Full text
No religion, or not sure · About 6 min ·  · God and evidence

Isn't religion just a crutch or wishful thinking?

The short answer

Sometimes people do believe things because they're comforting. But wanting something can't tell you whether it's true, and it can't tell you it's false either. And a lot of Christianity is hard in ways nobody would wish for.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

It's one of the oldest objections there is. Life is scary, and everyone dies.

So, the argument goes, people invent a loving father in the sky to make themselves feel better.

And it isn't just an insult. Two famous thinkers made this case, and they made it seriously.

Karl Marx, the man behind communism, called religion the sigh of the oppressed creature and the opium of the people.

Opium is a drug that dulls pain.

But he wasn't only sneering. He saw real pain behind religion, and he blamed whatever was causing the pain.

Sigmund Freud, the doctor who founded psychoanalysis, which is an early kind of talk therapy, called religion an illusion.

He meant a belief driven by a wish, like a small child longing for a dad who'll keep him safe.

And to be honest, there's truth in both. People do sometimes believe what comforts them.

Anyone who denies that isn't being straight with you.

Part 2 · Wanting doesn't decide it

Freud didn't think religion was true. But he admitted the key point. He wrote: Illusions need not necessarily be false.

A wish can push you towards a belief that turns out to be true.

And it works both ways. Someone could just as easily want there to be no God, with no one above them to answer to.

It would be just as much a wish.

Neither wish tells you who's right.

The Catholic Church makes the same point, from the other side.

Its , the summary of what it believes, says that when it comes to God, people…

easily persuade themselves that what they would not like to be true is false or at least doubtful.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 37

That's wishful thinking too, only pointing away from God. The Catechism says the truth about God asks a lot: it calls for self-surrender.

So a wish can push a person away from God as easily as towards him.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of exam results day.

The night before, you can barely sleep. Your palms are sweaty just thinking about it.

You want straight As so badly it hurts. You've already pictured telling your parents.

But wanting them doesn't mean you got them. And it doesn't mean you failed, either.

Your friend who's sure she did badly might have done brilliantly.

The result is already printed on the slip, whatever anyone is feeling.

The only way to find out is to open the envelope.

How much you want something tells you about you, not about what's on the paper.

It's the same with God. Whether you want him to be real or not, the wanting doesn't decide it. You still have to look.

Part 3 · Not what anyone would invent

Now try this. If you set out to design a comforting religion, would you come up with Christianity?

Its founder, Jesus, a Jewish teacher who lived about two thousand years ago, told people: love your enemies.

That's a strange rule to make up if all you wanted was to feel better.

Christians believe Jesus was God come as a human.

And he died in agony on a cross, abandoned by most of his friends.

Christians believe Jesus came back to life three days later. But nobody inventing a comfort would have their God go through that first.

Jesus said that one day everyone will answer to God for how they treated the hungry.

And Christianity says a person can lose God for ever. That's what Christians mean by .

Comfort is part of it, and Christians don't hide that. But it's comfort that costs you something.

It means forgiving people who hurt you, telling the truth when it's hard, and handing over control of your life.

The Catechism says God never stops calling every person to look for him.

But the looking takes every effort of intellect, a sound will, and other people to teach you. A crutch asks nothing of you.

A skeptic can reply that hard rules also hold a group together, so a religion could keep them whether it's true or not.

It's a fair point. And hard doesn't make a belief true, any more than comforting makes it false.

Where a belief comes from can't settle whether it's true. That goes for the comforting parts and the hard parts alike.

Part 4 · The longing is a clue

People in every culture, in every age, have searched for something more than this life, in their prayers and temples and their own ways.

The Catholic Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions, Buddhism and Hinduism among them.

It sees that search as part of being human, and as a search for God. Its Catechism puts it simply:

The desire for God is written in the human heart, because man is created by God and for God.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 27

A longing doesn't prove God, any more than any wish does. But if we were made for God, it's exactly what you'd expect to find.

So Christians read that longing as a clue, not a weakness.

About 1,600 years ago, a in North Africa called put it into a prayer.

He said to God: our heart is restless until it rests in you.

Part 5 · Hope that gets you working

But remember Marx. His worry was that hoping for , life with God after death, makes people put up with injustice here.

The Catholic Church took that seriously.

In 1965 the , a meeting of the world's Catholic bishops, answered that worry head on.

Hoping for heaven doesn't make working for justice here matter less, it said. It gives you even more reason to do it.

The Catechism even admits that one reason people turn away from God is the scandal of bad example on the part of believers.

In other words, Christians can be the problem.

So yes, some people use faith as a crutch.

But the question that matters is whether the thing you're leaning on is real.

That's a question about evidence, not about anyone's feelings.

The evidence has its own answers on this site: whether God exists, whether Jesus lived, and whether he rose from the dead.

They're among the questions below.

Quick check

Say you really, really want something to be true. What does that tell you about whether it is?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 7
  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 27–30 · The desire for God written in the human heart; man as a religious being; Augustine's restless heart.
  2. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 37 · People easily persuade themselves that what they don't want to be true is false.
  3. Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes (7 December 1965), 19–21 · The Council on modern atheism, believers' share of the blame, and hope that strengthens earthly duties.
  4. Matthew 5:44 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Love your enemies.
  5. Karl Marx, A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right, Introduction (1844) · Religion as 'the opium of the people'.
  6. Wikipedia, The Future of an Illusion (Freud, 1927) · Freud's case that religion is wish-fulfilment, and his note that illusions need not be false.
  7. Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate (28 October 1965), 2 · The Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions; Hinduism and Buddhism named.