Act 2 · 4 min

I don’t believe things easily

This is how I tested every belief the same way, starting with whether Jesus even existed.

Scroll to begin

I’m a skeptic by nature. I don’t take anything on anyone’s word. If you tell me something is true, I want to know why.

Then I want to know why that is true. I don’t stop at the first answer, or the second, or the tenth.

So when I finally saw that my real problem was that I was terrified of dying, I didn’t go looking for something to make me feel better.

I wanted truth, not just comfort. Is there life after death, and is there any real evidence for it?

I didn’t give up, and I didn’t let up. I studied Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism and secular philosophy.

I asked what science says happens when we die. I read about reincarnation cases, simulation theory, near-death experiences.

I was scouring the internet for answers, and I kept digging, and digging, and digging.

But I didn’t want to just pick whatever made me feel better. So I gave every belief I studied the same fair test, the same questions every time:

  1. 1Does it hold together logically, or does it contradict itself?
  2. 2Does it fit the historical evidence?
  3. 3Does it explain the world as it really is, including evil and suffering?
  4. 4Does it make sense of people, of who we actually are?
  5. 5Does it change lives, in a way that lasts?

I went through every one of those beliefs as honestly as I could.

But this site, The Trail, is about Christianity, so that’s the only one I’ll go through here.

Each of those faiths deserves its own careful look, and a few paragraphs here wouldn’t do it justice.

So here’s what happened when I put these questions to Christianity, the one I had walked away from.

It didn’t just hold up. It left me in complete awe.

Here’s what I found, starting from the very bottom: whether Jesus even existed.

Did Jesus even exist?

Quick background, for anyone who didn’t grow up with any of this.

Christians say Jesus was a Jewish teacher who lived in what is now Israel about two thousand years ago.

They say he was executed by the Romans, rose from the dead, and is God.

The four early accounts of his life are called the : Matthew, Mark, Luke and John.

Gospel just means good news, and each one carries the name of the man early Christians said wrote it.

In the years after Jesus was , his first followers spread out and started small churches in cities across the Roman Empire: Rome, Corinth, Ephesus and others.

They couldn’t be everywhere at once, so they wrote letters. Most were written by , a man who had hunted Christians down until he met the risen Jesus.

Others carry the names of , James, John and Jude, men from Jesus’s own circle.

In those letters they explained to the young churches what Jesus’s life, death and rising actually meant.

They answered their questions, sorted out their arguments, corrected their mistakes, and kept them going when following Jesus got them into trouble.

Put the four Gospels and those letters together. Add a history of the early Church (the Acts of the Apostles) and one last book of visions (Revelation).

And you have the , the second half of the .

The first half, the , is the Jewish Scriptures written before Jesus.

Let’s start with the most basic question. Maybe Jesus is just mythology.

Maybe Jesus is just a story parents pass down because it’s part of the culture, no more real than the Flying Spaghetti Monster, a god someone made up as a joke.

Quick check

Who would convince you more that Jesus really lived?

Pick an answer below.

If Jesus didn’t exist, nothing else matters.

So I went looking for people outside the Church who wrote about him, especially people who had no reason to be kind.

, a Roman historian writing around AD 116, was explaining the great fire of Rome, not defending anyone.

In passing, he explains where the name “Christian” came from.

He calls Jesus Christus, Latin for , a title meaning the rescuer God had promised.

And he names , the Roman governor who ordered Jesus to be crucified:

“Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus.”
Tacitus, Annals 15.44, around AD 116

Around AD 112, Pliny, a Roman governor, wrote to the emperor about the Christians he was putting on trial.

They met on a fixed day, he says, and sang a hymn “to Christ as to a god”.

And , a Jewish historian writing in the 90s, mentions “James, the brother of Jesus who was called Christ”.

In the Bible’s world, “brother” could also mean a close relative, and that’s how Catholics read it here.

Josephus’s longer passage about Jesus was later touched up by Christian copyists, and scholars say so openly, but most think there is a real original underneath.

These are sources with no reason to be kind, written within a century of the events, and they match the Gospels on the basic facts.

Today almost no historian, Christian or not, doubts that Jesus lived and was crucified under Pilate.

Even skeptical scholars who don’t believe a word of the , meaning Jesus rising from the dead, say so.

End of act 2

You can stop here.

The next act picks up right where this one ends, whenever you’re ready.