d. 1274

Bonaventure

Franciscan theologian, Doctor of the Church · Italy and Paris · feast 15 July

Painting of Bonaventure kneeling in his study as the Virgin and angels appear in the clouds above him.
The Virgin Mary appears to Bonaventure. Leandro Bassano, Gallerie dell'Accademia, Venice.

Giovanni di Fidanza was a doctor’s son from Bagnoregio whose mother, when he was dying as a boy, prayed to Francis of Assisi, and he lived. He became a Franciscan, a master of theology at Paris alongside Thomas Aquinas, and for seventeen years the Minister General, head of the whole order, who held Francis’s brothers together. He died in 1274 at the Council of Lyon, while working to reunite the Latin and Greek Churches.1,2,3,4,5,6,7

Known for

  • The Journey of the Mind to GodWriting · 1259

    He conceived it on La Verna in October 1259, where Francis had seen a six-winged seraph, an angel, and received the stigmata, the wounds of Christ in his hands, feet and side. The six wings become six steps, from looking at the world and into the soul to union with the Trinity through Christ.8,9,10

  • Head of the FranciscansLeadership · 1257

    Elected Minister General in 1257, he led more than 30,000 friars for seventeen years while they were split over how strictly to keep poverty. In 1260 he gave them the rules for daily life ratified at Narbonne.4,11,12,13

  • The Life of St FrancisWriting · 1263

    Written at the friars’ request after he talked with Francis’s surviving friends, it became the official life in 1263. In 1266 the order decreed the earlier lives be destroyed: some see an attempt to hide the real Francis, others only a rule for uniform readings in choir.14,15,16,17

  • Commentary on the SentencesWriting

    His commentary on Peter Lombard’s Sentences, the theology textbook of the time, written when he was twenty-seven and filling more than 4,000 large printed pages. Scholars long counted it his greatest work: all his other writings build on it.18,19

  • The Second Council of LyonLeadership · 1274

    Gregory X made him a cardinal and asked him to prepare a council to restore communion between the Latin and Greek Churches. He led its talks with the Greeks and died in 1274 while it was still sitting.5,6,20,21

The jaws of death

He was born at Bagnoregio, near Viterbo, in 1217 or 1221; Benedict XVI thought 1217 the likelier year. He was named Giovanni, and his parents were Giovanni di Fidanza, a doctor, and Maria Ritella. As a boy he fell so ill that his father gave up hope of saving him.

His mother turned to Francis of Assisi, lately canonised, and the boy recovered. Decades later he wrote that he remembered it “as though it happened but yesterday”.1,22,23,24,25

The friars’ door

He grew up in Bagnoregio and went to Paris to study, probably in 1235, taking his degree as a Master of Arts. The Franciscans had been in Paris since 1219. He knocked at their door and asked to join, and took the habit and the name Bonaventure in about 1243, though 1238 is possible.

Years later he said why: Francis’s brotherhood resembled the early Church, which “began with simple fishermen”.2,7,26,27,28,29

The master’s chair

He studied theology under Alexander of Hales, and was only twenty-seven, it is reckoned, when he wrote a commentary on Peter Lombard’s Sentences, the standard theology textbook of the day, so long that it fills more than four thousand large printed pages. Paris was hostile to the friars: the secular masters disputed their right to teach, and in 1256 William of Saint-Amour attacked them in The Perils of the Last Times.

Bonaventure answered with Evangelical Perfection. Pope Alexander IV stepped in, and in 1257 Bonaventure and the Dominican Thomas Aquinas were received as masters together.3,18,19,30,31,32,33

Thirty thousand brothers

That same year, on 2 February 1257, he was elected Minister General of the Friars Minor, and gave up his chair. The order had grown to more than 30,000 friars, from North Africa to Peking, and was pulling apart over how strictly to keep Francis’s poverty.

That April he wrote to every friar, urging them to recover the order’s “somewhat tarnished” lustre, and he walked the roads of France and Italy to visit them, as every friar travelled. In 1260 the friars’ general meeting at Narbonne adopted the rules he had written for their daily life, a way to hold so many different men together.4,11,12,13,33,34,35

On La Verna

In October 1259, for Francis’s feast, he went up to La Verna, where Francis had seen the six-winged seraph and received the wounds of Christ. Meditating there on how the mind climbs to God, he wrote, the seraph came into his thoughts, and he saw in it “the way that leads to it”.

From that visit came the Journey of the Mind to God: six steps like the seraph’s six wings, from the traces of God in the world, through the soul, to union with the Trinity through Christ. Put simply: everything God made is a signpost pointing back to him, and the last step of the climb is not more thinking but love.8,9,10

Blind, deaf and mute

He had Francis’s delight in created things. Whoever is not brightened by their splendours, he wrote, “is blind; he who does not awake at such clamours is deaf; he who does not praise God on account of all these effects is mute”. Benedict XVI called him “the seraphic poet of creation”.

Theology, for Bonaventure, began in love: one who loves wants to know the beloved better.

Reading will not suffice, he warned, “without unction”, nor “knowledge without love”.36,37,38,39

The old woman at the wall

Learned as he was, he never thought learning mattered most. The later lives of Brother Giles, one of Francis’s first companions, who had never learned his letters, tell that Giles once asked him whether an ignorant man could love God as much as a learned one.

“A poor little old woman can love God as much or more than a Master in Theology,” Bonaventure answered. Giles ran to the garden wall and shouted to a poor woman passing by that if she loved the Lord God she might be greater than Brother Bonaventure.40,41,42

Fragments

In 1260 the chapter asked him for a Life of Francis to replace those then in circulation. He went to Assisi and sat with Francis’s friends who were still alive, to gather his deeds and words, “fragments, as it were, overlooked in part, in part scattered”, before the last of those who had lived with Francis died.

He owed Francis his own life, he said, and would be ungrateful to keep silent. In 1263 the chapter at Pisa approved his Life as the official portrait of the founder.14,15,16,25,43

The evening bell

At that chapter he ordered that a bell be rung at nightfall in honour of the Annunciation, from which the Angelus seems to have grown. He took back the care of the Poor Clares, the nuns founded by St Clare, and wrote Holiness of Life for one of them, probably Isabella, sister of King Louis IX of France.

Louis was his friend, and at the king’s request he wrote an Office of the Passion. When Pope Clement IV named him Archbishop of York in 1265, he refused, and the pope gave way.44,45,46,47,48

A cardinal against his will

When Clement IV died, the cardinals gathered at Viterbo could not agree on a successor for nearly three years. Bonaventure preached an important sermon at Viterbo, and in 1271 they chose Teobaldo Visconti, who became Gregory X. In 1273 the new pope made Bonaventure, much against his will, a cardinal and Bishop of Albano, and asked him to prepare a council at Lyon to restore communion between the Latin and Greek Churches.

For the Byzantine emperor, Michael VIII, threatened by Charles of Anjou and other enemies, union was also a bargain: the Greek Church would accept the pope’s authority in return for his protection.5,21,49,50,51

Lyon

The council opened at Lyon on 7 May 1274, and in the same month he handed the order on to Jerome of Ascoli. The pope gave him the direction of the council’s business and the talks with the Greeks, and he preached twice to the assembled bishops. On 6 July the Greek delegates accepted union.

The emperor Michael’s delegates had accepted the pope’s authority and the filioque, the West’s addition to the Creed saying the Holy Spirit comes from the Father “and the Son”. Nine days later, at the hour of Matins, the night prayer, on Sunday 15 July, while the council was still sitting, he died.

He never saw what came next: at home the union met great resistance, the patriarch, Joseph, refused to sign and was deposed, and after Michael died in 1282 the union was renounced.6,20,52,53,54

Such grace

The council’s acts called him “a man eminent for his knowledge and eloquence”. Peter of Tarentaise preached at his funeral on David’s lament, “I am saddened over you, my brother Jonathan”, and there were many tears.

The pope, the King of Aragon and the cardinals attended his funeral, and Gregory X ordered every priest in the world to say Mass for him. An anonymous papal notary wrote of “a good, affable, devout and compassionate man”, whom all who saw him loved.53,55,56

In their own words

“For I, who remember as though it happened but yesterday how I was snatched from the jaws of death, while yet a child, by his invocation and merits, should fear to be convicted of the sin of ingratitude did I refrain from publishing his praises.”25
From the prologue to his Life of St Francis, written at the order of the chapter of 1260 (translated by E. Gurney Salter).
“I confess before God that the reason which made me love the life of blessed Francis most is that it resembled the birth and early development of the Church. The Church began with simple fishermen, and was subsequently enriched by very distinguished and wise teachers; the religion of Blessed Francis was not established by the prudence of men but by Christ”29
From his Letter on Three Questions to an unnamed master, explaining why he became a friar, as Benedict XVI quoted it.
“If you should wish to know how these things come about ... question grace, not instruction; desire, not intellect; the cry of prayer, not pursuit of study; the spouse, not the teacher; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that inflames all and transports to God with fullest unction and burning affection”8,57
The last chapter of the Journey of the Mind to God, conceived on La Verna in 1259, as Benedict XVI quoted it.

Stories told about them

Loved and retold, but not all of them records. Each says when it was first written down.

O buona venturaLegend

When the sick child was brought to Francis, the story goes, Francis cried out “O buona ventura”, “what good fortune”, and the boy took the name ever after. Visiting Bagnoregio, Benedict XVI repeated, as the town’s mayor had just recalled, that Francis had predicted “good fortune” for him.58,59

The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907) calls it highly improbable and thinks it seems based on a legend of the late fifteenth century. Bonaventure himself says only that he was saved through Francis’s invocation and merits, there is no evidence that Francis was still alive, and others bore the name before him.

The hat on the treeTradition

The pope’s envoys who brought him the cardinal’s hat are said to have found him washing dishes outside a friary near Florence. He asked them to hang it on a nearby tree until his hands were free.60

Repeated by the Catholic Encyclopedia (1907) as something that “is said”; it names no early source.

A saint working for a saintTradition

Thomas Aquinas, the story goes, came to Bonaventure’s cell while he was writing the Life of Francis, found him rapt in ecstasy, and withdrew, saying, “Let us leave a saint to work for a saint.”61

Called “well known” by the Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), which gives no early source.

The papacy refusedDisputed

During the long vacancy at Viterbo the electors are said to have offered Bonaventure the papacy, and he to have suggested Teobaldo Visconti instead.62,63

The earliest source for his naming Teobaldo, Bartholomew of Pisa, wrote about 1385, more than a century later. The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907) thought it most improbable that the cardinals let him nominate himself.

Poisoned at LyonDisputed

According to the chronicle of his secretary, Bonaventure was poisoned.64

In the chronicle of Peregrinus of Bologna, his secretary, recovered and edited in 1905. The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907) reports it with caution: the cause of his death is unknown.

What the Church says

Feast: 15 July

Dante put him among the saints in Paradise, but the canonisation was slow in coming, mainly because of the quarrels in the order after his death. Pope Sixtus IV canonised him on 14 April 1482, and Sixtus V later named him among the principal Doctors of the Church.

In 1562 Huguenots, French Protestants, plundered his shrine at Lyon and burned his body in the public square; his head was hidden by the superior, who paid for it with his life, and was lost in the French Revolution.65,66,67,68

He is called the Seraphic Doctor, and the Church keeps his feast on 15 July. His statue faces Thomas Aquinas’s across St Peter’s Square, at the start of the two wings of the colonnade, and Pope Francis wrote, for the 750th anniversary of their deaths, that the two “form a precious ‘companionship’ for every pilgrim journeying towards Christ.”69,70,71,72

Benedict XVI, who had studied him as a young scholar, called him “a man of action and contemplation, of profound piety and prudent government”, and confessed “a certain nostalgia” in speaking of an author “particularly dear to me”.73

The evidence73 quotations from 12 sources · ✓ checked line by line

Each quotation was compared, word for word, with a saved copy of the page it comes from.

  1. 1
    Named Giovanni; the illness, his doctor father's despair, his mother's prayer to Francis, recovery.
    “He was called Giovanni di Fidanza. An episode that occurred when he was still a boy deeply marked his life, as he himself recounts. He fell seriously ill and even his father, who was a doctor, gave up all hope of saving him from death. So his mother had recourse to the intercession of St Francis of Assisi, who had recently been canonized. And Giovanni recovered.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  2. 2
    Clothed about 1243 and named Bonaventure.
    “So it was that in about the year 1243 Giovanni was clothed in the Franciscan habit and took the name "Bonaventure".”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  3. 3
    Received as master together with Thomas Aquinas.
    “Pope Alexander IV ordered the secular Masters at Paris to accept Bonaventure and the Dominican Thomas Aquinas in their rightful places as Masters of Theology”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  4. 4
    Seventeen years in office; visiting provinces, writing, correcting abuses.
    “He fulfilled this office for 17 years with wisdom and dedication, visiting the provinces, writing to his brethren, and at times intervening with some severity to eliminate abuses.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  5. 5
    Made cardinal in 1273; asked to prepare the Council of Lyon for communion with the Greeks.
    “In 1273, St Bonaventure experienced another great change in his life. Pope Gregory X wanted to consecrate him a Bishop and to appoint him a Cardinal. The Pope also asked him to prepare the Second Ecumenical Council of Lyons, a most important ecclesial event, for the purpose of re-establishing communion between the Latin Church and the Greek Church.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  6. 6
    He died while the council was still sitting, Sunday 15 July 1274.
    “While the council was still in session, Bonaventure died, Sunday, 15 July, 1274.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  7. 7
    Childhood and youth in Bagnoregio.
    “He spent his childhood and adolescence here in Bagnoregio”
    Benedict XVI, 6 September 2009, Meeting with the people of Bagnoregio · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Bagnoregio, 6 September 2009 · the Holy See
  8. 8
    At La Verna in October 1259, where Francis received the stigmata, he conceived the Journey of the Mind to God.
    “For Francis’s feast day in October, 1259, Bonaventure visited Mt. Alverna, the very place where Francis himself had received a mystical vision of Christ “under the appearance” of “a Seraph having six wings” and had “imprinted in his flesh” the stigmata or wounds of Christ ... Here Bonaventure conceived the idea for his Journey of the Mind to God”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  9. 9
    His own account of how the Journey began.
    “While I meditated on the possible ascent of the mind to God, amongst other things there occurred that miracle which happened in the same place to the blessed Francis himself, namely the vision of the winged Seraph in the form of a Crucifix. While meditating upon this vision, I immediately saw that it offered me the ecstatic contemplation of Fr Francis himself as well as the way that leads to it”
    Benedict XVI, 10 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (2) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 10 March 2010, quoting the Journey, Prologue 2 · the Holy See
  10. 10
    The six wings as six stages to union with the Trinity through Christ.
    “The six wings of the Seraph thus became the symbol of the six stages that lead man progressively from the knowledge of God, through the observation of the world and creatures and through the exploration of the soul itself with its faculties, to the satisfying union with the Trinity through Christ”
    Benedict XVI, 10 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (2) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 10 March 2010 · the Holy See
  11. 11
    Elected Minister General on 2 February 1257, not yet thirty-six; the order divided over poverty.
    “In the meantime Bonaventure, though not yet thirty-six years old, had on 2 February, 1257, been elected Minister General of the Friars Minor — an office of peculiar difficulty, owing to the fact that the order was distracted by internal dissensions between the two factions among the Friars designated respectively the Spirituales and the Relaxati . The former insisted upon the literal observance of the original Rule, especially in regard to poverty”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  12. 12
    More than 30,000 friars, as far as Peking.
    “there were more than 30,000 Friars scattered throughout the West with missionaries in North Africa, the Middle East, and even in Peking.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  13. 13
    The constitutions ratified at Narbonne in 1260.
    “To avoid this danger in 1260 the General Chapter of the Order in Narbonne accepted and ratified a text proposed by Bonaventure in which the norms regulating the daily life of the Friars Minor were collected and unified.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  14. 14
    In 1260 the chapter asked for a Life of Francis to supersede the others.
    “The chapter which issued this code of laws requested Bonaventure to write a "legend" or life of St. Francis which should supersede those then in circulation. This was in 1260.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  15. 15
    He went to Assisi and talked with Francis's surviving friends.
    “I betook me unto the place of his birth, and there did hold diligent converse with his familiar friends that were yet living, touching the manner of life of the holy man and his passing away”
    Bonaventure, translated by E. Gurney Salter, in the Everyman volume The Little Flowers, Life and Mirror of St. Francis (1910), The Life of St. Francis (Legenda Maior, 1260-63), Prologue · J. M. Dent, via archive.org · Prologue, 4 · their own words or the earliest accounts
  16. 16
    Approved at Pisa in 1263 as the official biography.
    “the General Chapter of the Friars Minor in 1263, meeting in Pisa, recognized St Bonaventure's biography as the most faithful portrait of their Founder and so it became the Saint's official biography.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  17. 17
    The 1266 decree to destroy the earlier Lives of Francis, and the dispute over it.
    “In 1266 Bonaventure convened a general chapter in Paris at which, besides other enactments, it was decreed that all the "legends" of St. Francis written before that of Bonaventure should be forthwith destroyed ... This decree has excited much hostile criticism. Some would fain see in it a deliberate attempt on Bonaventure's part to close the primitive sources of Franciscan history, to suppress the real Francis , and substitute a counterfeit in his stead. Others, however, regard the decree in question as a purely liturgical ordinance intended to secure uniformity in the choir "legends".”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  18. 18
    The Commentary on the Sentences, written at twenty-seven, over four thousand folio pages.
    “The Commentary on the "Sentences" remains without doubt Bonaventure's greatest work; all his other writings are in some way subservient to it. It was written, superiorum praecepto (at the command of his superiors) when he was only twenty-seven and is a theological achievement of the first rank. It comprises more than four thousand pages in folio”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  19. 19
    The Sentences were Peter Lombard's.
    “the Sentences of Peter Lombard the theology manual in that time”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  20. 20
    He directed the council's deliberations and the talks with the Greeks; union accepted 6 July; he preached twice.
    “The pope himself presided at the council, but he confided the direction of its deliberations to Bonaventure, especially charging him to confer with the Greeks ... the Greeks accepted the union effected 6 July, 1274. Bonaventure twice addressed the assembled Fathers”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  21. 21
    Cardinal-Bishop of Albano much against his will.
    “Bonaventure, much against his will, was created Cardinal-Bishop of Albano , by Gregory X .”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  22. 22
    Born in all likelihood in 1217; died 1274.
    “St Bonaventure, in all likelihood born in 1217, died in 1274.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  23. 23
    Born at Bagnorea near Viterbo, in 1221 by the Encyclopedia's reckoning; died at Lyon 15 July 1274.
    “born at Bagnorea in the vicinity of Viterbo in 1221; died at Lyons , 15 July, 1274.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  24. 24
    His parents' names.
    “Nothing is known of Bonaventure's parents save their names: Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria Ritella.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  25. 25
    His own memory of being saved as a child through Francis.
    “For I, who remember as though it happened but yesterday how I was snatched from the jaws of death, while yet a child, by his invocation and merits, should fear to be convicted of the sin of ingratitude did I refrain from publishing his praises.”
    Bonaventure, translated by E. Gurney Salter, in the Everyman volume The Little Flowers, Life and Mirror of St. Francis (1910), The Life of St. Francis (Legenda Maior, 1260-63), Prologue · J. M. Dent, via archive.org · Prologue, 3 · their own words or the earliest accounts
  26. 26
    Went to Paris in 1235 and studied philosophy until 1243.
    “The general consensus remains that Bonaventure left Bagnoregio for Paris in 1235 and studied philosophy until 1243.”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  27. 27
    Master of Arts; drawn to the friars, who came to Paris in 1219; knocked at their door.
    “He had obtained a Master of Arts Diploma ... Fascinated by the witness of fervour and evangelical radicalism of the Friars Minor who had arrived in Paris in 1219, Giovanni knocked at the door of the Franciscan convent in that city and asked to be admitted to the great family of St Francis' disciples.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  28. 28
    Entry in 1238 or 1243, uncertain.
    “He entered the Order of Friars Minor in 1238 or 1243; the exact year is uncertain.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  29. 29
    His own reason for choosing Francis's life.
    “I confess before God that the reason which made me love the life of blessed Francis most is that it resembled the birth and early development of the Church. The Church began with simple fishermen, and was subsequently enriched by very distinguished and wise teachers; the religion of Blessed Francis was not established by the prudence of men but by Christ”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010, quoting the Letter on Three Questions · the Holy See
  30. 30
    Studied at Paris under Alexander of Hales.
    “Bonaventure was sent from the Roman Province, to which he belonged, to complete his studies at the University of Paris under Alexander of Hales , the great founder of the Franciscan School.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  31. 31
    William of Saint-Amour's attack of 1256.
    “The smouldering elements of discord had been fanned into a flame in 1256, when Guillaume de Saint-Amour published a work entitled "The Perils of the Last Times", in which he attacked the Friars with great bitterness.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  32. 32
    The friars' right to teach contested; he wrote Evangelical Perfection.
    “Their right to teach at the university was contested and doubt was even being cast upon the authenticity of their consecrated life. ... he composed a text entitled Evangelical Perfection.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  33. 33
    Alexander IV intervened; recognised as master in 1257; the same year elected Minister General and gave up the chair.
    “through the personal intervention of Pope Alexander IV in 1257, Bonaventure was officially recognized as a doctor and master of the University of Paris. However, he was obliged to relinquish this prestigious office because in that same year the General Chapter of the Order elected him Minister General.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  34. 34
    His first letter to the friars, 23 April 1257.
    “Bonaventure quickly set a firm direction for the Order in an “encyclical letter” to all the friars on 23 April 1257, which admonished them to recover the “somewhat tarnished” luster of the Order”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  35. 35
    He travelled on foot.
    “For most of the period from 1257 through 1266 Bonaventure trekked through France and Italy by foot, as did all friars when they traveled.”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  36. 36
    Blind, deaf and mute before creation.
    “He who is not brightened by such splendours of created things is blind; he who does not awake at such clamours is deaf; he who does not praise God on account of all these effects is mute”
    Benedict XVI, 17 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (3) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 17 March 2010, quoting the Journey I, 15 · the Holy See
  37. 37
    The seraphic poet of creation.
    “St Bonaventure was the seraphic poet of creation who, in the sequela of St Francis, learned "to praise God in all things and through all his creatures"”
    Benedict XVI, 6 September 2009, Meeting with the people of Bagnoregio · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Bagnoregio, 6 September 2009 · the Holy See
  38. 38
    Theology born of love.
    “One who loves wants to know his beloved better and better; true theology does not involve reason and its research prompted by pride”
    Benedict XVI, 17 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (3) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 17 March 2010 · the Holy See
  39. 39
    Reading will not suffice without unction; knowledge without love.
    “reading will not suffice "without unction, speculation without devotion, investigation without admiration, observation without exultation, diligence without compassion, industry without piety, knowledge without love”
    Benedict XVI, 6 September 2009, Meeting with the people of Bagnoregio · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Bagnoregio, 6 September 2009, quoting the Journey, Prologue 4 · the Holy See
  40. 40
    Giles was no lettered man but had learned at the feet of Francis.
    “he was not even a lettered man ... but he had studied in a fine school when he sat at the feet of St. Francis”
    Paschal Robinson (1907), The Golden Sayings of the Blessed Brother Giles of Assisi, introduction · Dolphin Press, via archive.org · Introduction, p. xxx · scholarship
  41. 41
    Brother Giles and the poor old woman.
    “" My Father," he once said to St. Bonaventure, " God hath laden thee with many graces in giv- ing thee that knowledge which helpeth thee to praise Him. But we poor ignorant creatures, how can we correspond with His goodness?" When the Saint replied that if God had given man His love alone it would suffice, " What," exclaimed Giles, " can an ignorant man love God as much as a learned one? " " Certainly," replied the Seraphic Doctor ; " a poor little old woman can love God as much or more than a Master in Theology." Whereupon Giles, run- ning to the garden wall overlooking the town, cried out to a poor woman who was passing: " O poor little old woman, foolish and ignorant as thou art, love the Lord God and thou mayest be greater than Brother Bonaventure."”
    Paschal Robinson (1907), The Golden Sayings of the Blessed Brother Giles of Assisi, introduction · Dolphin Press, via archive.org · Introduction, p. xxix · scholarship
  42. 42
    The lives of Giles survive in fourteenth-century compilations such as the Chronicle of the Twenty-four Generals, completed in 1379.
    “The well-known "Chronica XXIV Gene- ralium," a compilation of about the middle of ... the fourteenth century, but containing many early documents ... This Chronicle, which was completed in 1379”
    Paschal Robinson (1907), The Golden Sayings of the Blessed Brother Giles of Assisi, introduction · Dolphin Press, via archive.org · Introduction, pp. ix-x · scholarship
  43. 43
    Gathering fragments before the companions died.
    “might collect as best I could, albeit I could not fully, his deeds and words—fragments, as it were, overlooked in part, in part scattered—that they might not be utterly lost on the death of those that lived with the servant of God.”
    Bonaventure, translated by E. Gurney Salter, in the Everyman volume The Little Flowers, Life and Mirror of St. Francis (1910), The Life of St. Francis (Legenda Maior, 1260-63), Prologue · J. M. Dent, via archive.org · Prologue, 3 · their own words or the earliest accounts
  44. 44
    The evening bell for the Annunciation, the origin of the Angelus.
    “At this chapter of 1263, Bonaventure fixed the limits of the different provinces of the order and, among other ordinances, prescribed that at nightfall a bell should be rung in honour of the Annunciation, a pious practice from which the Angelus seems to have originated.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  45. 45
    He resumed the direction of the Poor Clares.
    “In 1264, at the earnest request of Cardinal Cajetan, Bonaventure consented to resume the direction of the Poor Clares which the Chapter of Pisa had entirely renounced the year before.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  46. 46
    Holiness of Life, written for a Poor Clare, probably Isabella, sister of St Louis.
    ““Holiness of Life” was addressed to a Poor Clare of Bonaventure’s acquaintance, probably Isabella, the sister of St. Louis, King of France.”
    Bonaventure, translated by Laurence Costello (1923), Holiness of Life (De perfectione vitae ad sorores), editor's introduction · B. Herder, via archive.org · Editor's introduction · their own words or the earliest accounts
  47. 47
    Louis IX his friend; the Office of the Passion at his request.
    “This was the first step towards the canonization of the holy king, who had been a special friend of Bonaventure, and at whose request Bonaventure composed his "Office of the Passion".”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  48. 48
    He refused the archbishopric of York in 1265.
    “In 1265 Clement IV , by a Bull dated 23 November, nominated Bonaventure to the vacant Archbishopric of York, but the saint , in keeping with his singular humility , steadfastly refused this honour and the pope yielded.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  49. 49
    The long vacancy; his sermon at Viterbo; Teobaldo elected Gregory X in 1271.
    “During the three-year Papal vacancy, from 29 November 1268 to 1 September 1271, Bonaventure preached an important sermon in Viterbo and was perhaps instrumental in ending the vacancy. ... After Teobaldi’s election as Pope Gregory X”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  50. 50
    The cardinals at Viterbo divided for nearly three years after Clement IV died.
    “the differences among the cardinals assembled at Viterbo to elect a successor to Clement IV , who had died nearly three years before”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  51. 51
    Michael VIII, threatened by Charles of Anjou, offered the Greek Church's acceptance of papal authority in return for the pope's help.
    “In response to these pressures, Emperor Michael VIII appealed for support to Pope Gregory X (r. 1271–1276), who opposed Charles’ designs on Constantinople. Michael suggested that in return for military assistance, the Greek Church would accept the authority of the Papacy.”
    Thomas Hopko, The Orthodox Faith, The Second Council of Lyons (The Orthodox Faith, vol. III: Church History) · Orthodox Church in America · The Second Council of Lyons · Catholic reference
  52. 52
    He handed the order to Jerome of Ascoli in May 1274; the council opened 7 May 1274.
    “Bonaventure continued to govern the Order of Friars Minor until 20 May, 1274, when at the General Chapter of Lyons , Jerome of Ascoli, afterwards Nicholas IV , was elected to succeed him. Meanwhile Bonaventure had been charged by Gregory X to prepare the questions to be discussed at the Fourteenth Oecumenical Council , which opened at Lyons 7 May, 1274.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  53. 53
    The council's acts on his death and funeral.
    “at the hour of Matins died Br. Bonaventure of happy memory, Bishop of Albano, who was a man eminent for his knowledge and eloquence ( homo eminentis scientie et eloquentie ), a man outstanding for his sanctity and acknowledged for the excellence of his life ... Br. Peter of Tarantasia [also a Cardinal] celebrated the funeral mass and preached on the theme “I am saddened over you, my brother Jonathan”. There were many tears and much weeping”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works, quoting the acts of the Second Council of Lyon · scholarship
  54. 54
    The Greek delegates accepted papal authority and the filioque; at home the union met great resistance; Patriarch Joseph deposed; renounced after Michael's death in 1282.
    “The Greek delegation brought letters accepting Papal authority and various Roman Catholic articles of faith, including the filioque clause in the Nicene Creed. ... When Emperor Michael VIII attempted to impose the so-called Union of Lyons upon the Byzantine Church, it was met with great resistance. When Patriarch Joseph of Constantinople refused to sign the agreement, he was deposed and replaced with John Beccus, who was the head of the minority party in Constantinople that favored the Union. But after Michael died in 1282, Beccus was quickly deposed, Joseph was restored to the patriarchal throne, and the Union of Lyons was officially renounced.”
    Thomas Hopko, The Orthodox Faith, The Second Council of Lyons (The Orthodox Faith, vol. III: Church History) · Orthodox Church in America · The Second Council of Lyons · Catholic reference
  55. 55
    The funeral attended by pope, king and cardinals; Gregory X ordered Masses throughout the world.
    “being honoured with a splendid funeral which was attended by the pope , the King of Aragon , the cardinals , and the other members of the council. ... Gregory X spoke of the irreparable loss the Church had sustained by the death of Bonaventure, and commanded all prelates and priests throughout the whole world to celebrate Mass for the repose of his soul .”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  56. 56
    The anonymous papal notary's eulogy.
    “An anonymous papal notary composed a eulogy to Bonaventure which gives us a conclusive portrait of this great Saint and excellent theologian. "A good, affable, devout and compassionate man, full of virtue, beloved of God and human beings alike ... God in fact had bestowed upon him such grace that all who saw him were pervaded by a love that their hearts could not conceal"”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See
  57. 57
    The Itinerarium's last words on grace, desire and fire.
    “If you should wish to know how these things come about, (the mystical communion with God) question grace, not instruction; desire, not intellect; the cry of prayer, not pursuit of study; the spouse, not the teacher; God, not man; darkness, not clarity; not light, but the fire that inflames all and transports to God with fullest unction and burning affection”
    Benedict XVI, 10 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (2) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 10 March 2010, quoting the Journey VII, 6 · the Holy See
  58. 58
    The "O buona ventura" story is a late fifteenth-century legend; the name was borne by others.
    “An attempt has been made to trace the latter name to the exclamation of St. Francis , O buona ventura , when Bonaventure was brought as an infant to him to be cured of a dangerous illness. This derivation is highly improbable; it seems based on a late fifteenth-century legend. Bonaventure himself tells us (Legenda S. Francisci Prolog.) that while yet a child he was preserved from death through the intercession of St. Francis , but there is no evidence that this cure took place during the lifetime of St. Francis or that the name Bonaventure originated in any prophetical words of St. Francis . It was certainly borne by others before the Seraphic Doctor.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  59. 59
    Benedict XVI, at Bagnoregio, repeats the mayor: Francis predicted "good fortune" for him.
    “had predicted "good fortune" for him, as your Mayor has just recalled.”
    Benedict XVI, 6 September 2009, Meeting with the people of Bagnoregio · The Holy See (vatican.va) · Bagnoregio, 6 September 2009 · the Holy See
  60. 60
    The cardinal's hat hung on a tree.
    “It is said that the pope's envoys who brought him the cardinal's hat found the saint washing dishes outside a convent near Florence and were requested by him to hang it on a tree nearby until his hands were free to take it.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  61. 61
    Thomas Aquinas at his cell: a saint working for a saint.
    “And the story of St. Thomas visiting Bonaventure's cell while the latter was writing the life of St. Francis and finding him in an ecstasy is well known. "Let us leave a saint to work for a saint", said the Angelic Doctor as he withdrew.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  62. 62
    Said to have been offered the papacy and to have suggested Teobaldo; the earliest source wrote about 1385.
    “He is said to have been offered the papacy by the electors and to have suggested Teobaldi Visconti instead. ... Bartholomew of Pisa, the earliest source for Bonaventure suggesting Teobaldo’s name, wrote ca. 1385.”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  63. 63
    The Encyclopedia doubts that the cardinals let him name himself.
    “That the cardinals seriously authorized Bonaventure to nominate himself, as some writers aver, is most improbable.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  64. 64
    The poison story rests on his secretary's chronicle, recovered in 1905.
    “The exact cause of his death is unknown, but if we may credit the chronicle of Peregrinus of Bologna, Bonaventure's secretary, which has recently (1905) been recovered and edited, the saint was poisoned.”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  65. 65
    Dante placed him among the saints in Paradise.
    “Though Dante placed Bonaventure among the saints in his Paradiso (Canto 12)”
    Tim Noone and R. E. Houser, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Saint Bonaventure · Stanford University (plato.stanford.edu) · 1. Life and Works · scholarship
  66. 66
    Canonised by Sixtus IV on 14 April 1482; delay due to dissension in the order; later Doctor of the Church by Sixtus V.
    “That its inception was so long delayed was mainly due to the deplorable dissensions within the order after Bonaventure's death. Finally on 14 April, 1482, Bonaventure was enrolled in the catalogue of the saints by Sixtus IV .”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  67. 67
    Huguenots burned his body in 1562; his head hidden, then lost in the Revolution; declared a Doctor by Sixtus V.
    “In 1562 Bonaventure's shrine was plundered by the Huguenots and the urn containing his body was burned in the public square. His head was preserved through the heroism of the superior, who hid it at the cost of his life but it disappeared during the French Revolution ... Bonaventure was inscribed among the principal Doctors of the Church by Sixtus V”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  68. 68
    His remains lay at Lyon, in the new church of St Francis from 1434.
    “in 1434, Bonaventure's remains were translated to the new church erected at Lyons in honour of St. Francis”
    Paschal Robinson, Catholic Encyclopedia vol. 2 (1907), St. Bonaventure · New Advent · St. Bonaventure · Catholic reference
  69. 69
    The Seraphic Doctor.
    “let us accept the invitation addressed to us by St Bonaventure, the Seraphic Doctor”
    Benedict XVI, 10 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (2) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 10 March 2010 · the Holy See
  70. 70
    Feast on 15 July; his titles in the Church's calendar.
    “15 July ... St. Bonaventure of Bagnoregio, Cardinal, Bishop of Alban and Doctor of the Church, Franciscan”
    Vatican News, Saint of the Day, calendar for 15 July · Dicastery for Communication (vaticannews.va) · Saint of the Day, 15 July · the Holy See
  71. 71
    Their statues stand side by side in St Peter's Square.
    “Even the statues of the two Saints in St Peter's Square are parallel. They stand right at the beginning of the colonnade, starting from the façade of the Vatican Basilica; one is on the left wing and the other on the right.”
    Benedict XVI, 17 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure (3) · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 17 March 2010 · the Holy See
  72. 72
    Pope Francis: Aquinas and Bonaventure as companions for pilgrims.
    “the Doctor Communis and the Doctor Seraphicus form a precious 'companionship' for every pilgrim journeying towards Christ.”
    Vatican News, on Pope Francis's message for the 750th anniversary of their deaths (October 2024), 'Saints Bonaventure and Thomas Aquinas are sources of inspiration' · Dicastery for Communication (vaticannews.va) · October 2024 · the Holy See
  73. 73
    Benedict XVI on Bonaventure as dear to him, and a man of action and contemplation.
    “I feel a certain nostalgia, for I am thinking back to my research as a young scholar on this author who was particularly dear to me. ... a man of action and contemplation, of profound piety and prudent government.”
    Benedict XVI, 3 March 2010, General Audience: Saint Bonaventure · The Holy See (vatican.va) · General Audience, 3 March 2010 · the Holy See

The life rests on Benedict XVI's three catecheses of March 2010 and his address at Bagnoregio (2009), on Bonaventure's own words in the prologue to his Life of St Francis (Salter's translation, 1910) and in the passages of the Journey of the Mind to God and the Letter on Three Questions that Benedict XVI quotes, on the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy for dates and the acts of the Council of Lyon, and on the Catholic Encyclopedia (1907). His birth year is given as 1217 by Benedict XVI and 1221 by the Encyclopedia; his entry into the order as about 1243 or 1238. The Encyclopedia gives the date he became a cardinal as 23 June 1273 and the Stanford Encyclopedia as 28 May, so the life gives only the year. The Encyclopedia's date for his proclamation as Doctor is a misprint, so no year is given. Stories first written down long after his death, and those the reference works repeat without a source, are kept in told_about. Researched 2026-09-26.

Questions people ask next

Whose feast is today? →