Are Catholics even Christians?
Yes. Catholics believe Jesus is God's Son, who died for our sins and rose again. They say the same ancient creeds as many Protestant churches, and share the same baptism. In some places Christian is used to mean Protestant, but that's a habit of speech, not a line the Bible draws.
Part 1 · The worry
Are you Christian or Catholic? In some places it's an everyday question, at school, at work, at family gatherings.
It can sound like a real choice. But most of the world counts Catholics as Christians.
Behind the question there's usually a real worry, and it deserves a real answer.
Catholics, the and Protestants are the three main branches of Christianity.
For many evangelicals, a Christian is someone who has personally trusted Jesus, not just someone born into a church.
Many also fear that Catholics lean on their good works, or on Mary and the saints, instead of on Jesus alone.
The saints are holy Christians who have died, and who Catholics believe are with God.
That's a fair thing to ask of anyone who calls themselves a Christian.
Part 2 · The same Jesus, the same creeds
Every Sunday, Catholics stand up and say the same creeds as many churches.
A creed is a short summary of the faith, from the first Christian centuries.
In them, Catholics say out loud that Jesus is God's Son, who died for our and rose again.
The Nicene Creed, written in the 300s, is still said by Catholics, the Orthodox and many Protestants.
Churches that never say a creed aloud still mostly believe what's in it.
Here's an analogy that might help. Imagine you meet someone at a party and ask her: Are you European or Italian?
She gives you a funny look. She was born in Rome, and her passport says European Union on the cover and Italy underneath.
She votes in European elections. And when the World Cup is on, she's in a blue shirt, screaming at the TV for Italy.
So which is she? She's both, obviously.
The question only sounds like a real choice because it puts two different kinds of name side by side.
One is the name of the whole family. The other is the name of one branch of it.
That's what happens with Christian or Catholic? Christian is the family name. Catholic is one branch, like Baptist or Orthodox or Methodist.
You can argue about which branch has things right. But you can't argue someone out of the family by changing the label.
Part 3 · The sharpest disagreement
The branches do disagree about important things. The sharpest one is how a person is put right with God.
The Reformers began the Protestant churches in the 1500s.
They said we're put right with God by his , received through faith.
It's not earned by our good works. And many Protestants think Catholics teach the opposite.
But look at the , the Catholic ' reply to the Reformers in the 1500s.
It condemned anyone who says you can be put right with God by his own works, without God's help through Jesus.
To be fair, Trent also condemned faith alone, when it means that nothing else is needed: no love, no turning from sin.
Many Protestants would answer that real faith always comes with those things.
What Trent meant by that has its own answer.
And in 1999 Catholics and Lutherans said together that we're accepted by God by grace alone, while admitting some questions are still open.
Later, the world bodies of Methodists, Anglicans and Reformed churches signed up to that statement too.
Baptist and Pentecostal churches, like most evangelical churches, haven't signed it. Many evangelicals still doubt what Catholics teach on this.
So between the churches that signed it, the argument is no longer over whether is a free gift.
It's over how that gift reaches a person.
Part 4 · Faith and baptism
The Catholic Church teaches that faith in and are what make someone a Christian. And it says this about Protestants without hedging.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says baptised Protestants have a right to be called Christians.
And Catholics accept them as brothers in the Lord.
Why baptism? Because that's how the talks about it.
wrote this to one church:
all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ
It doesn't make baptism a box to tick, though. Catholics agree that faith has to become your own.
Baptism is the start, not the finish. The Catechism says that for everyone baptised, babies included, faith must grow after Baptism.
And the Catholic Church acts on what it teaches. A baptised Protestant who becomes Catholic isn't baptised again, because baptism cannot be repeated.
The Catechism calls baptism the bond of unity between all Christians.
The , a meeting of all the world's Catholic bishops in the 1960s, went further.
Of the split at the Reformation, it said that often enough, men of both sides were to blame.
And people born into Protestant churches can't be blamed for the split at all.
The Council also said the Bible, grace and faith, hope and charity are found outside the Catholic Church too.
All these gifts, the Catechism says, come from Christ and lead to him.
Part 5 · The part that's hard to hear
To be honest, there's another side to Catholic teaching, and it's where the family picture only goes so far.
The Catholic Church believes the one Church Jesus founded is found in its fullness in the Catholic Church, not in every branch alike.
In 2000 a Vatican document looked at communities that haven't kept bishops in an unbroken line from the .
Without that, and without the full reality of , it said they are not Churches in the proper sense.
Being told you're a Christian but your church is missing something can hurt. That's a fair thing to feel.
But the same sentence goes on. People baptised in those communities are, by Baptism, incorporated in Christ: joined to him.
It's a claim about what a church has, not about whether its people belong to Jesus.
And the Council said the Spirit of Christ uses those communities as means of salvation: ways he brings people home to God.
Part 6 · It goes both ways
Plenty of Catholics say I'm not Christian, I'm Catholic too, and it helps no one.
One Methodist church worker who grew up Catholic asked Protestants to talk with Catholics as fellow travellers on the same road.
Catholics can do the same. Most Christians already share far more than the labels suggest.
So are Catholics Christians? Yes. Catholics are Christians, Protestants are Christians, and the argument between them is an argument inside one family.
A Catholic friend is asked: *Are you Christian or Catholic?* What's the most accurate answer?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 12
- André De Winne, “An underlying intolerance”, Methodist Message, The Methodist Church in Singapore (28 July 2013) · A Wesley Methodist pastor on Singapore's habit of using “Christian” to mean Protestant.
- GotQuestions.org, “I am a Catholic. Why should I consider becoming a Christian?” · An evangelical site's case for distinguishing Catholics from Christians, and its note that Catholics say it too.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 194–195 · The Apostles' Creed and the Nicene Creed, common to the great Churches of East and West.
- Council of Trent, Session 6 (1547), Decree on Justification, canon 1 · Condemns the idea that anyone is justified by their own works without God's grace.
- Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church, Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999), 15, 43 · The shared confession of salvation by grace, and the questions still open.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (6 August 2000), 17 · “Subsists in”, “not Churches in the proper sense”, and the baptised as incorporated in Christ.
- Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (21 November 1964), 3 · Both sides to blame for the split; the baptised “have a right to be called Christian”.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 816–819 · The one Church of Christ, and other Christians accepted as brothers and sisters.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1253–1254 · Baptism is the sacrament of faith; for all the baptised, children or adults, faith must grow after Baptism.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1271–1272 · Baptism as the foundation of communion among all Christians; it cannot be repeated.
- Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, "Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification: 20th anniversary edition" (4 November 2020) · The 1999 declaration later affirmed by the World Methodist Council (2006), the Anglican Consultative Council (2016) and the World Communion of Reformed Churches (2017): five partners in all.
- Pew Research Center, "U.S. Protestants are not defined by Reformation-era controversies 500 years later" (31 August 2017) · About two-thirds of white evangelicals say faith alone is the key to salvation, the point of the old dispute with Catholic teaching.