine, or sneak out for a cigarette.
A few make the whole ward worse for everyone. If you judged the hospital by its most difficult patients, you'd never go near it.
But none of that tells you whether the treatment works.
To find that out, you'd look at the patients who actually took the medicine, followed the treatment, and walked out healthier than they came in.
Whether the patients behave doesn't tell you whether the medicine works.
That's how the Catholic Church sees itself: full of sick people. The question is whether the cure is real.
In that picture, Jesus is the doctor. When religious teachers complained that he ate with tax collectors and sinners, he said:
Those who are well do not need a physician, but the sick do.
Priests and bishops are patients in this hospital too. Remember the Catechism: even the Church's ministers must acknowledge that they are sinners.
And some of them were never just difficult patients.
A leader who harms the people in his care is far worse, like a doctor poisoning the ward.
The abuse of children in Pennsylvania was terrible harm.
Harm like that is a reason to hold them to account. It isn't a reason to stop asking whether the medicine works.
The abuse scandal has its own answer on this site.
The Second Vatican Council also said believers can have more than a little to do with the birth of atheism.
When they live badly, it said, they conceal rather than reveal the authentic face of God.
In plain words: Christians who live badly hide what God is really like. Some people stop believing because of it.
And in 2000 , the head of the Catholic Church at the time, publicly asked forgiveness for the of Christians.
Then, naming the evils of today, he said:
We humbly ask forgiveness for the part which each of us has had in these evils by our own actions
He didn't start by pointing at anyone else.
But doesn't the Catholic Church judge people all the time? It does say some acts are wrong.
And it warns that serious sin, if a person never turns back from it, can cut them off from God for good.
But about people, it says: we must entrust judgment of persons to the justice and mercy of God.
Saying stealing is wrong isn't the same as saying you're going to hell.
So a Christian who tells you you're going to is claiming to know something the Catholic Church leaves to God alone.
Part 4 · Then why listen at all?
So why listen at all? Because the claim was never Christians are good people.
The claim is that Jesus is who he said he was: the , who died and rose from the dead.
If that's true, it's true even when his followers fail. If it's false, the nicest Christians in the world couldn't make it true.
So you don't have to trust Christians to look at the evidence. And Christians have no right to ask for trust they haven't earned.
The faith does claim to change people. So if Christians never change, that's fair to point out.
So here's what would count against it.
Say people who really practise the faith turned out, over years, no kinder or more honest than anyone else. That would count.
It's a fair test, and it's why the hospital picture isn't meant as a dodge.
Does it actually change people? The evidence is mixed, and worth stating carefully.
A 2019 study looked at the US and more than two dozen other countries.
People active in a religious community tended to be happier, and more involved in their communities, than others.
In the US, 58% of people active in a religious community also took part in at least one other group.
That other group might be a charity or a sports club, for example.
Among people with no religion, it was 39%. Active believers also smoke and drink less, though they're no better on exercise or weight.
And there are catches. Just calling yourself religious made little difference: what counted was taking part.
And the researchers couldn't say which way it runs. Happier, healthier people may simply join more things.
Remember the hospital, and the patients who actually took the medicine? People who take part do seem a little better off on average.
The study counted religious people in general, not only Christians. So it doesn't prove the medicine works. But it's one clue, worth taking into account.
Remember Jesus the doctor? He also said: I did not come to call the righteous but sinners.
But he didn't leave people where he found them.
Levi, a tax collector, got up from his tax booth and followed him.
Mercy, for Jesus, was never permission to stay the same.
Christians can't answer hypocrisy by denying it.
They can admit they need mercy as much as anyone, and point past themselves to Jesus.
Back to the hospital. If you wanted to know whether the medicine works, who would you look at?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 11
- Barna Group, A New Generation Expresses its Skepticism and Frustration with Christianity (21 September 2007) · Young non-Christians: 87% call Christianity judgmental, 85% hypocritical; views rooted in real experiences.
- Pennsylvania 40th Statewide Investigating Grand Jury, Report I (interim, redacted, 14 August 2018) · Six dioceses: credible allegations against over 300 priests, over 1,000 identifiable child victims, and leaders who covered it up.
- Matthew 23:1–28 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus against religious hypocrisy: "they preach but they do not practice".
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1861 · We may judge acts, but must leave the judgement of persons to God.
- Luke 18:9–14 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · The Pharisee and the tax collector.
- Mark 2:13–17 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Levi leaves his tax booth; Jesus came to call sinners.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 827 · All members of the Church, ministers included, must acknowledge they are sinners.
- Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (21 November 1964), 8 · The Church: holy and always in need of being purified.
- Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes (7 December 1965), 19 · Believers' failings can contribute to atheism.
- John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000) · The Pope asks forgiveness for the sins of Christians, beginning with each one's own part.
- Pew Research Center, Religion's Relationship to Happiness, Civic Engagement and Health Around the World (31 January 2019) · Actively religious people are happier and more civically engaged in many countries, smoke and drink less, but are no healthier on exercise or obesity; affiliation alone makes little difference; causation unclear.