Full text
Catholic · About 7 min ·  · Marriage and family

Why is the Catholic Church against IVF?

The short answer

Because it believes a child should begin through the parents' love-making, sex between husband and wife, not in a lab. And IVF usually means embryos that are frozen or lost. It isn't against couples who can't get pregnant. And every child born through IVF is fully loved by God.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

If you've struggled to have a baby, this isn't abstract.

It can mean months of hoping, test after test, and maybe miscarriages along the way.

IVF is where eggs are fertilised in a lab, and an embryo, a fertilised egg in its first few days, is placed in the womb.

After all that waiting, it can look like the only door left.

So the Catholic answer can sound cruel. IVF has given many families a child they longed for.

In one 2013 survey, in the US, only 12% of adults called it morally wrong.

Let's say the most important thing first.

A child conceived through IVF is a child of God, loved, with exactly the same dignity as anyone else. The Catholic Church says so itself.

If you were born this way, or your child was, nothing below changes that.

The Catholic Church shares the longing too. It says couples who can't have children suffer greatly, and it backs research to help them.

Its objection is narrower than most people think.

Part 2 · A gift, not something ordered

Here's an easy way to see where IVF fits. Contraception, like the pill or a condom, blocks a baby from coming through sex.

IVF makes a baby without sex.

The Catholic Church's key line on this is in the , the Church's official summary of its beliefs. It's short:

A child is not something owed to one, but is a gift.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2378

In other words, nobody has a right to a child, as if a child were property. The Catechism says only the child possesses genuine rights.

Among them is the right to come into the world through the loving union of a mother and father.

So the Catechism says IVF pulls apart two things that belong together: the couple's love-making, and the start of a new life.

Think of it like this

But if the child is the same, why does it matter how they begin? Here's an analogy that might help.

Think of a hug. Some things mean most when you do them yourself.

Say your best friend is going through a hard time in another city, and you can't get there.

So you ask her sister to give her a big hug from you.

The hug is real, and so is your love. It's why you asked.

Your friend is comforted. She matters just as much, and she's held just as warmly.

But it isn't quite your hug. Something meant to pass from your arms to hers has gone through someone else's.

Nobody in this story is second best. Not your friend, and not your love for her.

The only difference is whose arms she was held in.

The Catholic Church sees the start of a new life that way.

It's meant to come from the parents' own embrace, their love-making, not to be handed to a lab.

Nobody is doubting how much IVF parents love their children. The concern is how a child begins, never the worth of the child.

Now take the simplest case. A clinic uses only the couple's own egg and sperm, and puts every embryo back in the womb.

The Church still says no. It calls this morally unacceptable.

It sees this as perhaps less wrong than using a donor's egg or sperm, or a surrogate mother.

A surrogate mother is a woman who carries the baby for the couple.

Why? Because of how the child begins. Conception happens in a lab, not through the couple's love-making.

The child's start is put in the hands of doctors and scientists.

That's where the Church draws its line. Medicine that helps a couple's own love-making succeed is welcome. Medicine that replaces it isn't.

Part 3 · The embryos nobody talks about

Then there's the part most people never hear. IVF usually means producing many eggs, fertilising several, and putting back only some.

The rest are often frozen, and some are thrown away if they have defects.

In 2008 the Vatican, the Church's head office in Rome, wrote a document on these questions.

It noted that far more embryos are lost than born. Even in the best clinics of the time, over 80% were lost.

Practice has changed since. One example, from the UK: by 2019, one embryo was put back in 75% of cycles, up from 13% in 1991.

That means fewer risky multiple pregnancies. But the other embryos are usually frozen, and many are never used.

And single transfer doesn't touch the first objection at all: conception still happens in a lab, not through the couple's love-making.

Some reply that many embryos are lost in nature too, without anyone meaning it.

The Vatican's answer is that in IVF, many of the losses are foreseen and willed: known in advance, and accepted as part of it.

Many frozen embryos are never claimed. So what should happen to them now? The Vatican admits it has no good answer.

It calls the thousands of abandoned embryos a situation of injustice which in fact cannot be resolved.

Catholics believe each embryo is a human life, to be respected from the moment it begins. If that's true, these losses aren't side effects.

To be fair, many people don't believe that about early embryos. That's where much of the disagreement lies.

The same 2008 document says the Church recognizes the legitimacy of the desire for a child and understands the suffering of these couples.

But a good wish doesn't make every way of getting there right.

In its view, wanting a child can't justify making one in a lab, just as not wanting one can't justify harming one already conceived.

Part 4 · It isn't just no

So what does the Church say yes to? It welcomes treatments that fix the cause of infertility, like hormone treatment or surgery.

It welcomes anything that helps the couple's own love-making succeed. And it asks for adoption to be made easier.

The answer to infertility isn't just no. It's a different path, and help along it.

For couples who stay childless, the Catechism doesn't offer easy words. It says infertility is a real suffering, but not an absolute evil.

In other words, it doesn't make a marriage or a life empty.

It invites them to bring their suffering to the cross of Jesus, who Christians believe is God the Son. He died there, and rose again.

So the Catechism calls the cross the source of all spiritual fecundity: a place new life comes from.

And it points them to other ways of giving life: adopting, or serving others.

Those can be lonely words. They're meant with love.

And the Church asks the whole community of believers to stand with couples in this pain.

If you've been through IVF, God hasn't turned away from you. Blame can be lessened by not knowing the teaching, or by pressure and fear.

Whatever happened, the way back is open. The Catechism says there are no limits to the mercy of God for anyone who turns back.

And confession, where Catholics tell their to a priest and are forgiven, is there for anything you regret.

In 1987 the Vatican wrote about children born this way. Whatever the method, it said, every child:

must in any case be accepted as a living gift of the divine Goodness and must be brought up with love.
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Donum Vitae (1987), II.B.5

So if you were born through IVF, or your child was, hear this clearly. You're not a mistake, and neither is your child.

The Catholic Church's objection is to a method. It has never been to a person.

Quick check

Think back to the hug from her sister. What made it different?

Pick an answer below.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 7
  1. Pew Research Center, Abortion Viewed in Moral Terms: Fewer See Stem Cell Research and IVF as Moral Issues (15 August 2013) · 12% of US adults call IVF morally wrong; 46% say it isn't a moral issue.
  2. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Donum Vitae (22 February 1987), especially II.B.5 and II.B.8 · Why even "simple case" IVF is rejected; every child must be accepted as a living gift; the community must support infertile couples.
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2373–2379 · The suffering of infertility, donor and in-couple techniques, a child as gift not right.
  4. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dignitas Personae (8 September 2008), 12–19 · Treatments that are allowed, embryo losses in IVF, freezing, adoption, the desire for a child.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1735 · Ignorance, fear, duress and other factors can lessen or remove blame.
  6. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1864 · There are no limits to the mercy of God for anyone who repents.
  7. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (UK), Fertility treatment 2019: trends and figures · In 2019 one embryo was put back in 75% of IVF cycles, compared with 13% in 1991.