Full text
Another faith · About 6 min ·  · Family and ancestors

My child wants to become Catholic. Can they be baptised without our permission?

The short answer

Not while they're a child. The Catholic Church's own rules say parents must give permission, and church law keeps children under their parents' authority until 18. After that the choice is theirs, and the Church still asks them to honour you.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · Not without you

This can be one of the hardest moments for a family. A teenager says they want to be .

That's the rite where someone is washed with water as they become a Christian.

Parents can hear it as rejection. And underneath is often a fear: will the church go behind our backs?

That fear isn't silly. In the past, children were sometimes baptised without their parents knowing.

For a child, the way to baptism goes through the parents, not around them.

The Catholic Church has an official guide for bringing older children into the faith.

It says the parents' permission is required.

Church law backs that up. You come of age at 18, and from 7 a child is treated as old enough to reason.

But until 18, a child stays under their parents' authority, apart from a few exceptions the law spells out.

Church law doesn't name an age when a teenager stops needing a parent's yes for baptism.

So the guide's rule is the one that applies.

For babies the rule is stricter. A baby may be baptised only if at least one parent, or whoever legally takes their place, agrees.

The one exception is a baby in danger of death, who may be baptised even against the parents' wishes.

Why that one exception? Catholics believe baptism is God's gift, and a baby can receive a gift.

God gave baptism as the normal way in. The Church hopes in God's mercy for babies who die without it.

But baptism is the one way it knows for sure. So the Church won't hold baptism back from a dying baby.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a 15-year-old who dreams of studying abroad.

She reads about universities late at night. She saves her birthday money, and messages older students to ask what it's really like.

None of that needs anyone's permission. The dream is real, and it's hers.

But she can't sign the forms, buy a ticket and fly off on her own at 15. Her parents have to say yes.

At 18 or 21, the choice becomes hers.

And a good daughter still sits her parents down, explains why it matters so much, and asks for their blessing before she books the flight.

The Catholic Church treats a child's faith the same way.

The interest is real and can grow now. The step itself waits.

And when the time comes, baptism isn't a quick ceremony after one class.

A child old enough to reason is prepared the way an adult is, but at a child's pace, with the parents involved.

In practice that means lessons in the faith, often alongside other children the same age, and a few steps marked in church along the way.

It can take several years if needed. Parents are meant to be there at the first public step, or to show they've agreed.

There's another check. For anyone 14 or older, the parish passes the baptism to the , the leader of the area's Catholics.

He can baptise them himself if he thinks it right. So it isn't left to one parish alone.

Part 2 · If you say not yet

If you say not yet, your child can still pray, read, ask questions and come to , the Catholic Sunday service.

None of that needs anyone's signature.

And Catholics believe waiting doesn't put your child at risk. The , the Church's summary of its beliefs, explains why.

It says the wish to be baptised, with real sorrow for and with love, already brings the fruits of Baptism.

Those fruits are the good that Baptism does.

A sincere child who waits isn't shut out from God.

The Catechism asks respect from the child too. While living at home, a child should obey their parents in what is for their good.

Respect for parents never ends, even after obedience does.

There's one limit. If a child is convinced in conscience that an order is morally wrong, they must not obey it.

But being asked to wait isn't wrong. Your child can say I believe and still say I'll wait for you.

One word for the young person reading this. If you're ever afraid of being hurt at home, for any reason, your safety comes first.

It comes before any question of religion. Tell a teacher or another adult you trust, or find a helpline at findahelpline.com.

If you're in danger now, call your local emergency number.

Part 3 · Where the Church went wrong

Now the dark part, because it explains that fear of the church going behind your back.

In 1858 the , the leader of the Catholic Church, still ruled part of Italy like a king, with his own police.

The pope's police took a 6-year-old Jewish boy, Edgardo Mortara, from his family.

A servant said she had secretly baptised him when he was a sick baby she thought was dying.

Church officials ruled that this made him Catholic for good.

And the law there didn't let a Christian child be raised by people of another faith.

Pope Pius IX refused his parents' pleas to give him back.

Edgardo grew up under the pope's care and became a priest.

Edgardo's parents never had their little boy home again. It was a deep wrong done to a family.

The outrage across Europe helped end the pope's rule over that land.

To be honest, some Catholic writers have defended the pope's decision even in this century.

And we found no official Church apology for the Mortara case.

When Pius IX was beatified in 2000, Jewish commentators raised the case again and questioned his legacy.

But the Catholic Church's own teaching today points the other way.

In 1965 the world's Catholic bishops met at the .

They declared that no one is to be forced to act in a manner contrary to his own beliefs.

That cuts both ways. Nobody may push a child into a faith, and nobody may force a faith out of them.

And the said this about parents:

Parents, moreover, have the right to determine, in accordance with their own religious beliefs, the kind of religious education that their children are to receive.
Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (1965), 5

So here's where things stand. A baby in danger of death may still be baptised against the parents' wishes.

The Mortaras' servant believed that's what she was doing.

But under the Church's teaching today, taking a child from his parents to raise him in another faith would be a wrong against them.

That's because their right to bring up their own child is spelled out.

In plain words: under the Church's teaching today, a baptism like the servant's gives no one the right to take a child from his parents.

Part 4 · Listening both ways

The Catechism asks something of parents too. It says family ties are important but not absolute.

As a child grows up, parents should respect the calling God gives their child.

So for a child, the Catholic answer is: not without you. Its rules today don't let anyone go behind your back.

They ask your child to wait for you, and they ask you to listen to your child.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 8
  1. Mortara case (Wikipedia, drawing mainly on David Kertzer's 1997 study) · The 1858 seizure of Edgardo Mortara after a secret baptism, Pius IX's refusal, the fallout, and later defenders.
  2. Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults (ICEL English, Liturgy Office of England and Wales), 242–250 · Children of catechetical age come with their parents' permission; preparation over several years; parents' consent at the first rite.
  3. Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 97–98 · Majority at 18, use of reason presumed at 7, minors under their parents' authority.
  4. Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 851–868 · Adult rules apply from the age of reason (852); 14-plus referred to the bishop (863); infants need a parent's consent (868).
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1257–1261 · The desire for baptism brings its fruits when the sacrament can't yet be received.
  6. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2214–2220 · Children's duties to parents: obedience while at home, respect always, conscience as the limit.
  7. Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 2 and 5 · No coercion in religion; parents' right to decide their children's religious education.
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2232–2233 · Family ties are important but not absolute; parents respect their child's calling.