Full text
Catholic · About 7 min ·  · Death and what comes after

Do Catholics really have to believe in the devil?

The short answer

Yes. Catholics believe the devil is real: an angel God made good, who chose to turn against him. But he's only a creature, not an evil god as strong as God, and Jesus has already beaten him. So you don't need to live afraid of him.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

To a lot of people, the devil sounds like a character from a horror film.

So it's easy to assume that smart Catholics see him as a symbol: a picture for the evil people do.

And that's a fair thought. Watch the news for five minutes, and there's plenty of human evil to explain without adding anyone else.

Belief in demons has also done real harm. In 1976 Anneliese Michel, a young German woman, starved to death after nearly a year of exorcisms.

An exorcism is a prayer to free a person from evil. Those around her blamed demons. But she had epilepsy and mental illness.

Her parents and the priests were convicted of causing her death through negligence.

But the devil wasn't added to Christianity later. He's there in the life of Jesus.

In the , the devil tempts Jesus, and Jesus talks about him often.

He even says this, using the devil's other name, Satan:

I have observed Satan fall like lightning from the sky
Luke 10:18

To be fair, though, the idea has a history.

In the book of Job, the satan is a member of God's court, an accuser, not God's enemy.

The Catholic 's own notes say that in later biblical traditions this character will be developed as the devil.

Some scholars see that as a human idea that grew over time.

Catholics believe God showed things step by step, as people could take them in.

And the Bible's last book ties it together.

It calls the devil the ancient serpent: the snake that, in Genesis, tempted the first humans to turn from God.

So the real question isn't whether the Bible talks about him. It's what kind of being he is, and how much power he has.

Part 2 · Yes, he's real

The Catholic Church teaches that the devil is a fallen angel. Angels are spirits God made: real, but with no body.

The says he was at first a good angel, made by God.

Then he chose to reject God, completely and for ever. It was his own free choice.

In 1972 Paul VI put it bluntly. Evil isn't only a lack of something good, he said.

It's also someone: a living spiritual being, gone bad, dragging others down with it.

He named three mistakes: saying it doesn't exist, making it a rival to God, or calling it a made-up picture for what we can't explain.

Each one, he said, steps outside what the Bible and the Church teach.

Even the Lord's Prayer names the devil.

When Christians pray deliver us from evil, the Catechism says evil is not an abstraction, but refers to a person, Satan.

Part 3 · Not God's evil twin

Here's the part people often get wrong. The devil isn't God's evil twin.

In the 1100s and 1200s, a group in southern France called the Albigensians taught that there were two opposed powers, one good and one evil.

The evil one, they said, made the material world: everything you can see and touch.

A pope answered them with force too: a crusade from 1209 that killed men, women and children. That was wrong, plain wrong.

The River, the timeline on this site, tells that story in full. Here, the question is the idea itself.

In 1215 a meeting of answered the idea itself in one line:

The devil and other demons were created by God naturally good, but they became evil by their own doing
Fourth Lateran Council (1215), Constitution 1

So evil isn't something God made. It's what a good creature did with its freedom.

The devil is strong, because he's a spirit with no body. But he's still only something God made. The Catechism says:

The power of Satan is, nonetheless, not infinite. He is only a creature, powerful from the fact that he is pure spirit, but still a creature. He cannot prevent the building up of God's reign.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 395
Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of the best student a school ever had.

He had top marks, and every teacher trusted him. They even gave him keys to the building and a badge.

Then one day he turns against the school, on purpose, and walks out.

Now he spreads lies about it, and talks younger students into skipping class and breaking things. He's clever, and he can do real damage.

But look at what he isn't. He's still a student, not a second principal. He didn't build the school, and he doesn't run it.

He can't close it down, either. Whatever he does, the school is still open in the morning.

The devil is like that. He's powerful, and worth taking seriously, but he's a creature, not God's equal.

Part 4 · Two hard questions

So why can't the devil be forgiven?

The Catechism says the problem is that his choice can't be taken back. It isn't any limit on God's mercy.

And why does God let him act at all? The Catechism doesn't pretend to know. It calls it a great mystery.

But it adds that God works for good in everything, with those who love him.

Part 5 · Exorcism, and fear

So what about exorcism, that prayer to free a person from evil? It's real, but rare.

And possession, the devil taking hold of a person? It's real in Catholic belief, but the bishops of the United States call genuine cases rare.

The full kind of exorcism needs a priest with his bishop's permission, and he must first make sure he's facing evil and not an illness.

Before an exorcist is even involved, the person is meant to have a full medical, psychological and psychiatric check.

Mental illness, the Catechism says, is a matter for doctors.

The US bishops say the Church moves slowly here on purpose, so people don't get caught up in a sensationalist mentality.

There's also an everyday kind of exorcism: a short prayer said at every .

It asks God to protect the person from evil.

What about the spirits and creatures of the night in folk stories? Many cultures have them.

In the Philippines, for example, there are the aswang and the engkanto. And plenty of grandmothers elsewhere have stories of their own.

The Catechism doesn't mention any of them. Its teaching is about angels and demons.

What it warns against is where fear can lead: charms, mediums who claim to talk to the dead, or cures that call on evil powers.

Those are all ways of trying to get power over hidden forces. Catholics are asked to put themselves in God's hands instead.

So no, you don't need to live afraid. If something frightens you, talk to a parent, a priest or a doctor, and pray.

And go to confession.

The US bishops say it gives grace to fight evil: God's help, given for free.

Part 6 · Real, but beaten

The point of naming the devil isn't fear. It's confidence.

Christians believe Jesus beat the devil once for all by freely giving up his life on the cross.

And the cross wasn't the end. Three days later Jesus's tomb was empty: he came back to life.

Christians believe death comes from walking away from God, who gives us life. Jesus never walked away from God, so death couldn't hold him.

So the Catechism can say this:

One who entrusts himself to God does not dread the devil.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2852

And this isn't only a Catholic belief. For the , the ancient churches of the East, baptism begins with the rejection of Satan.

And a 1974 statement by evangelical Protestants, the Lausanne Covenant, speaks of constant spiritual warfare with the powers of evil.

So yes, Catholics do have to believe in the devil. It's part of the faith, written down by that meeting of bishops in 1215.

But they believe in him the way you'd believe in an enemy who's already lost: real, but beaten.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 14
  1. Wikipedia, Anneliese Michel · Died in 1976 after exorcisms; diagnosed with epilepsy and psychiatric illness; parents and priests convicted of negligent homicide.
  2. Luke 10 (New American Bible) · Jesus: I have observed Satan fall like lightning from the sky.
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 391–395 · The fall of the angels; Satan created good, only a creature, his power not infinite.
  4. Pope Paul VI, General Audience "Liberaci dal male" (15 November 1972), in Italian · Evil as a living spiritual being; denying it, making it a second power, or calling it a personification leaves biblical and Church teaching. English renderings are our own.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2850–2854 · Deliver us from evil: evil as a person; Christ's victory; no need to dread the devil.
  6. Catholic Encyclopedia, Albigenses (1907) · The Albigensian belief in two opposed principles, one good and one evil; the crusade against them from 1209.
  7. Fourth Lateran Council (1215), Constitution 1 · The devil and demons were created good and became evil by their own doing.
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1673 · Exorcism: only a priest, with the bishop's permission, with prudence, after ruling out illness.
  9. Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, Baptism · Orthodox baptism begins with the rejection of Satan.
  10. Lausanne Covenant (1974), 12: Spiritual Conflict · Evangelicals on spiritual warfare with the powers of evil.
  11. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2115–2117 · Divination, mediums, magic, charms and traditional cures that invoke evil powers.
  12. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Exorcism: questions and answers · Genuine possession is rare; medical, psychological and psychiatric checks come first; the Church moves cautiously; confession gives grace to fight evil.
  13. Job 1 (New American Bible, Revised Edition), with the note on 1:6 · The satan as a member of the heavenly court, the accuser; 'in later biblical traditions this character will be developed as the devil'.
  14. Revelation 12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Revelation 12:9: the huge dragon, the ancient serpent, who is called the Devil and Satan; the note ties it to the serpent of Genesis 3.