Sources · About 6 min

How do you know any of this? Show me the sources.

Scroll to begin

Fair question. People argue about God and history, usually from a few lines they half remember.

So any site that makes claims about either should show its working.

The Trail's answer is to put the documents on the table. Every quote links back to its source, so you can read it for yourself.

Here's what that evidence is, how it's checked, and where the checking stops.

Part 1 · Not all evidence is the same

Start with ancient texts: the books and letters themselves, and the manuscripts, the handwritten copies that carried them down to us.

The oldest surviving piece is a scrap of John's , one of the four accounts of Jesus's life. It was copied around AD 125–175.

Then there's archaeology. In 1961, at Caesarea on the coast of Israel, archaeologists dug up a stone with 's name and title carved into it.

Pilate was the Roman governor who ordered Jesus to be .

To be honest, archaeology can't prove a miracle. What it shows is that the people and places in the Gospels were real.

Then come historians who weren't Christian, and had no reason to be kind.

, a Roman historian writing around AD 116, names Christus, Latin for , and says he was put to death under Pontius Pilate.

Pliny, a Roman governor, and , a Jewish historian, mention him too.

Most scholars think one passage in Josephus is partly his own and partly added later by Christian copyists.

Almost no historian, Christian or not, doubts that Jesus lived and was crucified under Pilate.

Not every source carries the same weight. A ruling by the world's and a blog post aren't the same kind of thing.

So the site's 1,166 sources are sorted into five tiers.

Tier A is official texts: the , the Catholic Church's own documents, and other churches' official texts, in their own words.

For what a church teaches, that's the right source, the way you'd check a speed limit in the country's own traffic law.

But a church's word alone can't show what happened. So history starts at tier B: early Christian writers, old letters and chronicles, and eyewitnesses.

Tier C is scholars and reference books. The last two, Catholic explanations and popular articles, can point the way but never carry a claim alone.

And when serious scholars, or serious Christians, disagree? The claim is labelled Disputed, and the site gives both sides.

Critics speak for themselves too: skeptics argue that the Shroud of Turin, a cloth some believe was Jesus's burial cloth, is a medieval fake.

Their strongest evidence: in 1988, three laboratories carbon-dated the cloth to between 1260 and 1390.

Part 2 · One claim, start to finish

Here's how one claim gets onto the site. Around AD 107, , the bishop of Antioch, was being taken to Rome to be executed.

On the way, he wrote letters to the churches.

To the Christians of Smyrna, today's İzmir in Turkey, he wrote about people who stayed away from the .

The Eucharist is the Christian meal of bread and wine that Catholics believe becomes Christ's body and blood.

The Trail is built by one person, ACG, with a great deal of help from AI, and it says so openly.

AI research agents, programs that search and write on their own, look for the documents a question needs, like his letter.

Then a script, a small program that does one job the same way every time, saves each page as plain text.

More than 30,000 pages are saved, each with its web address at the top.

The agent copies the quote from that saved page, never from memory. Then a script looks for it there, word for word.

His words were there:

They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins
Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans 7, around AD 107

Next, the claim gets three labels: what kind of claim it is, how sure anyone can be, and how far it has been checked.

This one is Historical, because it's an old letter, not a Church teaching. It's Strong historical evidence, because most scholars accept the letter as his.

And it's Source verified, because its words were found. A quote that isn't found is shown to you as unchecked.

The labels keep it modest. The letter shows what one bishop believed around AD 107. It doesn't prove a Church teaching on its own.

The file keeps the other reading too: his opponents denied Jesus had a real body, so the passage is first about God becoming human.

In the saints' lives and the histories, a second agent, not the writer, reads each sentence beside its quote and cuts whatever says more.

Spot checks in 2026 found about one sentence in five saying more than its quote. The chapters aren't marked as checked this way yet.

Then ACG reads the pages, mostly on his phone, and sends back what's unclear, unfair or wrong.

He's a designer, not a priest, theologian or historian.

Two things reach you before any person reads them: Ask, the question box, and the line on each church's pin on the map.

A script checks Ask's sentences against their passages. The pin lines, written by AI from Wikipedia, aren't checked by a script or a person.

Part 3 · Where the checking stops

Now the honest part. The last step, review by a priest, theologian or historian, hasn't started yet.

No AI is allowed to mark anything approved. So read the site as checked research, not a finished, endorsed work.

Source verified doesn't mean right, either. A quote can be perfect and the conclusion drawn from it still wrong.

And no script notices what's missing. A page can quote every source correctly and still mislead by never raising the awkward question.

So the site says clearly where the evidence runs out. Its one rule is simple:

Never manufacture the trail. Follow it.

The full method has its own page, with every source listed tier by tier, each linked to the original.

You don't have to take anyone's word for it.

Quick check

A claim is marked “Source verified”. What does that tell you?

Pick an answer below.