Scotland's Parliament breaks with Rome
In August 1560 a Scottish Parliament, meeting without the queen's summons, adopts John Knox's Protestant confession, abolishes the pope's authority in Scotland, and makes hearing Mass a crime punishable, on a third offence, by death.
In the 1550s Scotland was a Catholic kingdom allied to France against England. Its queen, Mary, lived in France, and her French mother, Mary of Guise, ruled as regent.
Church courts had burned Protestant preachers, among them George Wishart in 1546, and Protestant conspirators had murdered Cardinal Beaton, partly in revenge. Protestant nobles, calling themselves the Lords of the Congregation, bound themselves together in 1557. In May 1559 the preacher John Knox came home from exile.
After his sermon at Perth a crowd wrecked the town's churches and friaries, and the quarrel became a war, which the Protestants won with English help.
The regent died in June 1560, and in August a Parliament met without any summons from the queen. On 17 August it ratified a Confession of Faith drawn up by Knox and other ministers. On 24 August it passed three acts.
The pope was to have ‘no jurisdiction nor authority within this realm’; the old laws protecting the Church were repealed; and anyone who said or heard Mass faced the loss of all goods, then banishment, then death. Mary never ratified the acts. They were re-enacted in 1567, after she was forced to abdicate.
The situation
In the 1550s Scotland was a Catholic kingdom with a dangerous neighbour. In the 1540s England had invaded more than once, trying to force a marriage between Scotland's infant queen, Mary, and Henry VIII's son Edward.
So Scotland leaned on its old ally, France. The child queen was raised at the French court and in 1558 married the heir to the French throne. Her French mother, Mary of Guise, ruled Scotland as regent, governing in her daughter's place, from 1554.
The Church was in poor shape. Cardinal David Beaton, Archbishop of St Andrews and Scotland's leading churchman in the 1540s, had lived openly with a mistress for 20 years. Councils of in 1549, 1552 and 1559 passed reforms, but no time was given to carry them out.
ideas had spread since the 1520s. The Church's courts answered with burnings for heresy, teaching they judged false: Patrick Hamilton in 1528, George Wishart in 1546, Walter Myln in 1558. Each death won the reformers sympathy.
Killing went both ways. In May 1546, partly in revenge for Wishart, conspirators murdered Beaton in his castle at St Andrews. A priest turned Protestant preacher, John Knox, joined the men holding it, and when the French took it in 1547 he spent 19 months chained in the galleys.
Go furtherFold· 5 notes, each with its source
- 01
The smoke of Patrick Hamilton
Hamilton was burned at St Andrews in February 1528, on the day of his sentence. The 1911 Britannica judges what his death achieved.
“His courageous bearing attracted more attention than ever to the doctrines for which he suffered, and greatly helped to spread the Reformation in Scotland.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Hamilton, Patrick' - 02
A Catholic reform that ran out of time
The Scottish bishops met in councils in 1549, 1552 and 1559 and passed reforming decrees. The Benedictine historian Oswald Hunter-Blair draws this conclusion in the Catholic Encyclopedia.
“No time or opportunity was given to the Church to carry out that reform of prevalent abuses which was foreshadowed in the decrees of her latest councils.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland', end of the second period - 03
Mary of Guise's aims
She governed for an absent daughter, with French help.
“her regency was dominated by her determination to protect and advance the dynastic interests of her daughter, maintain the Franco-Scottish alliance, and reassert the power of the Scottish crown.”
Wikipedia, 'Mary of Guise' · Wikipedia, 'Mary of Guise', opening section (tertiary; retrieved 2026-10-08) - 04
Wishart burned, Beaton killed
Pollard, in the 1911 Britannica, links the two deaths of 1546.
“Thence he was handed over to Cardinal Beaton, who had him burnt at St Andrews on March 1. Foxe and Knox attribute to him a prophecy of the death of the Cardinal, who was assassinated on May 29 following, partly at any rate in revenge for Wishart’s death.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Wishart, George', by A. F. Pollard - 05
Knox in the galleys
After the castle fell to the French, its defenders were sent to the French galleys.
“In June 1547 St Andrews yielded to the French fleet, and the prisoners, including Knox, were thrown into the galleys on the Loire, to remain in irons and under the lash for at least nineteen months.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John' · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John', 1547
What was at stake
Protestant nobles, calling themselves the Lords of the Congregation, bound themselves together in December 1557. At first they asked for freedom: that the heresy laws be suspended, so they could act ‘in matters of religion and conscience as we must answer to God’.
Knox, by then in exile, taught more than freedom. Rulers must put down false worship, and a godly nobility might resist a ruler who upheld it. To Knox, the , the Catholic service, was false worship.
In 1559 the regent forbade Reformed preaching. The question became who decided the faith of Scotland: an absent Catholic queen and her French regent, or Parliament and the preachers.
Knox's admiring biographer in the 1911 Britannica notes that each side appealed to freedom of conscience only while it was losing. Both then took up arms.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Knox asks Calvin and Bullinger
In his first year of exile Knox put to the Swiss reformers the question that would decide Scotland: must the godly obey a ruler who enforces what they count idolatry, and may nobles resist one?
“In his first year abroad he consulted Calvin and Bullinger as to the right of the civil “authority” to prescribe religion to his subjects”
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John' · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John', the years in exile - 02
The ruler's duty, in the Confession itself
The Confession that Parliament ratified gave rulers the task of putting down false worship. To the reformers, that meant the Mass.
“not only are they appointed for civil policy, but also for maintenance of the true religion and for suppressing of idolatry and superstition whatsoever”
The Confession of the Faith and doctrine believed and professed by the Protestants of the realm of Scotland · Scots Confession, chapter 24, Of the civil magistrate (RPS A1567/12/3) - 03
Freedom of conscience, for the losing side
Alexander Taylor Innes, Knox's biographer in the 1911 Britannica, on the truce of 1559, which promised every man freedom to use his own conscience.
“Both parties lapsed from the freedom-of-conscience solution to which each when unsuccessful appealed; both betook themselves to arms”
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John' · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John', 1559
The event
The preacher John Knox reached Edinburgh on 2 May 1559. Nine days later his sermon at Perth set off a riot that wrecked the town's churches and friaries, and the Protestant lords took up arms against the regent.
French troops held the port of Leith for the regent. In 1560 Protestant England sent a fleet and an army to help the lords. The regent died in Edinburgh Castle in June, and a treaty of 6 July sent the French home and left religion to the queen.
A Parliament met on 1 August without any summons from the queen. On 17 August it adopted a Protestant Confession of Faith, drawn up by Knox and other ministers.
On 24 August it passed three acts. The was to have no authority in Scotland, and the old laws protecting the Church were repealed.
The third act banned the Mass, the Catholic service. Anyone who said it or heard it would lose all their goods for a first offence, be banished for a second, and be put to death for a third.
Go furtherFold· 4 notes, each with its source
- 01
Perth, 11 May 1559
Knox's own account of the riot after his sermon. He blames the looting on the poor, not the destruction.
“Immediately the whole multitude cast stones, and laid hands on the said tabernacle, and on all other monuments of idolatry.”
The History of the Reformation of Religion in Scotland · Sidenote: The Mob wreck the Churches and destroy the Monasteries in Perth - 02
The vote
The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that the treaty of Edinburgh had left the religious question to the king and queen to settle.
“assemblage voted for adoption, as the state religion, of the Protestant Confession of Faith; four prelates and five temporal peers alone dissenting.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland', the parliament of August 1560 - 03
Correct us from Scripture
The Confession's preface, in the original Scots, asks anyone who finds a statement contrary to God's word to say so in writing, and promises either proof from Scripture or correction.
“Protestand that gif onie man will note in this our confessioun onie Artickle or sentence repugnand to Gods halie word, that it wald pleis him of his gentleness and for Christian charities sake to admonish us of the same in writing”
The Scotch Confession of Faith · The Scots Confession, Preface - 04
The act against the Mass
Passed on 24 August 1560 and re-enacted in 1567. It also forbade anyone but the Kirk's own ministers to baptise or give communion.
“that no manner of person nor persons say mass, nor yet hear mass, nor be present thereat, under the pain of confiscation of all their goods”
Concerning the abolition of the mass and the punishment of all that hears or says the same · A1567/12/4, reciting the act of 24 August 1560
The outcome
Mary, still in France, never approved the acts. She came home in 1561 as a young widow and had Mass said in her own household. Knox preached that one Mass frightened him more than 10,000 armed enemies.
In 1567 Mary was forced to give up her throne. The new regent's Parliament passed the acts of 1560 again and recognised the Kirk, the Reformed Church of Scotland, as the only church in the land.
Catholic worship went into hiding. The death penalty for the Mass was rarely carried out, in only one or two cases as far as is known. The loss of goods and the banishment it allowed stayed on the books.
The last Catholic Archbishop of St Andrews, John Hamilton, was hanged at Stirling in 1571 after what the Catholic Encyclopedia calls a mock trial. His see, the seat of the bishop, stayed without a Catholic archbishop for more than 300 years, until Leo XIII restored the Scottish bishops in 1878.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
How often the death penalty was used
Andrew Lang, writing the history of Scotland for the 1911 Britannica.
“The preachers could get the statute passed, but the sense of the laity prevented the death penalty from being inflicted, except, as far as we know, in one or two instances.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Scotland', history, 1560 - 02
One Mass and ten thousand enemies
When Mary came home in 1561, Mass was said in her household. Knox reports his own sermon the next Sunday.
“one Mass (there were no more suffered at the first) was more fearful to him than if ten thousand armed enemies were landed in any part of the realm”
The History of the Reformation of Religion in Scotland · Sidenote: John Knox preaches against the Queen's Mass (1561) - 03
The empty see of St Andrews
After Archbishop John Hamilton was hanged, the few canons left chose Robert Hay to succeed him.
“was never consecrated and the primatial see remained unoccupied by a Catholic prelate for upwards of three centuries.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland', third period
For the trail
Here the Presbyterian channel leaves the Reformed one. The Catholic Encyclopedia calls Knox the father of Presbyterianism: churches led by ministers and elected elders rather than bishops, a system that spread to English-speaking lands across the world.
As in England, a Parliament made the break with Rome. Unlike Henry's church, the Presbyterians refused to make the king head of the Church. Andrew Melville told James VI he was only one of its members.
In 1615 the Jesuit priest John Ogilvie was hanged in Glasgow for denying the same king authority over the Church. Both held that the Church is not the king's. They differed on where had placed its government, and the Catholic answer is and his successors.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
The father of Presbyterianism
John McHugh in the Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), on why Scotland begins a new channel.
“John Knox, who had lived with Calvin at Geneva, impressed upon the Scottish Reformation the ideas of his master, and may be regarded as the father of Presbyterianism as distinct from the Reformed churches.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Presbyterianism' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Presbyterianism', History - 02
Two kingdoms
Andrew Melville to James VI at Falkland, as his nephew James Melville recorded it. The Catholic Church agrees that the Church is not the king's; it disagrees about who governs it under Christ.
“there are two kingdoms—the kingdom of Christ, which is the church, whose subject King James VI. is, and of whose kingdom he is not a head, nor a lord, but a member”
Wikipedia, 'Andrew Melville' · Wikipedia, 'Andrew Melville', Moderator of the Church's General Assembly - 03
A shared confession of sin
The joint commission of the Catholic Church and the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, the worldwide family of Reformed and Presbyterian churches, ended its account of the Reformation with this.
“But, above all, for the ways in which our divisions have caused a scandal, and been an obstacle to the preaching of the Gospel, we need to ask forgiveness of Christ and of each other.”
Towards a Common Understanding of the Church: Reformed/Roman Catholic International Dialogue, Second Phase · Towards a Common Understanding of the Church (1990), §63
What the Church says
The Church does not blame today's Presbyterians for the break of 1560. Those born into these communities ‘cannot be accused of the sin involved in the separation’, and the Church embraces them ‘as brothers, with respect and affection’ (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). Dialogue with them began in 1970.
It honours St John Ogilvie as a martyr. Canonising him in 1976, Paul VI hoped his memory would soothe, not reopen, the wounds of religious violence.
The Church now teaches that ‘no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs’ (Dignitatis Humanae 2). That judges the Mass Act, and the burnings of Hamilton, Wishart and Myln under laws the Church then upheld.
“the three estates, understanding that the jurisdiction and authority of the bishop of Rome, called the pope, used within this realm in times past, has not only been contumelious to the eternal God, but also very hurtful and prejudicial to our sovereign's authority and commonwealth of this realm; therefore have statute and ordained that the bishop of Rome, called the pope, have no jurisdiction nor authority within this realm in any time coming”
Passed the same day as the act against the Mass, which set confiscation and bodily punishment for a first offence, banishment for a second and death for a third. Mary never gave her assent; the regent Moray's Parliament re-enacted both in 1567 as perpetual law.
Where people disagree
Was it a reformation or a revolution? The Catholic Encyclopedia blames the greed of nobles eager for the Church's wealth. The lords did take the Church's lands and turned down Knox's plan to spend them on ministers, schools and the poor.
Presbyterians answer that the Estates, Scotland's Parliament, acted for the nation, and that the Confession itself invited anyone to correct it from Scripture.
The legal question is real. The Parliament met without the queen's summons, though the treaty had left religion to her. Even Knox's admiring biographer held that the death penalty for the Mass meant the reformers had crossed the line.
Whether Wishart was part of a plot to kill Beaton is still argued. The 1911 Britannica says yes in its article on Beaton, and in its article on Wishart calls the case not proven and not probable.
Go furtherFold· 3 notes, each with its source
- 01
Revolution rather than reformation?
Oswald Hunter-Blair, a Benedictine, in the Catholic Encyclopedia. Knox's own disappointment partly bears him out: the lords turned down Knox's plan for the Church's wealth, calling it ‘a devout imagination’.
“As in England the greed of a tyrannical king, so in Scotland the cupidity of a mercenary nobility, itching to possess themselves of the Church's accumulated wealth, consummated a work which even Protestant historians have described as one of revolution rather than of reformation.”
Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Scotland', end of the second period - 02
Crossing the line
Knox's sympathetic biographer in the 1911 Britannica, on the third of the acts of 24 August 1560.
“But the third, inflicting heavy penalties, with death on a third conviction, on those who should celebrate mass or even be present at it, showed that the reformer and his friends had crossed the line”
Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John' · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Knox, John', August 1560 - 03
Was Wishart part of the plot against Beaton?
The 1911 Britannica contradicts itself. Its article on Beaton says Wishart ‘is now proved to have been a willing agent’ in the plot; A. F. Pollard, in its article on Wishart, calls the case against him ‘not proven and is not probable’.
“There has been much controversy whether he was the Wishart who in April 1544 approached the English government with a proposal for getting rid of Cardinal Beaton.”
Encyclopaedia Britannica · Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), 'Wishart, George'
The quotes on this page were checked word for word against the linked source. The story around them is the site’s own telling, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed it yet.
- Parliament of Scotland · 1560-08-24; re-enacted 1567-12 · The Records of the Parliaments of Scotland to 1707, K. M. Brown et al. eds (University of St Andrews)
- John Knox and other ministers, for the Scottish Parliament · 1560-08 · Christian Classics Ethereal Library (ccel.org), from Schaff's reprint of Dunlop's Collection of Confessions (Edinburgh, 1719-22)
- John Knox; ed. Cuthbert Lennox · written c. 1559-71; this modernised edition 1905 · Project Gutenberg, eBook 48250
- Oswald Hunter-Blair · 1912 · New Advent
- Alexander Taylor Innes (signed A. T. I.) · 1911 · Wikisource
- Joint commission of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and the World Alliance of Reformed Churches · 1990 · christianunity.va (PDF)