← No religion, or not sure
Jesus and the Bible

Didn't God order genocide and allow slavery in the Old Testament?

Read it as an illustrated story · 8 min

Some passages do describe God commanding the destruction of whole peoples, and its laws regulate slavery instead of banning it. Catholics don't hide that. The Catholic Church reads these texts as early steps in a long, patient teaching, and judges every one of them by Jesus.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

Catechism
122

Let's put the hardest passages on the table. The Old Testament is the first and older part of the Christian : the Jewish Scriptures, written before Jesus.

In one story, a prophet, a man who speaks for God, tells Israel's first king to attack an enemy people, the Amalekites, and kill men and women, children and infants.4

Elsewhere Israel is told that in the cities of the land it's taking, you shall not leave a single soul alive.5 That's an order to wipe out whole peoples.

The slavery laws are hard too. If a master beats a slave and the slave lives a day or two, the master isn't punished, since the slave is his own property.7

If you read these and feel sick, that's not a lack of faith. It's your conscience working. The real question is whether a God who says these things can be good.

A teacher who starts low

The Catholic Church holds that the whole Old Testament is the word of God. But it also says it isn't the last word.

The says that even though they contain matters imperfect and provisional, these books show God patiently teaching his people.1

That word provisional matters. It means some things in these books were meant for a stage along the way, not for ever.

In 2010 Benedict XVI wrote about the Bible's dark passages, and he didn't skip them.2

Revelation is suited to the cultural and moral level of distant times and thus describes facts and customs, such as cheating and trickery, and acts of violence and massacre, without explicitly denouncing the immorality of such things.
Benedict XVI, Verbum Domini (2010), 42

God started with people where they were, he explained. He chose a people and patiently worked to guide and educate them, and the prophets vigorously challenged every kind of injustice and violence.2

The slavery laws show how low the starting point was. Kidnapping someone to sell them was punished by death. A slave whose master knocked out an eye, or even a tooth, went free.7 That's still slavery, but with limits.

And the limits weren't the same for everyone. A fellow Israelite went free in the seventh year.7 Foreigners could be kept as perpetual slaves, and passed on to the owner's children.11

There's no softening that. It's one of the passages the idea of slow teaching has to answer for.

Think of it like this

Think of a small boy who hits back twice as hard every time his sister hits him. She pokes him, he punches. She grabs his toy, he shoves her over. His parents can't fix all of that in one afternoon. He's four.

So they start where he is. The first rule is simple: don't hit back harder. Poke for poke, no more. It's not a great rule. But for him, it's a big step.

Years later, when he's ready, the rule changes: don't hit back at all. Come and tell us. And later still, when he's old enough to really get it: be kind to her anyway. Even when she's unfair.

The first rule isn't the goal. It's a step toward it. That's how Catholics read the Old Testament's harsh laws. Not as God's final word on how to treat people, but as the first steps of a long lesson that ends somewhere far better.

This picture only covers the slow teaching, like the laws on slaves and revenge. The commands to wipe out whole peoples are a harder case, and come next.

Jesus is the measure

So where does the lesson end? With Jesus, who quotes the old law and goes further.

You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.' Then: But I say to you, offer no resistance to one who is evil.8

And: love your enemies, and pray for those who persecute you.8

Benedict XVI said it too. The key for reading all of it is the and the new commandment of Jesus .2

For Christians, Jesus is the measure of the Old Testament, not the other way round.

Were the war stories literal?

Many readers never notice this. One book says Israel's war leader, Joshua, conquered the entire country and left no survivors.12

Yet a few pages later, another book says the people living in Jerusalem were never driven out. They were still there to the present day, it says.6

So some readers think the war reports use sweeping language, like an army's victory report. Others think the commands were real, for one unique moment.

In 2014 the Vatican's panel of Bible scholars, the Pontifical Biblical Commission, took the first view further. In its own words, the story of the conquest should be seen as a sort of parable presenting characters of symbolic value.16

And the command to wipe out whole peoples requires a non-literal interpretation, like Jesus's command to cut off your hand if it makes you .16

A review of the report adds that it dates these stories long afterwards, when the peoples they describe had all but vanished.14

It reads them as an echo of a theme the prophets kept returning to: God judging the nations.14 Not everyone accepts that reading, and Christians still argue about it.

Either way, the words stay hard to read. An order to wipe out a people is far worse than a rule about hitting back. To be honest, slow, patient teaching explains where the Bible is heading. It doesn't explain away every passage on the way.

The Church and slavery: late and uneven

In 1452 Pope Nicholas V sent an official letter to the king of Portugal. It gave him permission to conquer Muslims and pagans and reduce their persons into perpetual slavery.13

It came as Turkish armies closed in on Constantinople, a great Christian city, today's Istanbul. That's the background to it. But it doesn't excuse it.

Colonial powers later used that letter, and another from 1455, to justify conquest and slavery.9,13 Other popes pushed the other way. In 1537 a pope wrote that the peoples of the Americas are by no means to be deprived of their liberty.9

Brazil, once Portugal's colony, is one example. About 4 in 10 of the 10 million Africans forced across the ocean to the Americas were taken there. It was the last country in the Americas to end slavery, in 1888.15

Catholic institutions owned slaves too. In 1838 the Jesuits of Maryland, a Catholic order of priests and brothers, sold 272 enslaved men, women and children to Louisiana.10

In 2023 the Vatican said the 1452 and 1455 letters did not adequately reflect the equal dignity and rights of indigenous peoples, and asked for pardon.9

Where the road ends

Today the Catholic Church names both genocide and slavery among what the called infamies: shameful crimes that poison human society.3

That's not a new verdict on God. It's what Catholics believe God was leading his people toward all along.

and Christians wrestle with these passages too, and many read them the same way: as a story moving toward Jesus.

These passages aren't fine, and Catholics don't pretend they are. The Old Testament is a road, not the destination. Catholics read every step of it in the light of where it ends: a God who would rather die for his enemies than destroy them.

Sources16
  1. 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 122The Old Testament contains "matters imperfect and provisional" but shows God's teaching.
  2. 2Benedict XVI, Verbum Domini (30 September 2010), 42On the Bible's "dark" passages and how to read them.
  3. 3Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes (7 December 1965), 27Genocide and slavery listed among "infamies".
  4. 41 Samuel 15 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The command to destroy the Amalekites.
  5. 5Deuteronomy 20 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"You shall not leave a single soul alive."
  6. 6Judges 1 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The Jebusites still living in Jerusalem.
  7. 7Exodus 21 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Laws on slaves, kidnapping, and freedom for an injured slave.
  8. 8Matthew 5 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"You have heard that it was said... But I say to you."
  9. 9Dicasteries for Culture and Education and for Promoting Integral Human Development, Joint Note on the "Doctrine of Discovery" (30 March 2023)Admits the 1452-1493 bulls failed indigenous peoples; quotes Sublimis Deus (1537).
  10. 10Georgetown Slavery Archive, Georgetown UniversityRecords of the 1838 sale of 272 people by the Maryland Jesuits.
  11. 11Leviticus 25 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Slaves bought from neighbouring nations may be kept as perpetual slaves.
  12. 12Joshua 10 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"He left no survivors": the sweeping language of the conquest reports.
  13. 13Wikipedia, "Dum Diversas"Nicholas V's 1452 bull, its setting, and its grant to reduce conquered peoples to perpetual slavery.
  14. 14Jason Bermender, review of the Pontifical Biblical Commission, The Inspiration and Truth of Sacred Scripture (2014), Catholic Books Review (2015)Summarises the Commission: the extermination narratives are not historical accounts but were composed much later, when their supposed victims had all but vanished.
  15. 15Wikipedia, Lei ÁureaBrazil's law of 13 May 1888 abolishing slavery; 40% of the 10 million Africans brought to the Americas were taken to Brazil; the last country in the Americas to abolish slavery.
  16. 16Jimmy Akin, Genocide in the Bible (2), Catholic Answers (24 May 2023), quoting the Pontifical Biblical Commission, The Inspiration and Truth of Sacred Scripture (2014), 127The Commission: the conquest epic is 'a sort of parable presenting characters of symbolic value'; the law of extermination 'requires a non-literal interpretation'.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.