The RiverThe Reformation
1620

The Pilgrims sail and found Plymouth

A Separatist church from Scrooby, exiled to Leiden, sends part of its flock across the Atlantic on the Mayflower; off Cape Cod they sign a compact, and at Plymouth they plant a self-governing church.

Historical evidence Quotes checked
In brief

Around 1600 some English Puritans gave up on reforming the Church of England from inside. These Separatists formed churches of their own by covenant, a solemn promise to God and to one another. One met at Scrooby in Nottinghamshire.

Harassed by the church courts, it escaped to Holland in 1607–08 and settled at Leiden under its pastor, John Robinson.

In 1620 part of the church sailed for America on the Mayflower. Storms brought them to Cape Cod, outside the land their permit covered, so on 11 November the men signed a compact to make their own laws. In December they settled at Plymouth.

By spring about half of the hundred or so passengers had died.

Where we are

The situation

Around 1600 England had one church by law, the Church of England. The monarch was its head and ran it. Everyone was expected at their parish church on Sunday, and staying away could bring fines.

Puritans wanted that church reformed further: plainer worship, more preaching, stricter discipline. Most stayed in and pushed from inside. A few, called Separatists, gave up on it.

Their reason was simple. A parish took in everyone who lived in it, believers or not. A true church, they held, was a company of believers who had chosen to join, bound by a , a solemn promise to God and to one another.

About 1606 such a church began meeting at Scrooby Manor in Nottinghamshire, the house of William Brewster. Its members, William Bradford wrote, joined themselves ‘into a church estate, in the felowship of the gospell’. No bishop or king had made this church; its members had.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    The Scrooby covenant

    Bradford, a member of the Scrooby church and later governor of Plymouth, describes its founding. The promise to follow whatever God should make known would matter later.

    “as the Lords free people, joyned them selves (by a covenant of the Lord) into a church estate, in the felowship of the gospell, to walke in all his wayes, made known, or to be made known”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book I, ch. 1 (Davis ed., p. 31)
  2. 02

    Two churches, one of them Smyth's

    Bradford records that the Separatists of the district formed two congregations. The one he leaves aside was John Smyth's, which became Baptist in Amsterdam.

    “These people became 2. distincte bodys or churches, and in regarde of distance of place did congregate severally”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book I, ch. 1 (Davis ed., p. 31)
  3. 03

    The first known church of its kind

    J. V. Bartlet's dating of Browne's Norwich church, and of Browne's retreat from it.

    “Between 1580 and 1581, when Browne formed in Norwich the first known church of this order on definite scriptural theory”
    Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Congregationalism', section on Browne
The problem

What was at stake

Leaving the Church of England was against the law. Bradford says the Scrooby Separatists were ‘hunted and persecuted on every side’. Some were jailed; others had their houses watched night and day.

The authorities had their reasons. In England church and crown were one system, and one religion was thought to hold the kingdom together. To set up a church of your own looked like refusing the king.

So in 1607–08 the congregation slipped away to Holland, where, they had heard, there was ‘freedome of Religion for all men’. One attempt failed when the ship's master betrayed them. By 1609 they had settled at Leiden.

Leiden was safe but hard. The work was heavy, and parents watched their children drift into soldiering and the sea. Bradford feared ‘their posteritie would be in danger to degenerate and be corrupted.’ Freedom to worship did not guarantee the church a future.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Not tarrying for the magistrate

    Browne's Treatise of 1582 answered Puritans who said reform must wait for the queen and Parliament.

    “howe then shoulde his kingdome tarie for the Magistrate, except they thinke that they are better able to vpholde it then he”
    A Treatise of Reformation without Tarying for Anie · A Treatise of Reformation without Tarying for Anie (1582), 1903 reprint
  2. 02

    Hunted on every side

    Bradford on what followed the founding of the Scrooby church.

    “For some were taken and clapt up in prison, others had their houses besett and watcht night and day, and hardly escaped their hands”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book I, ch. 1 (Davis ed., p. 32)
  3. 03

    Terms offered to the king

    To win leave to settle in the king's lands, the Leiden church sent the Privy Council seven articles in 1617, signed by Robinson and Brewster.

    “acknowledging the king's authority in all causes, and that of bishops as civilly commissioned by him”
    Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography (1897), 'Robinson, John (1576?-1625)', by Alexander Gordon
What happened

The event

In 1617 the Leiden church began planning to emigrate. Only a minority volunteered, so the pastor, John Robinson, stayed with the majority. William Brewster went as their elder, a lay leader of the congregation, not an minister.

After a day of prayer they sailed from Delfshaven on 22 July 1620. Their second ship proved unfit, and the Mayflower left Plymouth in Devon alone on 6 September with about a hundred passengers. Many were not church members at all.

Storms brought them to Cape Cod, outside the land their permit covered. Some of the non-members said that once ashore ‘none had power to command them’.

So on 11 November, before anyone went ashore, the men signed a compact, binding themselves into ‘a civil Body Politick’ to make their own laws. In December they settled at Plymouth.

Go further· 3 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    They knew they were pilgrims

    Bradford's account of leaving Leiden in July 1620 gave the settlers the name they are remembered by.

    “So they lefte that goodly and pleasante citie, which had been ther resting place near 12. years; but they knew they were pilgrimes”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book I, ch. 7 (Davis ed., p. 79)
  2. 02

    Why a compact

    Bradford says the compact was made partly because some of the strangers, passengers who were not of the Leiden church, talked of going their own way once ashore.

    “when they came a shore they would use their owne libertie; for none had power to command them”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book II, 1620 (Davis ed., p. 106)
  3. 03

    The first winter

    Bradford on the months after the landing.

    “in 2. or 3. moneths time halfe of their company dyed, espetialy in Jan: and February, being the depth of winter”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book II, 1620-21 (Davis ed., pp. 107-108)
What came of it

The outcome

The first winter was terrible. Of a hundred and more, Bradford wrote, ‘scarce 50. remained.’

They survived with the help of their neighbours, the Wampanoag. In March 1621 the Wampanoag leader, Massasoit, made a peace with the settlers that held for more than 50 years.

With him came Squanto, a man born where Plymouth now stood. An English captain had kidnapped him in 1614 to sell as a slave in Spain. He escaped to England, learned English, and came home to find his people, the Patuxet, wiped out by disease.

Squanto stayed with the settlers until he died in 1622, interpreting for them and showing them how to plant corn and where to fish.

The church lived on without its pastor. Robinson never came, and he would not let Brewster, an elder but not an ordained pastor, give the . Robinson died at Leiden in 1625.

Plymouth stayed small, about 300 people after ten years, but its example spread. When Puritans founded a church at Salem in 1629, Plymouth's delegates gave it ‘the right hand of fellowship’.

Within a few years the Massachusetts churches ran themselves the Plymouth way, each congregation choosing its own ministers.

The freedom they had wanted for themselves did not reach others. The Massachusetts colony banished dissenters, and between 1659 and 1661 it hanged four Quakers in Boston, among them Mary Dyer.

Go further· 6 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    Massasoit's peace, and Squanto

    Bradford tells how Samoset, then Massasoit, the great sachem, came to the settlers in March 1621 and made a peace with them, and how Squanto stayed on as their interpreter and guide.

    “Squanto continued with them, and was their interpreter, and was a spetiall instrument sent of God for their good beyond their expectation. He directed them how to set their corne, wher to take fish, and to procure other comodities”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Bradford, History of Plymouth Plantation, book II, 1621 (Davis ed., pp. 110-111)
  2. 02

    Kidnapped, and home to an empty village

    Davis's notes add that Thomas Hunt, an English captain, carried Squanto and others off in 1614 to sell in Spain, that the Patuxet had died of disease before he returned, and that Massasoit's peace 'continued more than 50 years'.

    “The friars caused them to be released and Squanto found his way to England, where he was a servant of Mr. John Slanie, a merchant of London. Before the return of Squanto to New England the Patuxet tribe had been swept away by disease.”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Davis's notes to Bradford, book II, 1621 (pp. 110-111)
  3. 03

    No sacraments without a pastor

    Robinson never reached Plymouth. Until his death he would not let the colony's elder stand in for him.

    “Meantime he refused to sanction the administration of the sacraments by Brewster, an elder, but not an ordained pastor.”
    Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography (1897), 'Robinson, John (1576?-1625)', by Alexander Gordon
  4. 04

    From Plymouth to Massachusetts Bay

    The 1911 Britannica on how Winthrop's non-separating Puritans ended up with churches like Plymouth's.

    “But the new conditions, backed by the special influence of the Plymouth settlement, were too much for them; they became Independent,—first, perhaps, of necessity, then of conviction and choice.”
    Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Congregationalism', In America
  5. 05

    The magistrate's sword kept

    Williston Walker, a Congregational historian, on the Cambridge Platform of 1648, the New England churches' own charter.

    “It urges the right of the civil magistrate to interfere in matters of doctrine and practice”
    The Creeds and Platforms of Congregationalism · Walker, The Creeds and Platforms of Congregationalism (1893), introduction to the Cambridge Platform, p. 185
  6. 06

    The gallows on Boston Common

    The colony that the Plymouth model shaped passed laws banishing Quakers on pain of death. Mary Dyer, a Puritan turned Quaker, came back and was hanged on 1 June 1660, the third of four.

    “Mary Dyer, you shall go from hence to the place from whence you came, and from thence to the place of execution, and there be hanged till you be dead.”
    Wikipedia, 'Mary Dyer' · Mary Dyer (tertiary), lead and sentencing
Why it matters

For the trail

Plymouth shows Congregational church order at its plainest. A covenanted congregation chooses its own officers and answers to no bishop and no synod, a of church leaders over a region.

The Savoy Declaration of 1658, the Congregationalists' own statement of faith, made it a rule: there is ‘not instituted by any Church more extensive or Catholic’ with power over the local churches. This is where the Catholic Church disagrees with them most.

The letters written just after the show a wider Church at work. About 96 the church of Rome wrote to Corinth when that church had thrown out its , its elders.

About 107 , bishop of Antioch, wrote on his way to execution in Rome, ‘wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.’

The Catholic Church holds that the one Church Christ founded still exists, whole, in the of bishops with the . In the Council's words, it ‘subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of ’ (Lumen Gentium 8).

Go further· 2 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    No church above the congregation

    The Savoy Declaration of 1658, the Congregational churches' own platform, states the principle outright.

    “Besides these particular Churches, there is not instituted by Christ any Church more extensive or Catholic intrusted with power for the administration of his Ordinances or the execution of any authority in his Name.”
    The Savoy Declaration of the Congregational Churches · Savoy Declaration (1658), Of the Institution of Churches, VI
  2. 02

    Baptisms recognised, 2013

    The United Church of Christ, which tells the Pilgrims' voyage as part of its own story, was one of the four signers at Austin, Texas, on 29 January 2013.

    “Representatives of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops and four Protestant denominations in the Reformed tradition have publicly signed an agreement that recognizes the validity of each other’s baptisms.”
    Catholics, four Reformed denominations recognize each other's baptisms · Catholic News Service report, February 2013
The Church’s judgement

What the Church says

The Catholic Church does not blame the Pilgrims’ heirs for the break their ancestors made. Those born into such communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’, and everyone truly baptised is in real, if imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church (Unitatis Redintegratio 3).

Since 2013 the US Catholic bishops and the United Church of Christ, which tells the Pilgrims’ voyage as part of its own story, have recognised each other’s baptisms. What the Church says is still missing is ‘the sacrament of Orders’ (UR 22): bishops and priests ordained in a line from the apostles.

The Pilgrims fled laws that forced conscience, and the Church now agrees with them: ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges the laws they fled, the Massachusetts gallows and Catholic Europe’s laws alike.

The Council admitted that the Church’s own history held ‘a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel’ (DH 12).

Read the text
“We, whose names are underwritten, the Loyal Subjects of our dread Sovereign Lord King James, by the Grace of God, of Great Britain, France, and Ireland, King, Defender of the Faith, &c. Having undertaken for the Glory of God, and Advancement of the Christian Faith, and the Honour of our King and Country, a Voyage to plant the first Colony in the northern Parts of Virginia; Do by these Presents, solemnly and mutually, in the Presence of God and one another, covenant and combine ourselves together into a civil Body Politick, for our better Ordering and Preservation, and Furtherance of the Ends aforesaid”
Mayflower Compact (11 November 1620) · Mayflower Compact, signed at Cape Cod, 11 November 1620 (as printed in Thorpe, The Federal and State Constitutions, 1909)

The signers bind themselves by covenant, the word the Scrooby Separatists had used when they founded their church. Bradford called the compact 'the first foundation of their govermente in this place'. It made a civil government, not a church: the church already existed, bound by its own covenant years before.

Other readings

Where people disagree

Congregationalists answer from the same early sources. J. V. Bartlet argued in the 1911 Britannica that self-governing congregations ‘prevailed for the most part during the first two and a half centuries’. himself says ministers were appointed ‘with the consent of the whole church’.

The Catholic reply is that consent is not the source of office. Clement traces the ministry to the apostles, who appointed men and provided for others to follow them.

The Pilgrim story has its own doubts. Robinson's famous farewell, that ‘the Lord had more truth and light yet to breake forth out of his holy Word’, first appears in print in 1646, twenty-six years after the parting.

And Bradford's 1908 editor warned that ‘an undue significance has been attached to this combination or compact.’ He pointed out that their charter already allowed laws and officers chosen by vote.

Go further· 4 notes, each with its source
  1. 01

    A doubtful farewell

    Alexander Gordon notes that neither Bradford nor Nathaniel Morton mentions Robinson's famous address, which Winslow printed twenty-six years later.

    “This famous address, recollected after twenty-six years or more, owes something to the reporter's controversial needs.”
    Dictionary of National Biography · Dictionary of National Biography (1897), 'Robinson, John (1576?-1625)', by Alexander Gordon
  2. 02

    Too much made of the compact?

    William T. Davis, Bradford's 1908 editor, points out that the royal charter and the Pilgrims' later patent already allowed laws and officers chosen by majority vote.

    “Perhaps an undue significance has been attached to this combination or compact.”
    Bradford's History of Plymouth Plantation, 1606-1646 · Davis's note to Bradford, book II, 1620 (p. 106)
  3. 03

    The Congregational case from history

    J. V. Bartlet argued in 1911 that self-government by each local church was the primitive pattern, lost only later.

    “On the whole, then, Congregationalism, the self-government of each local church, prevailed for the most part during the first two and a half centuries of Christianity”
    Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Congregationalism', primitive Congregationalism
  4. 04

    The apostles foresaw the quarrel

    Clement of Rome, writing to Corinth about 96, grants the congregation's consent but traces the office itself to the apostles' own provision for succession.

    “Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate.”

The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.

Go deeper
Questions people ask next