Full text
Orthodox · About 6 min ·  · God, grace and sin

Does Rome reject theosis and St Gregory Palamas?

The short answer

No. The Catholic Church teaches theosis, being made like God, in its own Catechism. What's still argued is how to describe it, including the line St Gregory Palamas drew between God as he is in himself and God at work in us.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

Here's one of the most astonishing ideas in Christianity. God doesn't only want to forgive you.

He wants to share his own life with you.

They call God sharing his life with us theosis, which is Greek for being made like God.

Theosis doesn't mean becoming a second God. It means sharing God's life as a gift.

The calls it coming to share in the divine nature. For Christians, this is what being saved is.

The Orthodox often call the Catholic Church Rome, since its leader is the of Rome.

So it would be a big deal if Rome rejected theosis. And some Orthodox think it does.

Part 2 · A monk, a mountain and a light

In the 1300s, Gregory Palamas, a monk of Mount Athos in Greece, defended monks who prayed in deep silence.

He later became Archbishop of Thessalonica, today's Thessaloniki, and the Orthodox keep a Sunday for him in .

The monks said they saw God's own light: the light that shone from Jesus when he was transfigured on Mount Tabor.

The say his face and clothes shone in front of three friends. Christians call it the Transfiguration: Metamorfosi in Greek, Preobrazhenie in Russian.

In Constantinople, Church councils backed Palamas.

His key point was a line between two things. What God is in himself can never be known or shared.

The Orthodox call that his essence. But God at work, reaching out to us, can truly be shared.

They call that his energies: God in action.

So we really touch God himself, not a stand-in.

Grace is God's free gift to us.

The Orthodox worry is that Western teachers, meaning Catholic ones, call it created: something God makes, not God himself.

If what we receive is only something created, do we ever really meet God?

The worry has history. In 1910 a Catholic reference book said Palamas's opponents got their arguments from Western teachers.

Its writer brushed off the monks' prayer as people fooling themselves. That was one scholar, not Catholic teaching, but Orthodox readers remember it.

Part 3 · The Catechism teaches it

So what does the Catholic Church actually teach? Open its , its summary of its beliefs, and you'll find theosis in black and white.

Christians believe that God the Son became one of us: Jesus.

The Catechism quotes St of Alexandria, a hero of the East.

He wrote: For the Son of God became man so that we might become God.

Right after it comes the West's best-known teacher, , a Catholic priest of about 750 years ago:

The only-begotten Son of God, wanting to make us sharers in his divinity, assumed our nature, so that he, made man, might make men gods.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 460 (quoting St Thomas Aquinas)

Only-begotten means God's one and only Son. Assumed our nature means he became fully human, so that we could share what's his.

Remember, make men gods doesn't mean becoming second Gods. It means sharing God's life as a gift.

The Catechism describes the same way: Grace is a participation in the life of God.

It even calls it deifying grace: grace that makes us like God.

And above all, it says, grace is first and foremost the gift of the Spirit. The is God himself, at work in us.

So in Catholic teaching, grace is God giving himself first. The healing it brings in us comes after.

Part 4 · What created grace means

Then why does the West say created? Aquinas said grace can mean two things.

It can mean God's love itself. Or it can mean the gift that love leaves in us.

He calls that gift created because it makes us new.

It names the change God makes in us, not a substitute for God.

Aquinas even calls grace a sharing in God's nature. He quotes the same verse as the Orthodox: share in the divine nature.

Many now read this as theosis in Latin words. The Catechism agrees: grace is a lasting gift that changes the soul itself.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a hot summer afternoon.

You're walking to the bus stop, and the sun is beating down on your arms.

You could never touch the sun itself. It's millions of kilometres away, and it would burn you up.

But the heat on your skin isn't a picture of the sun, or a copy of it. It really is the sun, reaching you.

And that heat leaves a mark. By evening you've got a tan.

The sun has gone down, but the tan is still there. Something in you has changed.

Palamas is talking about the sunlight. The Western phrase created grace is talking about the tan.

One is God himself reaching you. The other is what his touch leaves behind. Both are true at once.

Part 5 · Where the real question is

To be honest, a real disagreement is left, and it's about God himself.

Western thinkers have long held that God is simple. He isn't built out of pieces, the way a bike or a body is.

Whatever is in God simply is God. The only real distinction in him, they said, is between the three Persons: Father, Son and Spirit.

So they feared Palamas's line would cut God in two: one part you can reach, and one you can't.

Palamas replied that it no more divides God than the three Persons do.

There's a second sticking point. The Catechism says the saints in see the divine essence, God's very being, face to face.

For Palamas, God's essence is never seen, even in heaven. Catholics answer that seeing God isn't the same as taking in all of him.

That question is still open: theologians on both sides still argue whether God's simplicity and Palamas's energies can be fully squared.

But both sides agree on what matters most: we truly share God's life.

The Catechism doesn't mention Palamas, for or against.

But the , which worship the Eastern way and are united with the , keep his Sunday in Lent, as the Orthodox do.

Part 6 · Respect, not rejection

Since that 1910 reference book, the tone has changed completely.

In the 1960s the , a Catholic , honoured the East on exactly this point.

The Council spoke of the . There, it said, they:

enter into communion with the most holy Trinity, being made "sharers of the divine nature"
Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 15

And the Council said East and West sometimes describe a mystery in different words that complete each other, rather than clash.

In 1995 , the bishop of Rome and leader of the Catholic Church, wrote to the whole Church about the Christian East.

Divinization is another word for theosis. On being made like God, he said:

This theology of divinization remains one of the achievements particularly dear to Eastern Christian thought.
John Paul II, Orientale Lumen (1995), 6

So Rome doesn't reject theosis. Its own Catechism teaches it.

What's left is a real but narrower argument about how to talk about God, and it's one Catholics and Orthodox can have side by side.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 11
  1. 2 Peter 1 (New American Bible, USCCB) · "Share in the divine nature" (1:4).
  2. OrthodoxWiki, Gregory Palamas · His life, the hesychast controversy and the synods of 1341, 1347 and 1351.
  3. Jesse Dominick, "St. Gregory Palamas: Traditionalist or Innovator?", OrthoChristian.com · An Orthodox account of essence and energies and Palamas's arguments.
  4. Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), "Hesychasm" by Adrian Fortescue · The older, dismissive Catholic view; Barlaam's use of Aquinas.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 460 · "The Son of God became man so that we might become God" (Athanasius, Aquinas).
  6. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1996–2003 · Grace as participation in God's life, "deifying grace", the gift of the Spirit.
  7. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 110 (New Advent) · Grace as God's love and as gift; "created" explained; participation in the divine nature.
  8. Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 15, 17 · Eastern Christians made "sharers of the divine nature"; complementary formulations.
  9. John Paul II, Orientale Lumen (2 May 1995), 6 · Divinization as "particularly dear to Eastern Christian thought".
  10. Russian Wikipedia, Преображение Господне (Preobrazhenie Gospodne, the Transfiguration) · The Russian name of the feast; Mount Tabor (Favor) and the hesychast dispute.
  11. Greek Wikipedia, Μεταμόρφωση του Σωτήρος (Metamorfosi tou Sotiros, the Transfiguration) · The Greek name of the feast.