Isn't Christianity a Western religion that came with the colonisers?
Christianity began in Asia, with a Jewish teacher whose message was for every nation, and it spread across Asia and Africa while it was still banned. Centuries later it was tied to kings and empires, and Christians, popes among them, did real wrong in its name. That was wrong, plain wrong, and the Catholic Church now says so.
Part 1 · Where it really began
This one is personal for many families in Asia and Africa.
A child who becomes Christian may hear: you're becoming Western, or that's the white man's religion.
There's real history behind that, and this answer won't hide any of it.
But it isn't where the story starts. So let's start at the start.
Jesus was a Jew. He was born, lived, died and, Christians believe, rose again in the Holy Land, at Asia's western edge.
In 1999 , then the leader of the Catholic Church, reminded Asia's Catholics that Jesus took flesh as an Asian.
And what he taught wasn't any empire's message. It turned power upside down.
He told his closest followers that rulers lord it over people, but it shall not be so among you.
Then he knelt and washed their feet, a servant's job, and told them to do the same for each other.
After he rose, he sent his followers out to make disciples of all nations. Not one people. Every people.
On the first day Jesus's followers preached, Jerusalem was full of visitors. Acts, the 's book about the first Christians, says where they came from:
Persia and Mesopotamia, Egypt and Libya, Arabia, and Rome too. Asia and Africa were there on day one.
Christians in Kerala, in south India, trace their church to Thomas, one of Jesus's twelve closest followers. By tradition he arrived in AD 52.
In China, a stone tablet from 781 tells how a Christian teacher from Syria reached the capital in 635.
Africa's story is just as old. The Bible itself tells of an Ethiopian royal official who was on his way home from Jerusalem.
Baptism is a washing with water, in God's name, that marks a person as a Christian.
Egypt's church traces itself to Mark, who wrote one of the , which are the four books about Jesus's life.
By tradition, he was killed for his faith in Alexandria, in Egypt, in the 60s AD.
The first kingdoms to make Christianity their own faith were there too: Armenia, in the early 300s, then Ethiopia, whose king was baptised.
Both came before Rome made it the empire's religion.
For more than 1,000 years before Europe's empires came, Christianity was an Asian and African faith, as well as a European one.
To be fair, much of that Asian church didn't survive. The , which reached China, once had all across Asia.
Then, in the late 1300s, the armies of Timur, a Central Asian conqueror, almost wiped those Christians out.
Old churches lived on in the Middle East, Armenia and Kerala. But most Asian Christians belong to churches planted in the age of European ships.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of curry. Walk down almost any high street in Britain and you'll find it.
Supermarkets sell it in jars. A tourist in London might easily go home thinking it's a British dish.
But it was born in South Asia. It was cooked in kitchens there for generations, with spices ground by hand.
Restaurants in Britain only heard of it long after. And it still belongs to South Asia.
Curry travelled, and it changed on the way.
Then some people met it first in a British restaurant, and assumed it came from there.
Christianity is like that. It was born in Asia, travelled west, then came back east and south on European ships.
Like the tourist with the curry, many people thought it was European. But Europe was only its last stop before it reached them.
Part 2 · Banned, and growing anyway
For its first 300 years, the faith had no army, no king and no money behind it.
In the Roman Empire it was often against the law.
In AD 64 the emperor Nero blamed Christians for a great fire in Rome.
, a Roman historian, says many of them were put to death for it.
Around AD 112, a Roman governor called Pliny wrote to the emperor about Christians he had put on trial.
Those who wouldn't give up their faith, Pliny wrote, I ordered executed.
In 303 the emperor Diocletian began the worst persecution of all.
Churches were pulled down and their holy books burned. Christians were jailed and killed.
So how did it spread? Through ordinary people: farmers, mothers, slaves and traders, each telling the people around them.
When plagues swept the cities, many Christians stayed to nurse the sick, their own and their neighbours', while others fled.
A century later Julian, an emperor who wanted the old gods back, complained about it. Galilaeans was his sneer for Christians:
the impious Galilaeans support not only their own poor but ours as well
Scholars have tried to estimate the numbers. The historian Keith Hopkins put it at about 7,000 Christians in AD 100.
The sociologist Rodney Stark's figures run from under 50,000 around AD 150 to over a million by 250.
They're estimates, worked out from guessed growth rates. But nobody doubts the growth. And it happened while being a Christian could get you killed.
It spread for about ten generations with no sword behind it, while it offered nothing a powerful person would want.
Call it the first arrival: the message on its own.
Part 3 · When faith met power
Then, in 313, the emperor made it legal. Emperors began paying for churches and giving bishops a place at court.
In 380 a later emperor, Theodosius, made it the empire's official religion. Laws soon banned the old religion's sacrifices.
Faith and power got tangled together. And people started bending Jesus's words to fit what the powerful wanted.
Even great thinkers did it. , a bishop in North Africa, took a line from one of Jesus's stories.
In the old translations it reads: compel them to come in.
In the story, a host sends his servants out to fill his feast with guests.
Augustine read it as permission to use the law's force against a rival Christian group.
Later churchmen kept quoting it to defend force. Jesus was describing an invitation.
Part 4 · The empires, and popes who backed them
By the 1400s Europe's kings were Christian, and their ships were heading for Africa and Asia. In 1452 Nicholas V wrote to Portugal's king.
He gave him permission to conquer the Saracens and pagans: his letter's words for Muslims and other non-Christians.
It also allowed him to reduce their persons into perpetual slavery: in plain words, to make them slaves for life.
Historians see that letter, and another in 1455, as giving moral cover to the Portuguese slave trade from West Africa.
In Goa, Portugal's colony in India, the king ordered in 1546 that Hinduism be banned.
Hindus were made to sit through Christian preaching in churches.
Temples were to be destroyed and priests thrown out, and many people fled.
Goa also had an Inquisition, from 1560 to 1812: a church court that put people on trial for wrong belief.
It used prison and torture, mostly on converts accused of secretly keeping their old faith. Around 16,000 people were tried before 1774.
Most of the records were later destroyed. The few left show about 57 people sentenced to death.
In China, people who joined the church for food or protection were mocked as rice Christians.
In India the same slur is still thrown at Christians, to say they converted for money.
The colonial era even hurt Asia's own Christians, like the Christians of Kerala who trace their church to Thomas.
In 1599 a church meeting led by Goa's Portuguese archbishop, its most senior church leader, put them under Western church rule.
Books in Syriac, their old church language, that the meeting judged wrong were destroyed. Their worship was made more Roman.
One modern scholar calls it a sign of how domineering Europe's church leaders in India were.
In China, after the Opium Wars of the 1800s, Europe's powers forced unfair treaties on the country, with special rights for foreign missionaries.
France even took the side of Chinese Catholics in local disputes. To many Chinese, that tied the Catholic Church to foreign power.
Spain's empire had a pope behind it too. And some popes were just bad men.
Alexander VI, elected in 1492, was widely believed to have bought the job.
In a Church whose priests promise not to marry, Alexander had at least four children.
In 1493 he split the lands Europe was finding between Spain and Portugal.
His letter asked that barbarous nations be overthrown and brought to the faith.
That isn't the gospel. It's the gospel's words, bent to back a conquest.
In the Americas, Spain's soldiers read out a legal demand called the Requirement, in Spanish, to people who couldn't understand a word of it.
It told them to accept the Church and Spain's king.
If they didn't, it said: we shall make war against you.
We shall take you and your wives and your children, and shall make slaves of them.
And it told them that any deaths that result from this are your fault.
The slave trade those popes' letters of the 1450s helped cover ran for 400 years.
In 1992 John Paul II stood on Gorée, an island off Senegal where enslaved Africans were held, sold and shipped away in chains.
He said baptised people who didn't live their faith had taken part in that shameful trade.
This against people and against God, he said, must be confessed in truth and humility.
Then he asked 's forgiveness.
Later came the Congo. From 1885 to 1908 it was the private colony of Belgium's king.
His agents forced villagers to gather rubber, and soldiers cut off people's hands when quotas weren't met.
Nobody counted the people at the time, so the death toll can only be estimated, and estimates vary widely.
Many historians put it at 5 million to 10 million, through killing, hunger and disease.
Catholic missions were part of it. The king set up child colonies for orphaned children, who were often kidnapped.
They were sent to schools run by Catholic missionaries, to be trained as workers or soldiers. More than half of them died of disease.
Part 5 · Christians who said no
Even then, some Christians said it was wrong, out loud. In 1511 a friar called Antonio de Montesinos preached to Spanish settlers on Hispaniola.
Hispaniola is the Caribbean island that's now Haiti and the Dominican Republic. A friar is a member of a religious order, here the Dominicans.
He told the settlers they are all in mortal sin, because of the cruelty and tyranny they practice among these innocent peoples. Then he asked:
Tell me by what right of justice do you hold these Indians in such a cruel and horrible servitude?
In 1537 Pope Paul III wrote about the peoples of the Americas.
They are by no means to be deprived of their liberty or the possession of their property, he wrote.
That held, he added, even though they be outside the faith of Jesus Christ.
Many colonists ignored him. And the penalties he'd attached for anyone who broke it were soon withdrawn.
In the Congo, other missionaries, among them American Presbyterians, recorded the killings, and were taken to court for it.
Presbyterians are Protestants. With Catholics and the , Protestants are one of the three main branches of Christianity.
So here's the honest summary. What those Christians did was wrong. Plain wrong.
And it was wrong by Jesus's own standard. That's how other Christians could see it, and say it, at the time.
Part 6 · A long road back
The Catholic Church teaches that no culture owns the Gospel, which is the good news about Jesus.
John Paul II wrote that it is certainly not identical with culture.
He was honest about why that needed saying. Missionaries from the West, he wrote, couldn't help bringing their own cultures with them:
It was inevitable that the proclamation of the Gospel by Western missionaries would be influenced by the cultures from which they came.
The turn came slowly. In 1965 the , a meeting of the world's bishops, said faith must be free.
It called this one of the major tenets of Catholic doctrine:
no one therefore is to be forced to embrace the Christian faith against his own will
It also ruled out any persuasion that is dishonorable or unworthy, especially when dealing with poor or uneducated people.
That's the rice Christian problem, named and forbidden. By that rule, help from a Catholic school or hospital may never be used as bait.
The also admitted something about the Church's own past:
there has at times appeared a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it
Goa, the Requirement and the slave letters are that kind of history.
The Catholic Church also asks forgiveness for the harm done in its name.
On 12 March 2000, the Day of Pardon, John Paul II led Catholics in asking it.
Let us ask pardon for the divisions which have occurred among Christians, for the violence some have used in the service of the truth and for the distrustful and hostile attitudes sometimes taken towards the followers of other religions.
In Bolivia in 2015, Pope Francis named the conquest of the Americas itself:
I humbly ask forgiveness, not only for the offenses of the Church herself, but also for crimes committed against the native peoples during the so-called conquest of America.
In Canada in 2022 he apologised for church-run boarding schools, where Indigenous children had been taken from their families:
I humbly beg forgiveness for the evil committed by so many Christians against the indigenous peoples.
The Vatican is the Catholic Church's headquarters.
In 2023 it admitted the popes' letters of the 1400s did not adequately reflect the equal dignity and rights of the peoples they touched.
Colonial powers used them to justify immoral acts, sometimes unopposed by church leaders. The Vatican called that an error, and asked pardon.
To be honest, there's still no papal apology for the Goa Inquisition by name.
It took far too long to get here. But the Church now says openly that faith can't be forced, and that these wrongs were wrong.
Part 7 · After the empires left
If Christianity were only the colonisers' religion, you'd expect it to fade when they left. It didn't.
From 1910 to 2010, across Asia and the Pacific, Christians grew from 3% to 7% of people.
In Africa south of the Sahara the change was far bigger: from 9% to 63%.
The growth began under colonial rule, but it outlasted the empires. By 2010 Nigeria had one of the ten largest Christian populations on earth.
That's the century when most empires went home.
Korea is the most striking case.
Pope Francis said there in 2014 that the faith came through Koreans' own search for religious truth, not through missionaries.
In Seoul that year he beatified 124 Korean , people killed for their faith, declaring them blessed.
They died for a faith no empire gave them.
And India, where the rice Christian slur is still heard? Christians have made up 2 to 3% of India's people in every census since 1951.
A census is the government's count of everyone. But Christians may be undercounted.
In India, people are born into social ranks called castes. Dalits, from the lowest castes, can get government benefits.
But the census can't record anyone as both Dalit and Christian. So some reportedly list themselves as Hindu, and no one knows how many.
In a large 2021 survey, 0.4% of Indians said they were raised Hindu and are now Christian, most from the lowest castes and tribal groups.
Conversions happen, and the Catholic Church's own rule says any won with bait are wrong. But the numbers show no sign of mass conversion.
Many Indians suspect the rule against bait is broken today.
Since 1967, about 10 Indian states have passed laws against converting anyone by the use of force or by inducement or by any fraudulent means.
Supporters say the laws stop people taking advantage of the weak.
Critics, Christians among them, say they break India's promise of religious freedom. India's Supreme Court is hearing challenges to them.
So Christianity came to much of the world twice. The first time, it came with nothing but the message.
The second time, it came with the empires, and it brought real wrongs. The second doesn't erase the first.
And to be honest, in much of Asia the first church was almost wiped out. So the second arrival is the one most families remember.
The history matters, and nobody should pretend it doesn't. But bad Christians don't define the faith. Not even bad popes.
Jesus chose twelve men as his closest followers, and one of them, Judas, betrayed him.
He warned that calling him Lord isn't the same as following him.
So judge Christianity by Jesus, not by the people who betrayed him.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 45
- Wikipedia, Goa Inquisition · John III's 1546 order against Hinduism; Hindus made to hear preaching, many fled; Inquisition 1560–1812; about 16,000 trials to 1774; 57 death sentences in surviving records; Diamper 1599.
- Wikipedia, Rice Christian · Converts in China said to join for protection or food; unequal treaties gave missionaries special rights; still a slur against Indian Christians.
- Pope John Paul II, Ecclesia in Asia (6 November 1999), 1, 20–21 · Jesus took flesh as an Asian; the paradox of a Western Jesus; the Asian countenance of Jesus.
- Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage, Thomas Christians · Tradition of Thomas in 52; Cosmas in the early 6th century; Syriac books destroyed at Diamper (1599), the rite Romanised.
- The Nestorian Monument (Xi'an Stele, 781), Fordham Internet History Sourcebook · Olopun from Syria arrives at Chang-an in 635.
- Pope John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000) · Pardon asked for violence in the service of truth and hostility to other religions.
- Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 4, 10, 12 · No one may be forced to embrace the faith; no dishonourable persuasion of the poor; an admission of past ways of acting opposed to the Gospel.
- Pew Research Center, Global Christianity (19 December 2011) · Sub-Saharan Africa rose from 9% to 63% Christian and Asia-Pacific from 3% to 7%, 1910–2010; Nigeria among the ten largest Christian populations.
- Pope Francis, Homily at the Beatification of Paul Yun Ji-chung and 123 companions, Seoul (16 August 2014) · The faith came to Korea not through missionaries but through Koreans themselves.
- OrthodoxWiki, Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church · The church of the Axumite kingdom under King Ezana in the 4th century, through Frumentius; origins traced to Acts 8.
- CNEWA, The Coptic Orthodox Church (archived 2025) · The church in Egypt associated with St Mark the Evangelist, by tradition martyred in Alexandria in 63.
- Acts of the Apostles 8 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Philip baptises an Ethiopian court official on his way home from Jerusalem.
- Wikipedia, Dum Diversas · Nicholas V's bull of 18 June 1452 and Romanus Pontifex (1455), seen as facilitating the Portuguese slave trade from West Africa.
- Dicasteries for Culture and Education and for Promoting Integral Human Development, Joint Statement on the "Doctrine of Discovery" (30 March 2023) · The bulls did not reflect the equal dignity of indigenous peoples; their misuse at times went unopposed by church authorities; pardon asked.
- John Paul II, Address to the Catholic community of Gorée Island, Senegal (22 February 1992; French) · Baptised people took part in the slave trade; the sin must be confessed in truth and humility; heaven's pardon implored.
- Wikipedia, Congo Free State · Leopold II's rule 1885–1908; the rubber regime and severed hands; 5 to 10 million estimated deaths; Presbyterian missionaries Sheppard and Morrison sued for exposing abuses.
- Wikipedia, Atrocities in the Congo Free State · "Child colonies": kidnapped children sent to Catholic mission schools; more than half died of disease.
- Wikipedia, Anti-conversion law · The Orissa Freedom of Religion Act 1967; ten Indian states with laws by 2023; criticism and Supreme Court challenges.
- Pew Research Center, Population growth and religious composition (India, 21 September 2021) · Christians between 2% and 3% of India in every census since 1951.
- Pew Research Center, Religion in India: Tolerance and Segregation (29 June 2021) · Switching is rare; 0.4% raised Hindu now Christian, mostly from Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and OBCs.
- Acts of the Apostles 2 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Pentecost: visitors from Parthia, Media, Elam, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Libya, Arabia and Rome hear the apostles.
- Mark 10:42–45 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Rulers lord it over them; it shall not be so among you; the Son of Man came to serve.
- John 13:1–15 (New American Bible) · Jesus washes his disciples' feet and tells them to wash one another's feet.
- Matthew 28:19 (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations.
- Wikipedia, Christianization of Armenia · Traditional date 301; scholars' dates range from 284 to no later than 325.
- Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (Wikisource) · Nero blames the Christians for the fire of Rome (AD 64) and has many put to death.
- Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96–97 (Fordham Internet History Sourcebook) · Pliny's trials of Christians around AD 112; those who persisted were executed.
- Wikipedia, Diocletianic Persecution · Edicts of 303: scriptures and places of worship destroyed, clergy imprisoned; death, torture and imprisonment for many.
- Eusebius, Church History 7.22 (New Advent) · Dionysius of Alexandria on Christians nursing the sick in the plague while others fled.
- Emperor Julian, Letter to Arsacius (362), trans. W. C. Wright (tertullian.org) · "the impious Galilaeans support not only their own poor but ours as well".
- Wikipedia, Early Christianity · Keith Hopkins's estimate of about 7,000 Christians by AD 100.
- Wikipedia, Christianization of the Roman Empire as diffusion of innovation · From fewer than 50,000 adherents to over a million between 150 and 250.
- Wikipedia, Edict of Milan · Constantine and Licinius grant Christians legal toleration in 313.
- Wikipedia, Edict of Thessalonica, and Theodosius I · Nicene Christianity made the state religion in 380; Theodosius reiterated the bans on sacrifice (see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodosius_I).
- Wikipedia, Donatism · Augustine cites the parable of the great banquet, "compel them to come in" (Luke 14:23), to justify force against the Donatists.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Pope Alexander VI (New Advent) · That he obtained the papacy through simony was the general belief; his four children.
- Pope Alexander VI, Inter Caetera (4 May 1493), Papal Encyclicals Online · Divides the newly found lands; asks that "barbarous nations be overthrown and brought to the faith itself".
- Wikipedia, Requerimiento · The 1513 text read to native peoples: war, enslavement, and "any deaths that result from this are your fault".
- Wikipedia, Antonio de Montesinos · Sermon of 21 December 1511 on Hispaniola, as recorded by Bartolomé de las Casas.
- Pope Paul III, Sublimis Deus (1537), Papal Encyclicals Online · Indians "are by no means to be deprived of their liberty or the possession of their property, even though they be outside the faith of Jesus Christ".
- Wikipedia, Sublimis Deus · The brief Pastorale officium, threatening excommunication, was later annulled.
- Pope Francis, Address to the World Meeting of Popular Movements, Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia (9 July 2015) · Forgiveness asked for crimes against the native peoples during the so-called conquest of America.
- Pope Francis, Meeting with Indigenous Peoples at Maskwacis, Canada (25 July 2022) · Forgiveness begged for the evil committed by so many Christians against the indigenous peoples; the residential schools.
- Matthew 7:21 (New American Bible) · Not everyone who says to me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven.
- CNEWA, The Assyrian Church of the East (archived 2025) · By 1318 some 30 metropolitan sees and 200 dioceses; almost annihilated in Tamerlane's invasions in the late 14th century.