Part IX · Chapter 26
The Catholic Reformation and Trent

Did the Catholic Church reform itself, or only dig in?

9 scenes · about 29 min read

The short answer

Both. Between 1545 and 1563 the , the Catholic answer to the Reformation, did two jobs at once. It defined against the Reformers, and passed laws against the abuses they had named.

The reforms are dated. In 1562 it abolished the travelling indulgence-sellers. In 1563 it ordered , even cardinals, to live in their dioceses, and every cathedral to train priests.

On doctrine it held firm. It fixed the 's books and kept seven .

It taught that really changes the sinner inside, and that the bread and wine at become 's body and blood. Each ruling came with an anathema, cutting off anyone who denied it.

It also tightened control. Printing a book on faith needed a bishop's licence. From 1564, reading the Bible in your own language needed written permission, a rule the Catholic Church has long since left behind.

But the reforms held. Bishops who lived among their people, priests trained in seminaries and a new catechism shaped Catholic life for four centuries.

Follow the trail

Nine documents, from a council a century before Trent to the 1966 notice that ended the Catholic Church's list of banned books.

22 November 1439Historical2 min read

Seven sacraments, listed a century early

The Council of Florence, writing to the Armenian Church

On 22 November 1439, a of bishops in Florence gave envoys of the Armenian Church a list of seven sacraments. People often say Trent invented that count. In fact Trent defended the same list, in the same order, in 1547.

IWhat was going on

A council is a meeting of bishops called to settle what the Church teaches. In 1438 the and the Byzantine emperor, ruler of the Greek Christian East, brought East and West together at Ferrara. The council later moved to Florence.

The aim was to heal the split between Rome and the Greek churches.

The Greeks signed a union in the summer of 1439. The Western, Latin side then stayed on to reach the other Eastern Churches. First came envoys of the Armenian Church, with full powers to agree a union.

IIWhat was at stake

To unite, the two sides had to agree on what the Church believes and does, not only on who leads it. So the council wrote the Armenians a summary of Western teaching. That way they knew exactly what they were accepting.

Part of it was about the sacraments, rites such as . Through them, Christians believe, God gives his grace. How many were there, and what did each one do?

IIIWhat happened

On 22 November 1439 the council issued its decree for the Armenians. It is known by its first Latin words, Exsultate Deo.

It listed seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation, the , penance or confession, anointing of the sick, holy orders and marriage. The Eucharist is the bread and wine of the Lord's Supper. Holy orders is the ordaining of clergy.

It said what each one is for. It also set them apart from the rites of the , the Scriptures of ancient Israel.

IVWhat came of it

The union with the Greeks never took hold among their own clergy and people. Constantinople fell to the Ottoman Turks in 1453 before it could. The Armenian union fared no better.

The list of seven stayed in the Latin Church's books. Most Protestant Reformers of the 1500s later kept only two sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper. By then Rome's count was already on record in a council's decree.

VRead the source
There are seven sacraments of the new Law, namely baptism, confirmation, Eucharist, penance, extreme unction, orders and matrimony, which differ greatly from the sacraments of the old Law.
Council of Florence, Session 8: Exsultate Deo, Bull of Union with the Armenians (22 November 1439) · Session 8, Exsultate Deo, 22 November 1439

Why it matters

People often say Trent invented Catholic teaching under pressure. On this point it defended a list Rome had already put in writing a century before.

The count itself is medieval. The rites themselves are far older, and Catholics trace each of them to the .

What Trent added in 1547 was a penalty for anyone who denied the count.

8 April 1546Revealed3 min read

The Bible and tradition, received together

The Council of Trent, fourth session

On 8 April 1546 the Council of Trent made its first ruling on doctrine. It received the books of the Bible and the apostles' unwritten traditions together, with the same reverence. It also fixed which books belong in the Bible.

IWhat was going on

In 1518 , a German monk and university teacher, appealed over the pope's head to a general council, a meeting of bishops from the whole Church. German princes soon demanded one too. They wanted it free, and held on German soil.

It took 27 years to open. Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, ruled Germany and much of Europe. He and the popes distrusted each other, and France and the Empire kept going to war.

A council called to Mantua for 1537 never met. One called to Vicenza in 1538 drew six bishops.

Trent was the compromise: a town inside the Empire, as the Germans wanted, but on the Italian side of the Alps. The council finally opened there on 13 December 1545, with four archbishops and twenty-one bishops.

IIWhat was at stake

The Reformers held that Scripture is the final authority over everything the Church teaches. Creeds and teachers help. But nothing can be required of believers that can't be shown from the Bible.

Catholics held that the apostles handed on the faith in two ways. One was in writing. The other was in the life and teaching of the churches they founded. The question was whether that second stream still carried authority.

There was also the question of which books belong in the Bible. Luther's German Bible put Tobit, Judith, Maccabees and several others in a separate section. He counted them good to read, but not equal to Scripture.

IIIWhat happened

The bishops took up Scripture first, from 8 February 1546. On 8 April 1546, in the council's fourth formal session, they passed two decrees.

The first received the books of both Testaments and the apostles' traditions with the same reverence. The truth of the gospel, it said, is contained 'in the written books, and the unwritten traditions'.

People argue over the word equal, because the decree receives both 'with an equal affection of piety, and reverence'. But it joins the two with and. It doesn't split the faith into one part found only in the Bible and another found only in tradition.

It also listed the books of the Bible, with Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch and two books of Maccabees among them. Anyone who rejected the list was declared anathema: formally cut off from the Church.

The second decree made the Latin Vulgate the official text for preaching and debate. The Vulgate had been the Western Church's Bible for over a thousand years.

No one was to read Scripture against the Church's sense of it, or against the shared reading of the early Fathers, the great teachers of the first centuries.

IVWhat came of it

The second decree also required a bishop's licence before any book on sacred subjects could be printed. Nothing was decided about Bibles in ordinary languages. That question came back later, and more harshly.

For Catholics the list of books was now closed, with a penalty attached. It was the first time an ecumenical council, one counted as speaking for the whole Church, had done that.

Protestant churches kept the shorter Old Testament. The Church of England reads the extra books as examples of how to live, but not to set doctrine. The Orthodox, whose Old Testament is the Greek one, read them in worship.

VRead the source
following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety, and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament--seeing that one God is the author of both --as also the said traditions, as well those appertaining to faith as to morals, as having been dictated, either by Christ's own word of mouth, or by the Holy Ghost, and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continuous succession.
Council of Trent, Session IV: Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures · Session IV, Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures

Why it matters

This sitting of the council drew the line that still divides Catholics and Protestants. What has the last word: Scripture alone, or Scripture read within the Church's living tradition?

Four centuries later, the Second Vatican Council repeated Trent's Latin phrase almost word for word. That was the meeting of the world's Catholic bishops in Rome, from 1962 to 1965.

Scripture and tradition, it said, are both received 'with the same sense of loyalty and reverence'.

Catholics read that as Trent's own position. Protestants still see it as tradition raised to Scripture's level.

13 January 1547Revealed3 min read

Trent says grace really changes the sinner

The Council of Trent, sixth session

On 13 January 1547, after seven months of debate, the Council of Trent ruled on how a sinner is made right with God. It said this is God's free gift, and that it really changes the person inside, not only how God counts them.

IWhat was going on

Justification means how a sinner is made right with God. For Martin Luther it was not a classroom question. As a young monk he feared he could never do enough to satisfy a just God.

Then he read 's letter to the Romans, one of the early Christian letters in the Bible.

He came to see God's justice as a gift: the justice by which a merciful God makes us right through faith. He later wrote that it felt like walking through open gates into paradise.

From that came the heart of his teaching. Sinners are justified by faith alone, because of Christ. Their own good works don't earn it.

IIWhat was at stake

Both sides agreed that grace, God's free help, comes first and can't be earned. The question was what happens when God justifies someone.

Lutherans said God declares the sinner righteous for Christ's sake. He credits Christ's own righteousness to them, and a changed life follows as fruit.

Catholics said God's grace actually makes the person righteous inside. The person, moved by grace, freely says yes.

Put simply: is being made right with God more like a judge declaring you not guilty, or a doctor making you well? Lutherans stressed the first, Catholics the second, and both said it is God who does it.

Each side had a fear. Protestants feared any talk of cooperating would make people trust their own works. Catholics feared that faith alone would make a changed life seem optional.

IIIWhat happened

The debate began in June 1546 and ran for seven months. War was coming in Germany between the emperor and the Protestant princes. The emperor's party tried to slow the discussion down.

It took 61 general meetings and 44 smaller ones to settle justification and the duty of bishops to live in their dioceses. Some of the debates were stormy.

On 13 January 1547 the council passed the decree. It had sixteen chapters of teaching and 33 canons, short rulings that each end with an anathema on the opposing view. Chapter VII is the heart of it.

IVWhat came of it

Luther had died in February 1546. That summer the emperor went to war with the Smalkaldic League, the alliance of Protestant princes. He beat them at Mühlberg in April 1547.

By then the council had left Trent. An infectious disease broke out in the town, and in March 1547 most bishops voted to move to Bologna. The emperor's bishops stayed behind. The council stalled, and in September 1549 the pope suspended it.

The Lutherans' statement of faith, the Augsburg Confession of 1530, and Trent's decree now stood as two written answers. The anathemas were never withdrawn.

VRead the source
the alone formal cause is the justice of God, not that whereby He Himself is just, but that whereby He maketh us just, that, to wit, with which we being endowed by Him, are renewed in the spirit of our mind, and we are not only reputed, but are truly called, and are, just, receiving justice within us
Council of Trent, Session VI (13 January 1547): Decree on Justification · Session VI, Decree on Justification, chapter VII

Why it matters

Justification was the question that started the Reformation. This decree is still the Catholic Church's fullest answer to it.

In 1999 Catholics and Lutherans signed a Joint Declaration saying they share a basic understanding of justification. The chapter Martin Luther and the Reformation tells that story, and the readings below weigh what it settled.

1547Historical2 min read

Calvin answers from Geneva

John Calvin

In 1547, while the council was still meeting, John Calvin in Geneva published a point-by-point reply to its decrees. He argued it condemned a view no Reformer held. The same book called the church of Rome the great harlot.

IWhat was going on

John Calvin was a French scholar, trained in law, who joined the Reformation in the early 1530s. When the French crown turned against its Protestants, he left France.

In 1536 he published the first edition of his Institutes, a handbook of Protestant teaching. Its preface was a letter to King Francis I, defending French Protestants who were being called rebels.

By 1547 he was the leading pastor of Geneva, a city that had adopted the Reformation in 1536.

IIWhat was at stake

Calvin believed the medieval Church had buried God's free gift under human rules, rites and merits, the credit people thought their good works earned. For him, justification by faith alone was the good news itself, not a slogan.

So when Trent condemned faith alone, the question was this. Had it condemned what the Reformers actually taught, or a caricature of it?

IIIWhat happened

Calvin printed the decrees of the council's first sessions with his own reply after each part. He called the reply an Antidote, a cure for poison.

On canon IX, one of the council's short rulings, he wrote that no Reformer meant a dead faith without love.

Faith alone justifies, he argued, but the faith that justifies is never alone. It is like the sun's heat, which warms the earth but never comes without its light.

The book is also harsh. It calls the church of Rome the great harlot, an image of a corrupt city from the Bible's last book. It treats the council as the pope's tool.

IVWhat came of it

Trent went on with its work. The Reformed churches, the Protestant family shaped by Calvin in Switzerland, France, the Netherlands and Scotland, kept his teaching.

Each side now had a written case against the other, and each believed the other had misread it.

VRead the source
Add, that when we say a man is justified by faith alone, we do not fancy a faith devoid of charity, but we mean that faith alone is the cause of justification.
Acts of the Council of Trent with the Antidote (1547), in Tracts Relating to the Reformation, vol. III · Antidote to the canons of the Sixth Session, reply to Canon IX, p. 151 (Beveridge, 1851)

Why it matters

Calvin's point was that the council partly condemned a view no Reformer held. That is close to what Catholics and Lutherans said together in 1999.

So some of the split was real disagreement, and some was people talking past each other in anger. Telling the two apart is still the work of Christian unity.

11 October 1551Revealed3 min read

What the bread becomes at Mass

The Council of Trent, thirteenth session

On 11 October 1551 the council defined transubstantiation, a word a council had already used in 1215. The bread and wine at Mass become Christ's body and blood. It added that this had always been the Church's firm belief. Catholics point to writers like , who around AD 155 said the bread is not common bread but the flesh of Jesus.

IWhat was going on

The Eucharist, also called or the Lord's Supper, is the meal Jesus told his followers to repeat. He took bread and wine and called them his body and blood. The Mass is the Catholic service where it is celebrated.

Christians had long believed Christ is truly present in it. The Reformers split over how.

Luther held that Christ's body and blood are truly present with the bread and wine. Zwingli, the Reformer of Zurich, made the Supper a memorial. Calvin taught a real but spiritual feeding on Christ.

In 1215 the Fourth Lateran Council, a council held at the pope's church in Rome, had already used the word transubstantiation. It meant the change of the bread and wine.

The Catholic Encyclopedia of 1912 traces the word further back, to theologians of the late eleventh and twelfth centuries.

IIWhat was at stake

Suppose the bread stays bread with Christ alongside it, or is only a sign. Then the Mass is something different from what Catholics had believed. What the bread becomes decides what is happening at every altar.

Trent's bishops wanted one clear definition that ruled out the views they judged wrong.

IIIWhat happened

Pope Paul III died in 1549. His successor, Julius III, had chaired the council's opening as the pope's legate, his official representative. He reopened it at Trent on 1 May 1551.

France's king kept his bishops away, so most who came were from the emperor's lands. On 11 October 1551 the council passed its decree on the Eucharist, in eight chapters and eleven canons, or short rulings.

It taught that the whole substance of the bread becomes Christ's body, and of the wine his blood. What the senses perceive stays the same: it still looks and tastes like bread and wine. The Church, it said, calls that change, suitably and properly, transubstantiation.

The same day it offered Protestants safe conduct to come and be heard.

IVWhat came of it

That winter, envoys of several Protestant princes and cities came. They asked the council to reverse its decisions against the Augsburg Confession, the Lutheran statement of faith. They also asked it to declare the pope subject to a council. The council refused.

In spring 1552 Maurice of Saxony, a Protestant prince, turned on the emperor and marched south. With war close to Trent, the council suspended itself in April 1552. It didn't meet again for nearly ten years.

VRead the source
by the consecration of the bread and of the wine, a conversion is made of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood; which conversion is, by the holy Catholic Church, suitably and properly called Transubstantiation.
Council of Trent, Session XIII (11 October 1551): Decree on the Eucharist · Session XIII, chapter IV, On Transubstantiation

Why it matters

Catholics and Orthodox both believe the bread and wine truly become Christ's body and blood. But the Orthodox Church in America counts transubstantiation, the Latin term and its explanation, among the medieval teachings it rejects.

The Church of England's Articles, its founding statement of belief, say the term can't be proved from Scripture. They still affirm a true sharing in Christ's body.

So the meal that should unite Christians is also one of the clearest things that keeps them from one table.

16 July 1562Historical2 min read

The council shuts down the indulgence-sellers

The Council of Trent, twenty-first session

On 16 July 1562 the council abolished the licensed collectors who preached for money, the trade Luther had protested 45 years before. The decree admits that earlier councils had tried and failed, and that no hope of fixing it was left.

IWhat was going on

Catholics believe that when a is forgiven, some of its damage still needs healing. That happens in this life, or after death in , a final cleansing before .

An indulgence is the Church's release from some or all of that remaining penalty. It is granted for a prayer or a good deed.

Often the good deed was a gift of money to a good cause. That turned a spiritual practice into a source of income. Licensed collectors called questors went from town to town, preaching indulgences and gathering the gifts.

In 1515 Pope Leo X backed an indulgence to pay for the new St 's Basilica in Rome. In Germany it was run by Archbishop Albrecht of Brandenburg, deep in debt to his bankers.

IIWhat was at stake

Half of what the preachers raised in Albrecht's lands went to repay those debts. The chapter Martin Luther and the Reformation tells the deal in full.

Johann Tetzel, a Dominican friar, led the preaching. Luther had already warned that indulgences taught people to fear punishment rather than sin. To him the campaign looked like God's forgiveness being sold.

On 31 October 1517 Luther wrote ninety-five theses, points for debate, and sent them to Albrecht. They were soon printed and read across Germany.

IIIWhat happened

Councils had tried to rein in the questors before. Lateran IV did in 1215, then councils at Lyons and at Vienne. None of it had worked.

Pope Pius IV reopened the council in January 1562, and reform was high on its list.

On 16 July 1562 it abolished the office of questor everywhere. There was no exception for special privilege or old custom.

From then on, the local bishop was to announce indulgences. Two clergy of his cathedral would collect any gifts, and none of them was to be paid.

IVWhat came of it

In its last session, in December 1563, the council confirmed that the Church can grant indulgences and that they help the faithful. In the same decree it ordered every evil gain connected with them abolished.

The practice stayed; the trade went. Indulgences remain part of Catholic teaching today. But the travelling indulgence-seller was gone from Catholic law.

VRead the source
Whereas many remedies, heretofore applied by divers councils in their day, as well by that of Lateran, and of Lyons, as by that of Vienne, against the wicked abuses of questors of alms, have become in later times useless
Council of Trent, Session XXI (16 July 1562): Decree on Communion under Both Species and Decree on Reformation · Session XXI, Decree on Reformation, chapter IX

Why it matters

The Reformation began over indulgences. Forty-five years later, a Catholic council admitted in writing that the abuse Luther protested was real, and that it had beaten every earlier remedy.

It came too late to stop the split. By then whole countries, from Scandinavia to Scotland, had broken with Rome.

Catholics read the decree as the Church correcting itself. Protestants answer that it fixed the selling but kept the teaching underneath, which was Luther's deeper objection.

15 July 1563Historical3 min read

A school for priests in every diocese

The Council of Trent, twenty-third session

On 15 July 1563 the council ordered every bishop, even a cardinal, to live in his own diocese. It also told every cathedral to train boys for the priesthood, children of the poor first. This diocesan school for priests, the seminary, was something new.

IWhat was going on

A bishop leads a diocese, the Church's local region, and is meant to live among its people. By 1500 many did not. Some held several dioceses at once, took the income from each, and lived at Rome or at a royal court.

In 1537 a commission of nine churchmen, set up by Pope Paul III and headed by Gasparo Contarini, reported on the Church's abuses. It traced them to a claim about the pope's own power.

Some teachers had said the pope was lord of every church office. So, they argued, he couldn't be guilty of simony, the sin of selling church offices, when he sold them. The pope accepted the commission's advice but changed little at once.

There was no school every future priest had to attend. Many learned the work by helping an older priest.

IIWhat was at stake

At Trent everyone agreed bishops should live in their dioceses. They fought over why. Spanish bishops argued the duty came straight from God. Others treated it as a Church rule the pope could relax.

Behind that lay a bigger question. Does a bishop's authority come directly from God, or through the pope? That dispute put the council in deep trouble in 1562 and 1563.

IIIWhat happened

Two of the council's presiding cardinals died in early 1563. Their successors, Cardinals Morone and Navagero, slowly found a way through.

On 15 July 1563, with 235 voting members, the council passed its decree. Every bishop must live in his diocese, even a cardinal, one of the pope's senior advisers.

For any time away without good cause, he loses his income. It goes to the church buildings or the poor.

Chapter XVIII ordered every cathedral to run a college for boys at least twelve years old who could read and write. It was to prefer the children of the poor. The council called it a lasting seminary, a seed-bed, of ministers.

IVWhat came of it

Charles Borromeo, archbishop of Milan and Pius IV's own nephew, became the best-known bishop to put the decrees to work. He lived in his diocese, as the council now required, and in 1576 that mattered.

That summer plague reached Milan. Borromeo hurried back, made his will and gave himself to his people. He visited the plague-stricken houses, and the hospital where the worst cases lay.

At first the city's own clergy hung back, until he talked them into helping. He walked through the streets barefoot, with a rope round his neck, doing penance for his people.

New religious orders carried the reform too. The Jesuits, approved in 1540, had theologians at the council and opened schools across Europe.

A decree could order seminaries, but it couldn't build them. Founding them took decades, faster in some countries than others.

VRead the source
all cathedral, metropolitan, and other churches greater than these, shall be bound, each according to its means and the extent of the diocese, to maintain, to educate religiously, and to train in ecclesiastical discipline, a certain number of youths of their city and diocese
Council of Trent, Session XXIII (15 July 1563): Doctrine on the Sacrament of Order and Decree on Reformation · Session XXIII, Decree on Reformation, chapter XVIII

Why it matters

Today nearly every Catholic priest is trained in a seminary, and that system starts with this decree. The reform raised up a generation of saints who carried it out, from Charles Borromeo in Milan to Francis de Sales in Geneva's own diocese.

It answers one of the Reformers' fairest complaints: people were left with absent bishops and untaught priests. Protestant churches met the same need their own way, with university-trained pastors.

1564Historical3 min read

Rules for what Catholics could read

A commission of Trent, its rules issued by Pius IV

In 1564 Pope Pius IV published a list of banned books and ten rules for reading, finishing work the council had begun. The rules didn't ban Bibles in ordinary languages. But reading one now needed written permission.

IWhat was going on

The printing press, invented about 1440, let a pamphlet reach thousands. In the 1500s churches and governments across Europe, Catholic and Protestant, tried to control printing. Ideas now spread faster than anyone could answer them.

It was also a time of killing for faith on every side. Mary I, England's Catholic queen, burned at least 280 Protestants between 1555 and 1558. Among them was , the Protestant archbishop of Canterbury.

Protestant Geneva burned Michael Servetus, who denied the , in 1553. Catholic and Protestant authorities alike drowned or burned Anabaptists, who baptised only adult believers.

From 1577, 's England hanged, drew and quartered Catholic priests as traitors. Each side called its own dead and the other side's dead criminals.

IIWhat was at stake

Rome's rules said experience showed something about Bibles in ordinary languages. Read without guidance, they did more harm than good. Rome feared each reader would build a private faith, as it believed the Reformation had shown.

The Reformers answered that God's word belongs in every believer's hands. The question was how far the Church should go to protect people from error, and what that would cost.

IIIWhat happened

In 1559 Pope Paul IV had issued a harsh Index, a list of forbidden books. It banned the entire works of some 550 authors. Even many Catholics found it too severe.

In February 1562 the council set up a commission for a new list. It never finished. In December 1563 the council handed the work to the pope.

In 1564 Pius IV published the list with ten rules. Rule II banned every book by Luther, Zwingli and Calvin.

Rule IV allowed a Bible in a modern language only with written permission. Anyone reading one without it was refused , a priest's forgiveness in confession, until the copy was handed in.

IVWhat came of it

In 1571 Rome set up a permanent Congregation of the Index, a Vatican office, to keep the list up to date. It grew for four centuries.

The cost fell on learning as well as faith. The astronomers Copernicus and Galileo were both listed. Books arguing that the earth goes round the sun stayed under a general ban until 1758.

The killing went on too. In August 1572 Catholic crowds in Paris and across France murdered Protestants in the St Bartholomew's Day massacre. In Paris, gravediggers at one cemetery were paid to bury 1,100 bodies, and many more were thrown into the river Seine.

VRead the source
Since it is clear from experience that if the Sacred Books are permitted everywhere and without discrimination in the vernacular, there will by reason of the boldness of men arise therefrom more harm than good, the matter is in this respect left to the judgment of the bishop or inquisitor, who may with the advice of the pastor or confessor permit the reading of the Sacred Books translated into the vernacular by Catholic authors to those who they know will derive from such reading no harm but rather an increase of faith and piety, which permission they must have in writing. Those, however, who presume to read or possess them without such permission may not receive absolution from their sins till they have handed them over to the ordinary.
Ten Rules concerning Prohibited Books drawn up by the Fathers chosen by the Council of Trent and approved by Pope Pius (the Tridentine Index, 1564) · Ten Rules concerning Prohibited Books (1564), Rule IV

Why it matters

For generations, a Catholic needed permission to read the Bible in their own language. That was a real loss, and Protestants rightly pointed to it.

Catholic translations still appeared, among them the English Douay–Rheims New Testament of 1582. But reading one still needed permission.

The Catholic Church now teaches differently. In 1965 the Second Vatican Council declared that no one may be forced to act against conscience in religious matters. It also urged that Scripture be open to all the faithful.

In 2000 asked forgiveness for the violence some Christians had used in the service of truth.

14 June 1966Historical2 min read

The banned-books list stops being law

The Vatican's office for doctrine

On 14 June 1966, 402 years after the 1564 rules, the Vatican's office for doctrine said the Index no longer had the force of church law. From then on, Catholics were trusted to judge for themselves, guided by conscience and their bishops' warnings.

IWhat was going on

By the twentieth century the Index, the list of forbidden books, was kept by the Holy Office, the Vatican department for doctrine. Its last edition, in 1948, listed about 4,000 titles.

The , the world's bishops meeting in Rome from 1962 to 1965, taught religious freedom. On 7 December 1965 Pope Paul VI reorganised the Holy Office.

It became the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, called the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith since 2022. That left the Index's standing unclear.

IIWhat was at stake

Requests reached Rome asking a simple question: is the Index still in force?

The answer had to say what was changing and what was not. Were Catholics still bound by law? Did the Church still have a duty to warn against harmful books?

IIIWhat happened

On 14 June 1966 the Congregation issued a short notification, signed by Cardinal Alfredo Ottaviani.

It said the Index no longer has the force of church law, and its penalties no longer apply. Under the old law, reading some forbidden books brought excommunication: being cut off from the sacraments until reconciled.

The Index still binds in conscience, it said, as a warning to be on guard against writings that can harm faith and morals. The Church would trust the mature conscience of the faithful. Bishops would keep the duty to warn.

IVWhat came of it

No new edition was ever published. Rome still warns publicly about particular books and authors, but it no longer keeps a list backed by penalties.

It changed the method, from law and punishment to conscience and teaching.

VRead the source
announces that the Index remains morally binding, in light of the demands of natural law, in so far as it admonishes the conscience of Christians to be on guard for those writings that can endanger faith and morals. But, at the same time, it no longer has the force of ecclesiastical law with the attached censure.
Notification regarding the abolition of the Index of books (14 June 1966) · Notification of 14 June 1966, paragraph 2

Why it matters

The Index began in fear of a flood of printed error. It ended in a Church that trusted its readers more. 402 years separate the 1564 rules from this notice.

Critics, Catholic and Protestant, note that it apologised for nothing and reopened no case. Catholics answer that it follows what Vatican II taught: truth wins minds by its own power, not by force.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Catholics read Trent as the Catholic Church finally doing what it had failed to do in the eighty years before Luther. The council named the abuses in its own words and passed laws against them.

The indulgence-sellers were abolished. Absent bishops were ordered home. Seminaries were ordered built, and church leaders' relatives were cut off from church money.

The decrees are the Church's own admission that the complaints about how clergy lived were true. They aren't an admission that the Reformers' teaching was right: those were people failing, not what the Church teaches.

On doctrine, the Catholic claim is that Trent defined old teaching rather than inventing new teaching. A council at Carthage in North Africa, in 419, already listed Tobit, Judith and two books of Maccabees.

The Council of Florence counted seven sacraments in 1439, and listed the same Bible books in 1442. Lateran IV had used the word in 1215, for the bread and wine becoming Christ's body and blood.

What Trent added was exact wording and a penalty, under pressure, against a movement that denied each of them.

On Scripture and tradition, Catholics deny that the council demoted the Bible. The decree receives the books and the traditions together.

Basil of Caesarea, a Greek bishop, wrote about this in 375. He said that written teaching, and what is delivered 'in a mystery by the tradition of the ', both 'have the same force'.

Four centuries after Trent, Vatican II repeated Trent's Latin phrase, pari pietatis affectu ac reverentia, almost word for word. It did so in Dei Verbum, its teaching on how God reveals himself. In English the phrase reads 'the same sense of loyalty and reverence'.

So anyone who says Vatican II quietly reversed Trent here has to explain that sentence.

Trent didn't heal the split it was answering, and Catholics shouldn't claim it did. In the same decrees, it narrowed who was allowed to think aloud about what it had done: the pope kept all explanation of the council for himself.

But its reforms bore fruit. Within a generation came saints who carried reform into dioceses, religious orders and parishes: Charles Borromeo, Teresa of Ávila, John of the Cross, Francis de Sales. In 1566 the council's own catechism, the Roman , gave parish priests a clear summary of the faith.

And its teaching proved open to dialogue: in 1999 Catholics and Lutherans found they share a basic understanding of , though Rome's 1998 Response says some differences remain.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Lutheran

The of 1530, the Lutherans' founding statement of faith, sets out the teaching Trent's sixth session answers.

Its Article IV says that people 'are freely justified for Christ's sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor'.

It adds: 'This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight'. In other words, God credits their faith as righteousness. Trent's canon XI is aimed squarely at that crediting.

In 1999 Catholics and Lutherans signed a Joint Declaration. Lutherans read it as finding that the old condemnations don't fall on 'the teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration'.

They read that as a limited finding, not a repeal. The anathemas themselves were never withdrawn.

Reformed

, the Reformer of Geneva, answered Trent while it was still meeting.

He boiled its fourth session down to four points. Two were that doctrine is not to stand on , and that the council had marked all the books of the Bible with the same chalk.

On justification, he argued that canon IX condemned a description no Reformer owned.

Anglican

The Church of England's statement of belief is the Thirty-Nine Articles. Article XXI was drafted in 1562, while Trent was still meeting.

It rejects the council's method, not just one of its conclusions: general councils 'may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God'.

Article XXVIII says transubstantiation 'can not be proved by holy Writ'. The same article affirms that the bread is a sharing in the Body of Christ. So it rejects the explanation, not the presence.

Eastern Orthodox

teaching accepts that Trent reformed, and rejects what it defined. The Orthodox Church in America's history of the Church puts it this way.

Trent, 'While instituting many needed practical reforms, ... also officially reaffirmed the aberrant Medieval doctrines and practices of purgatory, indulgences, transubstantiation of the bread and wine in the Eucharist, communion for the laity with the bread only, the mass as a repropitiating sacrifice of Christ made to the Father, and extreme unction (whereby the sacrament of healing with holy oil became last rites for the dying)'.

Historians, on what to call it

Historians still argue over the name. Counter-Reformation, an older label from German historians, makes the whole era a reaction against Luther.

Hubert Jedin, the great Catholic historian of Trent, argued for two names together: Catholic Reformation and Counter-Reformation. Reform from within had begun before Luther; defence against Protestantism came after him.

John O'Malley, an American Jesuit historian, found every label too narrow. In Trent and All That (2000) he proposed Early Modern Catholicism: a Church shaped by its age, and shaping it in return.

On this reading, Trent was neither only reform nor only reaction.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
Nine of the council's decrees, and the papal letter that sealed them, in the order they were issued10 steps

The decrees on belief and the decrees on reform are mixed together here, because the council mixed them in its sessions.

Many end with let him be anathema. That is a solemn judgement that a teaching is outside the Catholic faith, and that whoever holds it is cut off from communion with the Church. It's a church penalty, like excommunication, not a physical punishment.

The English is J. Waterworth's translation of 1848.

  1. Session IV: the canon, with a penalty attached

    8 April 1546

    The list includes Tobias, Judith, Wisdom, Ecclesiasticus, Baruch and two books of Machabees. These are older spellings of Tobit, Sirach and Maccabees.

    The Council of Florence had listed the same books in 1442, with no anathema, no cutting-off for those who disagreed. Trent is the first ecumenical council to attach one.

    “But if any one receive not, as sacred and canonical, the said books entire with all their parts, as they have been used to be read in the Catholic Church, and as they are contained in the old Latin vulgate edition; and knowingly and deliberately contemn the traditions aforesaid; let him be anathema.”
    RevealedCouncil of Trent, Session IV: Decree concerning the Canonical ScripturesSession IV, Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures, closing clauseThe evidence ↓
  2. Session IV: and who may interpret it

    8 April 1546

    The same session declares the Vulgate, the old Latin Bible, authentic for public use. It also requires a bishop's licence before any book on sacred matters is printed.

    It also says who settles a reading when readings clash: not each reader alone, but the Church, with the shared reading of the Fathers. The licence rule is the seed of the 1564 rules on reading.

    “no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers”
    HistoricalCouncil of Trent, Session IV: Decree concerning the Canonical ScripturesSession IV, Decree concerning the edition and the use of the sacred booksThe evidence ↓
  3. Session VI: canon IX, and its qualifying clause

    13 January 1547

    The canon doesn't condemn the bare words faith alone. It condemns them only when they are taken to mean that no movement of the person's own will is needed.

    Whether any Reformer held that is exactly what Calvin denied the same year.

    “If any one saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of Justification, and that it is not in any way necessary, that he be prepared and disposed by the movement of his own will; let him be anathema.”
  4. Session VI: canon XI, on what justifies

    13 January 1547

    This is the canon aimed at imputed righteousness: the Lutheran teaching that God credits Christ's righteousness to the sinner. It carries a qualifier of its own: to the exclusion of grace.

    The grace it defends is Paul's own phrase: God's love poured out into our hearts through the holy Spirit (Romans 5:5). For Trent, God doesn't only count sinners righteous; he makes them so. The 1999 Joint Declaration rests on the qualifier, and Rome's 1998 Response said some differences remain.

    “If any one saith, that men are justified, either by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ, or by the sole remission of sins, to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is inherent in them; or even that the grace, whereby we are justified, is only the favour of God; let him be anathema.”
  5. Session VII: the count fixed at seven

    3 March 1547

    The canon defends rites the whole Church, East and West, already practised. The count is what was new in the Middle Ages.

    The list of seven that stuck goes back to Peter Lombard's Sentences, a theology textbook written in Paris about 1155. The earliest council to list them is Florence in 1439, a century before this canon.

    “If any one saith, that the sacraments of the New Law were not all instituted by Jesus Christ, our Lord; or, that they are more, or less, than seven, to wit, Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction, Order, and Matrimony; or even that any one of these seven is not truly and properly a sacrament; let him be anathema.”
  6. Session XIII: canon II, printed whole

    11 October 1551

    Canon II condemns the view that the substance of the bread and wine stays, alongside the body and blood of Christ.

    It names no one. Its target is the view of Luther and his followers: that the bread and wine remain, with Christ's body and blood truly present in them.

    “If any one saith, that, in the sacred and holy sacrament of the Eucharist, the substance of the bread and wine remains conjointly with the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, and denieth that wonderful and singular conversion of the whole substance of the bread into the Body, and of the whole substance of the wine into the Blood-the species Only of the bread and wine remaining-which conversion indeed the Catholic Church most aptly calls Transubstantiation; let him be anathema.”
  7. Session XXI: the trade shut down

    16 July 1562

    The office of the questors, the licensed alms-collectors, is abolished everywhere. No privilege or age-old custom is an exception.

    Indulgences themselves are kept. The bishops are to announce them, through men who receive no payment whatsoever.

    “(the Synod) ordains that, in all parts of Christendom soever, their name and use be henceforth utterly abolished”
  8. Session XXIII: bishops sent home

    15 July 1563

    The clause that matters is 'even though they be cardinals'. Bishops living away from their dioceses was a habit at the pope's own court in Rome, not only out in the provinces.

    The council had ruled on residence in 1547. Then it watched that decree being read as if it made it lawful to be away for five months in a row.

    “all persons who are--under whatsoever name and title, even though they be cardinals of the holy Roman Church--set over any patriarchal, primatial, metropolitan, and cathedral churches whatsoever, are obliged to personal residence in their own church, or diocese, where they shall be bound to discharge the office enjoined them”
  9. Session XXV: the money abolished, the doctrine kept

    4 December 1563

    Session XXV sat on 3 and 4 December 1563. The reform decree forbidding bishops and other senior clergy to enrich their relatives from church money is dated 3 December. The decree on indulgences is dated 4 December.

    The indulgence decree has two halves, and both stand. The evil gains are abolished. And anyone who says indulgences are useless, or that the Church lacks the power to grant them, is declared anathema.

    “It ordains generally by this decree, that all evil gains for the obtaining thereof,--whence a most prolific cause of abuses amongst the Christian people has been derived,--be wholly abolished.”
    HistoricalCanons and Decrees of the Council of TrentSession XXV, Decree concerning IndulgencesThe evidence ↓
  10. Benedictus Deus: interpretation reserved

    26 January 1564

    Pope Pius IV confirms the council in Benedictus Deus, a formal papal letter. He forbids anyone, clergy or lay, to publish any explanation of its decrees without papal authority.

    The penalty is excommunication, which falls automatically on whoever does it. Difficulties are to be taken to the Apostolic See, the pope in Rome.

    “We, by apostolic authority, forbid all men, as well ecclesiastics, of whatsoever order, condition, and rank they may be, as also laymen, with whatsoever honor and power invested ; prelates, to wit, under pain of being interdicted from entering the church, and all others whomsoever they be, under pain of excommunication incurred by the fact, to presume, without our authority to publish, in any form, any commentaries, glosses, annotations, scholia, or any kind of interpretation whatsoever of the decrees of the said Council”
    HistoricalBenedictus Deus, Bull of Pius IV confirming the Council of TrentBenedictus Deus, 26 January 1564, printed at the end of Session XXVThe evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on8 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

Session VII of Trent, 3 March 1547, anathematised anyone who says the sacraments of the New Law are more or fewer than seven, and named them. The count of exactly seven is late. The earliest surviving text that enumerates it is Peter Lombard's Sentences, Book IV, distinction II, written about 1155 to 1158, and the earliest conciliar enumeration is the Council of Florence's bull for the Armenians of 22 November 1439. Roughly eleven centuries separate the apostolic age from the first surviving enumeration.

Rests on
Other readings
  • Most Reformation churches count two sacraments instituted by Christ, Baptism and the Lord's Supper, and treat a fixed number of seven as a medieval construction. No Reformation confession on the number was retrieved for this chapter, so none is quoted here.
  • A Catholic reading is that the rites were all in use long before anyone counted them, and that counting a thing is not inventing it.
Limits
  • This is the widest attestation gap in the chapter. On what has been verified, roughly eleven centuries separate the apostolic age from the first surviving enumeration of seven.
  • That transcription carries uncorrected optical character recognition, and two artefacts sit inside the quoted sentence: 'ac cedamus' for 'accedamus' and, later in the same passage, 'alla' for 'alia'. It should be verified against a printed Grottaferrata copy before publication.
  • The profession of faith of Michael Palaeologus at Lyons II in 1274, the witness usually cited as the first official enumeration, could not be retrieved for this chapter and is not claimed here.
  • Earliest surviving is not earliest. A twelfth-century list could have had predecessors that did not survive. It is a limit on what can be shown, not proof that nobody counted seven earlier.
  • Nothing here disputes the antiquity of the seven rites themselves. The claim concerns the count only, and no early witness for any individual rite was verified for this chapter.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

02RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

On 8 April 1546 the Council of Trent decreed that it receives and venerates the books of both Testaments and the unwritten apostolic traditions with an equal affection of piety and reverence. The decree says the truth of the gospel is contained 'in the written books, and the unwritten traditions', joining the two with 'and'. It does not divide revelation into a part found in Scripture and a part found only in tradition. In 1965 Vatican II's Dei Verbum repeated Trent's Latin phrase, pari pietatis affectu ac reverentia, almost word for word.

Rests on
  • Session IV (8 April 1546), Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures, opening paragraph (Waterworth p. 18)
    “following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety, and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament--seeing that one God is the author of both --as also the said traditions, …”
    Read the full passage
    “following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and venerates with an equal affection of piety, and reverence, all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament--seeing that one God is the author of both --as also the said traditions, as well those appertaining to faith as to morals, as having been dictated, either by Christ's own word of mouth, or by the Holy Ghost, and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continuous succession.”
  • Session IV (8 April 1546), Decree concerning the Canonical Scriptures, preamble (Waterworth p. 18)
    “seeing clearly that this truth and discipline are contained in the written books, and the unwritten traditions”
  • Session IV, Latin printed opposite Waterworth's English
    “pari pietatis affectu ac reverentia suscipit et veneratur”
  • Denzinger 783 in Deferrari's numbering (DS 1501), Council of Trent, Session IV (8 April 1546)
    “[the Synod] following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and holds in veneration with an equal affection of piety and reverence all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament [...] and also the traditions themselves, those that …”
    Read the full passage
    “[the Synod] following the examples of the orthodox Fathers, receives and holds in veneration with an equal affection of piety and reverence all the books both of the Old and of the New Testament [...] and also the traditions themselves, those that appertain both to faith and to morals, as having been dictated either by Christ’s own word of mouth, or by the Holy Spirit, and preserved in the Catholic Church by a continuous succession.”
  • On the Holy Spirit 27.66 (AD 375)
    “Of the beliefs and practices whether generally accepted or publicly enjoined which are preserved in the Church some we possess derived from written teaching; others we have received delivered to us in a mystery by the tradition of the apostles; and both of these in relation to true religion have the same force.”
  • Dei Verbum 9 (18 November 1965)
    “Therefore both sacred tradition and Sacred Scripture are to be accepted and venerated with the same sense of loyalty and reverence.”
  • Dei Verbum 9, official Latin text (18 November 1965)
    “Quapropter utraque pari pietatis affectu ac reverentia suscipienda et veneranda est”
  • Article XXI, Of the Authority of General Councils (1562)
    “And when they be gathered together, (forasmuch as they be an assembly of men, whereof all be not governed with the Spirit and Word of God,) they may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God. Wherefore things ordained by them …”
    Read the full passage
    “And when they be gathered together, (forasmuch as they be an assembly of men, whereof all be not governed with the Spirit and Word of God,) they may err, and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God. Wherefore things ordained by them as necessary to salvation have neither strength nor authority, unless it may be declared that they be taken out of holy Scripture.”
Other readings
  • Calvin, writing in 1547, read the decree as demoting Scripture: 'There are four heads : First, they ordain that in doctrine we are not to stand on Scripture alone, but also on things handed down by tradition.'
  • Anglican Article XXI answers the method rather than the content: a general council's decisions have 'neither strength nor authority, unless it may be declared that they be taken out of holy Scripture'.
  • Protestant readers argue that Basil applied 'the same force' to liturgical customs such as the sign of the cross and facing east, and that Trent extended a principle about ceremonies into a principle about doctrine. That is a real argument, not a misreading.
Limits
  • 'Equal' is the contested word. Reformed and Lutheran readers take it to mean Scripture is being demoted; Catholic readers take it to mean tradition is being honoured, not Scripture reduced. The text alone does not settle which reading is right.
  • Claims about a rejected 'partim... partim' draft at Trent are a staple of the literature but no source for them was retrieved for this chapter, so nothing is asserted about the drafting history.
  • Basil's examples in On the Holy Spirit 27 are liturgical practices, such as signing with the cross and turning to the east to pray, not doctrines that could contradict Scripture.
  • The English is Waterworth's 1848 translation as carried by the Hanover College scan made by students in 1995. Line breaks have been collapsed to single spaces and the double hyphens are the scan's rendering of Waterworth's dashes.
  • Denzinger is quoted from a web reproduction of Deferrari's English translation on sensusfidelium.com, a devotional site, not from a printed copy. The bracketed ellipsis leaves out the clause 'since one God is the author or both', where that reproduction prints 'or' for 'of'; Waterworth's version of the same clause is quoted in full above.
  • The two English translations quoted here word it differently ('equal affection of piety, and reverence'; 'the same sense of loyalty and reverence').
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

03RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

Trent defined justification as a real inward renewal and not only a verdict: the alone formal cause is the justice of God whereby He makes us just, received within us. Canon IX condemns 'faith alone' only 'in such wise as to mean' that no co-operation of the will is required, but canon XI condemns justification by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ. Calvin replied in 1547 that canon IX attacked a position no Reformer held.

Rests on
  • Session VI (13 January 1547), chapter VII
    “the alone formal cause is the justice of God, not that whereby He Himself is just, but that whereby He maketh us just, that, to wit, with which we being endowed by Him, are renewed in the spirit of our mind, and we are not only reputed, but are truly called, and are, just, receiving justice within us”
  • Session VI, canon IX
    “If any one saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of Justification, and that it is not in any way necessary, that he be prepared and disposed by the movement of his own will; let him be anathema.”
  • Session VI, canon XI
    “If any one saith, that men are justified, either by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ, or by the sole remission of sins, to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is …”
    Read the full passage
    “If any one saith, that men are justified, either by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ, or by the sole remission of sins, to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is inherent in them; or even that the grace, whereby we are justified, is only the favour of God; let him be anathema.”
  • Antidote to the canons of the Sixth Session, reply to Canon IX, p. 151
    “This Canon is very far from being canonical ; for it joins things which are utterly at variance. They imagine that a man is justified by faith without any movement of his own will, as if it were not with the heart that a man believeth unto righteousness.”
  • Antidote to the canons of the Sixth Session, reply to Canon IX, p. 151, closing sentence
    “Add, that when we say a man is justified by faith alone, we do not fancy a faith devoid of charity, but we mean that faith alone is the cause of justification.”
  • Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (31 October 1999), paragraph 41
    “Thus the doctrinal condemnations of the 16th century, in so far as they relate to the doctrine of justification, appear in a new light: The teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration does not fall under the condemnations from the Council of Trent.”
Other readings
  • Calvin's reading: the canon joins things that are utterly at variance, since no Reformer taught a faith without the movement of the will or a faith devoid of charity.
  • Catholics who read canon IX as condemning every form of sola fide are reading past its qualifying clause. Protestants who conclude that the canons are therefore harmless have to reckon with canons XI and XII, which strike at imputation and at fiducial faith.
  • The 1999 Joint Declaration holds that Lutheran teaching as presented there does not fall under the Tridentine condemnations. The Catholic Response of 1998 had said the case was not yet clear.
Limits
  • The two Calvin quotations come from the same printed reply but are not continuous: an intervening sentence beginning 'Between them and us there is this difference' was not transcribed in the material available for this chapter, so they are given separately rather than joined.
  • Calvin is a polemicist here, not a neutral reporter. The same volume calls the Roman See the great harlot.
  • Calvin's text is an Internet Archive scan of the 1851 Beveridge translation with uneven optical character recognition; other passages on the same page are corrupt.
  • Canon numbering and wording come from the Waterworth scan and should be checked against a critical edition before publication.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

04RevealedEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

On 11 October 1551 Trent defined that by the consecration the whole substance of the bread is converted into the substance of the body of Christ and the whole substance of the wine into His blood, and that the Church suitably and properly calls this conversion transubstantiation. Canon II anathematises the view that the substance of bread and wine remains conjointly with the body and blood. The word was not new: the Fourth Lateran Council had used it in 1215, and the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia traces it to theologians of the late eleventh and twelfth centuries. The Catechism of 1997 still reproduces Trent's sentence as its own summary.

Rests on
  • Session XIII (11 October 1551), chapter IV, On Transubstantiation (Waterworth p. 78)
    “by the consecration of the bread and of the wine, a conversion is made of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood; which conversion is, by the holy Catholic Church, suitably and properly called Transubstantiation.”
  • Session XIII, canon II (Waterworth p. 82, Hanover scan)
    “If any one saith, that, in the sacred and holy sacrament of the Eucharist, the substance of the bread and wine remains conjointly with the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, and denieth that wonderful and singular conversion of the whole …”
    Read the full passage
    “If any one saith, that, in the sacred and holy sacrament of the Eucharist, the substance of the bread and wine remains conjointly with the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, and denieth that wonderful and singular conversion of the whole substance of the bread into the Body, and of the whole substance of the wine into the Blood-the species Only of the bread and wine remaining-which conversion indeed the Catholic Church most aptly calls Transubstantiation; let him be anathema.”
  • Session XIII, chapter IV, Latin printed opposite Waterworth's English
    “quæ conversio convenienter et proprie a sancta Catholica Ecclesia Transsubstantiatio est appellata”
  • Denzinger 877 in Deferrari's numbering (DS 1642), Council of Trent, Session XIII, chapter 4 (11 October 1551)
    “But since Christ, our Redeemer, has said that that is truly His own body which He offered under the species of bread [cf. Matt. 26:26ff.; Mark 14:22ff.; Luke 22:19 ff.; 1 Cor. 11:23 ff.], it has always been a matter of conviction in the Church of …”
    Read the full passage
    “But since Christ, our Redeemer, has said that that is truly His own body which He offered under the species of bread [cf. Matt. 26:26ff.; Mark 14:22ff.; Luke 22:19 ff.; 1 Cor. 11:23 ff.], it has always been a matter of conviction in the Church of God, and now this holy Synod declares it again, that by the consecration of the bread and wine a conversion takes place of the whole substance of bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord, and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of His blood. This conversion is appropriately and properly called transubstantiation by the Catholic Church [can. 2].”
  • Fourth Lateran Council (1215), canon 1, clause on the sacrament of the altar
    “the bread being changed (transsubstantiatio) by divine power into the body, and the wine into the blood”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'The Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist', section on Transubstantiation
    “The term transubstantiation seems to have been first used by Hildebert of Tours (about 1079). His encouraging example was soon followed by other theologians, as Stephen of Autun (d. 1139), Gaufred (1188), and Peter of Blois (d. about 1200), …”
    Read the full passage
    “The term transubstantiation seems to have been first used by Hildebert of Tours (about 1079). His encouraging example was soon followed by other theologians, as Stephen of Autun (d. 1139), Gaufred (1188), and Peter of Blois (d. about 1200), whereupon several ecumenical councils also adopted this significant expression, as the Fourth Council of the Lateran (1215), and the Council of Lyons (1274), in the profession of faith of the Greek Emperor Michael Palæologus.”
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church 1376, quoting Trent (vatican.va)
    “by the consecration of the bread and wine there takes place a change of the whole substance of the bread into the substance of the body of Christ our Lord and of the whole substance of the wine into the substance of his blood. This change the holy Catholic Church has fittingly and properly called transubstantiation.”
  • Article XXVIII, Of the Lord's Supper, second paragraph
    “Transubstantiation (or the change of the substance of Bread and Wine) in the Supper of the Lord, can not be proved by holy Writ; but is repugnant to the plain words of Scripture, overthroweth the nature of a Sacrament, and hath given occasion to many superstitions.”
  • Sixteenth Century, The West, on the Council of Trent
    “In response to the challenge of the Protestant Reformation, and spurred by its demands for widespread ecclesiastical reform, the Roman Church held the Council of Trent (1545–1547, 1551–1552, 1562–1563). While instituting many needed practical …”
    Read the full passage
    “In response to the challenge of the Protestant Reformation, and spurred by its demands for widespread ecclesiastical reform, the Roman Church held the Council of Trent (1545–1547, 1551–1552, 1562–1563). While instituting many needed practical reforms, it also officially reaffirmed the aberrant Medieval doctrines and practices of purgatory, indulgences, transubstantiation of the bread and wine in the Eucharist, communion for the laity with the bread only, the mass as a repropitiating sacrifice of Christ made to the Father, and extreme unction (whereby the sacrament of healing with holy oil became last rites for the dying).”
Other readings
  • Anglican Article XXVIII rejects the explanation while keeping the presence: the first paragraph of the same article says the bread is a partaking of the Body of Christ.
  • Canon II condemns the view that the substance of the bread and wine remains conjointly with the body and blood. No Lutheran or Reformed confession of the Lord's Supper was retrieved for this chapter, so no position on the eucharistic presence is attributed to any Reformation church here.
  • The Orthodox Church in America lists transubstantiation among the medieval doctrines Trent reaffirmed, while granting that the council also made many needed practical reforms.
Limits
  • The contestable sentence in the decree is the historical one, not the metaphysical one: the claim that it 'has ever been a firm belief in the Church of God'. No early witness to that belief was verified for this chapter. What can be dated here is that the word was in conciliar use by 1215 and the dogmatic definition is sixteenth-century.
  • The parenthesis '(transsubstantiatio)' in the Lateran IV quotation is the Fordham editor's insertion of the Latin word. It is not part of the English sentence. Deferrari's Denzinger renders the same clause 'the bread (changed) into His body by the divine power of transubstantiation'.
  • Canon II is quoted exactly as the Hanover scan of Waterworth prints it, including its capitals 'the Body', 'the Blood' and 'species Only' and its single hyphens for dashes. Schaff's Creeds of Christendom II prints the same English with 'the body', 'the blood', 'the species only', double dashes and a colon before 'let him be anathema'. The words are the same in both.
  • About 1,180 years separate the Last Supper from the Fourth Lateran Council's use of the word, and a further 336 years separate that from Trent's definition.
  • The Orthodox Church in America page also says Trent claimed that grace is a 'created effect'. That phrase appears in none of the decrees retrieved for this chapter; it is a theological characterisation of scholastic categories, not a quotation from Trent.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia's dating of the word's first use (Hildebert of Tours, about 1079) is its own, hedged with 'seems to have been'; no medieval text using the word before 1215 was read for this chapter.
  • Denzinger is quoted from a web reproduction of Deferrari's English on sensusfidelium.com, a devotional site, not from a printed copy; the bracketed references are that edition's.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-10-08).

05HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Trent legislated against the abuses the Reformers had named. Session V (1546) bound bishops to preach. Session XXI (16 July 1562) abolished the questors of alms, the professional indulgence-sellers, admitting that earlier councils' remedies had become useless. Session XXIII (15 July 1563) bound all prelates, cardinals included, to personal residence, and ordered every cathedral and metropolitan church to found and maintain a college for training clergy. Session XXV (December 1563) abolished all evil gains in the granting of indulgences and forbade prelates to enrich their kindred out of church revenue.

Rests on
Other readings
  • An Orthodox reading grants the discipline and rejects the doctrine: Trent instituted many needed practical reforms and in the same sessions reaffirmed what the East regards as medieval error.
  • A skeptical reading is that a council legislates most loudly against what it cannot control, and that the decrees are better evidence of the scale of the abuse than of its cure.
Limits
  • These are laws, not records of compliance. No document used here shows how many seminaries were actually built, how many bishops actually resided, or how long the questors' trade took to die.
  • The council argued for seventeen years over whether residence is of divine right and never settled the question. The 1563 chapter imposes the duty without answering it, and exists because the 1547 decree had been evaded.
  • The same Session XXV decree that abolishes the evil gains keeps indulgences and anathematises anyone who says they are useless or that the Church lacks the power to grant them. Both halves are in one paragraph.
  • The Orthodox Church in America page also says Trent claimed that grace is a 'created effect'. That phrase appears in none of the decrees retrieved for this chapter; it is a theological characterisation of scholastic categories, not a quotation from Trent.
  • The seminary decree is an innovation, not a restoration. Earlier cathedral-school legislation exists, but none of it was verified for this chapter, so no continuity is claimed.
  • Session XXV sat on 3 and 4 December 1563 and its decrees carry both dates. The reform decree on the kindred of prelates is dated 3 December in the edition used here; the decree on indulgences and the decree handing the index of books to the pope are dated 4 December. A single date for Session XXV would be wrong either way.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Council of Trent did not publish an Index of Prohibited Books. Session IV (1546) required a bishop's approval before any book on sacred matters could be printed and forbade private interpretation of Scripture against the Church's sense. Session XVIII (26 February 1562) appointed a commission on forbidden books; Session XXV handed its unfinished work to the pope. The Ten Rules and the Index were promulgated under Pius IV in 1564: Rule IV made reading a vernacular Bible a licensed act and the closing clause excommunicated anyone who read a heretic's book. Pius IV then reserved all interpretation of the council to the Apostolic See. The Index lost the force of ecclesiastical law on 14 June 1966.

Rests on
  • Session IV (8 April 1546), Decree concerning the edition and the use of the sacred books
    “no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that …”
    Read the full passage
    “no one, relying on his own skill, shall,--in matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, --wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which holy mother Church,--whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures,--hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers”
  • Session XVIII (26 February 1562), Decree on the Choice of Books
  • Session XXV (4 December 1563), On the index of books; on the catechism, breviary, and missal
    “It enjoins that whatsoever has been by them done shall be laid before the most holy Roman Pontiff, that it may be by his judgment and authority terminated and made public.”
  • Ten Rules concerning Prohibited Books (1564), Rule IV
    “Since it is clear from experience that if the Sacred Books are permitted everywhere and without discrimination in the vernacular, there will by reason of the boldness of men arise therefrom more harm than good, the matter is in this respect left to …”
    Read the full passage
    “Since it is clear from experience that if the Sacred Books are permitted everywhere and without discrimination in the vernacular, there will by reason of the boldness of men arise therefrom more harm than good, the matter is in this respect left to the judgment of the bishop or inquisitor, who may with the advice of the pastor or confessor permit the reading of the Sacred Books translated into the vernacular by Catholic authors to those who they know will derive from such reading no harm but rather an increase of faith and piety, which permission they must have in writing. Those, however, who presume to read or possess them without such permission may not receive absolution from their sins till they have handed them over to the ordinary.”
  • Ten Rules concerning Prohibited Books (1564), closing paragraph after Rule X
    “And if anyone should read or possess books by heretics or writings by any author condemned and prohibited by reason of heresy or suspicion of false teaching, he incurs immediately the sentence of excommunication.”
  • Benedictus Deus (26 January 1564), bull of confirmation
    “We, by apostolic authority, forbid all men, as well ecclesiastics, of whatsoever order, condition, and rank they may be, as also laymen, with whatsoever honor and power invested ; prelates, to wit, under pain of being interdicted from entering the …”
    Read the full passage
    “We, by apostolic authority, forbid all men, as well ecclesiastics, of whatsoever order, condition, and rank they may be, as also laymen, with whatsoever honor and power invested ; prelates, to wit, under pain of being interdicted from entering the church, and all others whomsoever they be, under pain of excommunication incurred by the fact, to presume, without our authority to publish, in any form, any commentaries, glosses, annotations, scholia, or any kind of interpretation whatsoever of the decrees of the said Council”
  • Notification of 14 June 1966, paragraph 2
    “announces that the Index remains morally binding, in light of the demands of natural law, in so far as it admonishes the conscience of Christians to be on guard for those writings that can endanger faith and morals. But, at the same time, it no longer has the force of ecclesiastical law with the attached censure.”
Other readings
  • A Catholic defence is that pre-publication licensing was ordinary practice in sixteenth-century states as well as churches, and that Session IV cites a canon of Lateran V (1515) as its precedent.
  • A Protestant reading is that a church which needs a licensing system to keep its people from reading the Bible in their own language has already conceded the argument.
  • Rule II names Luther, Zwingli and Calvin among the authors whose books are absolutely forbidden, so a Catholic who owned a copy of Calvin was excommunicated by the fact.
Limits
  • 'Trent banned books' is shorthand the council's own words do not support. Trent commissioned the list, demanded licensing from 1546, and handed the Index to Rome; Pius IV promulgated it in 1564.
  • These are the letter of the law. Nothing here shows how consistently the Index or Rule IV were enforced, and enforcement varied greatly by country.
  • The 1964 Fordham text of the Ten Rules does not name its translator; the page's own footnotes cite H. J. Schroeder, so the printed Schroeder edition should be cited before publication. The Latin was not consulted.
  • The 1966 notification is quoted from the verb onward. The full sentence begins 'To respond to the above-mentioned questions, this Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, after having asked the Holy Father, announces...'. It does not apologise, and it keeps the Index's moral force.
  • Nothing in the twenty-five sessions retrieved for this chapter addresses coercion, the Inquisition or the use of force against heretics in order to condemn them. Trent legislated on printing, licensing and forbidden books, and left that question alone. The research behind this chapter names Dignitatis Humanae of 1965 as the first document it identified that does repudiate coercion, but no text of Dignitatis Humanae was retrieved, so nothing is quoted from it here.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

07HistoricalProbable historical reconstruction Quotes checked

Trent fixed the Catholic canon of Scripture on 8 April 1546 and attached an anathema to it. The books were not new. A council at Carthage in 419, re-confirming canons of 393 and 397, already listed Tobit, Judith and two books of Maccabees, and the Council of Florence listed the same canon in 1442 without an anathema. Among the councils retrieved for this chapter, Trent is the first ecumenical council to attach a penalty to the list.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Reformers could claim antiquity for a shorter Old Testament: Athanasius's Festal Letter 39 of AD 367 gives a narrower list, and Calvin complained that Trent marked all the books 'with the same chalk'.
  • A Catholic reading is that Trent ratified a list the Western Church had used for more than eleven centuries and only added a penalty because the list was now being denied.
Limits
  • 'First ecumenical council to attach an anathema to the canon' is a negative claim resting on the councils actually retrieved for this chapter. It has not been checked against every conciliar text.
  • The New Advent page carrying the African canons warns that they 'seem to have been divided or numbered by some private and unlearned hand' and that some are confused and obscured.
  • Carthage 419 is a regional African council, not an ecumenical one, and its canon 24 asks that the list be confirmed by Rome.
  • No pre-fourth-century list settles the question in either direction.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

08HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

The Tridentine anathemas have never been withdrawn. The Augsburg Confession of 1530, Article IV, teaches that men are freely justified for Christ's sake through faith, and that God imputes this faith for righteousness. Trent's Session VI canon XI anathematises justification by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ to the exclusion of inherent grace and charity. The 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification says the sixteenth-century condemnations do not fall on the teaching of the Lutheran churches as presented in that Declaration. The Catholic Church's own Response of 25 June 1998 had said that it remains difficult to see how the Lutheran formula simul iustus et peccator is not touched by the anathemas of the Tridentine decree. Whether Trent's condemnations still reach Lutheran teaching is therefore disputed between two documents of the same dialogue.

Rests on
  • Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (31 October 1999), paragraph 41
    “Thus the doctrinal condemnations of the 16th century, in so far as they relate to the doctrine of justification, appear in a new light: The teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration does not fall under the condemnations from the Council of Trent.”
  • Response of the Catholic Church (25 June 1998), Part A, Clarifications, section 1
    “So, for all these reasons, it remains difficult to see how, in the current state of the presentation, given in the Joint Declaration, we can say that this doctrine on “simul iustus et peccator” is not touched by the anathemas of the Tridentine decree on original sin and justification.”
  • Session VI, canon XI
    “If any one saith, that men are justified, either by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ, or by the sole remission of sins, to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is …”
    Read the full passage
    “If any one saith, that men are justified, either by the sole imputation of the justice of Christ, or by the sole remission of sins, to the exclusion of the grace and the charity which is poured forth in their hearts by the Holy Ghost, and is inherent in them; or even that the grace, whereby we are justified, is only the favour of God; let him be anathema.”
  • Article IV, Of Justification (Concordia Triglotta, 1921)
    “Article IV. Of Justification. Also they teach that men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ's sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that …”
    Read the full passage
    “Article IV. Of Justification. Also they teach that men cannot be justified before God by their own strength, merits, or works, but are freely justified for Christ's sake, through faith, when they believe that they are received into favor, and that their sins are forgiven for Christ's sake, who, by His death, has made satisfaction for our sins. This faith God imputes for righteousness in His sight. Rom. 3 and 4.”
  • Session XVIII (26 February 1562), decree inviting all men on the public faith to the council
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'Council of Trent', Johann Peter Kirsch, on the Protestant ambassadors and on the subscription of the decrees
Other readings
  • A Catholic ecumenical reading is that the condemnations were aimed at positions, not at persons or churches, and that a finding of non-application is the most a council's canons can receive without being reopened.
  • A Lutheran reading is that agreement was reached on a document rather than on a repeal, and that the anathemas still stand in the books.
  • A skeptical reading of the 1998 Response is that it was later softened by the Annex of 1999 and by the signing itself. No text of the Annex was retrieved for this chapter, so nothing is claimed about it here.
Limits
  • The Joint Declaration is carefully hedged: 'in so far as they relate to the doctrine of justification', and 'the teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration'.
  • The Official Common Statement and the Annex of 1999 are part of this record and were not retrieved for this chapter, so the 1998 Response is not the last word in the process.
  • The Vatican page carrying the 1998 Response has visible transcription slips elsewhere on it, so further quotation from it needs checking.
  • The 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia is a confessionally committed source and its judgements should be read as such, not as neutral history. It is cited here for dates, attendance figures and the sequence of the negotiations, not as historiography, and the chapter no longer attributes its narrative to historians.
  • Protestants were formally invited to the council and given safe conducts. What the evidence shows is not exclusion but terms they could not accept.
  • Two items previously quoted in this claim are now cited without quotation. They are recorded here as references to be re-read, not as quotations.
  • No Lutheran statement on the Lord's Supper was retrieved for this chapter, so nothing about the Lutheran doctrine of the eucharistic presence is asserted anywhere in it.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-23).

Questions people ask next