Part XIV · Chapter 34
The saints timeline

Did the Church Jesus founded carry on in the open, century after century? Or did it grow so corrupt that it had to be rescued, or even go into hiding?

11 scenes · about 29 min read

The short answer

It carried on in the open. Every century since the has named Christians on record: , slaves, monks, a peasant girl who led an army, a Milan schoolboy.

They lived in public, in one visible Church the Catholic Church says is still here.

Most Protestants agree the Church never vanished. The Lutherans' of 1530 says 'one holy Church is to continue forever'. Their case is that the visible Church carried on but grew corrupt, and needed the Reformation to bring back the gospel.

So the real test for the saints is this: was the Church reformed from inside, or did it need rescuing from outside?

Some go further. Calvin, a Reformation leader, said the Church can at times have no visible form. The Trail of Blood, a 1931 booklet by J. M. Carroll, a Landmark Baptist, traces the true Church through hidden, persecuted groups instead.

The documents show no gap. Around 96 Rome's church wrote that the apostles arranged for successors. Late in the 100s , bishop of Lyon in Gaul, listed Rome's bishops by name.

The record isn't clean. Saints preached crusades and helped burn heretics, and a Church court sent Joan of Arc to the stake.

Nor does it settle which Church is the true one: the claim the same first thousand years. It does rule out a vanished Church.

Follow the trail

Eleven saints from twenty centuries, each set in the middle of the big events of their own time.

AD 64–68Historical2 min read

Nero blames the Christians for Rome's fire

Peter, in Nero's Rome

In July 64 a fire swept through Rome, and the emperor Nero blamed the Christians. , the fisherman Jesus had made leader of his apostles, was put to death in Rome in the years that followed.

An old bearded man nailed to a wooden cross while three labourers haul it upright with him head downwards.
The Crucifixion of Saint Peter, Caravaggio, about 1600. The story that Peter was crucified head downwards is first told around AD 200.
IWhat was going on

Peter was a fisherman from Galilee, in what is now northern Israel. Jesus renamed him Kephas, Aramaic for rock.

He became the leader of the twelve apostles, the men Jesus chose and sent out to spread his message.

By the 60s there was already a church in Rome, made up of Jewish and non-Jewish believers. To most Romans they were a strange new group from the east. They would not honour the gods that Romans believed kept the city safe.

IIWhat was at stake

In July 64 a great fire burned through much of Rome. Prayers and offerings to the gods did not stop a rumour that the fire had been started on someone's order.

, a Roman historian writing about fifty years later, says Nero needed the blame to land elsewhere. He chose the Christians, a group few Romans would stand up for.

IIIWhat happened

The Roman historian Tacitus had no love for Christians. Even so, he says a great many were convicted.

Some were sewn into animal skins and torn apart by dogs. Some were nailed to crosses. Some were burned to light Nero's gardens after dark.

He adds that the cruelty was so plain that even Romans began to pity them.

Peter died in Rome in the years between the fire and Nero's own death in 68. The does not say how or where he died. Later writers say he was .

IVWhat came of it

The church of Rome did not scatter. Around 96 it wrote a long letter to the church at Corinth, in Greece, to settle a quarrel there.

The letter named Peter and the apostle as its own recent : Christians killed for refusing to give up their faith.

By about the 160s Christians had marked a grave on the Vatican hill with a small shrine. Digging that began in 1939 found it directly below the high altar of St Peter's Basilica.

VRead the source
Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labours; and when he had at length suffered martyrdom, departed to the place of glory due to him.
First Epistle to the Corinthians · 1 Clement 5 (tr. John Keith, Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 9)

Why it matters

Some Christians hold that the true Church went into hiding after the apostles died. Thirty years after Peter's death, his church was writing to other churches under its own name.

Not everyone accepts that Peter reached Rome. In 2009 the scholar Otto Zwierlein argued that he never did.

The case for it rests on the letter of about 96, other early writers and the shrine on the Vatican hill.

c. AD 155–167Historical2 min read

An old bishop refuses to curse Christ

Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna

, bishop of Smyrna in today's Turkey, had been taught by apostles. In the 150s or 160s the crowd in his city shouted for him. In the stadium the Roman governor told him to curse Christ, and he refused.

IWhat was going on

Smyrna is today's İzmir, on the west coast of Turkey. Polycarp was its bishop, the leader of the local church.

Irenaeus, a later bishop who heard him preach as a boy, says apostles had appointed him.

He was a living link to the first Christians. He could still tell what John and others who had seen Jesus had said.

He was also a public figure. He had travelled to Rome to talk with its bishop, Anicetus, about the date of Easter. They disagreed and parted in peace.

IIWhat was at stake

For Romans, religion was a duty to the city. Swearing by the emperor's fortune and offering to the gods showed you were loyal. It also kept the city in the gods' favour.

Christians would not do it, so their neighbours called them atheists: people who put everyone at risk. For a Christian, calling the emperor Lord meant denying the only Lord they worshipped.

IIIWhat happened

After other Christians had been killed in the arena, the crowd shouted for Polycarp. Friends hid him on a farm outside the city. There he prayed day and night for the churches throughout the world.

When the police came, he had food and drink set out for them and asked for an hour to pray.

In the stadium the governor urged him to think of his age and curse Christ. He refused. He was put on a fire, and then stabbed.

IVWhat came of it

His church wrote down exactly how he died and sent the account to other churches. Many count it the oldest surviving account of a martyr's death outside the New Testament.

They gathered his bones and agreed to meet at the place every year on the day he died.

The same letter blames the city's Jews for joining the crowd and gathering wood for the fire. It is one side's account, written in grief.

VRead the source
Eighty and six years have I served Him, and He never did me any injury: how then can I blaspheme my King and my Saviour?
The Martyrdom of Polycarp (Letter of the Church of Smyrna) · Martyrdom of Polycarp 9 (Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1)

Why it matters

Scholars aren't sure of the year he died: around 155, or as late as 167. But there is no doubt about the man. A bishop appointed by apostles was still leading his church, in public, more than a hundred years after Jesus.

Irenaeus, who heard him as a boy, later became bishop of Lyons, in Gaul, today's France. He named the bishops of Rome in order.

Between them, Polycarp and Irenaeus link the apostles to the end of the second century.

AD 356Historical2 min read

Soldiers surround a bishop's church at night

Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria

, bishop of Alexandria in Egypt, was driven from his city at least five times. His crime was defending what the bishops at Nicaea had agreed in 325: that the Son is fully God. In February 356 soldiers surrounded his church during a night service.

IWhat was going on

Around 318 a priest of Alexandria named began teaching that the was not truly God. He said the Son was the first and greatest of God's creatures.

In 325 the emperor Constantine called the bishops to Nicaea, in today's Turkey. A meeting of bishops like this is called a council.

It answered Arius with a creed, a short statement of faith: the Son is of the same substance as the Father. Athanasius was there as his bishop's young secretary.

IIWhat was at stake

Nicaea did not end the argument. Many bishops thought its key word went too far. Later emperors wanted one wording that everyone could sign, to keep the empire at peace.

For Athanasius more was at stake than a word. If Jesus was a creature, Christians had been worshipping someone less than God. He held that only God himself could save human beings, so the point could not be traded away.

IIIWhat happened

He became bishop of Alexandria in 328. He refused to take Arius back into communion, the shared sacraments that mark who belongs to the Church.

His enemies charged him with crimes, including a murder. The man he was said to have killed turned up alive.

On the night of 8 February 356 the general Syrianus surrounded his church with more than five thousand soldiers. Athanasius sat in his bishop's chair and had a psalm read. He slipped away only after his people had gone.

His side was not blameless. A letter on papyrus from a rival group says his supporters beat their monks. The scholar who published it thought some of those charges were true.

IVWhat came of it

He spent six years in hiding, much of it among the monks of the Egyptian desert.

Meanwhile, in 359, bishops meeting at Rimini, in Italy, were pressured into signing a compromise. Before that, Pope Liberius, in exile in Thrace, had signed a weaker creed too.

When the emperor Constantius died, Athanasius came home in 362. He died in his own bed in 373.

In 381 a second council, at Constantinople, confirmed the faith of Nicaea, in the creed still said in churches today.

VRead the source
It was now night, and some of the people were keeping a vigil preparatory to a communion on the morrow, when the General Syrianus suddenly came upon us with more than five thousand soldiers, having arms and drawn swords, bows, spears, and clubs
Defence of his Flight (Apologia de Fuga) · Defence of his Flight 24 (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers II/4)

Why it matters

Calvin, a leader of the Protestant Reformation, pointed to this crisis. He argued that the true Church can survive without any visible form. It is the strongest example for that view.

But the faith did not go underground. It was held by named bishops in exile. They wrote, argued and went back to their churches when the emperor changed.

Even at its worst moment the Church was battered, not invisible.

AD 410–430Historical2 min read

Rome is sacked, and a bishop answers

Augustine, bishop of Hippo

In 410 the Goths, a Germanic people, sacked Rome, and pagans said the Christian God had failed to protect the city. , bishop of Hippo in north Africa, spent thirteen years writing his answer.

IWhat was going on

In August 410 the Goths, led by Alaric, broke into Rome and plundered it. No foreign army had taken the city for about eight hundred years.

Refugees brought the news to north Africa. Many pagans said the old gods had kept Rome safe for centuries, and that the city fell soon after it turned to Christ.

Augustine was born in 354 in today's Algeria. He had been a teacher of public speaking who lived for years outside the Church, until he became a Christian in Milan in 386. By 410 he had been bishop of Hippo for about fifteen years.

IIWhat was at stake

If Christianity was true, why had God let Christian Rome fall? The question unsettled Christians as much as pagans.

It was also a question about the Church itself. If the Church depended on the empire, it would fall with it.

IIIWhat happened

Between 413 and 426 Augustine wrote The City of God, twenty-two books long. He told the history of the world as the story of two cities built by two loves: love of self, and love of God.

No earthly city lasts forever, he argued, Rome included. The Church lives inside history, but it is not tied to any empire.

In 430 the Vandals, another Germanic people, besieged Hippo. Augustine prayed that God would free the city, or make his people brave, or take him. He fell ill in the third month of the siege and died on 28 August.

IVWhat came of it

The Vandals took Hippo and ruled north Africa. In the West the empire itself ended in 476, when the last western emperor was removed from power.

The Church went on. Augustine's books shaped Christian thinking in the West for the next thousand years, Catholic and Protestant alike.

Luther, who began the Protestant Reformation, was a friar in an order named after Augustine. Calvin quoted Augustine often.

VRead the source
either that He may be pleased to free this city which is surrounded by the foe, or if something else seems good in His sight, that He make His servants brave for enduring His will, or at least that He may take me from this world unto Himself.
Life of St. Augustine · Possidius, Life of Augustine 29 (tr. H. T. Weiskotten, 1919)

Why it matters

Empires rose and fell around the Church. Rome fell, and the bishops of north Africa kept preaching, under siege, to the end.

The Church outlived the empire that had first persecuted it and then protected it. That is the opposite of a Church that went into hiding.

AD 590Historical2 min read

Plague in Rome, and an unwilling pope

Gregory the Great, bishop of Rome

Early in 590 flood and plague struck Rome and killed the . The people chose Gregory, once the city's top official and now a monk. He led them through the streets in prayer.

IWhat was going on

By 590 Rome was a shrunken, battered city. Wars between the Goths and the emperor in Constantinople had taken and retaken it. The Lombards, a Germanic people, held much of Italy.

The emperor lived far away, and his governor at Ravenna had few troops to spare. More and more, it was the bishop of Rome who fed and protected the city.

IIWhat was at stake

The Tiber, Rome's river, burst its banks and ruined the Church's stores of grain. Then plague came. In February 590 it killed Pelagius II, the bishop of Rome, whom Catholics call the pope.

Clergy and people chose Gregory. He did not want the job.

He had been prefect of Rome, its highest official, and had given away his wealth to become a monk. He wrote to the emperor begging him not to confirm the choice.

IIIWhat happened

While he waited, Gregory led the city in prayer. For three days, every three hours, choirs walked the streets crying Kyrie eleison, Greek for Lord, have mercy.

A from the church of Tours, in Gaul, was there. He said eighty people fell dead in one hour as they prayed, and Gregory kept urging them on.

The prefect of Rome held back Gregory's letter to the emperor. On 3 September 590 Gregory was made bishop of Rome.

IVWhat came of it

He fed refugees from the Lombard wars with grain from the Church's estates in Sicily. When the Lombards besieged Rome in 593, the siege was lifted, most likely with money from the pope's treasury. He sent monks to preach to the English.

He called himself servant of the servants of God, a title popes still use.

He had hard sides too. The Church he ran held slaves, and he offered Jewish tenants of the Church lower rents if they became Christians.

VRead the source
Every three hours choirs of singers came to the church crying through the streets of the city "Kyrie eleison." Our deacon who was there said that in the space of one hour while the people uttered cries of supplication to the Lord eighty fell to the ground and died. But the bishop did not cease to urge the people not to cease from prayer.
History of the Franks, Book X, chapter 1 · Gregory of Tours, History of the Franks X.1 (tr. Ernest Brehaut, 1916), from his deacon who was in Rome

Why it matters

The Orthodox Church honours him as a saint too, as Gregory Dialogus. He belongs to the first thousand years, which the Catholic and Orthodox Churches share.

In the years when the old empire failed in the West, the Church was not in hiding. It was feeding the city.

AD 754Historical2 min read

A missionary killed at dawn in Frisia

Boniface, missionary and archbishop

Boniface was an English monk who spent his life taking the Christian message to the peoples east of the Rhine. In 754, nearly eighty, he was killed at dawn beside a river in Frisia, in today's Netherlands.

IWhat was going on

In the early 700s much of what is now Germany and the Netherlands still followed the old gods. People offered sacrifices to sacred trees and springs.

Boniface was born Winfrid in Wessex, in England, around 675. He became a monk and a teacher.

The Saxons across the sea were still pagan, and they said the English were of one blood with them. He asked the English to pray for them.

IIWhat was at stake

His first mission, to Frisia in 716, came to nothing. Its pagan king, Radbod, was persecuting Christians, and Winfrid went home.

The question was how a few monks could plant a Church that would last. These peoples had never had one, and the monks had no one to protect them.

IIIWhat happened

In 719 Pope Gregory II sent him to Germany and gave him the name Boniface. In 722 the pope made him a bishop. Boniface swore at Peter's tomb to keep the Catholic faith and the unity of the Church.

At Geismar he cut down a great oak sacred to the god Thor, and built a chapel from its wood.

He set up dioceses, areas each led by a bishop. He founded monasteries too, Fulda above all. He became archbishop of Mainz.

In 754 he went back to Frisia. On 5 June armed men attacked his camp at dawn. He told his men not to fight, and he and his companions were killed.

IVWhat came of it

The raiders broke open his chests hoping for gold. They found books, and threw them into the marsh.

His death was avenged. His biographer tells how a Christian force invaded Frisia days later, killed many and carried off women and children.

The biographer saw God's punishment in it. Boniface's last words had asked for the opposite.

VRead the source
Stop fighting, lads! Give up the battle! For we are taught by the trusty witness of Scripture, that we render not evil for evil
The Life of Saint Boniface · Willibald, Life of Saint Boniface, chapter VIII (tr. George W. Robinson, 1916)

Why it matters

Boniface did not work in secret. He swore loyalty to the bishop of Rome and held public councils. By his own admission, he relied on the protection of the king of the Franks.

That link with rulers kept the mission safe. It also tied the faith to power. Both are part of the record.

AD 1219Historical2 min read

Francis crosses enemy lines to the sultan

Francis of Assisi

In 1219 a crusader army was besieging the port of Damietta, in Egypt. Francis of Assisi, an Italian who had given up everything to live poor, crossed the lines to preach to the Muslim sultan.

IWhat was going on

Francis was the son of a rich cloth merchant in Assisi, Italy. He gave away everything to live poor and preach the Gospel.

In 1209 the pope approved the simple rule, the written way of life, of his brotherhood. Its members became the Franciscan friars: brothers who live poor and preach.

Since 1095 popes had called crusades, armed pilgrimages to the Holy Land, where Jesus had lived. They aimed to win it back or defend it: Muslim armies had conquered it in the 600s. In 1187 the sultan Saladin had retaken Jerusalem.

The next great crusade aimed at Egypt, the heart of the sultan's power. In 1218 it laid siege to the port of Damietta.

IIWhat was at stake

Around Damietta, Christians and Muslims met only as enemies. Francis believed the Gospel was owed to everyone, the sultan included.

He had already tried once to sail to the Muslims, his biographer says, hoping to preach to them or to die a martyr.

IIIWhat happened

Francis crossed to the enemy camp. The sultan's men seized him and beat him, then brought him to the sultan, al-Kamil.

The sultan received him with honour and offered him rich gifts. Francis refused them all.

Thomas of Celano knew Francis and wrote the first account of his life. He says the sultan listened to him very willingly.

IVWhat came of it

Francis neither converted the sultan nor died a martyr, and he went home. Damietta fell to the crusaders in November 1219, and they lost it again in 1221.

Francis died in 1226. Two years later the pope declared him a saint. This is called canonising: the Church declares that someone is certainly with God and offers them as a model.

VRead the source
For he paid him what honour he could and tried to sway his mind toward worldly riches by the offer of many gifts. But when the Soldan saw that he most stoutly held all such things in contempt like dung, he was filled with the utmost amazement and gazed on him as a man unlike almost all men. He was deeply stirred by his words and heard him very willingly.
The Lives of S. Francis of Assisi (First Life, 1228–29) · Thomas of Celano, First Life I, 57 (tr. A. G. Ferrers Howell, 1908)

Why it matters

Francis changed the Church from inside it, not against it. He asked the pope to approve his rule, and his brothers spread across Europe in the open.

Pope Benedict XVI read the meeting at Damietta as a model of dialogue between Christians and Muslims. Others stress that Francis went to convert the sultan, not to make peace. The sources support both readings.

AD 1431Historical2 min read

A Church court condemns Joan of Arc

Joan of Arc

Joan of Arc was a French peasant girl who led an army at seventeen. In 1431, two years later, a Church court at Rouen condemned her as a heretic, and she was burned at the stake.

A pen sketch in the margin of a handwritten page: a young woman with long hair holding a banner and a sword.
Joan of Arc, sketched in 1429, while she was alive, in the margin of the register of the Parliament of Paris by its clerk, Clément de Fauquembergue. French National Archives.
IWhat was going on

England and France had been at war, on and off, since 1337: the Hundred Years' War. By 1429 the English and their allies from Burgundy held Paris and much of the north. The French heir, Charles, had not been crowned.

Joan was born around 1412 in Domremy, a farming village. She never learned to read.

From the age of thirteen she said she heard the voices of saints, telling her to go to the help of France.

IIWhat was at stake

Was a girl who claimed voices from God a saint, a fraud, or something worse? Theologians, experts in Christian teaching, examined her for the French king. They found nothing evil in her.

For the English side the answer mattered politically. A Church court that found her a heretic, someone who rejects the Church's teaching, would also stain the king she had helped to crown.

IIIWhat happened

In 1429 she helped lift the siege of Orléans. She stood beside Charles when he was crowned at Reims. In 1430 she was captured at Compiègne and sold to the English.

At Rouen in 1431 a Church court tried her. The judges were Bishop Pierre Cauchon and a deputy of the Inquisition, the Church's court for heresy. Theologians of the University of Paris advised them.

She had no lawyer, and English soldiers held her in chains.

Afraid of the fire, she signed a statement taking back her claims, then withdrew it. On 30 May 1431 she was burned in the market square at Rouen, calling out the name of Jesus.

IVWhat came of it

Charles VII, the king she had crowned, did nothing to save her.

About twenty-five years later a new trial opened under Pope Calixtus III. On 7 July 1456 it declared her sentence null and void.

She was declared a saint in 1920. In 2000, on its Day of Pardon, the Catholic Church confessed that its members had used methods not in keeping with the Gospel in the service of the truth.

VRead the source
About Jesus Christ and the Church, I simply know they're just one thing, and we shouldn't complicate the matter.
Catechism of the Catholic Church (English, 2nd edition) · Catechism of the Catholic Church 795, quoting her answer to her judges (1431)

Why it matters

This is the Church at its worst, and it happened in public. A saint was condemned by a Church court, and the same Church later reversed the verdict and honoured her.

At her trial the judges asked her about the Church. She said Jesus and the Church were one thing. She said it to the men who were about to send her to her death.

AD 1535Historical2 min read

A former chancellor refuses the king's oath

Thomas More, former Lord Chancellor of England

Thomas More had been Henry VIII's chief minister in England. He would not accept the king as head of the Church in England, and on 6 July 1535 he was beheaded in London.

IWhat was going on

Henry VIII, king of England, wanted his marriage to Catherine of Aragon declared invalid: never a true marriage. She had given him a daughter but no son who lived, and he wanted to marry Anne Boleyn. The pope would not grant it.

So Henry broke with Rome. Parliament named him Supreme Head of the Church in England, and leading subjects were made to swear an oath.

Refusing to accept the king's new title became treason.

IIWhat was at stake

More had been Lord Chancellor, the king's chief minister and highest judge. He resigned in 1532 when the clergy gave in to the king.

He would swear to Anne's children as heirs to the throne. But the oath's words also rejected any authority over the Church from outside England.

For him, one kingdom could not cut itself off from the faith of the whole Church. So he would not swear.

IIIWhat happened

In April 1534 he refused the oath and was sent to the Tower of London. He stayed there more than a year, often ill. His daughter Margaret prayed with him when she was allowed in.

On 1 July 1535 he was tried in Westminster Hall. Richard Rich, the king's Solicitor General, a senior government lawyer, swore that More had denied the king's supremacy.

Two men who had been in the room said they heard nothing. The jury found him guilty. Only then did More say what he thought.

IVWhat came of it

He was beheaded on Tower Hill on 6 July. He asked the crowd to bear witness that he died in and for the faith of the Catholic Church.

His friend John Fisher, bishop of Rochester, had been executed two weeks earlier for the same refusal. Both were declared saints in 1935.

The Church of England keeps them in its calendar of saints' days too, as Reformation martyrs.

VRead the source
But if I should speak of those that already be dead, of whom many be now holy saints in heaven, I am very sure it is the far, far greater part of them that all the while they lived thought in this case that way that I now think; and therefore am I not bound, my lord, to conform my conscience to the council of one realm, against the general council of Christendom.
The Life of Sir Thomas More · William Roper, The Life of Sir Thomas More (1905 edition), pp. 92–93

Why it matters

The man who died for his conscience had helped send others to the fire for theirs. As chancellor, More played a major part in the cases of three Protestants burned in 1531 and 1532. He was not ashamed of it.

Both things are true. His last speech also shows what he thought the Church was.

For him it was not one nation's institution. It was the communion of Christians across the ages, with the saints in heaven.

AD 1941Historical2 min read

A priest takes a stranger's place at Auschwitz

Maximilian Kolbe, Franciscan friar

Maximilian Kolbe, a Polish Franciscan friar, was prisoner 16670 at Auschwitz, the Nazi camp in occupied Poland. In 1941 he offered his life in place of a man with a wife and children.

Seen through an iron grille, a small bare cell with a barred window, candles and a plaque on the wall.
Cell 18 in the cellar of Block 11 at Auschwitz, where Maximilian Kolbe and the men condemned with him were left to starve.
IWhat was going on

Kolbe was born in 1894 to a poor family of Polish weavers. He became a Franciscan friar, one of the brothers who follow Francis of Assisi, and a priest.

In 1927 he founded Niepokalanów, a friary near Warsaw with one of the largest printing works in central Europe. He also founded a mission near Nagasaki, in Japan.

Germany invaded Poland in September 1939. At Niepokalanów the friars took in people driven from their homes: about 2,000 Poles and, by one historian's count, about 1,050 Jews.

IIWhat was at stake

In February 1941 the Gestapo, the Nazi secret police, arrested him. In May he was sent to Auschwitz, which at the time held mainly Polish political prisoners.

If a prisoner escaped, the camp punished others in his place, so that every prisoner would fear for the rest. Ten men chosen for the starvation cell would die slowly, over many days.

IIIWhat happened

At the end of July 1941 a prisoner was missing from Kolbe's block. The camp leader, Karl Fritzsch, picked ten men to starve to death.

One of them, Franciszek Gajowniczek, cried out for his wife and children. Kolbe stepped out of the ranks, which broke the camp rules, and asked to take his place. The two men had never spoken.

In the starvation cell he led prayers and hymns as the men died one by one. On 14 August, still alive, he was killed with an injection of phenol, a poison.

IVWhat came of it

Gajowniczek survived the war. His two sons did not; both were killed in January 1945.

In 1971 Kolbe was beatified, the last step before being declared a saint. In 1982 he was declared a saint. Gajowniczek, who lived until 1995, was in Rome for both.

Kolbe's own writings contain phrases hostile to Jews that were common in Catholic Poland between the wars. Critics raised them when he was declared a saint. His defenders point out that he also told his editors not to stir up hatred of Jews.

VRead the source
Upon hearing his fellow inmate, Francis Gajowniczek, cry out, “My wife! My children!” Maximilian approached Fritsch and requested that his life be accepted as a substitute. His simple explanation, reported by witnesses: “I am a Catholic priest.
St. Maximilian Kolbe and the War Against Indifference · Church Life Journal (University of Notre Dame), quoting witnesses gathered by Patricia Treece

Why it matters

Nineteen centuries after Peter, the pattern is the same: a named Christian, in public, giving his life where everyone could see.

He did not die defending a creed before an emperor. He died for a stranger. His only explanation, witnesses said, was that he was a Catholic priest.

AD 2006Historical2 min read

A Milan schoolboy who built websites

Carlo Acutis, a schoolboy from Milan

Carlo Acutis was a Milan schoolboy who was good with computers and went to every day. He died of leukaemia, a blood cancer, at fifteen in 2006. He was declared a saint in 2025.

Pale carved stone with a sunburst around the letters IHS beneath a small cross.
The tomb of Carlo Acutis in Assisi, carved with the monogram of the name of Jesus.
IWhat was going on

Carlo was born in London in 1991 to Italian parents and grew up in Milan. His family was not especially religious: his mother had been to Mass only three times in her life.

He loved football, video games and Nutella. After his first Communion he went to Mass every day.

Mass is the Catholic service in which bread and wine are offered and shared as Christ's body and blood.

IIWhat was at stake

He could not understand why football stadiums were full and churches were empty. He wanted people to see what the , the bread and wine of the Mass, meant to him.

IIIWhat happened

He taught himself to write programs. From the age of eleven he researched the Eucharistic miracles recorded through history. These are accounts of the bread of the Mass said to have bled or changed.

He turned them into a website and an exhibition.

In October 2006 what his doctor took for flu turned out to be the most aggressive form of leukaemia. He offered his suffering for the pope and for the Church. He died on 12 October, aged fifteen.

IVWhat came of it

His exhibition has been shown in more than ten thousand parishes. Pope Leo XIV declared him a saint on 7 September 2025, together with Pier Giorgio Frassati.

Most of what we know of his life comes from his mother and the association that pushed for him to be made a saint.

Some of the medieval stories in his exhibition were once used to accuse Jews. The exhibition's panels leave that out.

VRead the source
I offer to the Lord the sufferings that I will have to undergo for the Pope and for the Church, so as not to have to be in Purgatory and be able to go directly to heaven.
Carlo Acutis: Millennial generation has a Blessed · Vatican News, 10 October 2020

Why it matters

The last saint on this trail was born in 1991. The line of named, public Christians that starts with Peter in Nero's Rome runs into our own day.

It is the same visible Church, with the same sacraments and the same creed. It has the same mix of saints and sinners.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church teaches that the Church founded cannot disappear. Its , the official summary of its teaching, calls the Church indestructible.

It points to Christ's promise to Peter in Matthew's (16:18), that the powers of death would not overcome his Church. It says Christ governs the Church through the successors of the apostles.

So for Catholics a Church that vanished is not just unproven: it would mean the promise failed.

The saints are that promise made visible. The Catechism calls them the source of renewal in the Church's hardest moments.

Some place the vanishing very early, soon after the apostles died. The earliest documents point the other way.

Around 96 the church of Rome wrote to Corinth, in the letter known as 's. It was written while people who had known the apostles were alive, and it says the apostles arranged for successors.

Polycarp was made a bishop by apostles. Irenaeus, who heard him preach, listed Rome's bishops by name.

If the true Church dropped out of sight, the men nearest the apostles did not notice.

J. M. Carroll's line of hidden churches, in The Trail of Blood, is harder to test, because by his account it was hidden.

Where his groups can be checked, they don't fit his picture of independent congregations that answered to no bishop. The Novatianists, a breakaway church of the 200s, set up their own pope. The Donatists, a breakaway church in North Africa, had bishops of their own.

The Cathars, whom Carroll lists among his persecuted churches, taught that there were two creators, one good and one evil.

Carroll also gives no source for his founding event: a in 313 that he says made the emperor Constantine head of the church.

Both sides in that story used violence, and the whole of it should be told. Donatist gangs beat Catholic clergy and threw lime and vinegar in their eyes.

Augustine's side answered with the emperor's laws: fines for the Donatist church and exile for its bishops, though no death penalty.

Later centuries were worse: crusades against heretics, and burnings at the stake. None of that makes the persecuted groups Baptist, and none of it makes the visible Church disappear.

Calvin's sharpest example comes from the Arian crisis, the fourth-century fight over whether the Son is fully God. It deserves a straight answer.

In 359 bishops at Rimini were bullied into signing a compromise. Pope Liberius, in exile in Thrace, signed a semi-Arian creed, a half-way wording, and disowned Athanasius. Still, he stood against the Rimini wording.

But the faith was not hidden away. Named bishops in exile held it. Among them were Athanasius and Hilary, bishop of Poitiers in Gaul.

When the emperor changed, the scholar Jerome says, they went back to their churches. In that crisis the Church was battered and humiliated, but it was never invisible.

That leaves the stronger case: the Church was there, but it went badly wrong. On the corruption, the record agrees. In 955 an eighteen-year-old nobleman became pope as John XII, and in 1376 Catherine of Siena had to beg a pope to come back to Rome.

The Catholic answer is that the cure kept coming from inside, through saints like Francis and Catherine. Protestants reply that reform from inside never fixed the gospel itself. That disagreement is real, and it is about , not about whether the Church was there.

None of this makes the saints an advertisement. Some preached crusades, some helped burn heretics, and Church courts condemned some of the best of them.

The Catechism says the Church is “at once holy and always in need of purification”. It says that in the great separations “men of both sides were to blame”.

What the record shows is one visible Church of sinners, reformed again and again from inside by its own saints.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Most Protestants, and the Landmark Baptists

Most Protestants hold that the Church never vanished. The Westminster Confession of 1647, the Presbyterians' standard, says that 'the purest churches under are subject both to mixture and error'. Yet 'there shall be always a church on earth'.

On this view the visible Church carried on, but grew corrupt, and the Reformation reformed it.

A smaller strand goes further. J. M. Carroll's The Trail of Blood (1931) sets out the Landmark Baptist view. Christ founded independent churches, each running its own affairs, that only people old enough to believe for themselves.

Such churches, it says, have existed in every age, outside the Catholic and Orthodox Churches. Their enemies gave them nicknames: Montanists, Novatianists, Donatists, Paulicians, Albigenses, Waldenses, Anabaptists.

On this reading the Catholic hierarchy, its ranks of bishops, grew out of an alliance with the Roman state under the emperor . It then went on to persecute the true churches.

R. L. Vaughn, a Baptist who holds this view, grants that Carroll calls some groups Baptist that cannot be shown to be. He rests the churches' unbroken life on Christ's promise rather than on historians.

Reformed

Calvin, a leader of the Reformation, opened his main book, the Institutes, with a letter to King Francis of France. It is dated 1536.

In it he argued that the Church “may exist without any apparent form”. Its marks are the pure preaching of God's word and the right use of the , not the see of Rome, the pope's office, and its hierarchy.

He pointed to Elijah, the prophet who thought he was alone when seven thousand had stayed faithful.

He pointed too to Hilary of Poitiers, who in the Arian crisis warned against a love of walls: of church buildings. On this view a continuous line of bishops proves nothing if the gospel itself was buried.

Eastern Orthodox

The Orthodox Church agrees that the Church never disappeared. It adds that the Church cannot be divided: “men may be in it or out of it, but they may not divide it”.

It holds that the full life of the Church is found in the historical Orthodox Church. It names the papacy, the pope's office and claims, as an obstacle to unity.

It honours many saints of the first thousand years, Western as well as Eastern. Among them is Pope , whom it calls Gregory Dialogus.

On this reading the continuity is real, and it runs through the Orthodox Church.

Anglican

The Church of England describes itself as “part of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church”.

Its calendar of saints' days keeps ten of the eleven saints on this trail. They run from Peter and Polycarp to Joan of Arc, whom it calls a visionary, and Maximilian Kolbe.

It keeps Thomas More and John Fisher as Reformation Martyrs. It gives the same title to William Tyndale, whom More argued against in print.

On this reading the saints belong to the whole Church, and continuity does not depend on with Rome.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself8
A witness for every century21 steps

One document for each of the twenty-one centuries, written by or about a Christian of that century.

Some centuries are thick with evidence, and the tenth is thin. Several of these documents show the Catholic Church at its worst.

  1. 1st century: the apostles provide for successors

    c. AD 96

    The church of Rome wrote this letter to Corinth, in Greece, where younger men had thrown out their elders. It says the apostles appointed bishops and their helpers, the deacons. They also arranged for approved men to succeed them.

    It was written while people who had known the apostles were still alive.

    It does not yet clearly separate bishops from presbyters, the elders who led each church. But it already assumes a ministry handed on in order.

    “Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate. For this reason, therefore, inasmuch as they had obtained a perfect fore-knowledge of this, they appointed those [ministers] already mentioned, and afterwards gave instructions, that when these should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry.”
  2. 2nd century: twelve bishops of Rome, by name

    late 2nd century

    Irenaeus of Lyons had heard Polycarp as a boy. Late in the second century some teachers claimed the apostles had passed on hidden mysteries.

    Irenaeus answered by pointing to something public: the bishops of each church, in order. He named Rome's twelve, from Linus to Eleutherius.

    The earliest lists differ in some details. But his argument rests on a succession anyone could check.

    “In this order, and by this succession, the ecclesiastical tradition from the apostles, and the preaching of the truth, have come down to us. And this is most abundant proof that there is one and the same vivifying faith, which has been preserved in the Church from the apostles until now, and handed down in truth.”
    HistoricalAgainst Heresies, book IIIAgainst Heresies III.3.3 (Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 1)The evidence ↓
  3. 3rd century: a bishop quarrels with a pope and stays

    AD 251–258

    Cyprian, bishop of Carthage in North Africa, wrote On the Unity of the Catholic Church in 251. Rival bishops had just split the churches of Rome and Carthage.

    He later clashed with Pope Stephen over rebaptism: whether people baptised outside the Church must be baptised again. He wrote of “the bitter obstinacy of our brother Stephen”, and lost the argument.

    He was beheaded in 258. Rome still names him in the Roman Canon, a central prayer of the Mass.

    “He can no longer have God for his Father, who has not the Church for his mother.”
    HistoricalOn the Unity of the Church (Treatise 1)On the Unity of the Catholic Church 6 (Ante-Nicene Fathers vol. 5)The evidence ↓
  4. 4th century: the whole world groaned

    AD 359

    The fourth century is the hardest for the Catholic case. At Rimini in 359 the Latin bishops were driven by threats to sign a compromise creed.

    Pope Liberius, in exile in Thrace, signed a semi-Arian creed, a half-way wording, and disowned Athanasius. Still, he stood against the Rimini wording.

    Then a new emperor let the exiled bishops go home. Those caught at Rimini protested that they had been deceived.

    Jerome, a scholar who translated the Bible into Latin, described the moment twenty years later.

    “At that moment the term Usia was abolished: the Nicene Faith stood condemned by acclamation. The whole world groaned, and was astonished to find itself Arian”
    HistoricalDialogue against the LuciferiansJerome, Dialogue against the Luciferians 19 (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers II/6)The evidence ↓
  5. 5th century: a deacon’s son at the edge of the world

    5th century

    Raiders carried Patrick, a British boy of about sixteen, to Ireland as a slave. He escaped, and years later went back as a bishop to the people who had enslaved him.

    His Confession is one of two writings of his that survive. It begins with his family: a father who was a deacon and a grandfather who was a priest.

    Catholic and Protestant writers have both claimed him since the seventeenth century.

    “My name is Patrick. I am a sinner, a simple country person, and the least of all believers. I am looked down upon by many. My father was Calpornius. He was a deacon; his father was Potitus, a priest”
    HistoricalConfession (Confessio)Patrick, Confession 1 (tr. Pádraig McCarthy, Royal Irish Academy)The evidence ↓
  6. 6th century: a little rule for beginners

    c. AD 530

    Around 530, at Monte Cassino in Italy, Benedict wrote a short rule for monks: a guide to their daily life.

    It asks them to pray and to work. They are to care for the sick as if they were Christ, and to receive every guest as Christ.

    Almost everything known of his life comes from Pope Gregory the Great, who had it from four of Benedict's disciples.

    Near its end the Rule sums up what it asks.

    “Thus they should anticipate one another in honor; most patiently endure one another’s infirmities, whether of body or of character; vie in paying obedience one to another—no one following what he considers useful for himself, but rather what benefits another—; tender the charity of brotherhood chastely; fear God in love; love their Abbot with a sincere and humble charity; prefer nothing whatever to Christ. And may He bring us all together to life everlasting!”
    HistoricalThe Rule of Saint BenedictRule of Saint Benedict, chapter 72 (tr. Leonard J. Doyle)The evidence ↓
  7. 7th century: two Easters and an appeal to Peter

    AD 664

    In Northumbria, in the north of England, monks trained in the Irish tradition kept Easter on a different date from those trained in the Roman one. At Whitby in 664 the king heard both sides.

    Bishop Colman spoke for the Irish side and appealed to the apostle John and to Columba, the great Irish monk. Wilfrid, for the Roman side, granted that Columba might be “ours also”. He appealed to Peter and to the whole Church.

    The king chose to follow Peter, and Colman went home.

    “The Easter which we keep, we saw celebrated by all at Rome, where the blessed Apostles, Peter and Paul, lived, taught, suffered, and were buried; we saw the same done by all in Italy and in Gaul, when we travelled through those countries for the purpose of study and prayer. We found it observed in Africa, Asia, Egypt, Greece, and all the world, wherever the Church of Christ is spread abroad, among divers nations and tongues, at one and the same time”
    HistoricalEcclesiastical History of the English NationBede, Ecclesiastical History III.25 (tr. Giles, revised Sellar, 1907)The evidence ↓
  8. 8th century: the emperor cannot bind and loose

    c. AD 730

    In 726 the emperor in Constantinople, Leo III, ordered Christians to stop honouring icons, the holy images used in prayer.

    John of Damascus, a monk who had once served the Muslim ruler, the caliph, as treasurer, lived beyond the emperor's reach. He wrote three defences of the images.

    A council called by the emperor condemned them in 754. The Second Council of Nicaea upheld his position in 787.

    At the court of Charlemagne, king of the Franks, theologians objected to a faulty Latin version of that council's decree. They sent their objections to Pope Adrian I.

    “I do not admit an emperor’s tyrannical action in domineering over the Church. The emperor has not received the power to bind and loose. ... I am not to be persuaded that the Church is set in order by imperial edicts, but by patristic traditions, written and unwritten.”
    HistoricalSt. John Damascene on Holy ImagesJohn of Damascus, On Holy Images, second discourse (tr. Mary H. Allies, 1898)The evidence ↓
  9. 9th century: it belongs to St Peter

    AD 870

    Cyril and Methodius, two Greek brothers, made the first alphabet for the Slavs. They translated the Church's worship into Slavonic for Moravia.

    Pope Hadrian II had their books laid on the altar of St Mary Major, a great church in Rome.

    When Methodius came back as archbishop, German bishops said he was working in their dioceses, their areas. A meeting of bishops removed him from office and imprisoned him in 870, until Pope John VIII ordered his release.

    The account of his life records his answer to them.

    “I would not have entered it had I known that it was yours, but it belongs to St. Peter.”
    HistoricalThe Life of Methodius (Slavonic, written shortly after his death), selected chaptersLife of Methodius 9 (tr. Jan Čulík, University of Glasgow, 2010)The evidence ↓
  10. 10th century: the worst popes and the first papal canonisation on record

    AD 955–993

    The tenth century is the thinnest stretch of this list. In 955 an eighteen-year-old nobleman became pope as John XII. The Catholic Encyclopedia, a reference work from the early 1900s, calls him a coarse, immoral man.

    That same year Ulrich, bishop of Augsburg, held his city against the Magyars, raiders from Hungary, until the German king, Otto I, came with his army.

    In 993, twenty years after Ulrich died, a pope did something new.

    “At a Roman synod held in the Lateran on 31 January, 993, Bishop Ulrich of Augsburg was solemnly canonized, an event which the pope announced to the French and German bishops in a Bull dated 3 February. This was the first time that a solemn canonization had been made by a pope.”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1910), 'Pope John XV'Catholic Encyclopedia (1910), Pope John XVThe evidence ↓
  11. 11th century: East and West part

    AD 1054–1098

    In 1054 the pope's envoy laid a document on the altar of Hagia Sophia, the great church of Constantinople. It excommunicated the patriarch, the city's bishop: it cut him off from the sacraments. The patriarch replied in kind.

    The sentences named persons, not churches. But the break hardened over the following centuries.

    By 1098 Greek and Latin bishops were arguing over how the Holy Spirit comes from God. Anselm, the exiled archbishop of Canterbury, spoke for the Latins.

    “In October, 1098, Urban held a council at Bari to deal with the difficulties raised by the Greeks in regard to the procession of the Holy Ghost. Here Anselm was called by the Pope to a place of honour and bidden to take the chief part in the discussion.”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'St. Anselm'Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), St. AnselmThe evidence ↓
  12. 12th century: take the sign of the Cross

    AD 1146

    Bernard, abbot of the monastery of Clairvaux, preached the Second Crusade at Vézelay in 1146. He also wrote to the clergy and people of eastern France to win them over. The crusade failed.

    In the same campaign a monk named Rodolph stirred up massacres of Jews along the Rhine.

    Bernard wrote that “the Jews must not be persecuted, slaughtered, nor even driven out”. He went to Mainz to stop him.

    “If you are a prudent merchant, if you are a desirer of this world: I show you some great bargains, see you lose them not. Take the sign of the Cross, and you shall gain pardon for every sin that you confess with contrite heart.”
    HistoricalLife and Works of Saint Bernard, vol. 2: LettersBernard, letter to the people of eastern France (tr. Samuel J. Eales, 1889)The evidence ↓
  13. 13th century: the material sword

    c. AD 1211

    In southern France the Cathars taught that the material world came from an evil principle. Dominic walked the roads arguing with them.

    Then the pope launched a crusade against them. Dominic followed its army. At the siege of Lavaur in 1211 he was at the side of its leader, Simon de Montfort.

    He also served as a theologian judging whether the accused held heresy. When Lavaur fell in 1211, several hundred Cathars were burned. His first biographer explains why the pope turned to force.

    “This move was taken by Pope Innocent, who decided that, if the rebellious spirit of the heretics could not be tamed by the pious measures of truth or pierced by the sword of the spirit, which is the word of God, then at least they would respect the power of the material sword.”
  14. 14th century: come, come, come

    AD 1376

    The popes had been living at Avignon, in France, instead of Rome. Catherine of Siena, a dyer's daughter who could barely read, dictated letters telling Pope Gregory XI to go back. In June 1376 she went to Avignon herself.

    He reached Rome on 17 January 1377. He went against the wishes of the French king and most of his cardinals, the pope's senior advisers.

    After his death rival popes were elected, and she gave her last strength to Urban VI.

    “I tell you, father in Christ Jesus, come swiftly like a gentle lamb. Respond to the Holy Spirit who calls you. I tell you, Come, come, come, and do not wait for time, since time does not wait for you.”
    HistoricalSaint Catherine of Siena as Seen in Her LettersCatherine of Siena, letter to Gregory XI (tr. Vida D. Scudder, 1905)The evidence ↓
  15. 15th century: the verdict reversed

    AD 1456

    The court that condemned Joan had two Church judges, a bishop and an inquisitor. Theologians of the University of Paris ran it.

    Pope Benedict XVI called her trial “a distressing page in the history of holiness”. He called her judges theologians “who lacked charity”.

    The new trial took evidence from about 120 eyewitnesses. Among them was the priest who had read out her retraction. Its sentence came on 7 July 1456.

    “About 25 years later the Trial of Nullity, which opened under the authority of Pope Calixtus III, ended with a solemn sentence that declared the condemnation null and void”
    HistoricalGeneral Audience: Saint Joan of ArcBenedict XVI, General Audience, 26 January 2011The evidence ↓
  16. 16th century: a sermon from a cross

    AD 1597

    Japan's ruler turned on the missionaries and their converts. Twenty-six Christians, Japanese and European, Jesuit and Franciscan, some of them boys, were paraded through Kyoto.

    On 5 February 1597 they were crucified on a hill at Nagasaki. Japan's rulers feared that Christianity was the first step towards a Spanish conquest, as in the Philippines.

    Paul Miki, a Japanese Jesuit brother, preached from his cross.

    “As I come to this supreme moment of my life, I am sure none of you would suppose I want to deceive you. And so I tell you plainly: there is no way to be saved except the Christian way. My religion teaches me to pardon my enemies and all who have offended me. I do gladly pardon the Emperor and all who have sought my death.”
    HistoricalAn account of the martyrdom of Saint Paul Miki and his companions by a contemporary writer (1597)Contemporary account of 1597, read in the Office of Readings for 6 FebruaryThe evidence ↓
  17. 17th century: a vow no one had made

    AD 1679

    Kateri Tekakwitha was a Mohawk woman, scarred by the smallpox that killed her family. Baptised at twenty, she left her village for a Christian mission on the St Lawrence River. She died there in 1680, aged twenty-four.

    Almost everything known of her comes from two Jesuit priests who heard her confessions. They wrote as missionaries in a time of colonial war.

    In 2012 she became the first Indigenous saint from the United States or Canada.

    “It is a bold, unusual and prophetic gesture: on 25 March 1679, at the age of twenty-three, with the consent of her spiritual director, Kateri takes a vow of perpetual virginity, as far as we know the first time that this was done among the North American Indians.”
    HistoricalHomily at the beatification of five Servants of God (the passage on Kateri Tekakwitha in English)John Paul II, beatification homily, 22 June 1980 (the passage given in English)The evidence ↓
  18. 18th century: a layman shot on a hill

    AD 1752

    Nilakandan was a Hindu official at the court of Travancore, a kingdom in south India. Baptised as Devasahayam in 1745, he ate with people his caste, the rank he was born into, forbade him to eat with.

    He was arrested in 1749 and shot in 1752. The charge was treason. The Catholic Church calls it a false accusation. Descendants of the royal family still say he died for treason, not for his faith.

    A British Resident, Britain's agent at the court, wrote in 1901 that he “is reverenced as a martyr”. In 2022 Pope Francis declared him a saint, the first Indian layman to be one.

    “Today, in Kottar, India, Devasahayam Pillai, has been beatified. He was a faithful layman who lived in the 18th century and died a martyr.”
    HistoricalAngelus, 2 December 2012Benedict XVI, Angelus, 2 December 2012The evidence ↓
  19. 19th century: Catholic and Anglican on one fire

    AD 1886

    At the court of Buganda, north of Lake Victoria, King Mwanga turned on the Christians among his pages, the young men who served him. On 3 June 1886 Charles Lwanga was burned to death at Namugongo.

    His companions, Catholic and Anglican, died on a pyre of reeds. Robert Ashe, an Anglican missionary who was in Buganda, described the pyre three years later.

    Within six years Catholic and Protestant factions there were at war.

    “Then followed the crowning act in the cruel tragedy, when Walukaga and some thirty others met their heroic deaths. A mighty pyre was heaped about the Christian captives. Each was firmly bound, a burning brand was brought, and soon the consuming fire enfolded this company of saints, of whom the world was not worthy”
    HistoricalTwo Kings of Uganda, or Life by the Shores of Victoria NyanzaRobert P. Ashe, Two Kings of Uganda (1889)The evidence ↓
  20. 20th century: stop the repression

    AD 1980

    Óscar Romero became archbishop of San Salvador in 1977, and the landowners and businessmen who had wanted him rejoiced.

    Then his friend Rutilio Grande, a priest, was murdered. After that, his Sunday sermons listed the week's disappearances, tortures and killings.

    On 23 March 1980 he spoke directly to the soldiers. The next day he was shot while saying Mass. A United Nations commission found in 1993 that Roberto D'Aubuisson gave the order. In 2018 Pope Francis declared Romero a saint.

    “In the name of God, then, and in the name of this suffering people, whose laments rise up each day more tumultuously toward heaven, I beg you, I beseech you, I order you in the name of God: stop the repression!”
    HistoricalThe Church Serves Personal, Communal, and Transcendent Liberation: homily of 23 March 1980Óscar Romero, homily of 23 March 1980 (Archbishop Romero Trust translation)The evidence ↓
  21. 21st century: a teenager from our own day

    AD 2025

    On 7 September 2025 Pope Leo XIV declared Carlo Acutis a saint, together with Pier Giorgio Frassati. The ceremony had been set for 27 April and was postponed when Pope Francis died.

    The list that begins with Peter and Polycarp now reaches, for the moment, a boy who built websites in Milan and died in 2006.

    “In this setting, today we look to Saint Pier Giorgio Frassati and Saint Carlo Acutis: a young man from the early 20th century and a teenager from our own day, both in love with Jesus and ready to give everything for him.”
    HistoricalHomily at the canonisation of Pier Giorgio Frassati and Carlo AcutisLeo XIV, canonisation homily, 7 September 2025The evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on12 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Tacitus records that Nero blamed the Christians for the fire of Rome and killed many of them, and Peter’s death is placed between July 64 and 68. About 96 the church of Rome remembered his martyrdom and wrote that the apostles had arranged for approved men to succeed the ministers they appointed. Polycarp, made bishop of Smyrna by apostles, was put to death at Smyrna in the second century; late in that century Irenaeus named twelve bishops of Rome in order; in 251 Cyprian wrote on the unity of the Church and later quarrelled with Pope Stephen without leaving communion.

Rests on
  • Annals 15.44 (Church and Brodribb)
    “Nero fastened the guilt and inflicted the most exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abominations, called Christians by the populace.”
  • General Audience, 4 February 2009 (on the date of Paul’s death)
    “the persecution unleashed by Nero himself after the burning of Rome in July 64 and the last year of his reign, that is, the year 68”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Peter, on the date of his death
    “The date of Peter's death is thus not yet decided; the period between July, 64 (outbreak of the Neronian persecution), and the beginning of 68 (on 9 July Nero fled from Rome and committed suicide) must be left open for the date of his death.”
  • 1 Clement 5
    “Peter, through unrighteous envy, endured not one or two, but numerous labours; and when he had at length suffered martyrdom, departed to the place of glory due to him.”
  • 1 Clement 44
    “Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate. For this reason, therefore, inasmuch as they had obtained a perfect fore-knowledge of this, they appointed those …”
    Read the full passage
    “Our apostles also knew, through our Lord Jesus Christ, that there would be strife on account of the office of the episcopate. For this reason, therefore, inasmuch as they had obtained a perfect fore-knowledge of this, they appointed those [ministers] already mentioned, and afterwards gave instructions, that when these should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed them in their ministry.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Pope St. Clement I, Doctrine
    “Presbyters are mentioned several times, but are not distinguished from bishops”
  • Martyrdom of Polycarp 9
    “Eighty and six years have I served Him, and He never did me any injury: how then can I blaspheme my King and my Saviour?”
  • Against Heresies III.3.4
    “But Polycarp also was not only instructed by apostles, and conversed with many who had seen Christ, but was also, by apostles in Asia, appointed bishop of the Church in Smyrna”
  • Church History V.20, Irenaeus to Florinus
    “For when I was a boy, I saw you in lower Asia with Polycarp”
  • Against Heresies III.3.3
    “In this order, and by this succession, the ecclesiastical tradition from the apostles, and the preaching of the truth, have come down to us. And this is most abundant proof that there is one and the same vivifying faith, which has been preserved in the Church from the apostles until now, and handed down in truth.”
  • On the Unity of the Catholic Church 6
    “He can no longer have God for his Father, who has not the Church for his mother.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Cyprian of Carthage
    “Meantime another message arrived with the news that Novatian, the most eminent among the Roman clergy, had been made pope”
  • Letter 73, to Pompey
    “why has the bitter obstinacy of our brother Stephen broken forth to such an extent”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Canon of the Mass
    “It is noticeable that St. Cyprian (d. 258), who had a serious misunderstanding with a Roman pope, is the only foreigner honoured by the Roman Church by being named among her own martyrs”
  • BMCR 2010.03.25, summary of the thesis
    “argues in this provocative and well documented study that the apostle Peter never visited Rome, did not undergo martyrdom there, was not buried there, and certainly was not the first bishop of Rome”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Pope St. Clement I, Doctrine
    “Harnack in 1897 (Chronol., I) upheld the paradox that the Church of Rome was so conservative as to be governed by presbyters until Anicetus; and that when the list of popes was composed, c. 170, there had been a bishop for less than twenty years; Clement and others in the list were only presbyters of special influence.”
Other readings
  • Otto Zwierlein argues that Peter never came to Rome and that the tradition begins only about 160–170.
  • Harnack held that Rome was governed by a group of presbyters until the time of Anicetus, so that the early names on the list were leading presbyters rather than single bishops.
Limits
  • 1 Clement does not distinguish presbyters from bishops, and the earliest lists of Roman bishops differ in some details.
  • The year of Polycarp’s death is uncertain: 155 on the usual reckoning, 166 on another.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

After the Council of Nicaea (325) declared the Son “of the same substance” as the Father, emperors backed the Arian side. Athanasius was driven from Alexandria at least five times between 336 and 366, and on a night in February 356 soldiers surrounded his church. At Rimini in 359 the Latin bishops were pressured into signing a compromise, and Pope Liberius, in exile, signed a semi-Arian creed and renounced Athanasius, though the Catholic Encyclopedia says he stood against the Rimini formula. Jerome wrote that the whole world groaned to find itself Arian; under a new emperor the exiled bishops returned to their churches.

Rests on
  • General Audience, 20 June 2007
    “the Greek term homooúsios is featured, in Latin consubstantialis: it means that the Son, the Logos, is "of the same substance" as the Father”
  • General Audience, 20 June 2007
    “At least five times - during the 30 years between 336 and 366 A.D. - Athanasius was obliged to abandon his city, spending 17 years in exile and suffering for the faith”
  • Defence of his Flight 24
    “It was now night, and some of the people were keeping a vigil preparatory to a communion on the morrow, when the General Syrianus suddenly came upon us with more than five thousand soldiers, having arms and drawn swords, bows, spears, and clubs”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Arianism
    “It was concerning this last council (359) that St. Jerome wrote, "the whole world groaned and marvelled to find itself Arian". For the Latin bishops were driven by threats and chicanery to sign concessions which at no time represented their genuine views.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Arianism
    “The Pope of the day, Liberius, brave at first, undoubtedly orthodox, but torn from his see and banished to the dreary solitude of Thrace, signed a creed, in tone Semi-Arian (compiled chiefly from one of Sirmium), renounced Athanasius”
  • Dialogue against the Luciferians 19
    “At that moment the term Usia was abolished: the Nicene Faith stood condemned by acclamation. The whole world groaned, and was astonished to find itself Arian”
  • Dialogue against the Luciferians 19
    “all the bishops who had been banished from their sees, by the clemency of the new emperor returned to their Churches.”
Other readings
  • Calvin, following Hilary of Poitiers, reads the crisis as proof that the true Church can survive in a hidden few while the visible hierarchy goes astray.
Limits
  • Most of what survives about the Arian side was written by its opponents; the winning party wrote most of the history.
  • Jerome wrote twenty years after Rimini, as a partisan of the Nicene side.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia does not date Liberius’s signature, and says he made a stand against the Homoean formula of Rimini; his lapse and the Rimini surrender are two events, not one.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Through the collapse of Roman rule in the West, named Christians and a working church order are recorded in every generation. Augustine answered the sack of Rome (410) with The City of God and died during the Vandal siege of Hippo (430). Patrick, a deacon’s son from Roman Britain, returned to Ireland as a bishop. Benedict wrote his Rule around 530. Gregory was chosen bishop of Rome in the plague of 590. At Whitby in 664 a Northumbrian king settled a dispute over the date of Easter by appeal to Peter.

Rests on
  • General Audience, 20 February 2008
    “was written between 413 and 426 in 22 books. The occasion was the sack of Rome by the Goths in 410. Numerous pagans still alive and also many Christians said: Rome has fallen; the Christian God and the Apostles can now no longer protect the city.”
  • General Audience, 16 January 2008
    “In May or June 430, "the destroyers of the Roman Empire", as Possidius described these barbarians (Vita, 30, 1), were surrounding and besieging Hippo.”
  • Life of Augustine 29
    “either that He may be pleased to free this city which is surrounded by the foe, or if something else seems good in His sight, that He make His servants brave for enduring His will, or at least that He may take me from this world unto Himself.”
  • Confession 1
    “My name is Patrick. I am a sinner, a simple country person, and the least of all believers. I am looked down upon by many. My father was Calpornius. He was a deacon; his father was Potitus, a priest”
  • Introduction
    “Both Catholic and Protestant church commentators claimed Patrick as their own in debates current in the seventeenth century, and continued to do so in the century that followed.”
  • Saint of the Day, 11 July
    “Benedict composed his Rule around AD 530.”
  • Rule of Saint Benedict, chapter 72
    “Thus they should anticipate one another in honor; most patiently endure one another’s infirmities, whether of body or of character; vie in paying obedience one to another—no one following what he considers useful for himself, but rather what …”
    Read the full passage
    “Thus they should anticipate one another in honor; most patiently endure one another’s infirmities, whether of body or of character; vie in paying obedience one to another—no one following what he considers useful for himself, but rather what benefits another—; tender the charity of brotherhood chastely; fear God in love; love their Abbot with a sincere and humble charity; prefer nothing whatever to Christ. And may He bring us all together to life everlasting!”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Pope St. Gregory I
    “Then, in February, 590, as if to fill the cup of misery to the brim, Pelagius II died. The choice of a successor lay with the clergy and people of Rome, and without any hesitation they elected Gregory, Abbot of St. Andrew's.”
  • History of the Franks X.1
    “Every three hours choirs of singers came to the church crying through the streets of the city "Kyrie eleison." Our deacon who was there said that in the space of one hour while the people uttered cries of supplication to the Lord eighty fell to the ground and died. But the bishop did not cease to urge the people not to cease from prayer.”
  • Ecclesiastical History III.25
    “The Easter which we keep, we saw celebrated by all at Rome, where the blessed Apostles, Peter and Paul, lived, taught, suffered, and were buried; we saw the same done by all in Italy and in Gaul, when we travelled through those countries for the …”
    Read the full passage
    “The Easter which we keep, we saw celebrated by all at Rome, where the blessed Apostles, Peter and Paul, lived, taught, suffered, and were buried; we saw the same done by all in Italy and in Gaul, when we travelled through those countries for the purpose of study and prayer. We found it observed in Africa, Asia, Egypt, Greece, and all the world, wherever the Church of Christ is spread abroad, among divers nations and tongues, at one and the same time”
  • Ecclesiastical History III.25
    “And if that Columba of yours, (and, I may say, ours also, if he was Christ’s servant,) was a holy man”
  • Ecclesiastical History III.25
    “And I also say unto you, that he is the door-keeper, and I will not gainsay him, but I desire, as far as I know and am able, in all things to obey his laws, lest haply when I come to the gates of the kingdom of Heaven, there should be none to open them, he being my adversary who is proved to have the keys.”
Other readings
  • Some Protestant writers have described an independent “Celtic Church”; at Whitby both sides honoured Columba, and the losing bishop went home rather than out of the faith.
  • Catholic and Protestant writers have both claimed Patrick as their own since the seventeenth century.
Limits
  • Patrick’s dates are uncertain; the sources give both 461 and 493 for his death.
  • Almost everything known of Benedict’s life comes from Gregory the Great’s Dialogues.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The eighth to tenth centuries are thinner but not empty. Boniface swore on Peter’s tomb in 722 to keep the Catholic faith and was killed at Dokkum in 754. John of Damascus defended the images against the emperor’s edict of 726, and the Second Council of Nicaea upheld his position in 787. Methodius, archbishop to the Slavs, was deposed by German bishops at a synod in 870 and freed at the order of Pope John VIII. In 955 an eighteen-year-old became pope as John XII; in 993 Pope John XV canonised Ulrich of Augsburg, the first solemn canonisation by a pope.

Rests on
  • Robinson’s note to chapter VI, the ordination oath
    “promise thee, Saint Peter prince of the apostles, and thy vicar, blessed Pope Gregory, and his successors, by the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, Trinity inseparable, and by this thy most sacred body, to exhibit all faith and purity of the holy Catholic faith”
  • Letter to Bishop Daniel of Winchester
    “the protection of the King of the Franks I can neither rule the people of the Church nor defend the priests and clergy, the monks and nuns of God”
  • General Audience, 11 March 2009
    “While he was beginning the celebration of Mass at Dokkum (in what today is northern Holland) on 5 June 754, he was assaulted by a band of pagans.”
  • Life of Boniface, chapter VIII
    “Stop fighting, lads! Give up the battle! For we are taught by the trusty witness of Scripture, that we render not evil for evil”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. John Damascene
    “In 726, despite the protests of Germanus, Patriarch of Constantinople, Leo the Isaurian issued his first edict against the veneration of images.”
  • On Holy Images (tr. Allies), Second Discourse
    “I do not admit an emperor’s tyrannical action in domineering over the Church. The emperor has not received the power to bind and loose. ... I am not to be persuaded that the Church is set in order by imperial edicts, but by patristic traditions, written and unwritten.”
  • General Audience, 6 May 2009
    “the three Discourses against those who calumniate the Holy Images, which were condemned after his death by the iconoclastic Council of Hieria (754).”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Caroline Books
    “This version was severely criticized by an assembly of Frankish theologians at which Charlemagne assisted. Some (85) obnoxious passages were gathered therefrom and brought to Pope Adrian I by Abbot Angilbert for correction.”
  • General Audience, 17 June 2009
    “The Slavonic Books were laid on the altar of St Mary of Phatmé (St Mary Major) and the liturgy in the Slavonic tongue was celebrated in the Basilicas of St Peter, St Andrew and St Paul.”
  • Life of Methodius 9
    “I would not have entered it had I known that it was yours, but it belongs to St. Peter.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Sts. Cyril and Methodius
    “In 870 King Louis and the German bishops summoned Methodius to a synod at Ratisbon. Here he was deposed and condemned to prison. After three years he was liberated at the command of Pope John VIII and reinstated as Archbishop of Moravia”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Pope John XII
    “Octavius, then eighteen years of age, was actually chosen his successor on 16 December, 955, and took the name of John. The temporal and spiritual authority in Rome were thus again united in one person — a coarse, immoral man, whose life was such …”
    Read the full passage
    “Octavius, then eighteen years of age, was actually chosen his successor on 16 December, 955, and took the name of John. The temporal and spiritual authority in Rome were thus again united in one person — a coarse, immoral man, whose life was such that the Lateran was spoken of as a brothel, and the moral corruption in Rome became the subject of general odium.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Ulric
    “It was due to Ulrich's ability and courage that Augsburg was able to hold out against the besiegers until the Emperor Otto arrived.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Ulric
    “died at Augsburg, 4 July, 973”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, Pope John XV
    “At a Roman synod held in the Lateran on 31 January, 993, Bishop Ulrich of Augsburg was solemnly canonized, an event which the pope announced to the French and German bishops in a Bull dated 3 February. This was the first time that a solemn canonization had been made by a pope.”
Other readings
  • Carroll dates “image worship” to the Second Council of Nicaea (787) and counts it among the departures from the New Testament.
Limits
  • Willibald dates Boniface’s death to 755; Benedict XVI and most modern accounts give 754.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia says Methodius was held three years; the Life of Methodius says two and a half.
  • The tenth century has fewer documented saints than any other in this chapter.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

In 1219, during the crusaders’ siege of Damietta, Francis of Assisi crossed to the enemy camp and was received by the sultan. In 1146 Bernard of Clairvaux preached the Second Crusade and, in the same campaign, forbade the killing of Jews. Catherine of Siena urged Gregory XI to leave Avignon; he returned to Rome on 17 January 1377, and after his death the Great Schism began. On 7 July 1456 a trial opened under Calixtus III annulled the condemnation of Joan of Arc.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Francis of Assisi
    “he was present at the siege and taking of Damietta. After preaching there to the assembled Christian forces, Francis fearlessly passed over to the infidel camp, where he was taken prisoner and led before the sultan.”
  • Thomas of Celano, First Life I, 57
    “For he paid him what honour he could and tried to sway his mind toward worldly riches by the offer of many gifts. But when the Soldan saw that he most stoutly held all such things in contempt like dung, he was filled with the utmost amazement and …”
    Read the full passage
    “For he paid him what honour he could and tried to sway his mind toward worldly riches by the offer of many gifts. But when the Soldan saw that he most stoutly held all such things in contempt like dung, he was filled with the utmost amazement and gazed on him as a man unlike almost all men. He was deeply stirred by his words and heard him very willingly.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Bernard of Clairvaux
    “A parliament was convoked at Vézelay in Burgundy in 1146, and Bernard preached before the assembly.”
  • Letter 363, 6
    “The Jews must not be persecuted, slaughtered, nor even driven out.”
  • Letter to Gregory XI
    “I tell you, father in Christ Jesus, come swiftly like a gentle lamb. Respond to the Holy Spirit who calls you. I tell you, Come, come, come, and do not wait for time, since time does not wait for you.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Catherine of Siena
    “Nevertheless she made such a profound impression upon the mind of the pope, that, in spite of the opposition of the French king and almost the whole of the Sacred College, he returned to Rome (17 January, 1377).”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Catherine of Siena
    “In the meanwhile the Great Schism had broken out in the Church. From the outset Catherine enthusiastically adhered to the Roman claimant, Urban VI, who in November, 1378, summoned her to Rome”
  • General Audience, 26 January 2011
    “About 25 years later the Trial of Nullity, which opened under the authority of Pope Calixtus III, ended with a solemn sentence that declared the condemnation null and void”
Other readings
  • Benedict XVI reads Francis’s visit as a model of dialogue; the Catholic Encyclopedia, citing Jacques de Vitry, says the preaching achieved little beyond a promise of kinder treatment for captives.
Limits
  • During the Great Schism holy people took different sides; Catherine backed Urban VI.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Saints and churchmen in this line did violence or backed it. Boniface’s killing was avenged with a massacre. Augustine defended imperial fines and exile against the Donatists. Bernard sold the Second Crusade to knights as a bargain. Pope Innocent III turned to “the material sword” against the Albigensians, and heretics Dominic helped convict were handed over to be burned. A Church court sent Joan of Arc to the stake. Thomas More helped prosecute three Protestants who were burned. The Catholic Church annulled Joan’s sentence in 1456, and in 2000 confessed methods “not in keeping with the Gospel”.

Rests on
  • Life of Boniface, chapter VIII
    “and overthrew with prodigious carnage the pagans who came up against them.”
  • Life of Augustine 10
    “They also threw lime mixed with vinegar in the eyes of some and others they murdered.”
  • Letter 185, 26
    “no capital punishment was imposed upon it, that even in dealing with those who were unworthy, Christian gentleness might be observed, but a pecuniary fine was ordained, and sentence of exile was pronounced against their bishops or ministers.”
  • Letter to the people of eastern France (Letter 363)
    “If you are a prudent merchant, if you are a desirer of this world: I show you some great bargains, see you lose them not. Take the sign of the Cross, and you shall gain pardon for every sin that you confess with contrite heart.”
  • Jordan of Saxony, Libellus 32
    “This move was taken by Pope Innocent, who decided that, if the rebellious spirit of the heretics could not be tamed by the pious measures of truth or pierced by the sword of the spirit, which is the word of God, then at least they would respect the power of the material sword.”
  • Constantine of Orvieto, Legend 51
    “a number of heretics who had been arrested and convicted by him were turned over to a state tribunal, after they refused to return to the Catholic Faith.”
  • General Audience, 3 February 2010
    “a heretical group which upheld a dualistic conception of reality, that is, with two equally powerful creator principles, Good and Evil. This group consequently despised matter as coming from the principle of evil.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Dominic
    “We find him by the side of de Montfort at the siege of Lavaur in 1211, and again in 1212, at the capture of La Penne d'Ajen. In the latter part of 1212 he was at Pamiers labouring, at the invitation of de Montfort, for the restoration of religion and morality. Lastly, just before the battle of Muret, 12 September, 1213”
  • General Audience, 26 January 2011
    “It was a great and solemn Trial, at which two ecclesiastical judges presided, Bishop Pierre Cauchon and the Inquisitor Jean le Maistre, but in fact it was conducted entirely by a large group of theologians from the renowned University of Paris”
  • General Audience, 26 January 2011
    “This Trial is a distressing page in the history of holiness and also an illuminating page on the mystery of the Church”
  • General Audience, 26 January 2011
    “these judges were theologians who lacked charity and the humility to see God’s action in this young woman.”
  • Catechism 795, quoting Joan at her trial
    “About Jesus Christ and the Church, I simply know they're just one thing, and we shouldn't complicate the matter.”
  • Commentary on the London evangelical martyrs (Thomas S. Freeman)
    “who suffered during an extensive crackdown on heresy conducted in 1531-2 while Thomas More was Lord Chancellor. More was clearly acting in an unofficial partnership with John Stokesley, bishop of London, and he played a major role in the persecution of three of these martyrs: Richard Bayfield, John Tewkesbury and James Bainham.”
  • Apostolic Letter of 31 October 2000, §4
    “even if, in his actions against heretics, he reflected the limits of the culture of his time.”
  • Universal Prayer, Confession II
    “will recognize that even men of the Church, in the name of faith and morals, have sometimes used methods not in keeping with the Gospel in the solemn duty of defending the truth.”
Other readings
  • Pius XII wrote that if the Second Crusade failed “the fault was surely not his”; the Catholic Encyclopedia holds that Dominic acted only as a theologian judging orthodoxy and always on the side of mercy.
Limits
  • The stories of torture in More’s house come from Foxe and are disputed by modern editors; the prosecutions themselves are not.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Between 1535 and 1886 the line runs across four continents. Thomas More was tried on 1 July 1535 for denying the royal supremacy and appealed to the saints and “the general council of Christendom”. Twenty-six Christians were crucified at Nagasaki in 1597. Kateri Tekakwitha made her vow in 1679. Devasahayam, a convert at the court of Travancore, was shot in 1752. On 3 June 1886 Charles Lwanga was burned at Namugongo, and Catholic and Anglican martyrs died in the same persecution.

Rests on
  • British Library, The execution of Sir Thomas More
    “On 1 July 1535, Thomas More stood trial for treason, and he was condemned to death for ‘maliciously denying the royal Supremacy”
  • Roper, Life of More, pp. 92–93
    “But if I should speak of those that already be dead, of whom many be now holy saints in heaven, I am very sure it is the far, far greater part of them that all the while they lived thought in this case that way that I now think; and therefore am I …”
    Read the full passage
    “But if I should speak of those that already be dead, of whom many be now holy saints in heaven, I am very sure it is the far, far greater part of them that all the while they lived thought in this case that way that I now think; and therefore am I not bound, my lord, to conform my conscience to the council of one realm, against the general council of Christendom.”
  • Office of Readings, 6 February
    “As I come to this supreme moment of my life, I am sure none of you would suppose I want to deceive you. And so I tell you plainly: there is no way to be saved except the Christian way. My religion teaches me to pardon my enemies and all who have offended me. I do gladly pardon the Emperor and all who have sought my death.”
  • “who feared that the introduction of Christianity was the first step in Spain's effort to conquer their country, just as the Spanish had already conquered the Philippines.”
  • Homily, 22 June 1980
    “It is a bold, unusual and prophetic gesture: on 25 March 1679, at the age of twenty-three, with the consent of her spiritual director, Kateri takes a vow of perpetual virginity, as far as we know the first time that this was done among the North American Indians.”
  • “Today, in Kottar, India, Devasahayam Pillai, has been beatified. He was a faithful layman who lived in the 18th century and died a martyr.”
  • Christianity in Travancore, p. 80
    “who in 1745 baptised a Travancore convert who is reverenced as a martyr.”
  • ThePrint, June 2022
    “was killed not because of his switch from Hinduism to Christianity but because he committed “high treason” and other offences. Or so members of the titular royal family of the erstwhile princely state of Travancore have claimed in a 5 June letter to Pope Francis.”
  • Saint of the Day, 3 June
    “Charles was burned to death at Namugongo on June 3, 1886, by Mwanga’s order.”
  • Two Kings of Uganda, chapter on the persecution of 1886
    “Then followed the crowning act in the cruel tragedy, when Walukaga and some thirty others met their heroic deaths. A mighty pyre was heaped about the Christian captives. Each was firmly bound, a burning brand was brought, and soon the consuming fire enfolded this company of saints, of whom the world was not worthy”
  • Homily at Namugongo, 28 November 2015
    “We remember also the Anglican martyrs whose deaths for Christ testify to the ecumenism of blood.”
  • Chronicles of Uganda, book II
    “But the stealing of a gun by a French partisan and the consequent shooting of a Protestant set a light to the mass of inflammable material in Uganda, which resulted in the deplorable war between the two factions, the French and English”
Other readings
  • Japan’s rulers and the Travancore court saw political danger rather than religion: fear of Spanish conquest in Japan, and treason in Travancore, as descendants of the royal family still maintain.
Limits
  • Kateri’s words and life reach us almost entirely through her Jesuit confessors.
  • Within six years of the Uganda martyrdoms, Catholic and Protestant factions in Buganda were at war.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Maximilian Kolbe, prisoner 16670 at Auschwitz, offered his life in place of another prisoner at the end of July 1941 and was killed on 14 August. Óscar Romero, archbishop of San Salvador from 1977, ordered the army in God’s name on 23 March 1980 to stop the repression and was shot the next day; a United Nations commission found that Roberto D’Aubuisson gave the order. Carlo Acutis, who built a website on the Eucharistic miracles, died of leukaemia in 2006 at fifteen and was canonised by Pope Leo XIV on 7 September 2025.

Rests on
Other readings
  • John Paul II decreed in 1982 that Kolbe be venerated “also as a martyr”, although Paul VI had beatified him as a confessor; the title was itself a decision.
Limits
  • Much of what is known of Carlo Acutis’s daily life comes from his mother and from those who promoted his cause.
  • Some of Kolbe’s writings repeated the antisemitism of interwar Catholic Poland.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

On 16 July 1054 the papal legate Humbert laid a bull of excommunication against Patriarch Michael of Constantinople on the altar of Hagia Sophia, and Michael excommunicated him in return. The censures named persons, not churches, but East and West drifted into a lasting break. In 1098 Pope Urban II had Anselm argue the Latin case on the Holy Spirit against Greek bishops at Bari. The Orthodox Church holds that the one Church is found in the Orthodox communion, and still honours Western saints of the first millennium such as Gregory the Great.

Rests on
  • The Orthodox Faith III, Eleventh Century, The Great Schism
    “on July 16, 1054, Humbert strode into the great cathedral of Hagia Sophia during a service and placed on the altar a bull of excommunication against "Patriarch Michael and all his followers." In a day or two, he and his fellow legates left for home. …”
    Read the full passage
    “on July 16, 1054, Humbert strode into the great cathedral of Hagia Sophia during a service and placed on the altar a bull of excommunication against "Patriarch Michael and all his followers." In a day or two, he and his fellow legates left for home. Michael, in his turn, excommunicated Humbert "and all those responsible" for the bull of excommunication against him.”
  • Joint Catholic–Orthodox Declaration, 7 December 1965, §3
    “They had directed their censures against the persons concerned and not the Churches. These censures were not intended to break ecclesiastical communion between the Sees of Rome and Constantinople.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia, St. Anselm
    “In October, 1098, Urban held a council at Bari to deal with the difficulties raised by the Greeks in regard to the procession of the Holy Ghost. Here Anselm was called by the Pope to a place of honour and bidden to take the chief part in the discussion.”
  • The Orthodox Faith I, The Symbol of Faith, Church
    “There can only be one Church and not many. And this one Church, because its unity depends on God, Christ, and the Spirit, may never be broken. Thus, according to Orthodox doctrine, the Church is indivisible; men may be in it or out of it, but they may not divide it.”
  • The Orthodox Faith I, The Symbol of Faith, Church
    “Orthodox Christians believe that in the historical Orthodox Church there exists the full possibility of participating totally in the Church of God, and that only sins and false human choices (heresies) put men outside of this unity. In non-Orthodox …”
    Read the full passage
    “Orthodox Christians believe that in the historical Orthodox Church there exists the full possibility of participating totally in the Church of God, and that only sins and false human choices (heresies) put men outside of this unity. In non-Orthodox Christian groups the Orthodox claim that there are certain formal obstacles, varying in different groups, which, if accepted and followed by men, will prevent their perfect unity with God and will thus destroy the genuine unity of the Church (e.g., the papacy in the Roman Church).”
  • Lives of the Saints, 12 March
    “Pope Saint Gregory the Great, as he is known, died in the year 604, and his relics rest in the cathedral of the holy Apostle Peter in the Vatican.”
  • The Orthodox Faith III, Nineteenth Century, Roman Catholicism
    “France was blessed with the lives of two remarkable saints in this century: the famous Curé d’Ars, Saint John-Baptiste Vianney (1786–1859), and Saint Thérèse of Lisieux (1873–1897).”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox read the same continuity as running through the Orthodox communion, with the papacy as the obstacle to unity.
Limits
  • The date 1054 is a symbol; the break hardened over later centuries, and the censures of 1054 were lifted in 1965.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Catholic Church teaches that the Church Christ founded is indestructible, citing Matthew 16:18, and that Christ governs it through the successors of the apostles; that this Church subsists in the Catholic Church; that it is at once holy and always in need of purification; and that the saints have been the source of renewal in its hardest times. It also teaches that in the great separations “men of both sides were to blame”.

Rests on
  • Catechism 869
    “The Church is apostolic. She is built on a lasting foundation: "the twelve apostles of the Lamb" (Rev 21:14). She is indestructible (cf Mt 16:18). She is upheld infallibly in the truth: Christ governs her through Peter and the other apostles, who are present in their successors, the Pope and the college of bishops.”
  • Catechism 870, quoting Lumen Gentium 8
    “"The sole Church of Christ which in the Creed we profess to be one, holy, catholic, and apostolic,... subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the bishops in communion with him.”
  • Catechism 827, quoting Lumen Gentium 8
    “the Church, however, clasping sinners to her bosom, at once holy and always in need of purification, follows constantly the path of penance and renewal."”
  • Catechism 828
    “The saints have always been the source and origin of renewal in the most difficult moments in the Church's history.”
  • Catechism 817, quoting Unitatis Redintegratio 3
    “But in subsequent centuries much more serious dissensions appeared and large communities became separated from full communion with the Catholic Church - for which, often enough, men of both sides were to blame."”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox hold the same promise of indestructibility for the Orthodox communion; Calvin located it in the faithful few wherever the word is purely preached.
Limits
  • The teaching is a claim of faith. History can show that a visible communion endured; it cannot by itself show that the promise is the reason.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Some Protestant writers deny that the Church Christ founded simply carried on in the open, and hold that after the apostles the true Church went into hiding. J. M. Carroll’s Landmark Baptist history The Trail of Blood (1931) traces the true churches through persecuted groups outside the Catholic and Orthodox Churches, and dates the Catholic hierarchy to a council of 313 under Constantine. Calvin held that the Church may exist without any apparent form, and is known by the pure preaching of the word and the due administration of the sacraments rather than by the see of Rome.

Rests on
  • Lecture 1, “The Chart”
    “They are all “nick-names.” Names given to those people by their enemies. “Christians”–that is the first: “The disciples were called Christians first at Antioch” (Acts 11:26). This occurred about A.D. 43. Either the pagans or Jews gave them that name …”
    Read the full passage
    “They are all “nick-names.” Names given to those people by their enemies. “Christians”–that is the first: “The disciples were called Christians first at Antioch” (Acts 11:26). This occurred about A.D. 43. Either the pagans or Jews gave them that name in derision. All the other names in that column were given in the same manner–Montanists, Novationists, Donatists, Paulicians, Albigenses, Waldenses, etc., and Ana-Baptists.”
  • Lecture 1, First Period A.D. 30–500
    “In A. D. 313, a call was made for a coming together of the Christian churches or their representatives. Many but not all came. The alliance was consummated. A Hierarchy was formed. In the organization of the Hierarchy, Christ was dethroned as head …”
    Read the full passage
    “In A. D. 313, a call was made for a coming together of the Christian churches or their representatives. Many but not all came. The alliance was consummated. A Hierarchy was formed. In the organization of the Hierarchy, Christ was dethroned as head of the churches and Emperor Constantine enthroned (only temporarily, however) as head of the church.”
  • Lecture 1, marks of the New Testament church
    “The churches in their government and discipline to be entirely separate and independent of each other, Jerusalem to have no authority over Antioch–nor Antioch over Ephesus; nor Ephesus over Corinth, and so forth. And their government to be congregational, democratic. A government of the people, by the people, and for the people.”
  • Essay, paragraph on the thesis
    “The thesis of The Trail of Blood is that there has been a continuation of biblical teachings and a succession of biblical churches from the time of Christ to the present. J. M. Carroll believes this succession was always Baptist in principle, if not …”
    Read the full passage
    “The thesis of The Trail of Blood is that there has been a continuation of biblical teachings and a succession of biblical churches from the time of Christ to the present. J. M. Carroll believes this succession was always Baptist in principle, if not in name.... These churches stood outside of the Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox Churches, refused to accept their legitimacy in either faith or practice, rejected infant baptism, and practiced believers’ baptism by immersion.”
  • Note ii
    “However, I think the “trail of faith,” often identified by the “trail of blood” those of that faith left, is not historically demonstrable at all times from the first century to today. Sometimes the stream flows underground, so to speak, moving …”
    Read the full passage
    “However, I think the “trail of faith,” often identified by the “trail of blood” those of that faith left, is not historically demonstrable at all times from the first century to today. Sometimes the stream flows underground, so to speak, moving forward and onward, while not visible to the human historians’ eyes. As a doctrine, church perpetuity stands or falls on the infallible word of God rather than the fallible record of human historians.”
  • Prefatory Address, section 6
    “The hinges on which the controversy turns are these: first, in their contending that the form of the Church is always visible and apparent; and, secondly, in their placing this form in the see of the Church of Rome and its hierarchy. We, on the …”
    Read the full passage
    “The hinges on which the controversy turns are these: first, in their contending that the form of the Church is always visible and apparent; and, secondly, in their placing this form in the see of the Church of Rome and its hierarchy. We, on the contrary, maintain, both that the Church may exist without any apparent form, and, moreover, that the form is not ascertained by that external splendour which they foolishly admire, but by a very different mark, namely, by the pure preaching of the word of God, and the due administration of the sacraments.”
  • Prefatory Address, section 6
    “But Elijah learned that there remained seven thousand men who had not bowed the knee to Baal; nor ought we to doubt that Christ has always reigned on earth ever since he ascended to heaven.”
Other readings
  • Carroll places the true Church in a hidden succession of independent congregations; Calvin places it in the faithful few, known by the word and the sacraments, rather than in an institution.
Limits
  • This claim records what these writers teach. It does not test their accounts, which the chapter does elsewhere.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

12HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Other Churches keep many of these saints. The Church of England, which calls itself part of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church, keeps ten of the eleven saints on this trail in its calendar, including Thomas More and John Fisher as Reformation Martyrs, beside William Tyndale. The Orthodox Church in America keeps Gregory the Great. Pope Francis at Namugongo in 2015 honoured the Anglican martyrs of Uganda.

Rests on
  • Preface to the Declaration of Assent
    “The Church of England is part of the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church, worshipping the one true God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit.”
  • Common Worship calendar, lesser festivals and commemorations
    “23 Polycarp, Bishop of Smyrna, Martyr, c.155 ... 2 Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria, Teacher of the Faith, 373 ... 30 Joan of Arc, Visionary, 1431 ... 5 Boniface (Wynfrith) of Crediton, Bishop, Apostle of Germany, Martyr, 754 ... 29 Peter and Paul, …”
    Read the full passage
    “23 Polycarp, Bishop of Smyrna, Martyr, c.155 ... 2 Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria, Teacher of the Faith, 373 ... 30 Joan of Arc, Visionary, 1431 ... 5 Boniface (Wynfrith) of Crediton, Bishop, Apostle of Germany, Martyr, 754 ... 29 Peter and Paul, Apostles ... 6 Thomas More, Scholar, and John Fisher, Bishop of Rochester, Reformation Martyrs, 1535 ... 14 Maximilian Kolbe, Friar, Martyr, 1941 ... 28 Augustine, Bishop of Hippo, Teacher of the Faith, 430 ... 3 Gregory the Great, Bishop of Rome, Teacher of the Faith, 604 ... 4 Francis of Assisi, Friar, Deacon, Founder of the Friars Minor, 1226”
  • Common Worship calendar, October
    “6 William Tyndale, Translator of the Scriptures, Reformation Martyr, 1536”
  • Common Worship calendar, March
    “24 Oscar Romero, Archbishop of San Salvador, Martyr, 1980”
  • Common Worship calendar, June
    “3 The Martyrs of Uganda, 1885-7 and 1977”
  • Lives of the Saints, 12 March
    “Pope Saint Gregory the Great, as he is known, died in the year 604, and his relics rest in the cathedral of the holy Apostle Peter in the Vatican.”
  • Homily at Namugongo, 28 November 2015
    “We remember also the Anglican martyrs whose deaths for Christ testify to the ecumenism of blood.”
Other readings
  • For Anglicans the shared calendar shows that the saints belong to the whole Church, not to the Roman communion alone.
Limits
  • Keeping a saint’s day does not mean agreeing with everything the saint believed; the Church of England keeps both More and Tyndale.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next