← No religion, or not sure
God and evidence

Who made God? Is there any good reason to think God exists?

Read it as an illustrated story · 7 min

Nobody made God, and that's not a dodge. God isn't one more thing inside the universe that needed a start. He's the answer to a bigger question: why is there anything at all? And there are good reasons to think that answer is real.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
31–35202–213

It's one of the most googled questions about God. In 2015 an economist looked at what doubting Americans typed into Google. The No. 1 question was: who created God?8

And it's a fair one. If everything needs a maker, who made the maker? It sounds like the question that ends the conversation.

But it rests on a small mix-up.

Not everything needs a maker

The mix-up is this. Christians don't say everything needs a maker. They say anything that gets its existence from something else needs one.

Look around you. Your phone came from a factory. You came from your parents. The sun formed from a cloud of gas. Everything you can point to is borrowing its existence from something before it.

So the real question isn't who made God? It's this: can everything be borrowing, with nothing that actually owns its existence?

Think of it like this

Think about the lights in your home. It's evening, you flick the switch, and the room lights up. Easy. But where did that light actually come from?

The bulb didn't make it. The power came through the wires in your walls. The wires got it from the cable under the street. The cable got it from the grid, and the grid got it from a power station miles away.

Now imagine someone tells you there's no power station. Just cables, passing power to more cables, forever. You'd laugh. Add a million more cables and you still haven't explained where the power comes from. Every cable is only passing along something it got from somewhere else.

Somewhere, something has to actually make the power, not just pass it on. That's the difference between borrowing and owning. And that's exactly the difference Christians are pointing to when they talk about God.

So God isn't one more thing in the chain, only bigger. He's the one who doesn't borrow his existence from anyone, so nobody had to make him.

The , the collection of holy books Christians read, has a scene for this. , the man God chose to lead his people out of slavery in Egypt, sees a bush on fire that doesn't burn up. God speaks to him from it, and Moses asks his name.3

God answers: I AM WHO AM. It's not a typo. Some Bibles put it I AM WHO I AM.3 Not I was made. Just: I am.

Everything else is the other way round. The says all creatures receive all that they are and have from him.3

The biggest question there is

Science can tell you a lot about how the universe works. But there's a question underneath all of it: why is there something, instead of nothing at all?

Nothing had to exist.

Not you, not the sun, not a single atom.

, a Catholic thinker who lived about 800 years ago, put it simply. Things that don't have to exist can't explain why they're here. So something must exist that doesn't depend on anything else.4

Even the Big Bang doesn't change this. Aquinas didn't think you could prove the universe had a beginning at all, and his point works either way.5,6 The question isn't what started it? It's what keeps it here right now?

A universe set just right

Then there's something modern science stumbled on. Some of the basic numbers that run the universe seem to sit in a very narrow range. Change them a little and there'd be no stars, no planets and no life.7

For a lot of people, that's the moment they stop and stare. It looks like a universe that was expecting us.

To be fair, scientists read it in different ways. Some see a designer. Some think there are countless universes and we're in a lucky one. Some say a lucky result needs no explaining.7 So it's a pointer, not a proof.

What the other side says

The best-known reply comes from the biologist Richard Dawkins. Any designer, he says, would have to be even more complicated than what it made. So you'd have to ask who designed the designer.10

That's a strong hit on a God who's just a very clever being inside the universe. But that's not the God Christians mean. Everything you know is made of parts: atoms, cells, gears. In classic Christian teaching, God has no parts. He isn't a complicated machine, so there was nothing to put together, and nobody needed to design him.3,11

Critics reply that a God who knows everything and makes choices sounds even more complicated.10 Christians answer that in God, knowing and choosing aren't extra parts. Anything built from parts depends on them, and God depends on nothing.11

A rough picture: a flame's light and its heat aren't two pieces you could take apart. They're one fire, seen two ways.

Then why can't the universe itself be the power station? Some philosophers say exactly that: maybe the universe is just there, and that's all.6

That's possible. But believers point out that the universe doesn't look like something that owns its existence. It changes. It has a history. It could have been different.

And if something could have been different, something else has to explain why it's this way and not another. Things that could have been different are borrowers, not the power station.

To be fair, that step leans on an idea philosophers call the principle of sufficient reason: whatever could have been different has an explanation.6

Skeptics reply that explanations have to stop somewhere. Believers stop at God, they say, so why not stop at the universe?6

Believers answer that it's fairer to stop at something that couldn't have been otherwise. But that's the step the whole argument turns on.

Someone, not something

Fine, you might say. Something has to own its existence. But why call it God? Why not just energy, or the laws of physics?

Energy and the laws of physics belong to the universe. They come in particular amounts and shapes, and they could have been different. By the same test, they're borrowers too.6

And laws don't make anything happen. They describe how things that already exist behave. Before there's anything for them to work on, there's nothing for them to describe.6

Thomas Aquinas gave two more reasons. A blind force does the same thing every time, the way gravity always pulls down. It can't pick this world out of all the worlds that could have been. Picking takes a mind and a will.12

And whatever is in a result has to come from its cause in some way.13 This universe has produced people who think, choose and love. Whatever is behind it can't be less than that.

Philosophers still argue over this step. Some say that outside time, a cause that isn't a person would do the job just as well, and nothing here forces you to call it a mind.6

None of this works like a lab test. Thoughtful people land in different places, and a God without parts is hard to picture.11

What the Catholic Church says

The Catholic Church teaches that you can know for certain that God exists by thinking carefully about the world, before you ever open a Bible.1 , writing some twenty years after Jesus, said the same: God's power can be understood and perceived in what he has made.9

The Catechism calls these arguments converging and convincing: clues that all point the same way. They aren't proofs like a science experiment. But together, it says, they allow us to attain certainty about the truth.2

But can an argument tell you the power station cares about you? Not on its own. The Catechism says careful thinking can bring you to a God who is someone, not something. To actually know him, it says, God chose to show himself.2

Christians believe he did: in Jesus, the one behind it all came looking for us.

Sources13
  1. 1First Vatican Council, Dei Filius (24 April 1870), chapter 2God can be known with certainty from created things by human reason.
  2. 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 31–35The ways of coming to know God: 'converging and convincing arguments', not proofs as in the natural sciences; they can predispose one to faith.
  3. 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 202–213God's nature 'entirely simple' (Lateran IV); the burning bush; I AM WHO AM (also rendered I AM WHO I AM): the fullness of Being, without origin and without end.
  4. 4Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 2, a. 3 (the Five Ways)Aquinas's five arguments for God's existence.
  5. 5Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 46, a. 2Reason alone cannot prove that the world had a beginning in time.
  6. 6Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Cosmological ArgumentThe arguments from causes and contingency, replies such as Russell's, and the debate over whether the first cause must be personal (section 8.6).
  7. 7Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fine-TuningThe evidence for fine-tuning and the design and multiverse replies.
  8. 8TheHumanist.com, When in Doubt, Google 'Who Created God?' (19 October 2015)Reports Stephens-Davidowitz's Google data: the top God questions in the US.
  9. 9Romans 1:20 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)God's invisible attributes perceived in what he has made.
  10. 10Wikipedia, The God Delusion (Richard Dawkins, 2006)Summarises Dawkins's argument that a designer raises the larger problem of who designed the designer.
  11. 11Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Divine SimplicityThe classical view (Augustine, Anselm, Aquinas) that God has no parts, and the debate over whether it is coherent.
  12. 12Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 19, a. 4 (New Advent)God acts by intellect and will, not by a necessity of nature: a natural agent produces one and the same effect.
  13. 13Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, q. 4, a. 2 (New Advent)Whatever perfection exists in an effect must be found in its cause, in the same way or a greater one.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.