Can you really trace a family tree from Adam to Jesus?
4 scenes · about 12 min read
Not as a record anyone can check. Two , the early accounts of Jesus's life, each give him a family tree, and they don't match.
Matthew runs forward from to Joseph, in three neat blocks of fourteen. Luke runs backwards from Jesus, past Abraham to , and past Adam to God.
Read as modern birth records, they contradict each other. Read as what they are, arguments set out as family trees, each says something clear.
Matthew says Jesus is the son of David and the son of Abraham. Luke says he belongs to the whole human race.
So the claim isn't an unbroken chain of names from Adam to Nazareth. It's narrower: the deliberately places Jesus inside the story of God's promises, and says so in its first line.
Four passages from Matthew and Luke that show what a family tree in the Bible is for.
Matthew opens with a family tree
Matthew, the Gospel writer
Matthew's Gospel, one of the four early accounts of Jesus's life, opens with a family tree. Before telling a single event, its first line calls Jesus the son of David and the son of Abraham. God had made promises to both men.
IWhat was going on
Most scholars date Matthew's Gospel after the Romans destroyed Jerusalem in AD 70, probably a decade or more later. Early Church tradition placed it earlier. It may have been written in Antioch in Syria, a big city of Jews and Greeks.
Its church started out largely Jewish. It was taking in more and more Gentiles, people who were not Jews.
Matthew opens his Gospel, and so the whole New Testament, with a family tree.
IIWhat was at stake
For Jews of Jesus's time, ancestry was not a hobby. It decided who could serve as a priest and which tribe of Israel you belonged to. It also decided who could claim a king's promise.
About a thousand years earlier, God had promised King David, through the prophet Nathan, that his house and his kingdom would last forever.
Jews hoped for the , the rescuer God had promised, and expected him from David's family. If Jesus was the Messiah, he had to be a son of David.
IIIWhat happened
Matthew's first line names David before Abraham, though Abraham lived about a thousand years earlier. It's his way of saying Jesus is the royal Messiah. Then he starts at Abraham, the father of the Jewish people, and walks forward, father to son, to Joseph.
He also names four women, each with an unusual story.
Tamar was a widow denied the husband she was owed. She disguised herself and became pregnant by her father-in-law, Judah. Rahab is usually taken to be the woman of Jericho who hid Israel's spies.
Ruth was a foreigner from Moab. Bathsheba is named only as Uriah's wife: King David slept with her, then had her husband killed.
IVWhat came of it
The list ends with a fifth woman. Joseph is the husband of Mary, and of her Jesus was born. Matthew does not call Joseph the father.
His next story tells why. Joseph takes Mary into his home and names the child, and so brings Jesus into David's family.
The claim was older than Matthew. In the mid-50s , the early Christian missionary whose letters are in the New Testament, had already written that Jesus was descended from David.
VRead the source
The book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham.
Why it matters
The opening line ties Jesus to two promises at once: a king for Israel, and a blessing for every nation. Abraham had been told that all the communities of the earth would find blessing in him.
The four women make the same point from another side. Foreigners and sinners stand in the Messiah's family tree, and God works through real, messy families.
Jewish readers, then and now, do not accept that Jesus fulfils these promises. For Christians, this list is where the New Testament first says he does.
Three fourteens, with names left out
Matthew, the Gospel writer
Matthew sets out Jesus's family in three blocks of fourteen generations, and says so himself. To make the count work, he leaves out names the gives. The shape matters to him more than completeness.
IWhat was going on
Matthew's list falls into three blocks. The first runs from Abraham to David, the founding fathers of Israel. The second runs through the kings who ruled from Jerusalem after David.
The third starts with the Babylonian exile. In 587 BC the Babylonians destroyed Jerusalem and its Temple, the centre of Jewish worship. They took its leading families away.
From then on David's descendants were ordinary citizens with no throne, down to Joseph.
IIWhat was at stake
The numbers don't match the Old Testament. Chronicles, an Old Testament history of Israel's kings, lists three more kings between Joram and Uzziah: Ahaziah, Joash and Amaziah. Matthew skips them.
His last block seems to have only 13 names.
He also gives only 9 generations for about 530 years, between the return from exile and Joseph. Luke gives 18 for the same stretch.
IIIWhat happened
Matthew wasn't careless. He states his scheme himself: fourteen generations, three times.
Why fourteen? In Hebrew, letters also served as numbers. The letters of David's name, D-V-D, add up to 14.
The New American Bible, an official Catholic translation, says that is probably his reason. The whole list is stamped with David's name.
IVWhat came of it
Readers have noticed the gaps for centuries. The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1909, a reference work by Catholic scholars, says the missing kings can't have been unknown to Matthew. He left them out to keep his count.
What about the 13 names in the last block? The New American Bible thinks a slip by a later copyist more likely than one by Matthew. Others count Jesus, as Messiah, as the fourteenth.
VRead the source
Thus the total number of generations from Abraham to David is fourteen generations; from David to the Babylonian exile, fourteen generations; from the Babylonian exile to the Messiah, fourteen generations.
Why it matters
Ancient family lists were not birth certificates. They were arranged to make a point. Matthew shows his arrangement openly, so he is not trying to fool anyone.
The point is the shape of Israel's history. David's family rose to a throne, lost it at the exile, and waited through centuries as ordinary people. Then, Matthew says, the son of David arrived.
Luke: Joseph's son, as people thought
Luke, the Gospel writer
Luke gives Jesus a different family tree, which also runs through Joseph. It begins with a small phrase that is easy to miss: Jesus was the son, as was thought, of Joseph. Luke is telling readers the line is legal, not by blood.
IWhat was going on
Luke wrote his Gospel for a reader named Theophilus, with non-Jewish readers in view. It is often dated to AD 80–90.
Unlike Matthew, Luke doesn't put the family tree at Jesus's birth. He puts it right after Jesus is , washed in water as a sign of a new start.
At that moment a voice from calls him my beloved Son. The list comes just before Jesus begins his work, at about thirty.
IIWhat was at stake
Luke has already told how Mary conceived Jesus without a man, by the power of the . So Joseph is not Jesus's father by blood.
Yet Luke's list, like Matthew's, runs through Joseph. And the two lists disagree.
Matthew names Joseph's father as Jacob; Luke names him Heli. From David down they follow different sons: Solomon in Matthew, Nathan in Luke.
IIIWhat happened
Luke writes that Jesus was the son, as was thought, of Joseph. He flags the gap himself.
Joseph took Mary into his home and accepted the child as his own. Through that adoption, as the New American Bible's note on Matthew puts it, the child belongs to the family of David.
Luke tells the reader the line is legal, and gives it anyway.
IVWhat came of it
Christians have tried for centuries to fit the two lists together.
In the 200s a Christian writer, Julius Africanus, pointed to levirate marriage, an old Jewish custom.
If a man died childless, his brother married the widow, and her son counted as the dead man's. So Joseph could have one father by blood and another by law.
Africanus admitted he had no proof. , the great North African , first suggested that Heli adopted Joseph, then preferred Africanus's answer.
Some read Luke's list as Mary's line, though the early Church writers mostly did not. The Catholic Church has never settled on one explanation.
The simplest answer may be that none is needed. Matthew states his scheme himself, and Luke marks his line as legal. Each list makes a claim about who Jesus is; neither was written as a register to check.
VRead the source
When Jesus began his ministry he was about thirty years of age. He was the son, as was thought, of Joseph, the son of Heli.
Why it matters
Luke could have hidden the problem. Instead he points to it in his opening line. That is a writer being straight with his readers.
For Catholics the point stands: Jesus is David's heir through Joseph, his legal father.
Early Christian writers, from and on, also held that Mary herself was of David's family. That is tradition, not something the Gospels state, and it is honest to say so.
Luke goes back to Adam, and to God
Luke, the Gospel writer
Matthew's list stops at Abraham. Luke's keeps going, past to Adam, the first man in Genesis, and then one step further: the son of God. His point is that Jesus belongs to the whole human race.
IWhat was going on
Adam is the first man in Genesis, the 's opening book. God forms him from the earth and breathes life into him. He and Eve live in a garden with God, until they choose to go their own way, and death enters the human story.
Luke's list climbs past David, past Abraham, past Noah, who survived the flood, all the way to Adam. It holds 77 names, eleven sevens. Matthew went back only as far as Abraham.
IIWhat was at stake
Luke wrote with non-Jewish readers in mind. Was Jesus only Israel's Messiah, the rescuer God promised, or everyone's?
A list that stopped at Abraham would make him the heir of one people. Luke wanted to show that the promised to Israel, God's rescue, reaches every nation.
IIIWhat happened
The list ends in three steps: the son of Seth, the son of Adam, the son of God. Adam had no human father; he came straight from God's hand.
Luke places this right after God's voice at Jesus's baptism calls him his beloved Son.
In the next scene Jesus is tested in the desert and holds firm, where Adam in the garden did not.
IVWhat came of it
Paul, the early Christian missionary, had already compared the two men. He calls Jesus the last Adam: as in Adam all die, so in all will be brought to life.
That comparison runs all through Catholic teaching. The Catholic Church reads the Genesis story of the first , the fall, as figurative language about a real event at the start of human history.
VRead the source
the son of Enos, the son of Seth, the son of Adam, the son of God.
Why it matters
Matthew's list says Jesus belongs to Israel. Luke's says he belongs to everyone. Whoever you are, your first ancestor is in this list too.
No one can check the names before Abraham against records; they come from Genesis.
So the claim is not a pedigree you can verify. It is that Jesus is the son of the whole human family, and the .
Why Catholics read it this way
The Catholic position here is modest, and has been for a long time. The family trees are part of Scripture, which Catholics believe God inspired. They teach something true about who Jesus is.
But they are not a register of descent anyone can verify. The Catholic Church has never required anyone to treat them as one.
What matters here is what the two Gospel writers meant. Both insist that Jesus is not a new religious idea but the continuation of one family, one promise and one kingdom.
People have discussed the differences between the two lists since the 200s. The Catholic Church has never settled on one explanation. That itself is a sign that no teaching of the faith depends on the answer.
How others read the same evidence
Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.
Harmonising readers
A long tradition tries to fit the two lists together. One idea is that Matthew gives Joseph's legal line and Luke gives Mary's.
Another is levirate marriage, the custom where a man married his dead brother's childless widow. It could explain why Joseph has two different fathers.
Julius Africanus, a Christian writer, argued the levirate case in the 200s. These remain proposals, not established findings.
Critical scholars
Most academic readers think both lists were built to make a point about who Jesus is. They hold that neither can be checked against records.
Many also think Matthew's fourteens are built on the number value of David's name in Hebrew.
Skeptical readers
Some conclude that two lists that can't be reconciled make both Gospels unreliable.
The honest answer is narrower. They undermine a way of using the Gospels that the Gospels themselves don't claim.
Skeptics reply with Luke 1:3. Luke promises an orderly account, written 'after investigating everything accurately anew'. That promise is real, but it is about the events 'fulfilled among us': the story of Jesus that Theophilus had been taught.
Luke gives his genealogy a different label. Jesus was the son, 'as was thought', of Joseph. He tells the reader what kind of line it is before giving it.
Check it yourself
Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.
Read the sources yourself1
- 2011 · United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
What a genealogy was for4 steps
Ancient family lists are arguments about who someone is and what they inherit.
Read them as birth certificates and they look like bad history. Read them the way they were written and they make sense.
They can be selective on purpose
Matthew announces his own pattern: three blocks of fourteen. That pattern needs names left out. He isn't hiding it. He points to it.
“Thus the total number of generations from Abraham to David is fourteen generations.”
They can run in either direction
Matthew goes down from Abraham to Jesus. Luke goes up from Jesus to Adam. The direction is part of the argument.
“He was the son, as was thought, of Joseph … the son of Adam, the son of God.”
They can be legal rather than biological
Luke's as was thought says it outright. Both lists run through Joseph, and in both Gospels he is not Jesus's father by blood.
“He was the son, as was thought, of Joseph.”
And they anchor a person in a promise
Matthew's first line sums up the story of God's promises told in the previous chapter. David's throne and Abraham's blessing are tied to one name.
“The book of the genealogy of Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham.”