Full text
No religion, or not sure · About 7 min ·  · Suffering, hell and hope

How can a loving God send anyone to hell forever?

The short answer

God doesn't send anyone to hell against their will. The Catholic Church teaches that hell is a person's own final refusal of God's love. It's real and it's for ever, but the Church has never said that any named person is there.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

For many people, this is where Christianity stops making sense.

You live a few decades, and then the punishment never ends? Even a harsh human judge wouldn't do that.

If God is love, looks like the opposite of love.

The popular picture makes it worse: God as a torturer with a list, and people a bit too sure who's going.

If that's hell, the objection wins.

But that isn't what the Catholic Church teaches.

Part 2 · Nobody is pushed in

Christians believe we were made to live for ever with God, the only one who can give us the life and happiness we long for.

They call that . Hell is losing it for good.

The Catholic Church describes hell as cutting yourself off from God for good, by your own choice.

Nobody is made for it, and nobody is pushed into it. God doesn't plan for anyone to end up there.

, the head of the Catholic Church at the time, spelled it out in 1999:

"Eternal damnation", therefore, is not attributed to God's initiative because in his merciful love he can only desire the salvation of the beings he created. In reality, it is the creature who closes himself to his love.
John Paul II, General Audience, 28 July 1999, 3

So why does God let anyone shut him out? Because of what love is.

The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says: We cannot be united with God unless we freely choose to love him.

A God who dragged people into heaven against their will wouldn't be offering love. He'd be overriding them.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a big family dinner the night before a holiday. The whole family's there.

The pot is bubbling, there's a seat with your name on it, and your grandmother keeps calling you to come and eat.

But you're angry, and you'd rather be alone. So you go to your room and lock the door from the inside.

She knocks. She calls your name again. She leaves a full plate outside the door, still warm.

Nobody has thrown you out or taken your seat. The laughter carries on down the hall, and the door could open any time you chose.

You're alone because you locked the door. That's how the Catholic Church describes hell.

It isn't God slamming a door on you. It's a person locking it from the inside, and refusing, for good, to open it.

Part 3 · Real, and for ever

So is hell real? Jesus, the Jewish teacher Christians follow, warned about it in strong pictures, like the unquenchable fire.

He also said that when he comes to judge the world at the end of time, he'll say to some:

Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire!
Matthew 25:41, as quoted in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1034

The Catechism quotes those words itself. So Jesus does judge.

But in Catholic teaching, his judgement doesn't override anyone's choice. It confirms the choice they made.

And the Catholic Church does teach that hell is real. Its Catechism says:

The teaching of the Church affirms the existence of hell and its eternity.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1035

It doesn't avoid the word punishment, either. It goes on:

The chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1035

John Paul II said pictures like the fire must be correctly interpreted. Hell, he said, is less a place than a state.

It's the condition of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God, the source of all life and joy.

And the Catechism says ending up there takes a willful turning away from God, and staying that way to the end.

The Catholic name for that kind of turning away is mortal : a serious wrong, done knowing it's serious, and freely chosen.

So nobody ends up there for a wrong they honestly didn't know was serious.

If you're wondering about family who weren't Christian, here's the short version.

The Catholic Church teaches that people who never truly knew the , the good news about Jesus, can still be saved.

They can, when it's through no fault of their own, and they sincerely seek God and follow their conscience.

The full answer is among the questions at the end.

Other Christians teach hell too: most churches, and the , meaning the churches of the Christian East, divided from Rome for nearly 1,000 years.

A statement of faith from the Southern Baptist Convention, a large Protestant family, uses the same word, calling it the place of everlasting punishment.

The Orthodox often add something beautiful. God's love doesn't switch off for anyone.

To those who love him, it's joy. To those who refuse him, the same love is pain.

Now comes the hardest part. Why should a choice made in one lifetime count for ever?

And if after death you see God clearly, why not just open the door?

The Catholic Church teaches that death ends the time for choosing.

Death, the Catechism says, puts an end to human life as the time open to either accepting or rejecting God's , his free help.

Why should death be the cut-off? The Catechism's answer is that our freedom has the power to make choices for ever, with no turning back.

Think about how people change. Small choices harden into habits, and habits harden into who you are.

Someone who spends a whole life shutting out love can end up not wanting it any more, even with it right in front of them.

Seeing love clearly isn't the same as wanting it.

Benedict XVI, a recent , took this further.

Hell, he wrote, is for people who have totally destroyed their desire for truth and readiness to love, who have suppressed all love within themselves.

For someone like that, seeing God wouldn't make them want him. Nothing is left in them that wants to open the door.

But didn't think that describes most people.

For the great majority, he supposed, there remains in the depths of their being an ultimate interior openness to truth, to love, to God.

However messy a life is, he thought, that openness can still be there underneath. And he believed people like that do get through the door.

Benedict pictured meeting Jesus after death as a fire that cleans: Before his gaze all falsehood melts away.

It hurts, the way facing the truth about yourself hurts. But it heals.

The Catholic name for that cleaning is .

Orthodox Christians don't teach it in that form, though they too pray for the dead.

So death fixes which way you're facing. But anyone who dies still turned towards God, however faintly, isn't shut out.

Hell isn't God refusing to forgive. It's a person refusing to be forgiven.

Some Christians go further. They believe that in the end everyone will come home, and hell will be empty.

Origen, an early Christian teacher of the 200s, taught something like it. Gregory of Nyssa, a of the 300s, is often read that way.

In 2019 David Bentley Hart, an Orthodox scholar, argued for it in a book called That All Shall Be Saved.

A God who is love, he says, could never lose anyone for ever.

Part 4 · Who's in hell?

The Catholic Church doesn't hold that view. It takes Jesus's warnings as real warnings, not empty threats.

And a yes that's guaranteed in advance isn't free. Catholics may hope everyone is saved, but the Church won't say it's certain.

The Catholic Church has never said that any named person is in hell.

It names saints, people it believes are in heaven. But it has never done the opposite, not once.

John Paul II said hell is a real possibility. But unless God reveals it, we can't know who is actually there.

So no Christian has the right to tell anyone you're going to hell.

We can say an act is seriously wrong. But judging a person's final state belongs to God alone.

Then why teach it at all? Because our choices matter. The Catechism calls it an urgent call to conversion: a wake-up call to turn back.

And John Paul II said it must not create anxiety or despair. Nobody stumbles into hell by accident.

The Catholic Church prays against it all the time. At , its main Sunday service, it asks God to save us from final damnation.

And the Catechism says The Church prays that no one should be lost, because God desires all men to be saved.

In Catholic teaching, nobody ends up in hell unless they keep saying no to God, right to the end.

He lets people keep saying no, because he won't force anyone to love him.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 10
  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1033–1037 · Hell as definitive self-exclusion; real and eternal; "God predestines no one to go to hell".
  2. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1857–1861 · What mortal sin is; freedom can choose for ever; judge acts, leave persons to God.
  3. John Paul II, General Audience (28 July 1999) · Hell as a state freely chosen, not imposed by God; we cannot know who is in it.
  4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1058 · The Church prays that no one be lost; God desires all to be saved.
  5. Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (30 November 2007), 45–48 · Hell as the state of those who have destroyed all desire for truth and love; for most people an ultimate interior openness remains, purified in the encounter with Christ; the East prays for the dead without teaching purifying suffering.
  6. Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. IV: Heaven and Hell · The Orthodox reading: God's presence is joy to those who love him and pain to those who refuse him.
  7. Southern Baptist Convention, The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), article X · A Protestant statement of faith: hell as "the place of everlasting punishment".
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1021 · Death ends human life as the time open to accepting or rejecting God's grace.
  9. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 846–848 · Those who through no fault of their own do not know the Gospel, yet seek God sincerely and follow conscience, may be saved.
  10. Wikipedia, Christian universalism · Origen and Gregory of Nyssa as early universalists; David Bentley Hart, That All Shall Be Saved.