The wars of religion end in exhaustion
Thirty years of Catholic and Protestant armies devastate central Europe; the peace settles by treaty what argument could not.
In 1555 the Peace of Augsburg let each ruler in the Holy Roman Empire choose Lutheran or Catholic for his land, and left Calvinists out. By 1600 both sides were armed and suspicious.
In 1618 Protestant nobles in Bohemia, afraid of losing their freedom to worship, threw two royal governors out of a castle window in Prague. A revolt became a war that drew in Denmark, Sweden, Spain and France.
For thirty years armies fought mostly across Germany and lived off the land. Historians estimate 4.5 to 8 million dead, most of them civilians. From 1631 Catholic France was paying Protestant Sweden to fight the Catholic Habsburgs. The peace of 1648 recognised Lutherans and Calvinists beside Catholics.
The pope protested, but Europe stopped trying to settle doctrine by war.
The situation
The Holy Roman Empire was a patchwork of hundreds of states in central Europe: kingdoms, duchies, free cities and lands ruled by . Over them sat an elected emperor, by now always from the Habsburg family, and always a Catholic.
After the Reformation the Empire's rulers split. The Peace of Augsburg in 1555 let each ruler choose Lutheran or Catholic, and his subjects had to follow or leave. Calvinists, the Reformed churches, were left out entirely.
By 1600 the deal was fraying. The Catholic revival after the , the Church's reforming of 1545–63, was winning lands back, and Calvinism was spreading. In 1608 princes formed a Union, and in 1609 Catholic princes answered with a League. Both sides were armed and expecting the worst.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Augsburg, 1555: everyone else excluded
The Peace of Augsburg covered only Catholics and Lutherans. Its seventeenth section left the rest out.
“All others, however, who are not adherents of either of the aforementioned religions are not included in this peace, but shall be altogether excluded from it.”
The Religious Peace of Augsburg · Religious Peace of Augsburg, § 17 - 02
Two armed camps
A modern survey dates the two alliances that faced each other when the war began.
“When Frederick IV, Elector Palatine formed the Protestant Union in 1608, Maximilian responded by setting up the Catholic League in July 1609.”
Thirty Years' War · Thirty Years' War (tertiary), Background
What was at stake
Bohemia, today's Czech Republic, was a Habsburg kingdom with a Protestant nobility. In 1609 the emperor had granted them a charter of religious freedom.
Then the Habsburgs put forward as their next king Ferdinand, who had already restored Catholicism in his own lands of Styria, and in 1617 the Bohemian nobles accepted him.
The Bohemian nobles were sure their charter would be next. Ferdinand and his supporters saw rebels using religion to defy their lawful king. Each side believed the other meant to destroy it.
And no one was left whom both sides would obey. Rome could not bind the Protestant princes, and the princes would not bind each other. The emperor was himself a party. The only remaining judge was an army.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
A Catholic historian on the causes
The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1912 names religious zeal on both sides as one cause, alongside a weak empire and foreign powers waiting to step in.
“If among Protestants the idealistic enthusiasm was perhaps not so great, still their partisan feeling was equally violent and their combativeness no less ardent.”
Thirty Years War · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Thirty Years War', Causes of the war
The event
On 23 May 1618 Protestant nobles in Prague tried two of the king's governors and threw them, with their secretary, out of a castle window. All three survived the fall. The revolt that followed lit a war that lasted thirty years.
It was fought mostly in Germany by armies of hired soldiers who fed themselves by plundering the country. Catholic and Protestant troops did the same things. In May 1631 Catholic forces sacked the Protestant city of Magdeburg, and of about 25,000 people only some 5,000 survived.
Swedish armies, Protestant, marched and burned across the Empire in turn. Historians estimate 4.5 to 8 million dead from fighting, hunger and disease, most of them civilians. Parts of Germany lost more than half their people.
And the religious lines blurred. Catholic France, whose chief minister was a cardinal, Richelieu, paid Protestant Sweden to fight the Catholic Habsburgs, because France feared Habsburg power more than it feared Protestants.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Out of the window
The Protestant estates tried the two governors on the spot and wrote a long defence of what they had done.
“Shortly thereafter, the two regents and their secretary were defenestrated, but they survived the 70-foot (21-metre) fall from the third floor.”
Defenestrations of Prague · Defenestrations of Prague (tertiary), 1618 - 02
Magdeburg, May 1631
The worst single massacre of the war was done by the imperial army and the Catholic League to a Protestant city.
“Of the 25,000 inhabitants, only 5,000 survived, at least 1,000 of these having fled into Magdeburg Cathedral and 600 into the Premonstratensian monastery.”
Sack of Magdeburg · Sack of Magdeburg (tertiary) - 03
The toll
Current estimates, with the older exaggerations set aside.
“Estimates of total deaths range from 4.5 to 8 million, most incurred after 1630 when Sweden entered the war, the vast majority being civilians.”
Thirty Years' War · Thirty Years' War (tertiary), Human and financial cost
The outcome
Peace was signed at Münster and Osnabrück in 1648. It declared a general amnesty, a promise on both sides to forget and forgive what had been done in the war.
It confirmed the legal standing the Lutherans' had won in 1555, and for the first time recognised the Calvinists. Church property and each land's official religion were fixed by how things had stood in 1624.
Minorities were promised at least the right to worship privately at home.
Innocent X protested. Dioceses and church lands were handed to Protestant rulers, and in November 1648 he declared those articles void. The powers went ahead anyway.
Europe stopped trying to settle by war. No one had won the argument. Both sides had simply run out of the strength to keep killing over it.
Go furtherFold· 2 notes, each with its source
- 01
Legal standing for Lutherans, and a fixed reference year
Article XXVIII restores churches and estates as they stood in 1624 and grants the free exercise of the Augsburg Confession in public and private.
“…shall be put in possession again of their Churches, and Ecclesiastical Estates, as they were in the Year 1624. as also that all others of the said Confession of Augsburg, who shall demand it, shall have the free Exercise of their Religion, as well in publick Churches at the appointed Hours, as in private in their own Houses, or in others chosen for this purpose by their Ministers.”
Treaty of Westphalia · Treaty of Westphalia, Article XXVIII - 02
Innocent X: 'null and void'
The Catholic Encyclopedia's account of the pope's protest. His concern was the dioceses and church lands the treaty gave to Protestant rulers.
“On 26 November, 1648, Innocent issued the famous Bull "Zelo domus Dei", in which he declares as null and void those articles of the Peace of Westphalia which were detrimental to the Catholic religion.”
Pope Innocent X · Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope Innocent X'
For the trail
The Thirty Years' War is where the practical case for forcing religion began to die in Europe. A century of wars had shown that neither side could make the other believe.
It took the Church much longer to state the principle. Only in 1965 did it declare that no one may be forced in religion, and that the right rests on the dignity of the person, not on who is right. The trail runs from here to that declaration.
Long after, the Church named the method itself as a fault. A study prepared for the Jubilee of 2000 listed the ‘methods of violence and intolerance’ once used to spread the faith among the things the Church confesses.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
What Rome eventually said about the method
The International Theological Commission's study for the Jubilee names the use of force in evangelising among the faults the Church acknowledges.
“Some of these are explicitly mentioned, like the separation of Christians, or the 'methods of violence and intolerance' used in the past to evangelize.”
Memory and Reconciliation: The Church and the Faults of the Past · Memory and Reconciliation, section 3
What the Church says
Pope Innocent X declared the peace's religious clauses void in November 1648. In his view church lands and dioceses had been handed to Protestant rulers without the Church's consent.
The Church's teaching since 1965 is that faith must never be imposed by force or by the state (Dignitatis Humanae 2). In 2000 John Paul II asked forgiveness ‘for the violence some have used in the service of the truth’.
Think of it like this
A family feud that ends not with anyone admitting fault, but with the house half burnt down and a lawyer drafting terms.
Westphalia did not decide who had been right about the Eucharist or the papacy. It decided that the question would no longer be settled by cavalry, drew lines on a map, and let each ruler's confession stand where it stood in a fixed year. Peace came as a legal truce over an unresolved argument.
“That there shall be on the one side and the other a perpetual Oblivion, Amnesty, or Pardon of all that has been committed since the beginning of these Troubles, in what place, or what manner soever the Hostilitys have been practis'd, in such a manner, that no body, under any pretext whatsoever, shall practice any Acts of Hostility, entertain any Enmity, or cause any Trouble to each other.”
Where people disagree
Historians argue over how religious the war really was. By its later years France was fighting for power, not faith. Others answer that the war began over religion and that people on both sides believed they were fighting for God.
The death toll is argued too. Older claims of 12 million dead out of 18 million are no longer accepted, and the figures rest on patchy local records.
What no one disputes is that both churches blessed armies that destroyed the same villages.
Go furtherFold· 1 note, each with its source
- 01
Older figures set aside
The same survey on why the famous figures are no longer used.
“Claims of up to 12 million deaths from a population of 18 million are no longer considered realistic”
Thirty Years' War · Thirty Years' War (tertiary), Human and financial cost
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- 1648-10-24 · Avalon Project, Yale Law School
- International Theological Commission · 2000-03-07 · Holy See