← Orthodox
Living side by side

Why do Catholics and Orthodox celebrate Easter on different dates?

Read it as an illustrated story · 6 min

Because most still work out Easter, which they call Pascha, with the old Julian calendar, while Catholics use the newer one from 1582. Both follow the same rule; the two calendars just give different answers. The Catholic Church says it's open to a shared date.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

For families with Catholic and Orthodox members, this hurts every year. One side is feasting while the other is still fasting. Leo XIV said in 2025 that it ends up dividing families.1

So why can't Catholics and Orthodox just pick one day? The answer is surprisingly simple, and it has nothing to do with belief.

Same rule, different calendars

Both celebrate Easter, which the Orthodox call Pascha, as the day Jesus rose from the dead. Both use the same rule: it's the first Sunday after the first full moon of spring.2

The difference is the calendar. In 1582 Pope Gregory XIII fixed the old Julian calendar, which had slowly drifted away from the real seasons. Almost all Orthodox Churches still date Pascha the old way, which now runs 13 days behind.2,3

That same gap explains Christmas. The Russian Church, and some others, keep all their feasts on the old calendar.3 Count 13 days on from 25 December, and you land on 7 January. That's why Russian Christmas falls on 7 January.

Greece is different. In 1924 Greece's Orthodox Church moved to a new, corrected calendar, so Greek Christmas falls on 25 December, like the Catholic one. But for Pascha, the old reckoning was kept, as it is almost everywhere in Orthodoxy.3

Even that half-step was costly. Groups who refused the new calendar broke away, and they're still separate today.3 So any change to Pascha needs the whole Orthodox world to agree.

Think of it like this

Think of two friends who agree to catch the same bus home every Friday: the first one after the school bell rings. Simple enough.

One checks the time on his phone. The other goes by the big clock in his family's hallway, the one the whole household runs on. It runs 13 minutes slow. He could reset his own watch, but then he'd be out of step with everyone at home.

So most Fridays they end up on different buses, each sure he followed the plan exactly. Each texts the other: where are you? Every so often the timing happens to line up, and they ride home together at last.

Nobody is wrong about the rule. They're reading it off different clocks. That's Easter and Pascha: same rule, same faith, two calendars.

Nicaea wanted one day

The first meeting of from the whole Church, at Nicaea in 325, wanted one shared Easter. Its ruling is lost.4 But Emperor 's letter afterwards says the bishops agreed to keep Easter by all and in every place on one and the same day.5

To be honest, that same letter speaks about the Jewish people with a hostility the Catholic Church has since rejected. It now teaches that Jews must not be presented as rejected or accursed by God.5,6

Must Pascha come after Passover?

You may have heard it at home: Pascha must always come after the Jewish . It's an old belief. And on the old calendar, which has slipped behind the seasons, the two feasts can no longer fall on the same day.7

But did the early Church ever say Pascha must come after Passover? An Orthodox archbishop who studied the old church rules, writing for the Orthodox Church in America, says no. The old rules forbade keeping Pascha with the Jews. That meant: don't work out the date from the Jewish calendar.7

It didn't mean the two feasts could never share a day. In the century after Nicaea, Pascha and Passover coincided several times.7

The after-Passover rule came later. Once the old calendar had drifted, later church lawyers read the old ban as a rule about order: Passover first, then Pascha.7 The archbishop calls this a literal but erroneous understanding of the old words.7

So the rule both Churches share is the one from Nicaea's time: the full moon, the spring equinox, and Sunday.7

Two saints who disagreed

Christians have disagreed about Easter before and kept the peace.

In the 100s, St , bishop of Smyrna, who had known John the of Jesus, visited the pope in Rome. They kept Easter on different days, and neither could change the other's mind.8

But here's the beautiful part. The pope still let Polycarp lead the service in his own church, and they parted from each other in peace.8

A later pope tried to cut off whole churches over the same question, and other bishops told him not to.8

Why Rome won't go it alone

The Catholic Church holds that Easter is the most solemn festival of the year. Every Sunday is a small Easter, and once a year the whole Church keeps it in full.9

But it doesn't treat its own way of dating Easter as sacred. In 1963 the said it would accept a fixed Sunday. There was one condition: that other Christians, above all those not in union with Rome, give their assent.9

That condition is the whole point. The Catholic Church won't change Easter without the Orthodox, because a date only one side keeps would make the split worse.9

The same let Catholics in mixed areas agree with their Eastern neighbours on a shared Easter Sunday, until such time as all Christians are agreed on one day.10

Where things stand now

In 2025 the two calendars happened to land on the same day. They will again in 2028, 2031 and 2034.1 In 2026 they were a week apart: 5 April for Catholics, 12 April for the Orthodox.2

In June 2025 Pope Leo XIV repeated the openness of the Catholic Church to a shared answer that respects the principle of Nicaea.1

In November 2025 he and Bartholomew, the Ecumenical Patriarch of Constantinople, wrote together of their shared desire to find a way of celebrating together the Feast of Feasts every year.11

For both Churches, Easter is the heart of the faith: the tomb was empty and death lost.

The Catholic hope is that both find the date together, as Nicaea wanted. Then the whole Church could sing is risen on the same morning.

Sources11
  1. 1National Catholic Register (CNA), Pope Leo XIV says Church open to universal Easter date (7 June 2025)Leo XIV's words on the pastoral cost of two Easters; the shared dates of 2025, 2028, 2031, 2034.
  2. 2Wikipedia, Date of EasterThe rule for Easter, the Gregorian reform, the 13-day gap, and the Finnish exception.
  3. 3Wikipedia, Old CalendaristsThe 1923 revised calendar, Greece and Romania in 1924, and the groups that broke away.
  4. 4Catholic Encyclopedia (1909), Easter ControversyNicaea's Easter decree is lost; Constantine's letter is the main witness.
  5. 5Eusebius, Life of Constantine, book 3, 18–20Constantine's letter after Nicaea: Easter on one and the same day everywhere.
  6. 6Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 4The Catholic Church rejects presenting the Jews as rejected or accursed by God.
  7. 7Archbishop Peter (L'Huillier), Concerning the Date of Pascha and the First Ecumenical Council (Orthodox Church in America)Nicaea forbade dating Pascha by the Jewish reckoning, not sharing a day with Passover; the later after-Passover rule (Zonaras) rests on a misreading.
  8. 8Eusebius, Church History, book 5, 24Irenaeus on Polycarp and Anicetus (different customs, shared Eucharist, peace kept) and on Pope Victor's attempt to cut off Asia.
  9. 9Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium (4 December 1963), 102 and AppendixEaster as the most solemn feast; openness to a fixed date if the Orthodox agree.
  10. 10Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (21 November 1964), 20Local agreements on a shared Easter Sunday until all Christians agree on one day.
  11. 11Joint Declaration of Pope Leo XIV and Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew (29 November 2025)Signed at the Phanar the day after the Nicaea commemoration: the shared desire to celebrate Easter together every year.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.