From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/brothers-of-jesus
← Protestant or evangelicalDid Mary have other children? The Bible mentions Jesus's brothers.
Read it as an illustrated story · 5 minCatholics and the believe Mary had no other children. The do name Jesus's brothers. But that word covered close relatives too, and two of the men named seem to be sons of a different Mary. Many Protestants once agreed, including John Wesley, who started the Methodists.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 487–511
The case for other children looks simple. Open Mark's Gospel. People in his hometown call him the son of Mary, and the brother of James and Joses and Judas and Simon.1
says he met James the brother of the Lord.2 This James led the church in Jerusalem, and tradition says he wrote the letter of James in the .12
Then Matthew's Gospel says Joseph had no relations with her until she bore a son.10 Luke calls Jesus Mary's firstborn son.11 To many readers, until and firstborn sound like more children came later.
This isn't a new reading. Around AD 383, a writer in Rome named Helvidius argued the same thing.3
He quoted an older writer, Tertullian, from North Africa around AD 200, as backing him.3 Early Christians weren't all of one mind.
Most Protestants today agree with Helvidius, and it's a reasonable reading.
Even the notes in a standard Catholic admit Mark may have meant brothers literally.1
Brother was a wide word
But in the Bible's world, brother didn't only mean a son of the same mother. Those same notes explain that in Hebrew, brother and sister were used for nephews, nieces, cousins and half-siblings too.1
Take , the father of the Jewish people. In Genesis 14:16 his nephew Lot is called his brother. And when the was put into Greek, the translators often kept the word brother in places like that.1
Think of it like this
Think of a big family gathering at a holiday. Every older man at the table is Uncle, whether he's your dad's brother, your mum's cousin or a neighbour who's been around forever.
And there's the cousin you grew up with. You lived on the same street, walked to school together every morning, and he stood beside you at your wedding. You call him your brother, and you mean it. Nobody at the table thinks twice.
Now imagine a stranger reading your family's messages a thousand years from now. He sees my brother and decides your parents had another son. He's not stupid. He just doesn't know how your family talks.
Nobody in the family is confused, but a stranger might be. The Bible's world worked a bit like that.
Greek, the language of the New Testament, did have a word for cousin, and the New Testament uses it once.4 So the word brother can't settle it either way. You need more clues.
Same names, different mother
And there's a clue hiding in plain sight. At the cross, Mark lists the women watching. One of them is Mary the mother of the younger James and of Joses.5 Matthew calls her the other Mary.7
James and Joses. Those are the first two brothers Mark names.
If they're the same men, their mother is a different Mary, not the mother of Jesus.
The Gospels don't say outright they're the same, but the names line up.
Who leaves his mother with a friend?
As he was dying, Jesus handed his mother to his closest , who took her into his own home.6
Think about that. Grown sons were expected to look after their mother. If Mary had other sons, why hand her to a friend?
It isn't proof, since his brothers didn't believe in him yet (John 7:5). But it fits.
And until and firstborn? The Catholic Bible's notes say until is there to show that Joseph wasn't the father, and doesn't tell us what happened later, either way.10 And firstborn was a legal title for the first son. It doesn't have to mean more sons came later.11
Mary's only son
The Catholic Church teaches that Mary stayed a virgin all her life, and that Jesus was her only son. The Orthodox Church teaches it too.12
The takes the brothers question head-on. It says James and Joseph, the James and Joses that Mark names, are the sons of another Mary. They are close relations of Jesus, in the Old Testament way of speaking.7
So who were they? The Orthodox say they were Joseph's sons from an earlier marriage.12
That idea first appears in a writing from the mid-100s, the Protoevangelium of James, which isn't in the Bible.13
Jerome, the Bible scholar who answered Helvidius, said cousins.3
The Catholic Church has never chosen between the two. It teaches only that they weren't Mary's children.
Now the honest part, and the Catholic notes say it themselves. The question of meaning here would not have arisen but for the faith of the church in Mary's perpetual virginity, her staying a virgin all her life.1
In other words, Catholics don't hold this belief because the Greek forces it. They hold it because it was handed down, and the text allows it.
Not just a Catholic belief
That handed-down belief was shared far beyond Rome. A statement of faith from 1566, used by Reformed churches across Europe, such as the Presbyterians, confesses that was born of Mary, who was ever a virgin.8
And John Wesley, the man who started the Methodists, wrote in 1749 that Mary, as well after as before she brought him forth, continued a pure and unspotted virgin.9
So this isn't simply Catholic against Protestant. For most of Christian history, East and West and many early Protestants believed Mary had one Son.
Why does it matter? Catholics see Mary's whole life as given to that one Son. But her spiritual motherhood, the Catechism says, extends to all men whom indeed he came to save.7 That includes you.
Sources13
- 1Mark 6:1-6, with note on verse 3 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The brothers named; the note on the breadth of "brother" and its honest limits.
- 2Galatians 1:18-19 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Paul meets "James the brother of the Lord".
- 3Jerome, Against Helvidius (c. 383)Helvidius's case and sources, and Jerome's cousin reading.
- 4Colossians 4:10 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"Mark the cousin of Barnabas": Greek had a word for cousin.
- 5Mark 15:40-47 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Mary the mother of James and Joses at the cross.
- 6John 19:25-27 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Jesus entrusts his mother to the beloved disciple.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 487-511Perpetual virginity and the brothers of Jesus (499-501).
- 8Second Helvetic Confession (1566), chapter XI (Schaff, Creeds of Christendom III)A Reformed confession: "natum ex Maria semper virgine".
- 9John Wesley, Letter to a Roman Catholic (Dublin, 18 July 1749)Wesley affirms Mary's lifelong virginity.
- 10Matthew 1:18-25, with note on verse 25 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"Until she bore a son": the note says the word neither implies nor excludes later children.
- 11Luke 2:1-7, with note on verse 7 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)"Firstborn son" as a legal title, not proof of other sons.
- 12OrthodoxWiki, "James the Just"The Orthodox view: the Lord's brothers were Joseph's sons from an earlier marriage (Protoevangelium of James).
- 13Wikipedia, "Brothers of Jesus"The idea of the brothers as Joseph's sons by an earlier marriage first appears in the mid-2nd-century Protoevangelium of James.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.